At the end of "Hamilton: An American Musical", Jefferson says "(Hamilton's) financial system is a work of genius. I couldn’t undo it if I tried... And I tried". Does this refer to specific failed financial reforms during Jefferson's Presidency?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Ross Douthat argues that the modern welfare state exists because popes and Catholic statesmen in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. How much truth is there to that? Does the marginalization of Catholics at that time in American political life explain America’s rather weak welfare state?

I paraphrased what he said from the Ezra Klein show episode 336.

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Why is Ireland not part of the United Kingdom?

Since I was a child I wondered why is Ireland not part of the U.K. or why are there two Irelands, but since I am from latinamerica none of my questions were answered at school (since it had nothing to do with the history of my country).

I've seen many memes and jokes about Ireland hating Northern Ireland and vice versa, so I was curious of why.

2 Answers 2021-05-15

Why did the Khmer Empire collect human gallbladders?

So the Chinese diplomat Zhou Daguan relates that in the Khmer Empire,

“In times gone by, (...) collection of gall took place. The king of Champa annually exacted a large jar filled with thousands and thousands of human gall bladders. In dead of night men were stationed here and there in the more frequented parts of cities and villages. When they met people walking by night they threw over their heads a hood gathered together by a cord and with a small knife removed the gall bladder low down on the right side. (...) Only recently this practice of gathering gall was abandoned (...).”

Why did this practice take place? Why did Champa demand human gallbladders from the Khmer Empire?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

What are the origins of the trope of Russia and China relying on overwhelming numbers in battle?

Is this perception in American media (especially video games) the result of German accounts of WW2 and American accounts of the Korean War or is there a longer history to this stereotype?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Do we have an idea what the carthaginian architecture was like in Carthage itself and in the colonies (Sicily, Spain etc.)? Was it hellenistic, or more phoenician/middle eastern?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Early KKK in the North

Looking for resources about the earliest evidence of the Ku Klux Klan in northern states. Did chapters appear after the Civil War, or more in the 1920s with the KKK's resurgence? Thanks.

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Recommended reading for Lebensraum?

Hello, got an assignment coming up and I'm choosing to do a question about what policies the Nazi's implemented in order to achieve/work towards Lebensraum.

Of course the topic comes up in pretty much all histories discussing German policy in the East, but I was wondering if anyone had any particular recommendations on texts that deal specifically with Lebensraum and German deportation, resettlement etc in the East?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-05-15

How and why did red become the color of the left-wing and blue the color of the right-wing?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

WW2: Why did the Nazis continue to spend resources on the death camps, even as the Allies were closing in and resources and manpower were desperately needed?

They used up fuel to transport prisoners to the camps in the first place, then again as they moved them away from the advancing Allies. Why not just leave them behind, and use all those soldiers for actual fighting?

I've seen an account that insists that the Nazis sped up the Holocaust as things got more and more dire. As bad as things were towards the end, why did they remain hyper-focused on extermination?

2 Answers 2021-05-15

Did English Catholicism naturally die out after the conversion to Protestantism or were there ever any surviving communities who remained Anglo Saxon Catholics? Is there any such thing as an indigenous English Catholic community or after a certain point were all Catholics just Irish Celtic heritage?

Never really understood this. Whenever in England there's any discussion about Catholics its kind of implicit that the Irish community is being discussed. For example the historical discrimination in England against Catholic people is tied up with ethnicity (Irish Celtic).

So does this mean Anglo-Saxon Catholicism was totally wiped out starting with Henry VII attacking it and eventually the Dissolution of the Monasteries etc etc and all of that?

Was there actually some intangible point (but a real one) where Anglo-Saxon Catholicism simply no longer existed in England, and to be Anglo-Saxon meant to be Anglican?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Why wernt people like Tycho Brahe and Johannes Kepler prosecuted by the Catholic Church like Galileo or Bruno?

I was wondering why Tycho Brahe and Johannes Kepler weren’t prosecuted by the Catholic Church like many other astronomers of their time. I tried searching this question up on google to find no helpful articles. Does anyone know?

3 Answers 2021-05-15

A lot is said about when Europeans came to the Americas they carried diseases such as smallpox that greatly affected the native population. Was there a similar effect on Europeans with diseases that originated in the New World?

The quick population decay in a lot of native groups in different parts of the Americas are attributed among other things to diseases brought over by Europeans. but I haven't seen or heard much about American diseases affecting Europeans. Were there no rapidly spreading diseases in the Americas at the time? Or maybe it was related to advances in Western medicine?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Is there any evidence that thinkers in ancient Rome or Greece postulated what life would be like thousands of years into the future? What did they say about how they expected humanity to be living in our modern times?

2 Answers 2021-05-15

How were converts to Judaism treated during the Holocaust?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Why are the Diadochi so lesser known throughout history and the mainstream public? Everyone has heard of Alexander the Great but why are Ptolemy I Soter or Seleucus I Nicator overlooked? Both helped start dynasties/empires that lasted for centuries. What do historians make of this?

2 Answers 2021-05-15

Who started the system of AD and BC? And if Christ was born in 4 BC how were 1,2 and 3 BC still before Christ? How did the use of AD and BC become so widespread?1

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Has anyone read the book "Making the Arab World: Nasser, Qutb, and the Clash That Shaped the Middle East"? Would you recommend it?

Hello,

I am trying to get into the history of the Middle East outside of a cursory knowledge of it. In this, I want to start through Nasser. Would you therefore recommend this book to a beginner?

Some of the comments mention that it is hard to follow through mentioning little-known figures in large detail, and does not detail the history of major parties during that time. Can anyone confirm this?

Thank you

1 Answers 2021-05-15

What did Helen Keller think of "The Miracle Worker?"

It would have been produced about 8 years before her death. Was she aware it existed? Did she have any thoughts on it? How would a blind and deaf person witness a play in that day and age?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

The Czechoslovakian Socialist Republic did not change its flag after adopting socialism, unlike the rest of the eastern bloc. Why is this the case?

Was noticing that all the Soviet states and satellite states all seemed to have changed their flag to have some form of socialist iconography. Czechoslovakia seems to be the exception. Why is this the case?

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Who occupied the land that is occupied by Palestiniens and Jews today, first?

Hi!

So as someone looking from the outside and would like to be more educated on the topic, I’m curious to know, if any historian knows what this answer is.

As everyone has said and even after trying to find info (maybe someone can put me in the right direction) it always seems there’s a sort of bias depending on the outlet. Not all of course but I’m not well versed to know what’s what.

So if someone is nice enough to help me answer my question I’d appreciate it!

Tl;dr who occupied the land first out of curiosity and what are some great sources or subreddits that give factual historical information

1 Answers 2021-05-15

What kind of the arms and armour were used in Ancient India (before 800AD)?

Was armour even used by common soldiers? Which type of bows were used? Was horse archery ever a thing? Until when were the chariots used? If elephants were not effective then why were they used so commonly?

I have so many questions, answer to any one of them is appreciable.

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Why did Brezhnev withdraw Soviet military forces from Czechoslovakia after negotiations with Dubcek during the Prague Spring?

In late July and early August 1968 a Czechoslovak delegation led by Alexander Dubček met with Soviet and other Warsaw Pact delegations to negotiate over the Prague Spring reforms. The Warsaw Pact leaders felt that any liberalization in Czechoslovakia could threaten the military and strategic position of the Pact against the West in the Cold War. As I understand, this was their primary concern. So why did Brezhnev then compromise and willingly weaken the Pact's strategic position by withdrawing Soviet troops from Czechoslovakia? That seems to me like the last thing he should have compromised on, even if he believed it would only be temporary, and it seems like after that the invasion was inevitable. According to Wikipedia, "The KSČ delegates reaffirmed their loyalty to the Warsaw Pact" during this meeting as well. How does that mesh with asking Soviet troops to withdraw? Should Brezhnev have not simply refused to withdraw troops and instead compromised in another area? It seems like he wasn't negotiating from an especially weak position. Especially considering that there was still a substantial anti-reformist wing of the KSČ.

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Since when the west has been eating Bread? Where and how would they find Yeast to bake it??

1 Answers 2021-05-15

Learning about history

Hello everybody, i always liked learning about history but the country im from only teach us a little bit about it, so my question is if i wanted to start learning history where should i start? Like what era was the first, i wanna learn about all of history and i dont mind buying books but i just dont know where to start

1 Answers 2021-05-15

706 / 7255

Back to start