What happened to the armies immediately after a battle in Medieval Europe?

Did the victor try and hunt down the remainder of his opponent's army? How did the general or king regroup and what happened to all the defeated soldiers who were displaced within foreign land?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

How effective were the pacifist movements during the early stages of WWI?

I've done a bit of reading on the British pacifist front and it seemed that during the first stages of the war (up until about 1916) there was so much support that any opposition was confined to a few dusty corners of academia (one interesting account is is Bertrand Russell's autobiography).

Was there really so little opposition at the beginning of the First World War? Were the pacifist movements any different in France, Germany, Austro-Hungary or Russia? Did the pacifists deal any significant influence or did we have to wait later for conscription and war fatigue to kick in?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

How valid was the concern that Jews owned too much money in Europe before World War 2? To what extent did Jewish ownership of banks and businesses cause problems for Europeans?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Just ~40 years ago, many gays in South Africa were forced to undergo treatment to be 'cured', sometimes including forced sex changes. Today gay marriage is legal. How did this transition happen so quickly?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Economics of Ottoman Stagnation

My question is concernecd with the forces at work during the period of Ottoman stagnation and to what extent it was Politics or Economics.

My understanding of the this time is that you have a series of ineffectual leaders, rise in the power of the Janissaries, a series of uprising, and trade being rerouted around Africa instead of the silk road.

I guess my question is how much was stagnation a product of outside forces like the rerouting of trade or stronger western alliances versus internal political factors?

3 Answers 2014-02-12

Helmuth von Moltke the Younger, the German general who was defeated in the early WW1 Marne campaign, was apparently awarded "Knight Commander of the Royal Victorian Order"(An honor bestowed for ones personal service to the commonwealth, the UK) ... How can this be true?

I'm not a history buff but came across this very odd tidbit on Moltke's wikipedia page. I cannot seem to find any history that backs this up, and it seems really strange considering the requirements of the award for one's service to the UK, and obviously Moltke was a German general fighting against the British. Perhaps some WWI experts can clear this up?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

How truly anti-science has Christianity been historically?

Science in it's current form has not existed in the same way as today. I have always learned from popular culture and some documentaries that Christianity has always had a certain anti-science stance, but most of the supporting evidence doesn't hold when I learn more about those themes. Most of the time it seems to compare current empiricism with old times politics and truth searching disagreements that don't really compare. For some examples, please correct me if I'm wrong in any of those:

  • Galileo was working for the catholic church and his problems were mostly from politics with scientific rivals and writing a book insulting the Pope when he was asked to write a book comparing the heliocentric and geocentric models. He could also not prove the complete heliocentric model, just that Venus orbited the Sun, not the rest of the planets.

  • The dark ages is a concept completely disregarded by historians.

  • The supposed burning of the library of Alexandria by Christians wasn't burned by Christians and while it was an awful lost of books it wasn't a big loss of scientific knowledge.

  • Charles Darwin was buried with honors by the church of England.

  • The inquisition was more about prosecuting false converts than anything else.

So those are usually the big examples of the church being anti-science that don't seem to hold. Most of those examples seem to be people having problems with their time's believes and politics more than any church actively pushing against them. So the church may have been anti-science, but which would be the real examples for that or on which points am I wrong.

I understand that currently there are some problems with certain brands of Christianity with a clear anti-science stance, but has that been true historically?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Why is "fun" one of very few short adjectives that is not made comparative/superlative by adding "-er" and "-est"?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Was communism popular in Eastern/Central Europe after WW2, or was it simply imposed by the Soviets?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Why is it that there is a Iberia and a Galicia in both Eastern Europe and the Iberian peninsula?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

How old could the guy on the right be assumed to be if he lived 70 years ago? And why did we age faster before our days?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Looking for a documentary and/or book on Alexander the Great post-mortem

I honestly don't even know how to describe the scenario of what was going on after his death, however I'm interested in the fragmentation of his empire and would like to expand my knowledge on it. Any advice?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

The 'One-Handed' Flintlock Pistol

When I see flintlock pistols (or any kind of black powder pistol) represented in popular media, they are often fired with one hand. Since modern marksman hold their pistols with two hands, this confuses me as a matter of accuracy. Is the one-handed powder pistol a misconception of popular culture or was this an actual practice?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Did ancient Romans paint their replicas of ancient Greek statues?

We now know that ancient Greek statues were not white, but were painted all over to show the color of skin and clothing. Did ancient Romans know that, did they paint their replicas and original statues as well?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

What was Kemal Ataturk's involvement and view of the Armenian Genocide and how extreme were his views on Turkish Nationalism?

Mustafa Kemal Ataturk was brought up in a class I was taking about Middle Eastern Government and Politics, but it was more of a cursory glance and it showed him in a pretty positive light. While the Armenian genocide was covered briefly in the course, I am curious to what extent he was involved? My understanding is that he did not directly order it, but what were his feelings towards it? How much did he know about it at the time and how instrumental was he in suppressing it after the Treaty of Lausanne? In the same line of thought, how extreme were his views of Turkish nationalism? Thank you guys!

PS: I would love to hear some more background on the Armenian genocide in general, I figure this forum is more appropriate to ask questions like I did above, but if anyone could add more information about it I would greatly appreciate it, I am trying to become better informed on the topic.

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Were there many noted instances of fake currency being used in earlier civilizations?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

While reading about the history of the Jews in Medieval Europe, it seems that very often, kings, nobles, and high-ranking clergymen would defend jewish communities legally and denounce anti-jewish acts. Why, then, were common Europeans still so universally brutal to their Jewish neighbors?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

How did ancient Greek perception of cults differ from how we think of cults today?

The ancient Greeks seemed to have quite the affinity for cult behavior centered around many different things, ranging from individual gods, mathematicians, to deceased heros.

Was cult participation popular and accepted? How does the ancient Greek perception about cults and cult activity differ from our own perceptions about cults today?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Why did we used to be so fine with such brutal and public executions?

In just a few hundred years, we have gone from agonizing and public executions to debating whether lethal injection is too inhumane. How did this shift in behavior come about? We used to be fine with gathering to watch their fellow man burn to death or be broken on the wheels, but now are queasy at the death penalty altogether. Why did we used to have no problem with such horrible ways of killing people?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Was it ever a tradition to put your teacher's name as author on your work instead of your own? Or has such a practice always been viewed as forgery?

I was discussing the deutero-Pauline epistles (1,2 Timothy and Titus) with our friend who is an ecumenical minister and he denied that these epistles count as forgeries. He claims that it was common practice at the time for students/followers to use their teacher's name instead of their own. Because after all, the ideas were given to them by the teacher and are therefore rightly the teacher's.

Is anyone here aware of a time when such a practice was common?

Thank you all for your time and consideration.

2 Answers 2014-02-12

How did martial arts films become so widely produced in Communist China?

It is my understanding that martial arts outside of those used by the military are widely illegal in China. My question is about the cultural climate in the 60's - 70's that allowed so many films to be made glorifying something that was essentially illegal? I accept that my understanding if China during this period may not be perfect but I cannot see the government allowing these films to be made and eventually sold to overseas audiences.

I'd love to get some perspective on Communist China and the entertainment industry during the height of the martial arts film.

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Has a first lady ever had a job while living in the white house?

2 Answers 2014-02-12

Did Talleyrand really save France after the Napoleonic wars?

Can we further say that France diplomats like Richelieu, Talleyrand, DeGaulle save France when that nation was in critical danger. Without that kind of men France would be doom.

1 Answers 2014-02-12

How was Laurence Olivier's use of black face in the 1965 movie "Othello" viewed by the African American Civil Rights Movement that was going on at the time?

Was there any controversy surrounding the choice to portray Othello in black face? Did any prominent civil rights leaders criticize the choice to use a white actor in black face for the lead protagonist or was the decision to use Laurence Olivier well received by the civil rights community?

1 Answers 2014-02-12

Do most South Asian countries speak a form of language that derived from Chinese?

I was wondering, since a few Asian languages sound alike to Chinese words. When I listen to Thai, it sounds very similar to Cantonese. And I pick up several words in Filipino, Japanese and Korean that sounds the same when spoken in Chinese. I guess this would be similar to Latin developing into French, Spanish, Italian etc.

2 Answers 2014-02-12

7104 / 7255

Back to start