Owain Glyndŵr and King Arthur

Hey! I've just joined this subreddit in the hopes of having a questioned answered. I've been doing a lot of research on the Owain Glyndŵr (including looking into Henry IV by Shakespeare) and was wondering if the mythical history of Arthur and Glyndŵr overlapped at all? I know there's myth around both of them being folk heroes awaiting the call to return and liberate their people- would they have existed in the same mythological universe?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

What happened to the things the Americans stole when capturing the Eagles Nest? They must be worth millions. Where are they?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Was Francisco Franco a true ideological fascist, or did he simply co-opt the more organized fascist movement in an effort to achieve his ultimate goals of power?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Question Succession/Claims and women in Middle ages.

Is it true that rulers couldn't press woman's claims on a title against a man? Also is it true that women couldn't inherit even a minor title if there was a male heir? Mainly asking about Europe during 11th century.

1 Answers 2021-03-01

What are the best resources for historical context on the 1920s US eugenics movement?

I am writing an article about a woman who was a progressive figure in the 20s, a woman of compassion, known for her socially progressive attitudes. I have discovered that she was at least an implicit eugenics supporter.

I would like to understand her motivations better and give the full context behind her support of this obviously dangerous ideology. She was a physician, and she did extensive charitable work with disabled children. Her statements are mostly about "unfit" children. She did not support legislated sterilization programs. She did voice support for social problems to be "solved in the laboratories".

Any thoughts or pointers toward the best references for this subject would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Was Pete Seeger correct when he said that Americans don't sing together nearly as much as they used to? If so, why don't Americans sing together anymore.

Near the end of his life the famed folk musician Pete Seeger gave an interview where he lamented the fact that Americans don't sing together as a group nearly as often as they did when he was a child and young man (he was born in 1919). If I am recalling correctly he gave examples such as singing on family car rides, drinking songs, and religious events. I guess one could add camp songs to that as well. While obviously singing in church remains a vibrant affair in some traditions, in many others it is not (at my own church growing up hymns were strictly perfunctory). And I can't remember any bar I ever went to having an atmosphere welcoming to big drunken singing group, including probably one of the few honest-to-God community pubs that exists west of the Mississippi.

Is Pete Seeger correct in his estimation that Americans used to sing together much more than they do today? If so, why did Americans stop singing together?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

The CIA built a tunnel to tap into Soviet Army telephone landlines in 1950s Berlin. The KGB knew about it from the start but waited a year before sharing to protect their British mole. Did this create any internal backlash, such as from the GRU, Red Army, or Stasi?

I'm talking about Operation Gold in particular. I'm wondering since the KGB neglected to tell anybody else for a year, and likely ended up compromising lots of intelligence and political secrets.

  1. Did this end up with other Eastern Bloc intelligence agencies and military organizations hesitating to share information with the KGB?
  2. Did it also cause East German and local Soviet politicians from trusting the KGB as well, since I'm guessing a lot of their secrets went through that landline.

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Black originating from the US

I’ve seen some articles stating there were Black tribes originating from the US and being shipped out to and throughout Europe as slaves. I haven’t seen any sources within them, is there historical validity to this? If so why isn’t it ever discussed?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Were Ancient Chinese aware of Ancient Egypt? If yes, how did the two civilizations view each other?

I'm thinking from the earliest days up until the fall of Rome mainly. Very curious about this.

Thanks you

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Disregarding the awful conditions and morality of it all, were the British-run concentration camps successful in winning the Second Boer War?

My understanding is that the British were trying to deny the Boer guerillas the ability to hide amongst civilians and use their resources, so they rounded up all the civilians and conducted a scorched-earth campaign throughout the countryside. This led to tens of thousands of civilian deaths in the camps - partly due to disease, partly due to starvation (the Boers had been attacking supply trains). It is important to note that these were not the same camps that Nazi Germany would later use; their intended purpose was merely internment rather than extermination.

Anyway, my question is purely about the military aspect of the camps. Was this strategy effective in defeating the Boers, or was it inconsequential?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

How significant was the control of straits during the High Middle Ages?

How much power did the controller of naval straits such as Bosporus exert over the trade through the strait itself? Would they be able to impose significant blockades against merchant ships of opposing powers?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Why was Middle English spoken for a shorter period of time than Old English and now Modern English?

From what I can find: Old English (Anglo-Saxon): 400s - 1066 Middle English: 1066 - 1400s Modern English: 1400s - present

Is there a concrete, identifiable reason why Middle English got shorted by 200 years? When will we be able to put a cap on Modern English and define a start to Post Modern English?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Are historians able to create an accurate map of Pagan Roman Italy at any time before 300 AD which would include most of its cities, towns and hamlets, or is re-creating a map to this level of detail no longer possible due to loss of knowledge?

This is something I've always wondered because all maps of Roman Italy I've ever seen seem to be incredibly basic - just listing the main cities when lots of minor places like Falerii Novi would have existed (surely)...

So, before 300 AD when Rome was still pagan, would historians be able to accurately recreate the map of Roman Italy including MOST of its towns and cities that would have existed at the time?

Does any map to this level of detail exist anywhere or is this something no longer possible due to lost knowledge?

And if they can't, does this imply that lots of lesser Roman towns or hamlets may lie unburied and undiscovered under the ground?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Current public discourse seems to be dealing much more with Holocaust trivialization than with its denial (e.g. “This is just how the Nazis treated the Jews”). Is this a recent development or has this often been the “little sibling” of denial? How does it affect your research?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

I am a seven year old Viking child. What does my daily routine look like?

I know "Viking" can be a bit of a loaded term, so let's specify that I am a Norse child from the early 10th century. My father is away raiding/exploring, and presumably it's the same for many of my peers.

What sorts of games would we play? What toys would we have? Would we receive any sort of structured education, or be mostly left to our own devices until we're old enough to apprentice?

Are the answers different for boys as for girls?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

High Medieval/Renaissance Cities

  1. What was the average population/minimum population to be counted as a city?
  2. How big were most cities
  3. How big were the garrisons(how many soliders/police typically guarded them)

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Why does white supremacist have a history of hating jews when jews are white?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Ibram X. Kendi recently said in an interview "the majority of white Southerners opposed secession and opposed the Civil War." Is this true?

In a profile on Ibram X. Kendi's reading habits for the New York Times, he says the following:

What’s the most interesting thing you learned from a book recently?

I finished “A People’s History of the Civil War,” by David Williams recently. It was so interesting to learn in yet another book that the majority of white Southerners opposed secession and opposed the Civil War (not to mention the opposition from enslaved and free Black Southerners). But we’d never know that history today, with so many Americans making ahistoric claims that Confederate monuments and memorials are commemorating Southern pride or showcasing Southern history. When the Confederacy lived, ordinary Southerners distinguished between themselves and the wealthy and well-connected Confederates waging war to maintain slavery.

Source here: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/25/books/review/ibram-x-kendi-by-the-book-interview.html?smid=tw-share

I had understood that many poor whites supported secession, slavery, and the Civil War for racial reasons. But Kendi quotes "A People's History of the Civil War" to say the opposite is true. I'm curious, how did the majority of white Southerners feel about secession and Civil War?

2 Answers 2021-03-01

What forms of labor were most enslaved people in the Ottoman Empire used for? The harem sex slaves, court eunuchs and janissary slave soldiers get the most attention, but what about the rest?

Asking because I'm curious how the slave economy of the Ottoman Empire worked, and what projects and businesses were purchasing such a large number of slave laborers. Attempting to dig into this online I've found most popular sources out there focus on harem, eunuch and janissary slaves and from my limited understanding these were not typical.

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Did people in the past romanticize past eras, just as we do now?

I feel like I can’t go a week without hearing someone bring up how they wished they’d been alive to experience the music and general aura of the 1950s (minus the racism yada yada yada). My question is: Did people in the past do the same? Did people in the 1920s reminisce about the 1870s (or other decades)? Did they also wish they had been alive to experience the music and culture of those times?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

How did mathematicians in the roman empire express fractions and decimals?

i guess another way to frame it is: "How were decimals and fractions expressed in the roman numerical system?"

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Were the Nazis of the 30's and 40's subtle?

Today's neo-nazis are fond of plausible deniability. They'll make an ok symbol or obfuscate their intent with codes like 88. Did Nazis % the past do this “hint-hint' style of communicating?

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Would an Arabic speaker from today be able to at least somewhat communicate with an Arabic speaker from around 1200 AD?

My logic is because the Qu'ran is still written in the same way it was originally at around 700AD an Arabic speaker from today should be able to at least have a limited conversation with someone from the past.

2 Answers 2021-03-01

When did understanding about the holocaust break into common knowledge around the world?

When did the knowledge about the holocaust by the nazis break into general knowledge around the world?

I’ve read lately several books in which at least a part of the story takes place during the late 1930’s or early 1940’s. Several of them have discussed about the holocaust as a reason to go to war with Germany. However, I have had the understanding that the topic was not widely discussed by the public before the war or during the early war years. Thus I’ve started to wonder if the authors are reflecting their later knowledge of the atrocities to explain wrongly the motivation of their main characters to advocate entering the war.

As I am most definetely not an expert on this area, it would be interesting to know more about it.

1 Answers 2021-03-01

Is the Aryan invasion in India true?

In India, while learning about the Harappan civilisation, we are taught that the civilisation's downfall was caused by the invasion of the Aryans, who originated from regions near the Caspian Sea. We also learn that they brought in new materials and objects like books, horses, chariots and so in to India. This is what i know about it in brief. However, in a video I watched on Youtube, it seems to be that the Aryan invasion theory is actually fake. Apparently it was introduced by Europeans and the British Empire while India was under colonial rule, for reasons I can't exactly remember. I think it was along the lines of showing that the colonies had always been uncivilised and had to have some outsider ruling them. Would any historians like to present their point on this and prove/disprove the Aryan invasion theory, and also state why it ever came to be in the first place if it actually is fake?

In the Youtube video, they have disproved the theory by using various techniques like genetics, linguistics, etc. I can't exactly remember which video it was, since I had watched it a while back, but I have provided a link of what i think is the video I saw.

Aryan Invasion Theory: Prove AIT, Win 2 Cr | David Frawley, Niraj Rai, Abhijit, Aravind, Sanjay - YouTube

Feel free to correct me as I don't have much knowledge on this topic or history in general.

2 Answers 2021-03-01

824 / 7255

Back to start