Hello everybody,
This is a question that has been on my mind for quite some time. The Wikipedia article goes into some detail about the Oder-Neisse line, but doesn't really cover the other transfer of territory that took place. I'm referring to the territory annexed by the Soviet Union as seen on this map. The amount of land transferred, along with how this redefined Poland, was huge. Furthermore if I am not mistaken, there were areas transferred where the majority of the population was Polish. So what was the reaction (both inside and outside Poland) to such a big change?
Many thanks in advance for your replies.
1 Answers 2014-03-19
1 Answers 2014-03-19
A redditor made an off-hand comment that:
"[The Roman's would] separate the men from the women (at least the younger women), move all the men to other parts of the empire and then move Roman men in to the conquered settlements to breed new Romans. This system was ignored in later centuries and has been blamed for the fall of the western empire. The Germans that entered the Empire were never culturally shattered in the same way leading to kingdoms within the empire."
Is there any truth to this claim? To what extent?
4 Answers 2014-03-19
The picture with the country/province encircled
This is a picture from my history class book (dutch). It is about the US foreign policy after ww2. I understand the division of post ww2 Germany, but i have never heard of the (encircled) area on the map. Was it a province of France or a previously annexed country? I have never seen or heard (in special) about this area. If anyone could tell me more (in addition to my question), that would be greatly appreciated.
1 Answers 2014-03-19
A "NASA-funded study examined the "falls" of various empires throughout history to identify certain factors that led to major instability, and has also identified those factors today, with limited specifics. Factors include things like overuse of resources and large income disparities.
While this doesn't strike me as obviously completely wrong, the only empire they mention that I know anything about is Rome, and I think of income disparity as more of a problem that undermined the Republic rather than the Empire, though I don't know enough to be confident in that opinion. Can you give me a little more of an idea of what was going on during the end of any of these empires?
2 Answers 2014-03-19
This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.
2 Answers 2014-03-19
I'm not talking about roll playing questions like "I'm a Roman latrine cleaner, what is my quality of life?" But stuff like this which got quickly downvoted. Upon reading it, I had a number of uncharitable thoughts, before I realized OP really was asking a valid question. Given that, I answered to the best of my ability and started hating whatever education system failed to adequately prepare someone to be able to answer what to most of us here should be a simple answer.
There are truly stupid questions out there, but there are a number that look bad, but should be answered and treated as valid, even if on the surface it appears stupid or offensive.
5 Answers 2014-03-19
8 Answers 2014-03-19
2 Answers 2014-03-19
This is a repost from [/r/AskReddit/] (http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/)
Im doing a bit of research for a History of Film essay. Im trying to determine at what point we realised there was no breathable air on the moon. Just to give you some context for this question, Im comparing George Mieles Voyage Dans la Lune and Duncan Jones' Moon. Im looking at Costume, Set design and representation of the moon and space. So I thought I'd see at what point we realised you couldn't breathe on the moon, as for those that don't know, in Voyage Dans la Lune, the astronauts are able to breathe on the moons surface and even encounter some aliens.
In the previous post it was advised I come and speak to some experts to determine at what point we all were aware that we could not breathe on the moon.
1 Answers 2014-03-19
I go to a private christian school, unfortunately, and my religion teacher insists that America was founded on christian principals. I tried to explain to her that she was wrong but, as expected, I was told to shut my mouth.
1 Answers 2014-03-19
How did the French Revolution and Napoleonic Wars affect France and Spain's overseas empire?
I was thinking that these events destabilized France/Spain and also pitted them against Great Britain, which had a large navy.
What areas did France/Spain lose? What parts of their overseas empire were they able to hold onto, and why?
Was anything returned to France/Spain after the Bourbons were restored?
2 Answers 2014-03-19
Is there still a lot of support from the people of Argentina to annex the Falklands? What were the repercussions of Argentina losing the conflict?
1 Answers 2014-03-19
Seeing as aiding Italy in Greece pushed back the timetable for Barbaross by several months, how come Germany didn't delay until next year when the time was right?
1 Answers 2014-03-19
Based on the work, organization and success they did
1 Answers 2014-03-19
1 Answers 2014-03-19
I know there are many people, including college professors, who believe that it never happened or that it was greatly exaggerated. If so many people believe this, there must be some compelling evidence. I'd like to look at the evidence of both sides so I can make my own opinion. I looked this question up online but I couldn't find any good answers. So if someone could give me evidence for both sides of the argument I would greatly appreciate it. Sorry if this question offends anyone.
2 Answers 2014-03-19
6 Answers 2014-03-19
This is something I have always wondered about.
1 Answers 2014-03-19
I was watching an old tv show and it showed a woman in the late 1800s or so out on the farm, running from a boar, when she tripped over her skirt. It got me wondering why women traditionally wore (and still wear) skirts and dresses, but especially in historical times? I can think of very few pre-modern activities in which wearing a long skirt would be advantageous - hunting, riding a horse, farming, running from a wild animal... Why didn't both sexes' fashion evolve to wear pants?
6 Answers 2014-03-19
1 Answers 2014-03-19
I notice that all images of the past have these very somber-looking people. I understand painted portraits of royalty, wanting to showcase themselves as regal and a force to be reckoned with etc etc... But what about the regular people who got portraits done with their families that we see? There never seem to be any smiling faces. Whereas now - and for as long back as I've seen (pictures of my parents, and even grandparents) - people smile in photographs. You're TOLD to smile for pictures.
Was getting a picture taken not a happy occasion? Were smiles considered frivolous things to waste on such an expensive thing? I'm very curious, and would love to hear your insight.
1 Answers 2014-03-19
To provide some background, this question is based on the game Crusader Kings 2 where a war over a territory can end if the defending ruler dies, even if the attacker is heavily favored in the "war score".
So as a secondary question, are there any examples of emperors/kings/dukes/counts who died while defending against an invasion and the attacker stopping their invasion?
1 Answers 2014-03-19
I read an article about pirates raiding Egypt from 1287-1102 BCE (or something along those lines, specifics arent relevant to my question) but who decided what year to start counting down from, were records actually kept this way or do people try to create timelines and fit them into it? When they say the copper age in Asia was 4500 BCE and the bronze age was 3500 BCE were they actively counting down on their records as well? Is it the same exact 4500 BCE in Europe? What was Asia counting down for- if it is the case. If its not the case then when did the world get on the same page with what year it is (I know some places still arent but when did the majority)
1 Answers 2014-03-19