Just saw “Come and See”. How accurate are the depictions of the German’s cruelty to the Russian civilians?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Was a cow convicted of sorcery in 1740 Paris, France?

I've seen this claim on a number of "useless fact" websites but I cant seem to find the original source for it, so Im coming here to settle it. Is this true?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

How old is my Globe?

Heres some clues from what i can tell.

  • no sri lanka still called Ceylon
  • still called Ussr
  • no taiwan
  • no north/ south Korea just korea but there’s a border
  • rhodesia and shouthern rhodesia
  • bechuanaland
  • east pakistan?

2 Answers 2021-04-26

Today is Marcus Aurelius' birthday. Was he really as good as history remembers him? And what were his subjects attitudes to him during his reign?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Why didn't the Germans use the Luftwaffe for logistics and supplies during Operation Barbarossa in WW2?

Why didn't they use their aircrafts or aircrafts of occupied countries to deliver supplies to the Soviet Union? Their trains and trucks were having a hard time travelling due to the winter and muddy roads of the Soviet Union. Is it because they needed the Luftwaffe for the invasion that they didn't have enough aircrafts for supplying the front lines? Please answer thanks :))

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Why wasn't Quebec separatist sentiment influential in other French speaking Canadian communities?

For a short version of my question - why wasn't there significant separatist sentiment among French Canadians outside of Quebec, particularly in Ontario? Despite French language and culture being neglected to an even greater degree in English-speaking Canada, there doesn't seem to have been an equivalent separatist/terrorist movement among French speakers outside Quebec. Is my view of this correct, and if so, why was this the case?

For a longer version of my question - though I'm American, my mother comes from a French-Canadian family in northern Ontario (Timmins and Sudbury, specifically). The town she grew up in had a very large French-speaking community, and my grandfather was very active in various societies and groups that promoted French language and culture. Despite all of that, my mother said that there wasn't any separatist sentiment among the French population of her area, and viewed the Quebecois separatist movement as distinct. She also believes that this feeling was mutual - she went to university in Quebec at around the height of the student separatist movements, and recalled that despite being French-Canadian and speaking primarily French, she was often mocked by other students as "l'anglais" (the englishman") because she was from Ontario

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Ancient Mesopotamia and Desertification

Many times now, when searching for reconstructions and portrayals of the Ancient Near East, I have been struck by the incredible difference in fertility on display. I know that the region which is now Iraq was considered a breadbasket in ancient times, and that even today, large parts of it are still fertile flood-plains, but clearly there has been a seismic shift.

Look, for instance, at these reconstructions of ancient Ur, and then compare it to how the site looks today. The green hills, the flood-plains, the trees - all gone. The rivers can still be seen, but it is sand down to the banks.

When did this happen? Did it happen to the extent portrayed, or are these reconstructions exaggerated in how green they make the region look? I have heard it said many times that it was a combination of overharvesting and gradually salinisation due to the irrigation systems, but even so, it is a dramatic change. Are there any historical documents of people noting that the once-verdant bread-baskets were beginning to turn to desert?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Did people share the "internet is a cesspit" attitude 20 years ago that many people have today?

It's a common thing to hear these days, about how horrible everyone is on the internet and that no one is nice to each other. Did people have these attitudes at the turn of the millenium? Or is this a more recent phenomenon due to social media (out of the scope of the sub I realise) ?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Why was Provence called Provincia Romana? Why didn't every other provence called like that?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Why is there such a stark contrast in Far-eastern and Abrahamic religions in terms of Individualism?

Confucianism, Buddhism, Shinto - all of them encourage the submission of self for a greater whole, with the ultimate goal of buddhism being the entire loss of individuality and self.

Contrasted with abrahamic faiths where the self is preserved past death, and one's identity remains intact forever - whether as punishment or reward.

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Did Middle Age scholars really considered seriously the question of how many angels could dance in the head of a needle?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Why is it that in modern Western society that Wine is seen as more highbrow and beer and spirits as more lowbrow, when did alcohol start to get viewed this way, and did socities before this time view different times of alcohol, did they rank alcohol in terms of highbrow and lowbrow status?

Edit: Sorry about the spelling errors, times should be read as types

1 Answers 2021-04-26

[META] I don't think mods need to apologise for moderating according to our community standards.

It is normal to see a standard response such as this to a comment which needed to be removed:

Sorry, but we have removed your response, as we expect answers in this subreddit to be in-depth and comprehensive, and to demonstrate a familiarity with the current, academic understanding of the topic at hand. Before contributing again, please take the time to better familiarize yourself with the rules, as well as our expectations for an answer such as featured on Twitter or in the Sunday Digest.

I don't think the mods need to apologise, nor should they. It kind of implies that you have done something wrong, which might even result in more angry, aggressive responses.

I know you are only being polite - and thank you for that! - but there are other ways to be polite without apologising for doing your jobs.

Maybe something like:

Thank you for wanting to participate in AskHistorians! However, we have removed your response as we expect...

Just a thought.

7 Answers 2021-04-26

Why did the pike disappear from the battlefield in antiquity and what contributed to its return in medieval and renaissance era Europe?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

What’s the significance of the Istanbul trials of 1919-20?

Now that the armenian genocide is resurging in popularity, I want to ask a question I’ve always wondered: what’s the significance of the 1919-20 istanbul trials in which the perpetrators of the armenian genocide were found guilty of crimes against humanity in turkish martial court, and sentenced to execution?

How can Turkey deny that a genocide has occurred, if they have tried the people responsible?

In short, what’s the significance of those trials, what do they mean for turkey, for armenians, and for the international community at large? I never see them mentioned anywhere, neither in Turkish or international circles.

(My last question got deleted, and I can’t click on it to see why in notifications, so i’m re-asking)

Edit: the more i read from wiki, the more this has increased in complexity, and the more i am struggling to connect the dots.

How are the trials connected to the sevre treaty and the partition of the ottoman empire?

How come turkey denies genocide, when it has tried the perpetrators of genocide with crimes against humanity, and had them executed?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Why did Greek gods do things that were considered unethical at the time they were worshipped?

I mean they committed rape, beastiality, incest, and a fearful amount more. Yet people worshipped them? Why would the priests create stories that would scare people of the gods they worshipped?

2 Answers 2021-04-26

As a woman living during the time periods of ancient Greece or Rome, would I live in constant fear of being sexually assaulted due to the normality of sexual assault (specifically men against women) through slavery at those times? When did it stop becoming less of an issue?

In other words, was rape not regarded as a "big deal" during those times? Or, was it just a normal thing for women to be enslaved and used specifically for sexual purposes as a form of punishment?

Is there a way to determine the likelihood for a woman to be sexually assaulted in Ancient Greece or Rome and compare that to the present-day numbers?

3 Answers 2021-04-26

Was it known during WWII what Germany was doing and how extensive the holocaust was? If so, did Hitler ever meet with any foreign leaders or representatives and comment on what was going on?

I have always wondered about this. If it wasn't a secret, did Hitler ever try to explain what he was doing to foreign powers?

3 Answers 2021-04-26

From Justin’s “Epitome of the Philippic History of Pompeius Trogus” he states that the Scythians are “older than the Egyptians”. Is there any truth to this or is it just a bogus mythology?

I heard this quote from a video about Scythians and it confused me because I thought the Scythians were relatively new compared to other ancient civilizations. Could it be a mistranslation?

https://www.forumromanum.org/literature/justin/english/trans2.html

Here’s the best quote of it that I could get

1 Answers 2021-04-26

In what ways was Georg von Trapp (of The Sound of Music fame) opposed to Nazi ideology as is stated on his Wikipedia page and the National Archives page it references.

Do we have sources about his political beliefs outside the personal record provided by his wife? It seems suspicious that a wealthy rural Christian patriarch in that time and place would be opposed to the Nazis or fascism more generally.

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Are there archaeological evidence for Julius Caesar's massacres during the Gallic Wars?

I often read how Julius Caesar commited genocide against the Gauls during the Gallic Wars, usually citing Plutarch's figure of one million killed and one million enslaved. Even Caesar's own book describes numerous massacres and mass enslavement taking place.

But AFAIK ancient writers in general were prone to exaggeration when it came to these kind of numbers, and I'm wondering if there are any archaeological evidence for this. I'd imagine if there were such a sudden and massive depopulation in the region, it would leave some trace in archaeological evidence, like sudden termination of inhabited settlements, smaller number of burials and changes in settlement patterns. So my question is, what does archaeology say about the depopulation of Gaul after Caesar's conquest?

2 Answers 2021-04-26

The Netherlands has more foreign direct investment abroad than any other country. How did this happen? Is it a lingering effect of the Dutch East India Company?

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_FDI_abroad

1 Answers 2021-04-26

How long did it take for leaded gasoline/paints to be banned after it was discovered to be harmful? Was there significant societal pushback or skepticism towards banning it?

Title basically. With all the discussion lately around fossil fuels, micro plastics etc it makes me wonder how we used to view harmful things such as lead. Was it discovered to cause issues early and hidden, such as with fossil fuels causing climate change, or cigarettes causing heart disease/lung cancer? Or was it swiftly banned with little pushback from either the public or private sectors? Was there denial about the dangers of lead before it was banned? Etc

1 Answers 2021-04-26

Hot food, and hot peppers in general, are extremely common in africa despite not being native to the continent. How did the integration of hot peppers from the new world affect african cultures and customs, and why was the adoption of hot peppers so widespread?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

What Caused The Decline of Polish-Lithuania?

From what I understand it was a powerhouse of Europe, but eventually was wiped off the map for centuries. What happened? How? Why?

1 Answers 2021-04-26

734 / 7255

Back to start