How does Steven Runciman's "A History of the Crusades" hold up today?

I enjoy his three volumes and reread them every so often, but they are more than half a century old. So how do current historians view his work? Has later research shown any of his facts to be inaccurate? Are any of his points of view or interpretations outside the current mainstream?

2 Answers 2014-03-26

How has Hitler's "Mein Kampf" been used by historians? How has it been misused by others?

I saw something today about Mein Kampf going into public domain soon, and concerns that it would be misued. It got me to thinking: it's book is written by one of history's most notorious figures and its most influential leaders. It's an insight into his mind before the Holocaust, before invading Poland, before even he became Chancellor. It talks about the plans he would later put into terrible effect. The book must have been a goldmine for WWII historians, right? What parts were they able to use as a historical document and was anything simply too biased? Also, how have people misused it, and how will that be different when the copyright expires? (If that's not against the no current events rule.)

1 Answers 2014-03-26

What was Christianity's influence on Women's Rights?

I read a post on Reddit not too long ago regarding how Paul actually opened the door for women's rights in Ancient Greece. I can't find the comment. Is this true?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

What are the other Holy books mentioned in the Qur'an?

In the Qur'an there are 5 holy books mentioned.

Qur'an Injiil Tawrat Zabur Sukhuf

To some degree I am aware that injiil is the bible and Tawrat is the old testament. My question is,what book is Zabur and Sukhuf? Also why are they almost unknown compared to the other three?

Edit:Tawrat correct spelling is Torah..

1 Answers 2014-03-26

How did we come to have a near universal mathematical system, yet tens of hundreds of languages?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

What were the greatest successes, challenges, and impacts today of nationalism in Russia?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

Was homosexuality more prevalent during the World Wars?

During the World Wars, many spouses were split up. Men were often in tight quarters with each other, often not seeing women for long periods of time. Women often worked in factories alongside one another and in many countries most eligible men were at war. This leads me to believe that human urges took over and more homosexuality occurred during the World Wars. I can't seem to find much on this though. Does my hunch have any truth to it?

2 Answers 2014-03-25

What do you think is most strategically impressive battle of all time?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

People often believe that video games are bad for you. But has there been any other media that has caused a moral panic in recorded history?

Often I hear people think that video games are bad for children. Causing violence and addiction or other behavior issues. I would like to know if there has been similar accusations in earlier media in previous history?

7 Answers 2014-03-25

How accurate was the 2004 film "The Alamo"?

I have a decent amount of knowledge about the history of the Alamo, but I was wondering if any experts could shed some light on the most recent film for me. I know that it is far more accurate than the 1960 version.

A few specific questions:

The defenders are portrayed as mostly struggling to put up a fight. Was this done accurately or did they actually manage to fight even less in the battle?

The relationship between William Travis and Jim Bowie. Are any specific showdowns or tensions between them proven? In the film, there is even somewhat of a reconciliation. Is there any proof of that?

Sam Houston's delay. Did the film portray his reasons accurately?

And if there are any other ways the film was inaccurate, I'd like to know what insight you have. Mainly because I base all of my assumptions of the conflict from the film.

1 Answers 2014-03-25

How many people were liberated from Nazi concentration camps at the close of WWII?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

Origin of the Lenin's and Stalin's nom de Guerra? At what point and why did they change their names from Ulyanov and Dzhugashvili to Lenin and Stalin?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

What are some good books (or possibly essays)on the civil war, written in the last 10-12 years?

Hi! This is my first time asking a question here. I am a huge fan of history, especially the civil war. I have seen you have a great wealth of information about the civil war and slavery, and I guess this is a rather specific question. I am writing a research paper on the causes of the war and much to my dismay my professor said she would prefer if the majority of my sources were from the last 10 to 12 years. The great majority of the books I have were left to me by my grandfather, The Negro's Civil War by James Mcpherson, The Angry Scar by Hodding Carter, Battle Cry of Freedom of course and a few others I can't remember right now. I do have access to an academic search through my college but its a bit of a chore to navigate and i would much rather hear from you! So please what are some good, reputable sources on the civil war from the last decade or so?

2 Answers 2014-03-25

Why was French the lingua franca?

My history teacher told me that French used to be the global lingua franca and language of diplomacy. Was this because France was very powerful (Napoleon?), and when did people start using English instead?

3 Answers 2014-03-25

Why didn't the US join the League of Nations?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

In Anglo-Saxon England, would people distinguish between Angles, Saxons and Jutes? When did this distinction disappear?

2 Answers 2014-03-25

Has it ever happened in history that a region wanted to break away from a country, and this country was generally OK with it, with the two states immediately establishing friendly diplomatic relations?

Edit: these are some good and interesting answers. Thanks!

4 Answers 2014-03-25

What were medieval and classical dog breeds like compared to ours? Many different ones?

What were dog "breeds" like 500 years ago? I have read about the explosion of dog breeds in the 1800's (especially late 1800's), and have seen that most modern dog breeds are about 150 years old, though some are closer to 500 years old. In the 1500's or 1400's, were there different (fewer?) breeds, or where there just a handful of different types? And if you go back to the Middle Ages or Classical Antiquity, were dog breeds very different at all? Would we recognize them as similar to some of ours?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

What are some notable trends in hairstyles in different cultures throughout history?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

What did pre-scientific plant and animal breeders think that they were doing?

Humans have been using artificial selection to create new breeds of plants and animals for as long as we know, even if we have only very recently come to understand the science behind it.

Do we know what they understood about what they were doing? Did they have any explanations for why some characteristics were hereditary and others were not?

3 Answers 2014-03-25

At the beginning of WWI, why was the German army so much more professional/organized/effective than the French or English armies?

2 Answers 2014-03-25

Do historians believe that Jesus declared himself to be the son of god/divine?

I know that most historians believe in a historical Jesus. Is there a consensus on what this person may have preached?

Do most historians believe that Jesus declared himself to be some sort of divinity/son of god?

-Edit-

This is what I found on wikipedia: there's a "consensus of sorts" on Jesus existing, getting baptized, debating with authorities, being seen as a healer, teaching some people, gathering a following, and being crucified.

Do historians agree on this basic outline?

Do historians have any good guesses about what the historical Jesus preached?

3 Answers 2014-03-25

German POWs Receiving College Credit

So, I was on wikipedia today, and saw in the "did you know" section that German POWs at Camp Aliceville in Alabama during WWII had to opportunity to take college classes taught on site by professors from the University of Alabama, and that the credits were accepted by the Third Reich's Ministry of Education accepted the credits.

So, my question is this: how was this managed logistically? How did the University of Alabama get in contact with the MoE to negotiate this, and how did the transcripts get sent back to Germany so that they could be given credit back home?

As a side question, are there any other situations like this WWII (or any modern conflict), or is this unique?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2014-03-25

How did English vowels sound before the Great Vowel Shift?

I was reading this thread asking if Modern and Early English speakers would be able to understand each other, and also read the section about the evolution of languages in the FAQ, and it got me wondering, what did English sound like before the great vowel shift, or indeed, how did Early and Middle English sound compared to Modern English? And how can we know what they sounded like, without recordings?

3 Answers 2014-03-25

What is the history of terrorism? Where did it originate and when?

1 Answers 2014-03-25

6939 / 7255

Back to start