In light of "Kim Jong-un fed his uncle to dogs" story, has there ever been documented incident in history of execution by dogs?

2 Answers 2014-01-12

Aztec Sacrifice

I know that the sacrifice had a lot to do with keeping the world running, but I'm not sure exactly why they did it. How much did they sacrifice? Why?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Did Andrew Jackson always dislike John C. Calhoun? Or did it start because of Nullification?

Jackson has been quoted as saying his two biggest regrets from serving as president is not shooting Henry Clay and not having Calhoun hanged.

My question is, with such disdain for Calhoun, why did Jackson choose him as his running mate in the 1828 election? Did Jackson actually like/trust Calhoun at one point and then see the nullification crisis as a betrayal?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

What would the world be like today if the Treaty of Versailles had been different/more reasonable?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Day of Reflection | January 06, 2014 - January 12, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

5 Answers 2014-01-12

Has a bomb ever failed to detonate during a test of nuclear weaponry?

During the Cold War, there were a very large number of nuclear tests conducted by both the US and the USSR. Were there ever any failures to detonate any of these weapons? What protocol had to be followed in the case of an undetonated, but still presumed active nuclear weapon?

3 Answers 2014-01-12

Just Finished Reading "The Secret History" by Procopius. How Much Is Meant To Be Taken As Gospel Truth and How Much Is Elaboration?

Just curious some of the scenes described sound pretty fantastic for a secular historian writing in the style of Thucydides (i.e. Justin's demonic face changing abilities, Theodora's stage exploits)

1 Answers 2014-01-12

How did Japanese and U.S. relations improve so relatively quickly after WWII?

I could be wrong, but it seems relations between the two countries improved rather dramatically after the war ended.

The bomb was dropped in '45, and 20 odd years later Hondas were being introduced into the American economy.

What happened to improve relations so quickly?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Was King George IV a good naval officer before he became king?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Non-western discovery of America

As a casual geographer (I've seen a map or two in my day), I can't help but notice that Eastern Russia practically touches what is now known as Alaska, and pre-industrial Tudor superpowers like Japan and China are also pretty close to the the US.

Was Leifur Eiriksson the first man to place America on the map?

I'm also interested if anybody discovered it between Leifur Eiriksson's discovery and Colombus' "discovery".

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Bengal was supposedly one of the richest countries in the planet at one point. So what happened?

Ok so I recently read a claim that the Europeans regarded ancient Bengal as the richest country to trade with. There are accounts of the wealth in this region from many sources ranging from Marco Polo to Ibn Battuta. Incidentally, the Dutch East India Company and the British counterpart were based out of this region. These were two of the richest companies of all time, the VOC especially. And at a topical level it makes sense. Before the age of banking and finance, wealth was almost always a function of agricultural output. Bengal has always been one of the most fertile spots on the planet. So it only follows that it would be a wealthy place as well. So my question I guess is: is there any merit to these claims, and if so, the hell happened? Why is the region so poor now? And is there hope for the future? Thanks in advance.

7 Answers 2014-01-12

Around the years 1900-1910, were the Western states (in the US) slightly more racially tolerant than Eastern ones?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

How popular were axes actually to the vikings? Did many have swords? What weapons did they mostly use? How did they fight?

I'm interested in learning about vikings and their way of fighting. I have of course heard about the hit and run looting tactics, what would they do if they faced an organized force?

Is it true that only the wealthiest had swords?

How many used spears?

What made them favor round shields over other kinds of shields?

I imagine chainmail was quite expensive and difficult to make, did many vikings have chain mail?

How many were in a raiding party?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

META: With history being a narrative...

1 Answers 2014-01-12

What was medicine like in the American Frontier?

What was medicine like in the old west (1840's - 1890's)? How educated was the average doctor? What equipment and medicine did they have at their disposal? Did most small towns have local doctors? If so, did the doctors do house calls, or did they actually have a kind of clinic in the town? How much did they charge for their services, or did that vary too much to answer?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

How did iron manufactured well into the post-Iron Age compare with bronze at peak/end of the Bronze Age? What about the bronze used years later to make cannons?

There are several frequently asked questions about bronze and iron, but about the transition itself. This is about Bronze Age bronze, post-Iron Age (so skipping the entire Iron Age) bronze, and post-Iron Age iron.

Also, what weapons (any era) were the worst for bronze?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Did William the Conqueror expect that the invasion of England would be harder than it was? If so, what main centers other than London and York would he have planned to take?

There might not be sources for his mindset on this. If so, just say what the most important cities for economic or military purposes were at the time.

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Why did the Neanderthals (200,000 BCE - 30,000 BCE) start burying their dead?

This question came up in my history class. Some simple answers were brought up, but I think there is more to it.

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Why was Poland so badly treated compared to other occupied nations during WWII?

6 Answers 2014-01-12

Which history book(s) should every historian read?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Why were US territories divided when it came time for statehood?

I noticed when looking at the maps on this wikipedia page that often, when states were admitted, only a part of that territory became the actual state, and the remainder of the land was transferred to another territory or became unorganized. Why wouldn't the whole territory just become the new state?

2 Answers 2014-01-12

Were propertied slave owners (i.e. plantation owners) in the antebellum South well-educated?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Mass Migrations-- what are the notable ones and why? What were the effects of these migrations?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

Was the ability to afford Coca-Cola an indicator of class in the 19th or early 20th Century U.S.?

I have heard people who grew up in the 1930's, or earlier, refer to their inability to afford Coke as a way of describing their poverty or their sudden decline in wealth.

Was Coke ever an expensive, sought after treat associated with wealth? Was there some reason that people would choose to use Coke as the reference point when describing their class?

1 Answers 2014-01-12

US Military Historians - Who was Edwin K ?Loverley?

This seemed like the best sub for this, but please move or delete if Inappropriate. While at an estate sale today (SoCal area) I picked some obscure books on military history/tactics.

Not obscure but neat

  • 1st Edition Men From Earth; signed by Buzz Aldrin

Finally the one that I am perplexed by is Bob Woodward's Veil: the secret wars of the CIA it's signed by someone name Edwin K ?Loverly?

I have to figure; if you are getting books signed by your "good friend" Napolean Valeriano (who trained the Cubans for the bay of pig invasion), you wouldn't toss an insignificant signature in a book.

My Google Fu is not turning up any results for this Edwin ?Loverley? I was hoping some of the historians here would be able to shine some light on who he is and the possible relationship to Woodward or CIA Ops of the early 80's.

Thank you in advance. Thanks

1 Answers 2014-01-12

7215 / 7255

Back to start