Author Tom Holland argues that it was not our Greco-Roman western heritage that lead to liberal values, but Christianity, and that the ancient world was notably cruel. Do historians mostly agree with this stance?

2 Answers 2022-10-31

How have cultures adapted warfare to regions of heavy rainfall?

Specifically, how did pre-industrial societies adapt in their armor, arms, and practices to mitigate the problems of heavy rainfall? Are there any examples of armor or equipment designed to deflect rain or deal with high humidity environments generally?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Is Ernst Kantorowicz’s biography of Holy Roman Emperor Friedrich II (1927) considered trustworthy and credible by contemporary historians of the Middle Ages?

I’ve just purchased it, and I’m fascinated by the man, but I don’t know how much has changed in the scholarship over the last 95 years.

1 Answers 2022-10-31

At the end of the 2022 movie adaption of All Quiet On The Western Front an unnamed German general sends his troops into a suicidal attack against French forces out of sheer spite, only hours before the war ends. Did such an attack or such attacks really happen during the last hours of WW1?

3 Answers 2022-10-31

Why did the Nazis Choose the so called 'final solution' over the 'madagascar plan'?

The Nazis were of course, without need to say so, among some of the most evil people to ever live, but I can't help but ask myself, why did they choose the greater of two evils?

Why did they choose to kill? Just so many people? On an industrial scale, I just can't understand it, it's, incalculably unfathomable and shocking how and why a person or group of people could be so evil.

Edit, apologies, my question was based on a faulty premise, the Madagascar plan would have been just as lethal as what the Nazis ended up doing, Reddit mods I shall delete upon request if you deem it necessary.

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Why didn’t the ancient Egyptians mint coins?

I read the first coin minted in Egypt was 360 BC by Egyptian rebels against Persia. Coins were invented in 650 BC in Lydia.

In the intervening period the Greeks were making drachmas and the Persians making darics.

Presumably during this period (650-360 BC) the ancient Egyptians were using foreign coin?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Until recently left handedness was considered an ailment but now (at least in the west) it isn't. What forces caused it to be more accepted? Did the concept of left handedness being bad just fizzle out or was it an active de-stigmatization process by pediatricians and activists?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Why was Franz Ferdinand assassinated and why did people think that that would free Bosnia?

" The political objective of the assassination was to free Bosnia and Herzegovina of Austria-Hungarian rule and establish a common South Slav ("Yugoslav") state. "

I don't understand how an assassination would help establish a state. Can anyone explain?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

How did one become an archer in ancient armies?

Medieval and beyond combat appears especially brutal, maybe even more before the advent of plate armor. Being an archer, at least at face value, seems like it would have kept you somewhat safer because you're not guaranteed a position in the melee.

Was this a coveted position in different armies, and how did one get the chance to be an archer as opposed to an infantryman?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Before Christianity's growth, what did cults/religions that were obvious money- or power-making schemes look like?

Many modern, Western cults that are obvious scams imitate Christianity in that their leader claims to be the son of God, God himself, or both. I'm curious how the leaders of these schemes gained followers at the time. Were there even any "scam cults" at all at the time, or did most every religious leader (apart from god-kings) truly believe in their beliefs?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

How common were out-of-wedlock births in early-1300s England?

Last night I was watching a "Lucy Worsley Investigates" on the Black Death. To humanize the event, she followed a family (using the Court Records of the time), and specifically a woman within the family.

Before the plague, the woman was fined for an out-of-wedlock birth, and then married off not long after. During the plague, all the woman's male relatives died, as did her husband. After, she inherited all their land, and lived into her 60s, never marrying again. It was presented as kind of a "she started on bottom and ended up on top!" type of narrative.

I was left wondering how "scandalous" the woman's out-of-wedlock birth was. Obviously it's something discouraged (hence the fine), but in her community of approximately 1,200 people (pre-pandemic), would this have been something that happened multiple times a year? Once a year? Once every few years?

(I am also assuming the rate of out-of-wedlock births would be rather lower than out-of-wedlock pregnancies, and that if the mother was married between conception and birth it was considered acceptable and not fined. Is this a valid assumption?)

1 Answers 2022-10-31

How did Benjamin West paint Christ rejected? The technical side?

I was at a wedding this weekend at the Pennsyvania Academy of Fine Arts. There's an outstanding 16'x10' painting of Christ before a rabbi and a mass of people being rejected and turned over to Pontius Pilate. I know the general bible story.

Here's my question. This paint is huge. If you look at the dates, Benjamin West was 80 when he painted. I could not attempt to do something that size due to a lot of logistical limitations.

It raises the questions:

  • Where did he get the canvas for this? (My guess, sailmakers?)
  • How did he paint this? Wall of a barn with scaffolding? A giant floor in sections?
  • How did he light this to paint it? This is not long after the revolutionary war. I'm thinking candles or oil lamps.
  • There are 93 (my count) portraits in this painting. I'm wondering if anyone has identified a self-portrait.
  • Did he have a bunch of (young) assistants painting sections?
  • This painting was taken from place to place as a backdrop to speeches. Rolled? Folded?
  • And finally, it's in great condition abet the size makes it impossible to view anything above eye level closely. Has this painting spent a bunch of time in restoration?

Thanks!

2 Answers 2022-10-31

How were the conditions of African slavery and black discrimination in Spanish colonial America?

Doing a lesson for my class tomorrow that touches on Maroon communities in Spanish Florida in the 1700s. The Wiki article on the topic states the following:

Under Spanish, colonial rule the enslaved in Florida had rights. They could marry, own property, and purchase their own freedom. Free blacks, as long as they were Catholic, were not subject to legal discrimination. No one was born into slavery. Mixed "race" marriages were not illegal, and mixed "race" children could inherit property. This was "unthinkable" in the United States.

Beyond the generous use of "quotations marks," this statement is cited with Matthew Calvin's Battle of Negro Fort and a WaPo Article that simply discusses how slavery existed in what is now the US prior to 1619.

The "no one was born into slavery" remark is especially hanging me up. How much validity is there to that statement?

For fear of misinterpreting the situation, what legal protections or discrimination did people of African descent - free and enslaved - face in Spanish colonies at large? And in Florida? I know that the Spanish crown under King Charles II offered asylum for fugitive slaves escaping from French and British colonies, but the details surrounding that are still murky to me. Did colonial Spain really grant that much more equality to African descendents as early as the 1600s?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

What was the relationship between the Jutes and the Anglo-Saxons during the Danish invasions of the 800's?

The Jutes are oft overlooked when talking about the Germanic settlement of England, but they hailed from Denmark proper just as the Viking invaders did. Additionally, they were directly adjacent to Wessex, so were there strained relations or fears that they might ally with the Danes? Were they considered fellow countrymen?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Is this photo genuine? Was there really a black member of the nazi party?

https://i.ibb.co/MGtkxHf/Screenshot-20221007-153454.png

1 Answers 2022-10-31

The new weekly theme is: Halloween!

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Partition of India: Why was Bangladesh (East Pakistan) not given independence in the first place, and what role the the British play in the whole story?

Partition of India is very bloody, so is Pakistan's suppression of East Pakistan. Here comes the questions:

  1. Why was Bangladesh given to Pakistan in the first place? Didn't the British know in the beginning that Pakistan could not rule it properly (owing to ethnic and geographic problems)?
  2. What was Britain's role and goal in the Partition? The British knew India could not be kept as imperial possession anyway, so what interest did they want to secure in this partition? Was it their major goal to avoid ethnic and religious wars (which seemed inevitable despite best efforts)?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Why does so much black plague literature focus on Medieval Europe? Everything I read mentions China or Mongolia as backdrop then focuses almost exclusively on Europe.

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Why did the United Kingdom willingly transfer so many island colonies to Australia between 1914 and 1958?

Australia has 7 external territories (all small island groups), 6 of which were transferred from the UK to Australia after Australian independence in 1901:

  1. Norfolk Island in 1914
  2. Australian Antarctic Territory in 1933
  3. Ashmore and Cartier Islands in 1934
  4. Heard Island and McDonald Islands in 1947
  5. Cocos (Keeling) Islands in 1955
  6. Christmas Island in 1958

All of these seem to have been willingly offered by the UK to Australia. Why would the UK willingly give up so much land? My first assumption was that the territories were too far away to be viable, but that can't be the sole explanation because:

  1. The UK has kept far more remote and unproductive colonies to this day (e.g. St. Helena, Ascension, and Tristan da Cunha; Pitcairn Islands; and South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands).
  2. Specifically for Antarctica, the UK kept part of their claim (British Antarctic Territory) implying that they found it useful, but then for some reason decided to cede some of it to Australia (today called the Australian Antarctic Territory)

2 Answers 2022-10-31

Hello? I would like to get a help in something...

you see, I've been doing some little project, and i need some information sources for 2 themes:

  1. Teutonic Order in Eastern Europe
  2. Beginning of Polish kingdom (900 ABC - ...)

I'll be very grateful

1 Answers 2022-10-31

To what extent were Union soldiers really fighting to end slavery?

I've read some commentary on this topic suggesting that many, if not most, Union soldiers were motivated to fight in the Civil War because they wanted to end slavery. But this analysis doesn't entirely make sense to me when considering the Draft Riots, in which Black people suffered violent reprisals from people who were being forced to fight ostensibly to end slavery; the high number of Northern white working class votes for Horatio Seymour in 1868; and the general prevailing racial attitudes toward Black people in the North and West. Was the motivation based more on economic factors from a "free soil" perspective to end competition from enslaved labor, or were they actually motivated by moral reasons to end slavery?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Are there any primary source records about Jesus’ resurrection or miracles other than the Bible?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

What became of the trenches after World War 1 ended on the Western Front? Did they fill them in and clean them up, or just leave them alone?

2 Answers 2022-10-31

Why did European swords tend to be straight while Asian (Middle East, Steppes, south and Southeast Asia, even Japan slightly) tend to favor curbed swords?

I know both straight and curved swords were used everywhere, but it seems that generally Europeans favored straights swords while Asia went with curved swords. Even the katana is slightly curved.

1 Answers 2022-10-31

Why was (is?) the western canon so nostalgic for the late 19th century?

From Walt Disney's "Main Street USA," to the collective french reminiscing of the "Belle Epoque," is there any sociological consensus on the rose-tinted view of the late 19th century?

From where did it emerge? When did it emerge? And when did it disappear?

1 Answers 2022-10-31

70 / 7255

Back to start