Why was Edward Plantagenet dubbed "Edward I" when he was the 4th Edward to rule England?

I noticed Edward "Longshanks" Plantagenet is called Edward 1st despite being preceded by Edward the Elder, Edward the Martyr, and Edward the Confessor. At first I thought maybe the numbering of Kings was a Norman convention, but we have Harald II at the end of Saxon rule.

Was there an official proclamation restarting the numbers with William the Conqueror? If not, was there any controversy or discussion of the issue when Longshanks was crowned?

1 Answers 2014-05-30

Why, during the American Civil War, would people gather and watch battles for recreation? Wouldn't heads being blown off disturb them and their picnics?

1 Answers 2014-05-30

How did the Lion, a creature who's habitat is thousands of miles from Europe, become such a common figure in heraldry?

1 Answers 2014-05-30

During WWII Allied invasions of various beaches, how was it decided who had to stand up front of Higgins Boats (LCVP)?

At least in the case of Saving Private Ryan, the men standing at the front of the Higgins Boats seemed to draw the proverbial short straw as German machine gun nests immediately picked them off. Was there some strategic logic in putting these unfortunate few up front or did these men just happen to be the last ones to hop on?

Edit: the most thorough answer so far is slightly buried and can be found here:

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/26u03d/during_wwii_allied_invasions_of_various_beaches/chv2q32

(Sorry for formatting. I'm on mobile.)

2 Answers 2014-05-30

When did people start smiling in photographs?

In some of the earliest photographs from the late 19th/early 20th centuries (and in some daguerreotypes earlier than that), most people are pictured with straight, stoic faces. These days, however, it's normal to smile for all photographs, even formal ones for informational purposes.

How did this begin? When did this start? Or has it always been this way, and we're merely overlooking it?

2 Answers 2014-05-29

How true is the statement "History repeats itself" and why (with examples)?

How likely is another plague, another world war? Is this a case of confirmation bias or are we just 'flawed' in such a way that we overcompensate for progress. I'm referring to how progress (e.g vaccination, societal tolerance for differences) is very easily reverted.

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Why Didn't Hitler order the use of chemical weapons in the defense of Berlin at the end of the war?

Since they had them, and to them this was Götterdämmerung, why didn't the Nazi leadership use gas attacks in the defense of Berlin at the end?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

How Important was Japan's Role in WW1

An article I read recently mentioned Japan specifically as a country that had a major role in defeating Kaiser Wilhelm II. How accurate is that?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Important Aspects / Concepts of WW2 that People Don't Know?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Was the Island City of Tyre real? Did Alexander the Great actually Siege it?

Also, What happened to the Island City afterwards?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Why do classical sculptures have small penises?

I'm relatively certain that classical statues have penises that are much smaller than average, no? Like, often 1-2 inches on a life-size adult statue. It seems counter intuitive to me that classical nude sculptures would have unusually small penises. I've always wondered and it's never been talked about in the museum tours/classes I've taken. Google didn't help much either.

Examples of what I'm talking about:

Apollo Belvedere

Farnese Herakles

Laocoon and His Sons

I really do mean this as a genuine question, I'm not trying to be a jerk. I'm just curious... Today we think of penises as being symbols of masculinity and whatnot. I'm wondering what the different... Did people idealize having a small penis? Or would giving them larger penises have been considered crude? Are their any theories?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Was the Iran-Iraq War inevitable?

I have a vague understanding of the background leading up to the war, and a fairly decent idea of the conduct of the war itself (I'm a nearly graduated Middle Eastern Studies student and my time at Defense Language Institute learning Arabic included a number of papers on the Iran-Iraq War), but some of my most recent reading (Guardians of the Revolution by Ray Takeyh) seems to imply that the Khomeini was intentionally provoking Saddam and trying to get a reaction out of him that would give casus belli for spreading Islamic revolution. I understand the whole dynamic of Iraq being 60+% Shi'a under Sunni rule during Saddam's reign, but if Iran thought they needed to spread their version of Islam into Iraq why didn't they just declare war? I'm a terrible International Relations student.

1 Answers 2014-05-29

When historians say feudalism never existed, what do they mean?

How can it be contested that serfs answered to a lord who answered to a king?

2 Answers 2014-05-29

The World Wars

How accurate is the history channel documentary "The world wars?" A lot of it sounded theatrical, however I don't have enough in-depth knowledge to know for sure. Are the minor details accurate?

2 Answers 2014-05-29

Military medicine in the Roman Empire?

I've been accepted to a military MD program in the United States, which got me thinking about this question! What was military medicine like in Ancient Rome? Were treatment rates high? Were there any special military medical schools? Did the army train and sign a service contract with its physicians in exchange for special benefits, like the US does?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Historians, it's to my knowledge that a ranking Japanese official stated that it's possible to INVADE the United States during WW2, but it's impossible to OCCUPY it. Who said this? And the actual quotation is welcomed.

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Were we trying to get to space before 1944?

How much of a part did the B2(?) rocket play in this quest, or did it create the quest?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Has Talmudic scholarship always been a Jewish affair?

I assume it has always been mostly a Jewish area of study because the law only impinges on Jews. But have there been Christian/Muslim scholars who also studied Talmud? I remember that the translators of the King James Bible knew Hebrew, is it so outlandish to think that some Christians would have read/studied it as well?

2 Answers 2014-05-29

Why is there such a great population difference between England and Scotland

Current English population: >50 million Current Scottish population: >5 million

In 1800s English population: 7 million Scottish population: 1.6 million

What accounts for this huge population discrepancy? Is this solely due to climate as Scotland is north of England?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

How did it end up to where dozens of countries in The Americas spoke Spanish but only two spoke English, and one Portuguese?

2 Answers 2014-05-29

Dear historians, how accurate is Neil DeGrasse Tyson's narrative about Mozi in 'Cosmos'?

2 Answers 2014-05-29

The Teutonic State

So, I was wondering, the state of the Teutonic Order was created by land concessions of the Polish Kings to the Knight's Headmasters? Anyone well-versed in their history is welcome to post everything, from the dawns of the Order to their fall. Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2014-05-29

Why didn't the Soviets keep Germany for themselves?

Right after World War II, after the Russians had rolled over the Germans, why didn't they give Germany back to the Germans? Didn't they want to have as much land and power as possible?

2 Answers 2014-05-29

How accurate is Master and Commander's representation of naval warfare during the Napoleonic Wars?

Were there fights between ships for days and days? Did ships use sneaky tactics like the do in the film? Were there children on ships? Were commanders treated in the same way by their crews? Would ships have orders to hunt down a single boat?_

1 Answers 2014-05-29

How did Commodore Perry and/or his men communicate with the Japanese when they got there? Did the Japanese have people who could understand English or did the Americans find & take an interpreter somewhere in the west?

1 Answers 2014-05-29

6682 / 7255

Back to start