Is it true that Lincoln doesn’t deserve to be called the Great Emancipator. He really didn’t care about the morality of slavery, and he only freed the slaves so that the North would win the war.

How did Lincoln’s views on slavery change? Did political and social forces push him towards emancipation? Did ethical and moral concerns influence Lincoln, or did he issue the Emancipation Proclamation only out of wartime expediency? Should the reasons motivating emancipation matter to how we evaluate Lincoln as a leader?

I read the 1st and 2nd inaugural and the proclamation, to me Lincoln personally favors abolition, but he freed the slaves as a military tactic so that slaves can fight for the Union army.

2 Answers 2014-02-22

Compared to the vast the majority of colonies granted independence by Britain in the 20th century, how did Ireland so quickly become a prosperous 1st world country whereas many of the other former colonies are still 3rd or 2nd world nations?

First of all, I know 1st, 2nd, and 3rd world countries are outdated terms, but it's the best way I could convey what I was trying to ask.

Ireland's rise to economic success (we'll just ignore the recent recession for now) just seems out of line with that of a former British colony. Especially given that it was a small island with few natural resources to speak of, a long history of oppression by the British, and even after independence, Britain was Ireland's main trading partner.

And when you factor in a population cut in half by the Great Famine and a long tradition of emigration even after independence, it just doesn't make sense - even though I've studied the history books on this topic.

Now, I'm well aware that Ireland didn't become truly prosperous until the 1990's, but the rate at which it climbed to the top tiers of GDP and economic success is still rather startling for a nation not even 100 years old.

2 Answers 2014-02-22

Can someone explain to me the contradictory context of the song "Kill The Boer" And why it is still sung today?

Since Mandela died I've been occasionally looking up South African stuff from the 90's. I was born in 1992 so I don't have any memory of what was going on, but the videos are very confusing. The Kill The Boer song I know springs from colonialism, but its current use seems so contradictory. I see South African Flags, Communist Flags, people calling for white genocide wearing Mandela's face on a shirt, White people marching with black people while they all sing the song, people with large amounts of guns, and from the documentary I watched on PBS Mandela was arming people from the beginning for a violent revolution. Yet... the world heralds him as a man of peace and equality? I'm really very confused. Can someone explain the whole picture to me? I'm sure there is something getting lost between cultures, but I'm not sure what.

1 Answers 2014-02-22

House reps who voted against US entry into WWI?

Does anyone know the names of the members of the house of reps who voted against US entry into World war one? If so, please list their names. Thanks :)

1 Answers 2014-02-22

Why did the United States abandon its isolationist stance in the 1890s? What were the changes in U.S. foreign policy?

2 Answers 2014-02-22

Has the taboo around children's knowledge of sex existed forever, and if not, when and why did it emerge?

EDIT: Wow! This has exploded! Thanks for all the brilliant answers.

3 Answers 2014-02-22

Did there ever exist swordsmen that were of a near legendary caliber?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

What is the history of the bandanna as seen in the American West?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

Did any army have rules / laws dealing specifically with murder of troops on the same side?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

What exactly -was- the involvement of non-Europeans in the trans-Atlantic slave trade?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

Use of paratroopers in war? [xpost from r/History]

When did the use of paratroopers become common place? Are there any notable paratrooper battles or attacks? Please include countries besides the United States like France, Russia, Israel, Korea, or China. The reason I ask is I read briefly about of the Nazi paratrooper attack at Fort Eben-Emael[1] in The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich by William L. Shirer.

2 Answers 2014-02-22

Why are the colors red, white, and blue so commonly featured in so many nations' flags?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

How useful was the sling as a weapon during Greco-Roman Antiquity?

Specifically around the time of the Punic Wars if possible.

2 Answers 2014-02-22

Was the bay of pigs incident responsible for the cuban missile crisis?

or was it because of personality issues between Kruschev and JFK?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

When did we first start seeing artists capable of painting what we would deem to be photo-realistically?

I have a passing familiarity with the various art styles throughout history, but to my knowledge, they are just styles. This would imply that artists might be capable of producing works in different styles, but that they would choose to make works in the style of their era and location. Or, the photo-realistic works simply don't get attention like the pieces that are representative of era or location. Whatever the explanation, I still wonder when and where we first started seeing artists who had the capability to produce photo-realistic works (even if it was just their own private stuff that they didn't share).

Example. Be sure to scroll down to the 5th image.

Edit: Apologies for the typo in my post title.

1 Answers 2014-02-22

How does the modern Catholic Church view historical Antipopes?

2 Answers 2014-02-22

Did US policy in Chile directly lead to Allende’s downfall?

Basically I'm doing a presentation on this topic where I have to argue against this statement, any help or information would be much appreciated! Edit: Sorry I didn't elaborate further, basically I need someone to point me in some better directions, I need to argue against the statement but pretty much everything I have found so far seems to blame the US. I was not asking for people to do my homework for me, something that isn't possible as this work must be referenced and checked through a plagiarism filter. So once again, thank you very much if you can help in any small way!

2 Answers 2014-02-22

What should I do with this tomahawk that my father found in 1950s as a boy? He is considering loaning or donating to museum but we don't know where to start. Also, any info about the actual artifact would be AWESOME!

Not sure if this is okay to post this here, so please direct me where I should go if this isn't appropriate. I love this sub and its great information from its historians so just thought to go here first.

First of all, here's a link to the album I created. I can take more pics if needed: http://imgur.com/a/q9lC3

My father comes from a long line of Iowan farmers, and this was found on a plot of their land in the "timber" as they call it (out east we call it "woods"). He was 7 or so and was out looking for mushrooms (not the magic kind!) and was sort of shuffling his feet along the ground. He struck a rock and hurt his toe, and instinctively reached down to examine the offending stone, and found that it was actually this AMAZING artifact, partially buried in the earth. He took it home to his mom, my grandma ,and it has sat in my grandparents' den up until a few months ago when Grandma went in to the hospital.

I'd always held the tomahawk (if it is indeed a tomahawk- not even sure that's correct) as a child and been so intrigued by it- it really is an amazing artifact and would love to know more about it. My family is still deciding what to do with it. I've heard some bad stories about loaning to museums- that loaning is the same thing as donating pretty much- and some people advise to just hold onto it in the family.

So I guess my questions are:

  1. Can anyone give me more information about the artifact itself? Is it indeed a Tomahawk? What was it used for?

  2. Should we keep, loan, or donate? If the latter, to what museum- a local one in Iowa or a bigger one?

Thanks so much!!

5 Answers 2014-02-22

In Sid Meier's game Civilization IV, the printing press technology increases the profitability of villages and towns. Is there a historical justification for this, or is it just a game mechanic?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

How 'successful' has the process of a nation splitting in the past been

The reason I ask this is because of some viewpoints of people looking at the ukraine violence see the nation potentially splitting to 'pro Russian / pro EU' nations.

Meanwhile looking back on Sudan which was a fairly peaceful split and Yugoslavia as a fairly violent split, has me wondering how 'successful' has the process of nations splitting been in the past?

Are there any big examples of large nations in the past (pre 1900's) splitting relatively peacefully or is it always achieved through bloodshed?

2 Answers 2014-02-22

Was the quest for a warm-water port a serious motivation behind the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan?

I seem to remember, in the aftermath of the Soviets invading Afghanistan, there was a lot of speculation by the talking-heads as to why? And the story that stuck in my mind was that the Soviets were trying to annex a corridor to the Indian Ocean because it was too easy to bottle up their fleet otherwise. I heard that theory again when the US aiding Pakistan was being discussed.

Was there ever really a serious plan by the USSR to invade all the way through Pakistan to the Indian Ocean? Or was that story just a plausible enough sounding talking point to rationalize US involvement? Or was it Soviet propaganda to rationalize their invasion really carried out for other purposes? Or was it just complete BS dreamed up by talking-heads?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

Saturday Reading and Research | February 22, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

10 Answers 2014-02-22

What were Hitler's and his Generals biggest mistakes that lead to the defeat and retreat of Wehrmacht on the eastern front?

What could they have done differently so the eastern front was successful?

4 Answers 2014-02-22

Why are chopsticks so prevalent in the Orient while Forks/Spoons in the West?

To me it seems that chopsticks are much easier to make compared to a fork/spoon that needs to be carved out slowly (assuming wooden implements). So why did the Fork/Spoon become so prevalent while other methods didnt?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

Do you think the world would still be as ubiquitously interconnected and globalized as it is today without Rome adopting Christianity?

1 Answers 2014-02-22

7067 / 7255

Back to start