Why didn't the Crusaders form a one big kingdom?

After the first Crusade why did they split the lands they took? (Antioch, Jerusalem etc.)Those kingdoms were some small kingdoms on the enemy homeland, far away from the allies. They could've formed a one big kingdom from Anatolia to Egypt but they split it. Is there any logical reason for it or was it because of fedualism?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

When did we stop using wires to hold up the tails of airplanes?

I’ve seen many images of older planes, notably fighters and bombers from the WW2 era have string/wires connected from the top of the plane, usually suspended by a stick or something, connected to the tip of the tail.

What was the reason for that, and around when did we stop suspending the tails with wires?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

Did the Soviet had any plans to re-conquer finnish lands during WW2?

1939: Despite stubborn finnish resistance, soviets troops managed to snatch some lands off them.

1941, Finnish troops re-capture those lands

I understand that in 1941-42 the soviet were pretty busy with the german army, but once they got the upper hand and Berlin was getting closer everyday, were any plans to re-conquer those lands?

Were there any troops available? Were they wary of the finnish resistance? Would the allies disaprove of such venture?

Could not find anything online, so I am trying here for an answer, thanks!

1 Answers 2021-01-18

How are guerrilla forces able to maintain supply lines are other logistics?

War requires a complex logistical system, from delivering everything from food to munitions. So how is a guerrilla force, such as the Taliban in Afghanistan, able to feed and acquire enough ammunition to effectively fight, especially when guerrilla warfare places an emphasis on not holding land, and thus an industry to produce weaponry?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

Were cannonballs ever recycled from battlefields?

I came across an interesting article from the Detroit Free Press while browsing t'internet about a US Civil War explosive shell being found in a Michigan recycling plant:

https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2020/05/20/kent-county-recycling-center-civil-war-cannonball/5233484002/

And this got me thinking, a single cannonball doesn't consist of much iron, but if you knew of a battlefield where several thousand solid shot had been fired into a concentrated area, would it be economically worthwhile to dig up spent cannonballs?

Was there an industry for recycling spent ammunition during the 16th Century and onwards? And if so, when did that industry stop being sustainable?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

I found some old photos in a book. What's the process a historian would/ should use to figure out when and where they are from?

Photos: http://imgur.com/gallery/9NzHBnG

Are there clues you look for? Do you consult other historians? What sources would you compare against to check your hypothesis once you think you know when/where they are from?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

In 1941, what percentage of Japanese (home-island) imports was carried on Allied (US, UK+Commonwealth, USSR, maybe Dutch) flagged shipping? What was the Japanese Imperial Government's plan to deal with the loss of this import shipping upon the declaration of war with the US/UK?

If there was a reasonable plan, how well was it executed? I imagine that if the plan involved seizure of foreign cargo vessels in Japanese and captured ports, you still have the problem of crewing them, and thus would need a surplus of merchant crews ready and available at the outbreak of war.

Was Allied flagged shipping to Japan in significant decline 1939-1941 due to UK commonwealth war needs and/or the various US embargoes against Japan put in place prior to the declaration of war?

Also since the USSR was nominally neutral with Japan in the December 1941-August 1945 period, did the USSR and Japan continue to (officially) trade with each other? Despite what I would imagine to be German and US/UK pressure to end such trade.

1 Answers 2021-01-18

How similar are Indo-European archetypal gods and myths to Aborigional African/Asian archetypal gods and myths?

Some rather smart Ancient Mediterranean myth experts (and also me) were joking around recently about the comparative similarities of their mythological gods. I cracked a joke/comment about "And they're all derived from long lost Indo-European gods from 15,000 years ago." (Not entirely unseriously, as there's a theory backed by proof of that re: Comparative Mythology)

But it got me a-pondering: What I've read of Comparative Mythology has focused a lot on similar themes and archetypal gods in Indo-European cultures, but I'm not as familiar with similar work on largely Sub-Saharan African mythologies. Along those lines, Comparative Mythology, along with linguistics and archaeology and paleontology has long supported the idea that much of the Indo-European world has a shared base culture. So how does that compare to Africa and Asia mythology. And how collectively similar are all human mythologies?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

In the article about wrestler Gorgeous George, Wikipedia claims that "It is said that George was probably responsible for selling as many television receivers as Milton Berle". How could this assertion be either proved or disproved?

I'm actually less interested in if it's true or not (though it would be nice to know) and more interested in how a historian could verify such a claim. It's not like people were signing a form saying why they were buying the TV for. I imagine you could see the ratings for different programs and extrapolate from there, but that doesn't seem much rigorous

2 Answers 2021-01-18

In the age of kings and castles what was Africa like?

When I think of kings and castles I think of mostly European decent. We all know the stories but I was curious what was going on in Africa during that time?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

How did Creedence Clearwater revival become so synonymous with the Vietnam war?

Specifically, how did fortunate son become so entwined with Vietnam war media such as apocalypse now, and the game Black ops when it was clearly a protest song against said war. Logically it shouldn’t be used to ‘glorify’ Vietnam warfare, but rather to condemn it

1 Answers 2021-01-18

What kind of security would the Soviet embassy in Washington DC have had? Who guarded the interior of the facility?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

How Do Historians Deal With Terminology Getting Co-Opted By Racists & Nationalists?

I guess I'm mainly thinking of how many white supremacists co-opt terminology like "Nordic" or "Germanic" for their movements, and some of them reach back for some kind of mythic white past...how do historians deal with that? Is there a proper response, or should it just be ignored?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

Did film stars have to go to war?

In the 1910s-30s film business was already blooming in the US and I can imagine that there were a couple of very famous lads out there. When World War 2 happenend, did they have to serve as well or were they privileged because of ongoing projects or something similar?

If I google this topic, I only find actors that got famous after serving but were there already established actors in the war?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

Why Muhammad Ali Pasha's reform to modernize Egypt failed while in the same period Japanese attempt succeed?

Just reading the wiki page of Muhammad Pasha and it seems like for two decades he worked quite hard to do what Japan did successfully in the same century. He reformed military basing it on western armies, had build a domestic armament industry, paved the way for industrialization employing western managers etc, purged old nobility i.e. Mamluks, created a central bueracaracy and much more.

But even though Egypt was much closer to Europe, it seems like that Egypt failed in modernizing even while actively trying to attempt it at this point in time whereas a faraway Japan succeeded, why is that? What undid all the advances made in Egypt during Muhammad Pasha?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

Why was 1898 seen by Spaniards as such a disaster?

My knowledge of the topic is exceptionally basic. I understand the de Lome letter was a major factor in starting hostilities in Cuba, and the Treaty of Paris essentially signified the end to Spanish colonial ambitions in much of the World. However I am struggling to find any information regarding how this year was viewed in Spain by the ordinary member of Spanish nobility? Any sources both primary and Secondary would be massively helpful :)

Thank you !

1 Answers 2021-01-18

What was the experience of the representatives of Germany with the peace negotiations after world war 1?

I've read that on this day (18 January) in 1919 the peace conference started to discuss the peace treaty to end world war 1. What was the experience of german representatives at this conference? What was their role in this conference? Had they any say at all in this conference or was their task only to sign the treaty?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

The saying that “through discipline comes freedom” is attributed to Aristotle. Is this true, and where exactly was it written?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

Why did the Americans romanticise the IRA so much?

What my question relates to mainly is what seems to me to be an overly positive image of the IRA, at least certainly back in the time of the Troubles from what I've read. I've read and heard about significant fundraising which was done in Irish-American communities in the USA which went towards the upkeep of the IRA and purchasing of weaponry for use in Northern Ireland. Was this a case of people being aware of the group's activities and choosing to ignore the worst of it, or was this more a case of total ignorance? Obviously these weapons and so on were used on "fair" game but also for the assassination of soldiers and policemen, car bombings, and so on. These all obviously being rather underhand, especially with the risk of injuring civilians as frequently happened.

(Edited out the bottom section as I was informed it was too close to he inflammatory language. Sorry for the mistake.)

2 Answers 2021-01-18

Why is Mansa Musa considered as the richest man in the history? Like weren't there Asian rulers from China or Indian sub continent who were significantly better off then him?

Just a doubt in my head, since I'm asian and have not studied history of African continent pre colonisation much, I just don't understand how an African ruler could be better off then emperors from either of these countries considering the fact that both of these countries together controlled half of the world gdp according to books that I have read. I could be horribly wrong and if that's the case I'm really sorry.

1 Answers 2021-01-18

What was the situation in South American countries during the World War I & II? Were they affected by the wars?

I've read and seen many documentaries on the World Wars but none of them talked about South America. I know South America didn't really take part in the wars but what was the impact of the wars to the south american countries? Were they affected as same as Europe?

2 Answers 2021-01-18

How would a galley from the Mediterranean civilizations (Greeks/Romans/Phoenicians) during the Classical Antiquity era compare to a junk from the eastern Asian civilizations (Chinese/Koreans) during the same time period?

By galleys and junks I just mean ships/water-going vessels of each of their respective cultures. Also, by a comparison I mean what are the strengths and weaknesses of both ship styles and where and how does one have the advantage over the other such as; speed, mobility, armorment, battle worthiness etc. Please note that I'm asking for a comparison, not necessarily who was the absolute best at seafaring/ship building.

1 Answers 2021-01-18

Is "Dark Emu" a reliable source? Why/why not?

Dark Emu by Bruce Pascoe is a book detailing groundbreaking findings about Indigenous Australian agriculture and land management.

However, it seems to be controversial. Some people have very politically-charged opinions on the book, and it is a subject of frequent flame wars like this.

So is Dark Emu a reliable source? Why/why not?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

When did the Austrians start to create their own identity? When did they start to not consider themselves german anymore?

I am from Austria and here everyone is keen is telling you the difference between Germans and Austrians. Why is that? Werent the Austrians part of the HRE and even a leading force?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

In the Ottoman Empire, you had the Janissaries & in Rome you had the Praetorian Guard, but what about the Mughal Empire? what elite army was considered the go to for the Mughal Emperor?

Title. I just find it interesting that there is nothing that I can find that can help provide me which elite group the Mughal Empire had that the emperor could rely on, etc. Did they even have one?

1 Answers 2021-01-18

897 / 7255

Back to start