Mecca and Bakkah

Hey everyone,

In an audio book I was listening to, Tom Holland discusses how Bakkah was likely distinct from Mecca. I wanted to look into it, but a cursory Google search found little.

Was wondering if any early Islam scholars could explain the evidence for this claim (or lack thereof).

Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-03-30

How come Germany got all the blame for WWI when it was Austria-Hungary that started the war when they invaded Serbia?

1 Answers 2014-03-30

How much do we know about the average lives of people in ancient Rome?

What did they eat? Wear? Do? What sort of houses did they live in? Really any detail of what makes up an average day in ancient Rome.

2 Answers 2014-03-30

What would have happened to the surviving crew of Svetlana after Battle of Tsushima (Russo-Japanese war)?

After my grandfather's passing I was looking through his diaries. There I found some notes regarding yacht ship Svetlana, digging more I found out that my great-great grandfather served on it as a cook. Intrigued I contacted my father and he recollected that he did have discussion about same exact topic just prior to grandfather's passing.

The story goes that my ancestor served on a ship Svetlana. He was very critical of war and the way the ship was sent out to its doom. The ship was mostly used by royal family for pleasure and in his words, "not prepared for combat". When Russo-Japanese war broke out Svetlana joined the rest of the navy. During Battle of Tsushima it was lost with about 40% of the crew. What I was able to find out was mostly just stories told by him to my grandfather. They fought till they had no more ammunition, once the ship went under he said that one of the Japanese cruisers approached them and sailed several times through the surviving crew. He lost one of his closest friends, when he disappeared underneath the Japanese ship. He did not talk much about time in Japan's captivity. Again, in his own words there was a happy ending. All in all he spent about 15 years living in Japan, he claimed to have lived in a small village on the shores of Japan, he even became friends with the same men he fought against, supposedly he even had a mistress. In the end he stated that he missed Russia too much and went back.

I would appreciate any and all information about cruiser ship Svetlana you can provide, any sort of information about where the crew may have spent their time and how were they treated. Perhaps even somebody may have came across some documentation mentioning the ship? Thank you.

Photos of Svetlana

Article about Svetlana in English

1 Answers 2014-03-30

If vellum was so expensive in the Middle Ages, why do medieval books have such large blank margins?

1 Answers 2014-03-30

Did any prominent historical figures have any well-defined senses of humor?

2 Answers 2014-03-30

Oliver Stone frequently says 'the Japanese wanted to surrender towards the end of WW2, we didn't want them to so we could have an excuse to use the Atom bomb to scare the Soviets', is this true?

2 Answers 2014-03-30

Why Did Hitler Think Germany Could Build A Bigger War Machine Than The Allies?

1 Answers 2014-03-30

How accurate is 'Vikings' from the history channel?

Also, if anyone knows of a map that shows where the Vikings are attacking to and from that would be interesting to see (even if the show is not all that accurate).

1 Answers 2014-03-30

Considering that USD is a fiat currency, has there ever been a time when the material value of a US coin has exceeded its perceived value?

basically I want to know if it has ever been profitable to melt down coins for material value (regardless of legality)

Edit: I have heard that it costs more to produce pennies than they are worth but I'm not sure if that cost is associated with the material cost or the manufacturing cost

1 Answers 2014-03-30

After the Roman empire acquired Greece and "took inspiration" from their religious entities, in what capacity could the Greeks worship their gods?

I understand the Romans were inspired by the Greek gods, altering names and styles to fit the roman way of worship. I also understand they made illegal certain forms of worship inside their empire. I'm having a hard time finding information about what happened in the Greek temples after that! Was worship of Zeus still acceptable? Was animal sacrifice still alright (in Greece or Rome)?

I understand worship of dionysis was frowned upon. What were the requirements for a religion to be banned in the roman empire?

2 Answers 2014-03-30

Can anyone recommend some good books about ancient The Sumerians? I'm open to anything compelling.

1 Answers 2014-03-30

What would someone from 1714 think of the world as of 2014?

2 Answers 2014-03-30

When did leaders stop being the strongest warrior and why did this happen?

1 Answers 2014-03-30

Was drug abuse an issue in the Greek and Roman times? Did they have any laws regulating drug consumption?

Also, were drugs a luxury item for the rich, or were they more commonly abused by the poor? What kind of drugs were available?

7 Answers 2014-03-30

Was Babe Ruth really as great as he is made out to be?

I was watching Ken Burn's Baseball on Netflix and they have a part where Ray Chapman is killed by a baseball in 1920. This ushered in the new rule that any dirty ball is immediately replaced. This also meant the pitcher gave up a lot of control of a ball BECAUSE it was dirty and scuffed. THEN Babe Ruth just happens to show up on the Yankees in 1920 and seem like the greatest slugger ever.

2 Answers 2014-03-30

Can you help me with the 1800s in regards to foreign affairs?

So I'm in an experimental class which has a really big impact on my future. We have to write blog posts analyzing cited information that has to do with certain time periods and topics. My topic is Foreign Affairs, and I am unable to find anything my teacher finds "Worthy." I really, really need help. Last week I made a 60 for a quiz grade by writing about the effects the Louisiana purchase had on American foreign affairs because it wasn't "quirky" or "Interesting" enough.

So my question, Do you know of any interesting documents that I could use for the 1800s in regards to foreign affairs? I would appreciate it.

I was initially going to write about how treaties tended to have secret tag-along treaties, but wasn't able to find any usable information because I couldn't find anything to cite.

1 Answers 2014-03-30

Was allied-occupied Vienna as shady as it was in "The Third Man"?

In "The Third Man" it seemed like almost every other person was involved in something shady, especially racketeering. Ordinary people avoided dealing with law enforcement. When Holly discovers what Harry Lime is in trouble for, he seems to be the only character who was genuinely shocked by the inhumanity of Harry's crime. Were things really this bad, or was it exaggerated in the name of film noir?

1 Answers 2014-03-30

What did people call World War 1 before World War 2 happened?

1 Answers 2014-03-30

Before the invention of toilet paper and wet wipes, how did humans cleanse themselves after using the restroom?

I assume taking poops was an entirely new ballgame, not so much enjoyed as it is today.

1 Answers 2014-03-29

Bataan Death March survivor?

1 Answers 2014-03-29

Starting Medieval History how?

How would I start to learn about Medieval History? What books should I buy?

5 Answers 2014-03-29

Why didn't president Eisenhower make bigger strides to stop Joe McCarthy?

I'm open to hear any interpretations!

1 Answers 2014-03-29

Why does it seem that the Roman persecution of Christians was so often haphazard, goal-less and poorly directed?

As a layperson and not a historian, it seems to me that the methods of persecution just seem completely ineffective and laughable.

This is Rome we're talking about, an empire that could field several armies at once at four different corners of the continent. And even the most anti-Christian emperors such as Decius II and Diocletian couldn't come up with a coherent way to stamp out a tiny sect that almost everyone disliked? How hard could it have really been to deal with such a small and powerless minority?

Note: I understand and can excuse the poor effectiveness of persecutions by some emperors. Nero, for example, just wanted a scapegoat to momentarily distract the angry crowds. But I feel that some of the more dedicated anti-Christian emperors (such as the two I mentioned above) should have been intelligent enough to design more effective methods.

Maybe I'm simplifying this too much. In which case, please enlighten me. Thank you.

2 Answers 2014-03-29

To what extent was the early Rastafari movement influenced by Hinduism?

There are several (apparent) similarities between Indian Sadhus and early rastafarians, such as the dreadlocks, vegetarianism, and spiritual use of cannabis. Why is this?

1 Answers 2014-03-29

6921 / 7255

Back to start