Where does the play symbol originate from?

What's the history behind the play symbol that's still used for controlling audio?

I have heard that the pause symbol is originally from the Japanese character リ which means pause. Is it something similar behind the history of the play symbol or does it comes from a more practical viewpoint similar to how diskettes indicates save?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

To what extent were the Crusades a vehicle for gaining political capital & monetary funds for the Papacy?

In 1059 In nomine Domini placed the election of the pope solely in the hands of the Cardinal Bishops of Rome - removing the ability of the Holy Roman Emperor or other European Nobility from naming a pope of their choosing.

From what I understand in that year the Papacy also gave itself the right to grant land in exchange for feudal obligations to Rome [1]

Following Dicatus Papae in 1075, Pope Gregory VII received this letter from Henry IV - Holy Roman Emperor at the time - accusing him of being a "false monk" and reacting to the tenets of the Dicatus Papae, notably the power to depose an emperor (of the Holy Roman Empire) badly;

"As if we had received our kingdom from thee! As if the kingdom and the empire were in thine and not in God's hand! And this although our Lord Jesus Christ did call us to the kingdom, did not, however, call thee to the priesthood."

Gregory called for a Crusade but became embroiled with the Holy Roman Emperor as per the above, and subsequently could not push through a proper campaign, it would seem.

In 1079, again under Gregory VII, we have a document pointing to the start of formal financing for the Papacy, and in 1095 we have the first example of a Pope appropriating funds for the Papacy through procuratio canonica [2]

In 1095 Urban II made a speech at the Council of Clermont in which he said the following.

"Let hatred therefore depart from among you, let your quarrels end, let wars cease, and let all dissensions and controversies slumber. Enter upon the road to the Holy Sepulcher-, wrest that land from the wicked race, and subject it to yourselves. That land which, as the Scripture says, `floweth with milk and honey' was given by God into the power of the children of Israel. Jerusalem is the center of the earth; the land is fruitful above all others, like another paradise of delights."

This primary source points to Urban uniting European nobility against a common foe in exchange for land and riches - the speech contains the same inherent message that Gregory/Hildebrand had conveyed 21 years prior.

The results of the early crusades were lands in the hands of leaders who were politically indebted to the Papacy, and Papal Legates such as Dagobert of Pisa, attempting to directly take the Holy Lands for the Papacy and to turn said lands into Theocratic States [3], amongst other things.

It would appear that not all European leaders were warm to the idea of a strong independent Pope at the time, as displayed by the Holy Roman Emperor's letter and actions.

It would also appear that through the steps mentioned above the Papacy consolidated resources and power throughout the latter part of the 11th Century under the guidance of Hildebrand/Gregory VII.

Subsequently: Where the Crusades part of a plan by Gregory VII to enrich and empower the Papacy from the very beginning?

[1: Peter Partner, The Lands of St. Peter, 1972, p. 122]

[2: Rosamond McKitterick, David Edward Luscombe, The New Cambridge Medieval History: pts. 1-2. c. 1024-c. 1198 p. 406]

[3: Steven Runciman, A History of the Crusades: Volume 1, The First Crusade, 1951, p. 325]

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Who was the most important Nazi leader to face trial?

I know a lot of the important members of the Nazi party killed themselves or fled. Because of this it is my understanding that most of the important Nazi leaders didn't face war crime charges due to these reasons. So out of the small amount of Nazi leaders to face trial, who is generally agreed upon by historians as the most important/influential?

3 Answers 2014-03-31

How was France able to recover from crushing defeats at Crecy, Poitiers and Agincourt and still win the Hundred Years' War?

A few related questions:

Did the English nobility speak to each other in French at that time? How would they communicate to English and Gascon soldiers?

Did the French impose any punishments on Gascon and Bordeaux in particular at the end of the war?

Why did hobelars dismount before fighting? Isn't that like tankers getting out of their tank to engage the enemy in hand to hand combat?

3 Answers 2014-03-31

Some questions about women's suffrage in the U.S

  • Who were the major opponents of women's suffrage?
  • Was their a split between party lines? If not was there where was there a split? (class, age, etc.)
  • Were there any prominent women who were against it?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Were there any large anti-war movements prior to modern warfare(WWI)?

If there were any anti-war movements, why were they opposed to the war? Moral objections, economic, etc...

I know there was plenty of objections to the Spanish-American and Philippine-American wars in America, mostly against the idea of imperialism or expansionism. Are there any other similar cases?

2 Answers 2014-03-31

How exactly did the Second Temple operate?

Hello /r/askhistorians.

I'm wondering about the Second Temple in Jerusalem. It had a huge operation of sacrifices, with tons of animals and people. Surely it was a logistical nightmare.

Sorry if this question is too broad, but how did the priests run it? What systems/devices did they use to assist in what must've been a massive sacrificial operation?

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2014-03-31

Why does some parts of Switzerland speak Italian when the Italian language is so much younger then Switzerland?

I am curious about why and how Switzerland decided to accept Italian as one of their official language.

People in Ticino speak Lombardian, traditionally, when they made the change to Italian? Why they didnt adopted French as an oficial language, as it would make integration with their country easier? Or even why didnt Switzerland addoped their "dialect" as an oficial language instead of Italian? Italian was, for all effects, an foreign language to the Swiss! Or it wasnt? Did they got any say in the creation of Italian?

I guess the same questions can be asked about the german speaking part of Switzerland.

Bonus question: How did the Swiss that speak italians reacted to the Risorgimento?

edit: I guess most people think that Italian was a natural language spoken by Italians: that is not the truth.

Nel 1861, secondo la stima di Tullio De Mauro[13], era in grado di parlare in italiano solo il 2,5% della popolazione italiana. Secondo la stima di Arrigo Castellani alla stessa data la percentuale era invece del 10%

In 1861, only 10% to 2.5% of italians could actually speak italian.

Italian people spoke natively their "dialects" (who are in fact languages as they are not all mutually inteligible, but are called dialect because of political reasons) before speaking standard Italian, not the other way around. Those "dialects" dont have Italian as their origin.

Modern Italian was built on the Fiorentin "dialect" in the 15th century onwards, and then adopted by Italy after the risorgimento.

I can see why the "italian" people of Swiss would adopt Italian. But I also see plenty of reasons to adopt german or french. I would like more then "logic". If possible I would like to see the reasoning of the people who adopted it , not our conjectures. I couldnt find it on my researches.

2 Answers 2014-03-31

War photography from WWII and earlier seems to only show "neat" corpses. Was this something imposed on photographers or something they limited themselves to?

I know this is a bit of a generalization, but for the most part photography from pre-Vietnam wars seems to be mostly of individuals who died of bullet wounds. That is to say, the body is mostly intact and is not terribly bloodied, relatively speaking. We know, however, that vast numbers of war casualties don't look that way.

(Note: I'm most familiar with American war photography and to a lesser extent, photos taken by the Viet Cong. So, it's possible other countries did capture this more.)

Was photographing corpses of this nature something that was ordered of the photographers? Did the photographers self-censor? Did they take more graphic photos but the photos just aren't as widely known?

As a photographer and former historian, this has always nagged me. Modern photojournalism definitely shows more of the reality of war and conflict. I'm thinking specifically of photos from Nicaragua, the first Gulf War, lots of work done since the start of the "age" of terrorism, and so on.

Thanks in advance.

6 Answers 2014-03-31

Are there instances of failed nationalism throughout history? Cases where nationalism should have arisen but didn't?

I was reading a review of "Inside the Confederate Nation: Essays in Honor of Emory M. Thomas" and the reviewer was noting how the essays expanded on the Confederate's ultimately unsuccessful nationalist movement. It made me wonder how many other groups like the Confederates made up a nationalist movement but, for whatever reason, failed to achieve regular nationalist goals (e.g. self-determination or representation in government).

It would seem like failed nationalism would be a regular occurrence throughout history but I haven't been able to find any decent scholarly background on failed nationalist movements or the theories behind failed nationalism itself. Thoughts?

2 Answers 2014-03-31

How did Italy become such a major player in the world of coffee?

In Europe at least, Italy is famous for its coffee. How and why did the 'Italian' way of enjoying coffee spread across Europe and the world? Why is a country that doesn't produce coffee beans itself deemed an expert, rather than somewhere like Colombia.

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Marshall, allied planning and Normandy

I recently read Ed Cray's bio of George C. Marshall. If it's true that the original Allied plan for WW II was to invade France and destroy Germany's war-making ability, but that this was lead astray by Allied planning that insisted, for various reasons and mostly from the British, on first invading Africa and fighting into Italy, how might events have been different if they had stuck to the plan and invaded France earlier, avoiding the African expedition altogether?

I actually first made this thread on What If but there was a lot of disagreement over why the Allies invaded Africa in the first place and whether a Normandy invasion in '43 would have failed, so I was hoping to get some more professional feedback. I realize I am only portraying Cray's point of view on Allied planning, which suggests Marshall wanting to stick to the France invasion and Churchill constantly leading Allied plans astray.

2 Answers 2014-03-31

What was the prevalent agricultural system in England before the Open field system?

From wiki: "The open-field system appears to have developed to maturity between 850 and 1150 AD in England, although documentation is scarce prior to the Domesday Book of 1086" What was used before this?

Bonus question which I might make its own later: After Rome and before Open Field, how much ancient forest would have been standing? In Ian Mortimer's "Time Traveller's Guide to Medieval England" he states that in the 14th century the level of forest cover would have been about equivalent to what it is today.

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Why the trade of spices and silk was so important?

Honestly, it never made sense to me in economical sense. Trade wars of today concentrate on oil and gas: resources that are important to everyone and are used in a lot of different types of industries.

But how come the spices, tea, silk, and furs which are not really that important in everyday life, became so important? Were they really that big a part of economy? Or the reasons for all that were not economical at all?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Why did the ruling class fight as infantry in Greece, Rome, and Scandinavia, but as cavalry in medieval Europe?

Also, how did cavalry originate as auxiliaries in European warfare, become elite troops, and then become auxiliaries again during the pike and shot era?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Were the spartans that ripped?

Was it possible for the Spartans to be as buff as they are in the movies?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

What exactly makes Neo-Confucianism different, and how did it come about?

Sorry if I should be asking this in a philosophy subreddit or something, I came across the term in class, but we didn't really cover it in much detail. Any sort of introduction would be greatly appreciated, thanks!

EDIT: I mean, what made Neo-Confucianism different from Confucianism. Thanks again.

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Post WWII Japan

I have always heard that Japan denied many of the crimes they committed during WWII, especially in Manchuria. I have also heard that they denied very well recorded incidents, such as the Rape of Nanking. I was wondering if these accusations have any basis in history, or if they are just stereotypes?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

I'm interested in organised crime in the USA from 1900 onward.

Especially the questions how they formed and were structured, and the "mentality" behind them. (i.e. do Italian Mafias really care about "the family" that much etc.)

I'm mostly interested in the Italian, Jewish and Irish crime organisations.

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Did radio have a reputation as being vapid or intellectually detrimental, the way TV does today?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

I only speak English. What is the furthest I could go back in time and still be able to communicate with other English speakers, and where would I have to be?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

Why did the Highland Army have so many problems with desertion upon its return to Scotland?

3 Answers 2014-03-31

What country(s) can claim to have the longest running democracy?

1 Answers 2014-03-31

The Secret History of...

Welcome back to another floating feature!

Inspired by The Secret History of Procopius, let's shed some light on what historical events just didn't make it into the history books for various reasons. The history in this thread may have been censored because it rubbed up against the government or religious agendas of that time, or it may have just been forgotten, but today we get the truth out.

This thread is not the usual AskHistorians style. This is more of a discussion, and moderation will be relaxed for some well-mannered frivolity.

EDIT: This thread was part of April Fool's 2014. Do not write a paper off any of this.

16 Answers 2014-03-31

How high ranking/connected did a WWII German soldier have to be, to know about the holocaust?

2 Answers 2014-03-31

6915 / 7255

Back to start