Why was the USSR the "preferable" ally in WW2 if the West knew Stalin planned to invade the rest of Europe? Why not ally with the Nazis against the USSR and later have a Cold War with the Third Reich?

Stalin was an ally because "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" right?

Well was hitler also in that same boat? The West hated communism and considered them to be a looming enemy. With someone who was also as vehemently anti-communist as Hitler, why not ally with him against the USSR?

6 Answers 2014-02-12

How did the grid layout become an integral part of Roman city design, considering the chaotic street plan of Rome itself?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Why was succession to the Ottoman throne "open" and not decided by the order of birth? Why did it often involve fratricide?

I've read that many of the ottoman sultans such as Mehmed II often ended up having to kill their brothers. Why did the previous sultan not not pick his successor rather than leaving the empire prone to internal strife?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

How was video recorded during battles in World War 2?

I'm a big fan of watching old footage on the history channel of World War 2, how were cinematographers able to record video during battles and who was in charge of procuring the equipment?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

When and why did "bad words" become bad?

I'm just wondering when so-called "curse words" became bad, and why. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Where dogs ever viewed by Westerners the same way they tend to be viewed by some Islamic nations today?

Dogs are generally, not always of course, seen as beloved members of families today in the Western world. In some Islamic countries, dogs are viewed as a combination of unclean pests and tools for practical jobs like herding sheep. Was this ever the case in Western nations like France, the UK, US, or Canada?

Edit: *Were dogs ever viewed by Westerners the same way they tend to be viewed by some Islamic nations today?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

What affect did the Black Death have on the royal families of Europe? How did they handle it?

Were any royal lines killed off due to plague? Did any houses cut themselves off from the outside (as much as possible at the time)? Would domestic staff be barred from leaving the premises? Did anyone take advantage of the plague to force claims and take land by force? What kind of practices were used to protect families from the disease?

Was reading an article and realized I've never really heard about what happened among the aristocracy, just that millions died. Interested in anything of note among these lines.

4 Answers 2014-02-12

What are some good readings/sources on the Iran-Contra Affairs (Irangate)?

I'm trying to understand the whole situation, but it's hard with huge controversies like this. I'm interested in any reliable articles on the topic as well as differing opinions on it. Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Did filmmakers in the Soviet Union portray American culture and/or western capitalists as villains in their movies? Or at least as similarly to how the west portrayed the Soviet culture and/or communism?

I was just watching Rocky IV, where Rocky Balboa battles the near-unbeatable Ivan Drago. As the fight approaches, the link between this monster of a man and his country is heavily stressed, as it occasionally is in other American movies from that time period.

Did filmmakers in the USSR portray American culture and/or western capitalists as villains, just like we (Americans) often did to them?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Why do a lot of events and descriptions in classical Indian epics (and their later representations) seem to involve such large numbers?

A lot of people probably have a fairly passing acquaintance with depictions of various mythological figures from the Indian subcontinent having hundreds of arms or heads, and while reading Section 6 of the Sauptika Parva of the Mahabharata, I was struck by this passage:

His face was adorned with thousands of beautiful eyes. His body was incapable of being described, as also his attire. The very mountains, upon beholding him, would split into a 1,000 fragments. Blazing flames of fire seemed to issue from his mouth and nose and ears and all those thousands of eyes. From those blazing flames hundreds and thousands of Hrishikeshas issued, armed with conchs and discs and maces.

That kind of sheer multiplicity seems to happen a lot in the Mahabharata, and stands in contrast to other Indo-European epics like the Iliad. Have people ever remarked on this as a trait of Indian epic, and have there ever been attempts to explain or interpret it?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Who exactly were the Prussians?

This question might be far too broad, but I will ask it anyways.

My grandfather was theoretically ethnically Polish (at least, our name is Polish, and he spoke Polish). However, he always identified as "Prussian", as did his father and grandfather, who immigrated to the US around 1870. This confuses me.

Is there a Prussian ethnicity?

What were the distinct aspects of Prussian culture? Or was it just German culture?

Was Prussia ever distinct from Germany? Not just on a map, but in a cultural sense.

Why would an ethnic Pole identify as a Prussian? What was the relationship between the Poles living in Prussia and the state itself?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Why has France had a slow increase in population compared to other Western European countries, especially during the Industrial Revolution?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Van Goug was relatively unknown during his life, how does his reputation suddenly grow into that of a historically important artist after death?

Not sure how many art historians hang out here but I'm curious to know.

Perhaps I'm being too cynical but I'm imagining someone buying his works on the cheap, suddenly "discovering" his genius and promoting his works for their own gain, kind of like a penny stock pump on wall street.

1 Answers 2014-02-12

If you were to walk down a London street in the 1890s and ask people at varying economic strata "Why is the Empire important?" what answers would I receive?

Would there be anybody who would tell me that it's a waste of resources and/or immoral to colonize other countries?

Edit: Apologies for the switch between first and second person in the title.

6 Answers 2014-02-12

What led to the Winds of Change in Africa? Why would the British Empire voluntarily reduce itself? What was the advantage for Britain?

It's interesting to me that it seems like this was a sustained feeling from the governments in Britain, over many years. Such a drastic and outwardly self-harming principle seems unlikely to have lasted for so long, and to have yielded the massive fruits that it did.

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

So, what's new this week?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

What if Japan had dropped nuclear bombs on us first?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Due to the massive size of the Ottoman dynasty, are there a significant number of people in modern Turkey, the Middle East, or Eastern Europe who bear the surname Ottoman or Osmanlı? If not, why not?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

What genre were the gospels and do we know of any books that influenced them?

Besides the Old testament, of course, do we have any specific examples of books that influenced the structure, style or content of the Gospels?

3 Answers 2014-02-12

What were Hannibal's battle tactics that made him such a successful general? Were his ideas revolutionary?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Why has there been so much animosity towards the Irish throughout history?

It always seems like Europe picks on the Irish. Just curious if there is a reason.

3 Answers 2014-02-12

Did Mao want to "export the revolution" to countries in Southeast Asia?

Countries like the Philippines, Malaysia, and Indonesia all experienced communist insurgencies. What was China's stance to these groups? Did they supply them with arms and training?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

800,000-Year-Old Footprints Discovered in England Does it change anything?

Source: http://higherperspective.com/2014/02/800000-year-old-footprints-discovered-england.html

I'm really curious about these footprints, what is the conclusion in a historical perspective? I haven't found it in the article. Thanks for reply!

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Why is Poland refereed to as the Poland-Lithuania commonwealth

I'm polish, in school we always called it Poland. I know that it was made up of the merge of Poland and the Grand Duchy of Lithuania but it was ruled by one king, under one flag, and had basically one capital. It was one country for several hundred years so why is in not simply refereed to as Poland?

It might probably a stupid question but never the less I want to know why is it universality refereed to as the commonwealth, outside of Poland.

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Is there any evidence that King George VI pushed the scandal that led his brother, King Edward VIII into abdicating the throne?

I know that conventional wisdom and Wikipedia say quite the opposite, but I was wondering if there is evidence that King George directed the whole thing, so that he could be king.

My question comes from that scene in the film, "The Kings Speech," when King Edward accuses his brother of pushing him off the throne. I don't recall the exact words used in the film.

Perhaps I'm watching too much "House of Cards".

So I'm asking the experts.

1 Answers 2014-02-12

7103 / 7255

Back to start