Why isn't The 7 Years war referred to as a world war?

From what I've read it was fought on as many continents as WW1, yet doesn't have the distinction of being called WW#, what gives?

1 Answers 2021-04-17

How did the term "nativism" come to be used for an ideology which, in the US, is all about the descendants of colonists and immigrants who massacred and displaced the country's native population?

This thought was prompted by seeing descriptions of the new "America First Caucus" as a nativist movement. While true to the meaning of the word as it's used, it struck me as a strange word to end up with this meaning considering just how non-native to the US anything "Anglo-Saxon" is.

1 Answers 2021-04-17

Did the United States receive any African dignitaries during Jim Crow? If so, how were they received?

3 Answers 2021-04-17

The legality of Conn Witch Trials

I work with the Connecticut Witch Memorial to exonerate witches posthumously. We currently are presently working to try to research if the courts in Connecticut Colony were illegal and if they actually had the authority to try capital cases such as witchcraft. I ask this because CT was a British colony when the trials occurred (1640's) and years before the CT witch trials, spectral evidence was dismissed in English courts. How was a colony able to convict and hang witches when England no longer accepted spectral evidence? Were these trials even legal?

1 Answers 2021-04-17

How did Kim Il Sung consolidate his power in North Korea and what happened to other communist opposition groups? Unlike Vietnam, North Korea didn’t have any pro soviet and pro Chinese factionalism

1 Answers 2021-04-17

Why did Germany invade China at the start of the 1900 and build the port Tsingtao (today Qindao)

I had a talk with a Chinese friend when I bought a Chinese beer which has the name "Tsingtao" and we got into a talk about it but we both don't know much about it besides a short documentary about its use today.

It just seems like such a SUPER strange move to go across the world and even up to the north/west of china, surrounded by enemies to actually build a proper city with proper waterworks, etc and I would love to know more about why the hell they would do something so strange, seemingly for someone like me, so what was the context/motivation back in the day to go for it?
Also would love recommendations on stuff that I could read to know more!

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Was Irish/Scottish/English folklore and mythology a part of everyday life in the past?

In modern times we often think of Irish/Scottish/English folklore and mythology as being a prominent part of everyday life in the past. Banshees, leprechauns, fairies, etc. Movies are made depicting folklore/mythology playing prominent roles in everyday life, books written showing the depth and richness of folklore/mythology for these respective cultures. Even making Irish soda breads we cut a cross to bless it, but also to let the fairies out.

Would the people of these cultures, let’s say between 1700-1800’s (a lot of my post are deleted for not giving a specific time period, but it can be any time period post-paganism/druids once Christianity spread) have thought much of this folklore/mythology in their everyday life or do we make more of it in modern times?

Do we exaggerate the significance of the folklore in the past where it was much less of a way of life back then?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Being an Emperor sounds pretty good. There also seem to be really no requirements to qualify as one except being a ruler and deciding that you’re an Emperor. Why didn’t more Kings declare themselves Emperors?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

What do historians think about the term "Anglo-Saxon"?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Why was it specifically chess that became such a focus of Soviet investment and national pride in the post-war period?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Did the KGB ever try to exploit black-white relations in the US?

Seems to me like the KGB had a prime opportunity after WW2 to start race wars or rebellions. They even had lots of black russians, who came to Russia from Africa on scholarships. Furthermore, Russians never colonized or participated in the slave trade, so they had that card as well.

1 Answers 2021-04-16

In the early 1900s, some Black Americans looked at Imperial Japan with admiration as it was one of the few non-White countries on the world stage at that time. Can someone elaborate more on this unique relationship?

How did the Japanese perceive their new found admirations?

Did they try to exploit it?

How did other Americans feel about it? Pre and Post war?

2 Answers 2021-04-16

I've heard that sandals were a sign of royalty in aztec culture, does that mean everyone else was barefoot?

It wouldn't be too crazy I guess, but sandals don't seem that hard to make...

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Did classical composers of music borrow from each other in a similar manner to the way modern artists cover or sample other artists?

Are there any examples of famous orchestral composers lifting elements (with or without permission) of their compositions from other composers? Was there any similarities to the modern transactional nature of borrowing from an artist?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Life in the Americas before the arrival of Europeans

I'm not sure if questions like this fit this sub, but can anyone suggest any good books for leaning about what life was like in the Americas before Europeans arrived?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Why was the Old Testament of the Bible kept if it could put Jews in a favorable light? Or was that hand waved away?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Did roman legions every mutiny against their commanders due to the harsh punishments?

I've been reading up on military culture in ancient Rome and it feels like there's a lot of questionable punishments being employed. Of course I understand my modern sensibilities are probably influencing a lot of that assertion. Still it seems hard for me to see people just willingly killing their best friend(decimation) or just being beat severely cause they messed up in drill wouldn't cause some lingering resentment. So I guess the question is simple were there any examples of Roman soldiers (and by that I mean those that met the requirements to enlist in the legions free born, roman citizen, and all that jazz not auxiliary since those would necessarily have additional reasons to mutiny given they weren't romans.) mutinying in direct result of said punishments.

1 Answers 2021-04-16

When did OKW realize that the Allies would not land in Calais?

I've heard a lot about the impact of Operation Fortitude, and read books on double agents and fake armies, but I dont recall reading about when the Germans realized they had been fooled. Did they ever truly realize this? What was the German situation by the time they released the troops in Calais? Did this come as a sudden realization or was it a conclusion they came to gradually? Did they realize they were duped or did they think the Allies just re-worked their plans since Normandy landings proved successful? Was it a fait accompli by the time they realized it?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Why didn’t people ride reindeers to battle

I hear about dukha tribes domesticating reindeer and riding them in Mongolia then why didn’t reindeer cavalry exist?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

When was the first Monday and how was the calendar standardised?

So how did Roman emperors get months named after them and what where they before, similar question with Nordic mythological figures on our days of the week and lastly how did this all amalgamate into the system we have today?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

We see multiple instances in modern political history of women not being allowed to vote, gaining the right, only to lose it again a few years later. What were the causes of repealing suffrage for women after achieving it?

2 Answers 2021-04-16

The Soviet seems willing to create an unified, disarmed and perfectly neutral Germany with the cooperation of the west before1955 but totally changed its mind after that, what happened?

Is it so the fault of the western power at first that Germany remain divided until the Soviet were collapsing?

1 Answers 2021-04-16

During the Civil war why did the confederates not take advantage of the fact that the Mississippi River was not very well defended(am I right here?) So why did they not encircle the troops at Vicksburg?

If they encircle it, that could have got them the city back, through attrition

1 Answers 2021-04-16

Historians and their specialities

Hello,

I'm a history student, i've almost finished my second year (i'm french so I don't really know how does it work in other countries) but next year I will have to look for a master. I am thinking of taking a research one to then maybe continue into that field. But I have multiple apprehensions, one of them being: Which speciality would I pick ? There are a bunch of subjects or periods that interest me more than others, but i can't really imagine myself studying these for so long. For example I really like to learn about the period right after the first world war, but after a few months I feel like I'm already kinda "full" if i can put it like that. I know the work that historians do is completely different than how i personally learn, I'm mainly reading and taking notes, when historians do that but also investigate. But i don't feel like there are any subject as large or as specific as it can be that would suit me for a very long period of time, even one that would interest me long enough to write a thesis.

So i wanted to know how did you find the subject that you're currently working on ? Is it a subject you always knew you wanted to work on? Or is it something you found out about later? How long do you think you can study and work on one subject ?

Of course I know that I still have a lot of time before having to choose anything, and thanks to the french system I can easily try things, so I'm asking by curiosity more than by necessity.

I hope this post fits this sub, I'm sure I already saw someone posting a similar question but unfortunately i didn't find it back. And of course I'm not a native english speaker I hope I didn't butcher this language too much.

Thanks in advance

2 Answers 2021-04-16

Announcing the AskHistorians Digital Conference 2.0—Once again, right here on reddit!

Many, if not most, and perhaps all of you will probably remember that AskHistorians embarked upon the ambitious venture of hosting a digital conference last year. Our decision to do so was based, in large part, upon the dynamic and ever-evolving reality of early pandemic life. As conference after conference was cancelled in order to keep people safe, we at AskHistorians looked at the situation and realized that as a digital public history forum—in fact the largest digital public history forum in the world, we were uniquely well placed to fill this conference void.

And so we did it. And we did it well. So well, in fact, that the organizers of last year’s conference were invited to submit a piece to the academic history journal, History, reflecting upon what it was like to organize a born-digital history conference and the impact such a conference might have on the future of public history more broadly.

So, If you haven’t already checked out the panels from last year’s conference, what are you waiting for?! There was a lot of great work featured in these panels, which you can find on our YouTube channel and in the following threads:

But, all of this has been to say that the AskHistorians Digital Conference is now officially out of beta, and we’re ready to do it again!

This year’s conference will take place right here on the subreddit between the 19th and the 21st of October. Please save the date! Our theme, “[Deleted] & Missing History: Reconstructing the Past, Confronting Distortions” engages with all the ways that we as historians grapple with and confront historical narratives that are deliberate or accidental misrepresentations of the past. From propaganda to poorly researched media of all kinds, the historical past has often been represented and misrepresented in some pretty spectacular and awful ways. Everyone loves to complain about bad history and our conference this year is an opportunity to do exactly that. All periods of human history and all physical locations are welcome subjects for the conference.

You can find our full Call for Papers (CfP) here with details on how to write an abstract if you’ve never done one before and how to apply. So far, we have distributed this CfP to 422 institutions in eleven countries, but nothing would make us happier than receiving proposals from our users here. As with our forum, criteria for selection will not be based on job title, degrees, or publications, but on how well you are able to communicate in-depth, up-to-date historical knowledge about the subject(s) in which you are an expert.

Not sure if you’re ready to commit to a full ten-minute paper? That’s ok! There are still plenty of ways in which you can participate. For one, we hope to see you here in October, listening to papers, asking questions, and participating in the special activities that we have planned. We are also asking for our community’s help with making this conference as good as it can be. While we are already seeking support and sponsorship from various institutions, the strength of this subreddit has always been its users. And so, it is to our users that we turn once again. We have set up a Fundrazr campaign to raise money to cover the costs of hosting the conference. This support will allow us to push our conference even further than we did last year by utilizing new and better digital platforms and making the conference as accessible and inclusive as possible. Contributors will be offered the chance to pick up some exclusive and limited-edition AskHistorians swag and be a part of behind-the-scenes events.

If you would like to help support the 2021 AskHistorians conference, please click here to donate.

We are incredibly excited to be hosting this conference again and hope that you will join us in this excitement. Feel free to ask questions, leave comments, and spread the word. We look forward to receiving your abstracts and will keep you updated as our plans continue to unfold!

37 Answers 2021-04-16

749 / 7255

Back to start