What did they do with all the heads during the French Revolution?

About 17000 people were guillotined, so where did all these heads go?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

How did Hitler react to the Italians sheltering jews?

Hi. So apparently Mussolini did not wanto kill jews and aparantly protectes jews from Hitler . The article mentions that Hitler was pissed at the Italians but didn't actually do much? Why did Hitler still continue to ally with Italy or not force them to do anything about it? If Hitler actually did try and force the Italians to stop sheltering jews how exactly did he do this? How successful was he and why? I have so many questions about this! And what was Italys motive for keeping jews alive if they had one or was it just genuine goodness. If theres anything else about this topic please let me know!

1 Answers 2021-01-15

I'm a wealthy Roman Citizen at the height of the Empire, are the far reaches of Rome's territory actually accessible to me? Can I pack up my things and start a life in Northern Gaul or the western coast of Iberia? Will I be welcomed as a countryman?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

What happened to the Hohokam? Who did later tribes in Hohokam territory think the Hohokam were?

Side note: Anyone know of an online English to Hohokam dictionary?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

What was Puyi "officially" within the Co-Prosperity Sphere?

While it is without question that Puyi - in his role as head of state for Manchuko - was an unambiguous puppet for the Japanese Empire, what was his "official" status and prestige within the broader network of vassals and puppet states that made up the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere? Did Puyi ever publicly, unambiguously bend the knee to Japan? Did he ever swear fealty to Hirohito or a representative? How did the Imperial Cults of both Japan and China(both of which, I believe, declared their respective sovereigns to be without equals or superiors) deal with the presence of another monarch claiming equal prestige to their lord? Thank you for any response.

1 Answers 2021-01-15

looking for some literature on modern retirement savings

I am looking for literature on the history of contemporary and modern savings methods specifically in the form of pension funds, stock investment etc. When did this phenomenon arise, what caused and it and why?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

Were ever found Dinosaurs fossils from people in ancient times? What did they think of them?

2 Answers 2021-01-15

After the Mexican-American war of 1846, why didn't the U.S. absorb Mexico as new American territory? With Manifest Destiny being so prevalent in this century, wasn't this a great opportunity for the U.S. to get a massive piece of land after their victory?

2 Answers 2021-01-15

Why were Military Uniforms so colourful and stylish prior to WW1?

New to history and I've noticed how almost every military had bright uniforms prior to WW1 and I even heard about how French Soldiers were easy to pick off in WW1 because of their blue outfit. So why was it that no one had blander more natural colours until WW1?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

What's the origin of the sea shanty?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

We all recognize that this is the year 2021. Who or what is responsible 2021 years ago for saying “you know what, let’s start counting NOW”?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

I'm an African man who was invited to go to school in the Soviet Union. What's my daily life like? How am I treated? Am I touted around like a piece of propaganda?

Were there any type of anti-miscegenation laws? What happens if I have a kid while I'm there? Were African women also permitted to attend university?

Follow up question: What about black Americans. Were they invited to go to school in the Soviet Union as well? If so, did the US permit it?

3 Answers 2021-01-15

If Henry VII's paternal grandfather was Edmund Beaufort, would that make his claim stronger or weaker?

I recently read that Henry VII's paternal grandfather may not have been Owen Tudor, but Edmund Beaufort, the putative lover of Catherine de Valois. According to Wikipedia:

"By its very nature the evidence for Edmund Tudor's parentage is less than conclusive, but such facts, as can be assembled, permit an agreeable possibility that Edmund 'Tudor' and Margaret Beaufort were first cousins and that the royal house of 'Tudor' sprang in fact from Beauforts on both sides." -G.L. Harris

A major hiccup for Henry's claim to the throne was that his only connection to the Lancasterians was through his mother; but Edmund Beaufort was the grandson of John of Gaunt, and thus the great-grandson of Edward III. So if Henry really was his grandson, that would make Henry a direct patrilineal descendant of Edward, same as all the Lancasterian Kings. Of course, that would also make his father illegitimate; but if I'm not mistaken Edmund Tudor (Henry's father) owed his status chiefly to the patronage of Henry VI, of whom he was a maternal half-brother, and that would be true regardless of who his father was.

So my question is: why did Henry's propaganda never lean in on the Beaufort rumor? Was it not common knowledge at the time? Did they perhaps fear offending the Lancasterians by implying that Catherine de Valois was unfaithful? Or would that have had an adverse effect on Henry's claim? If so, why?

EDIT: fixed one "son" to "grandson".

1 Answers 2021-01-15

English translations of the writings of Niketas Byzantios.

Hi, does anyone know where to find the works in English of this 9th century Byzantine theologian/philosopher? or even if they exist? I'm looking particularly for the text titled: ‘Positive exposition of Christian doctrine, developed from general concepts by means of dialectical method, rational arguments, and multiple syllogistic proofs, followed by a confutation of the letter sent by the Hagarenes to the Emperor Michael, son of Theophilus, in order to slander the Christian faith.’

1 Answers 2021-01-15

A question about the firebombing of Dresden in WW2.

I remember read an excerpt of an account from an allied POW who present in Dresden during the bombing and he told of these giant fire tornadoes that were literally sucking people in.

Who was he?

Was he exaggerating?

2 Answers 2021-01-15

Is there any insight into why Marcus Aurelius (viewed as a wise philosopher Emperor) chose his son Commodus (viewed as one of the worst Roman emperors) as his heir?

Marcus Aurelius is generally viewed as a wise and “good” Roman emperor, while his son and successor Commodus is generally viewed as one of the worst and most vicious Roman emperors. My understanding is that Commodus didn’t become particularly unhinged until his solo reign as emperor, but in theory one might assume there were “warning signs” prior to this? Was Commodus really a different man after becoming solo emperor? Or, for all his wisdom, was Marcus Aurelius simply blind to the viciousness of his son (as any parent can be with their child)?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

J. Edgar Hoover became Director of the Bureau of Investigation (predecessor for the FBI) at age 29. How was this possible? Did he engage in blackmail and other nefarious tactics? We know he engaged in abuses of power later in his career, but do we know much about his early career?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

Here They Are, The Winners of the 'Best of AskHistorians 2020' Contest!

2020 is in the rear view mirror, and I think few are sad to see it go, but the year wasn't a total wash! We saw hundreds upon hundreds of amazing answers written on the subreddit, not to mention the multitude of insightful questions asked. All of them are worthy of recognition, as it is the collective contributions of everyone, from the most overactive flairs to the quietest of lurkers, who make this community the amazing place that it is, but nevertheless it is always a pleasant way to cap off each year by showing a little extra recognition to a few of them with our yearly contest.

As always, the winners receive some snazzy AskHistorians swag, joining the exclusive AskHistorians Mug Club, and everyone nominated for an award is also going to get some limited edition [Removed] stickers!

But enough of my babbling. It was, as always, an amazing field of candidates to narrow down from, and without further ado, I present you the 2020 Awardees!

Users' Choice Award: Voted on by the subreddit as a whole.

Flairs' Choice Award: Voted on exclusively by the Flaired User community.

Greatest Question: Chosen in a vote by the Moderators of the subreddit.

Excellence in Flair: Finally, one more award needs to be handed out. My original draft for this was going to mention a conspicuous absence, but of course, in the final voting, /u/mikedash nevertheless made an appearance for his fantastic answer to our 'GQ' winner, which in the end is why we're singling him out. After winning one of the yearly awards three times running and amassing, quite literally, an AskHistorians tea-set, the mod team decided to use a massive abuse of our power this year and exclude him from the year end voting, and instead highlight him for higher honors as the winner of our year end Excellence in Flair award, which is something we give out to recognize not merely good answers, but exceptional contributions to the AskHistorians community. Mike's breadth of knowledge is surpassed by few here, nor is his talent for the engaging and insightful way in which he communicates it. So on behalf of the Mod team, and the community as a whole, thank you so very much, Mike, for all you do to make this such an incredible place.

Once again, a warm congratulations to all the winners, and a thank you to everyone who worked over the past year to contribute in their own way to this community.

37 Answers 2021-01-15

Friday Free-for-All | January 15, 2021

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

11 Answers 2021-01-15

Papal Letters Looking for sources.

Hi Im looking for Papal letters written to Mongols and their sources (preferably can be accessed over the internet). I am looking for cum non solum by Pope Innocent IV 1245, Pope Nicholas IV to Arghun Khan 1288 and Pope Urban IV to Hulegu Khan 1263.

3 Answers 2021-01-15

Historic Price of Gold

According to this chart (found on more than one website)

http://www.finfacts.ie/Private/curency/goldmarketprice.htm

The price of gold during the 1800s was ≈$18.95 per troy ounce. But what I cannot find anywhere is whether this figure is adjusted for inflation at all. In other words, in, say, 1899, would a troy ounce of gold fetch $18.95 which was about as much as a month's wages for a farm laborer and could give meager subsistence to his family?

If so, then so 'strike it rich' in gold and be set for life, one would have to find pounds of the stuff (not just one nugget or pawnable necklace?

(asking for my novel)

Thanks,

Mary.

3 Answers 2021-01-15

I’ve heard it claimed that the bolshevik revolution was actually financed and engineered by wealthy bankers in London and New York City, so whats the real story behind thing?

I’ve often heard it claimed, generally by my more reactionary friends, that the bolshevik revolution was largely brought about by and in the interest of wealthy bankers in the West.

Now, given that the kinds of people spreading this information tend to be of a neoreactionary or conspiritorial sort, I’m somewhat skeptical about the authenticity of these events or their interpretation. I’m curious as to what the mainstream historiography is.

1 Answers 2021-01-15

Any good books about the French Revolution written by people who lived through it?

Hi. I’m looking for books about French Revolutions, written during it, or shortly after, and written by people who actually lived through it. Those can be memoirs, political essays, or any other genre. Thanks in advance

2 Answers 2021-01-15

What books do you recommend on connections between music and history?

Interested in learning more about music through history/how historical events have affected music, anywhere in the world through any period of time.

2 Answers 2021-01-15

Cynical agnostic here. Was the Christian assertion of suicide being a mortal sin meant to discourage peasants from escaping the misery and toil of their lives (particularly throughout medieval Europe), therefore preserving a working-class to perpetuate the wealth of the church and nobles?

1 Answers 2021-01-15

902 / 7255

Back to start