How far did the Japanese sail into the Pacific Ocean in the pre-modern time? What did they think was at the end of the ocean?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

How did race and skin tone factor into beauty standards of Ancient Greece?

Modern art depicts a lot of famous beauties from back then, e.g. Andromeda, mythical wife of Perseus, or Roxana, wife of Alexander, as white. However, Andromeda / Cassiopeia were from Ethiopia, and Roxana was from central Asia. The Ancient Greeks definitely knew that these women wouldn't have looked obviously European. At the same time, being "pale" as a sign of wealth/staying indoors has been a standard of beauty across many ancient cultures, even before the racial Darwinism stuff of the colonial era.

So how exactly did the Ancient Greeks (or Romans, or whatever) view beauty, especially when involving women of color?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Where can i find drawings of armor and weapons of the Middle Ages? Any good website or books you can recommend?

While this might be an incredibly broad question, I am struggling to find any solid website/book/video etc. etc. on the subject of armor, clothing, weapons, any kind of such tools of war.

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Why did multiple civilisations spring up independently of each other after ~4000 BC? What was special about this time period and why don't we have examples of complex societies forming earlier?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

In the early days of cinema, outside of repeat viewing, were there ever attempts to steal film from a theatre for home viewing?

Before widespread use of televisions and the VHS, it's my understanding, people could only see a movie at the theatre.

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Vikings are famed for their fighting prowess. Do historians think this skill is related to widespread training in Glima, the ancient martial art mixing grappling, throws, and striking? Would your average Viking have trained in it?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Best of September Voting Thread

A bit delayed due to travel, but better late than never!

13 Answers 2022-10-07

Friday Free-for-All | October 07, 2022

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

6 Answers 2022-10-07

Why were Chinese walls built so differently to European walls? What caused this divergence in wall construction?

So in a previous answer, EnclavedMicrostate observes Tonio Andrade's 'Chinese Wall Thesis', and I'll quote EM's words here:

Chinese walls were generally earthworks several metres thick, which are hard to damage or destroy with siege equipment, and especially not by bombardment; in contrast, European walls were generally masonry works rarely more than 2m thick, and thus much less resistant to the sudden impacts of cannon shots.

We're ignoring everything gunpowdery about this. What I'm interested in is the walls themselves. Is Andrade's premise correct - is the average Chinese wall that different from the average European wall? What factors in their respective environments led to these differing preferences re walls? We can skip post-gunpowder European wall development, the move to star forts and sloping glacises, and everything. Why does a European city have a different wall to a Chinese city?

3 Answers 2022-10-07

As I understand, it's well-established that gunpowder and guns were invented in China. Why didn't this lead to a legacy of Chinese primacy in terms of innovation and dominance in firearms production?

My guess is that it has something to do with different metallurgy processes having been available in Europe, but I wasn't able to find a good source to check.

More to the point: if it's not just different access to minerals, what kept China from continuing to be at the forefront of development in this field that was pioneered there?

2 Answers 2022-10-07

Why is Etruscan culture and language so vaguely deciphered and documented?

Despite their cultural significance and influence on the Roman Empire, it seems their writing language was never truly deciphered, and they seem to be a relatively "mysterious" subset of people. Considering other sub-cultures that were conquered are documented in more detail- I'd like to know more about why so little is known. Were they a reclusive people? Was their spoken language never translated either?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Did Roosevelt have a plan to end up in war with Nazi Germany if Hitler didn’t declare war on the US following Pearl Harbor?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Why did the almost entirety of Jewish communities in the Arab speaking world left for Israel and Europe?

To my understanding, there is no longer a Jewish community in Baghdad, a community that has a long history, and was considered to be rich and prosperous. Similarly, Cairo's Jewish community had emmigrated, and most of the Jewish communities of modern day Morrocco and Tunis emmigrated to Israel or France. I was told that Jews in the Muslim world did not suffer from persecution as often and as severily as Jews in Christian lands, and were generally more politically effluent. In addition, I got the impression that traveling between in the Muslim world was easier, so if they could have moved to Palestine prior to the 20th century. Why is the sudden change?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

When did the Catholic Church begin to hate abortions?

And have there ever been any serious abortion scandals within the Church?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Why doesn't America cop more anger and outrage over the use of nuclear weapons against Japan in WW2?

Over the past 25 years (if not more) it's pretty clear that nuclear weapons are seen as the biggest threat to the world (in regards to conflict) with outrage over Iran, North Korea and now Russia all testing and indicating they have nuclear weapons. So why doesn't the US see more backlash or anger over their use of nuclear weapons in the bombing of Japan?

I find it odd that it's not seen as literally one of the worst, if not the worst act of war and one of the worst things a country has ever done. Totally understand a lot of bad things were happening in WW2 but given how many innocent people were killed and continue to suffer to this day it's strange no one really views it this way.

1 Answers 2022-10-07

What's a "keel haul gambler?"

I have been wondering this for sometime. I know what Keel hauling is (the practice of dragging sailors under a ship) but in John Ford's Stagecoach, the banker derogatorily refers to Hatfield as a "keel haul gambler." Did the term keel haul have a separate meaning among gamblers at this time?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

How did pikeman v. pikeman combat work in the era of the Spanish tercio?

I recently watched 'Alatriste' (good film!), and in the last big battle scene, we have two forces of pikemen opposing each other. Instead of closing and hitting home, they kind of stand a few paces apart, pretty much the length of their pikes, and shake them in each other's faces, maybe occasionally thrusting a little bit. A lot of the actual killing though seems to be done not by the pikes, but my a small number of soldiers who duck under the pikes, scuttle to the other side, and stab at the legs of the opposing force with knifes and swords.

I had never considered this possibility before, but after watching the film, well, it kind of makes a lot of sense. So was this common practice for the era, or from the imagination of the screenwriter?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Did the "Anarchist Prince" Pyotr Kropotkin and Karl Marx have much interaction?

Kropotkin is considered to be one of the key, foundational figures in Anarcho-Communism. He would have been considerably younger than Marx, but he was active in Europe during Marx's later years. I couldn't find any sort of mention of them working together, just that Kropotkin was a member of the IWA.

So, what do we know about their interactions, if any? And more generally, how did they feel about the others' work?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

Was the Boston Tea Party inspired in part by a tax cut by the Tea Act?

There's a thread making the rounds on Twitter claiming that the Boston Tea Party was organized by the Founding Fathers in part because the Tea Act lowered taxes and cut into smuggling profits.

This sounds off, as I thought Britain kept increasing taxes, without colony representation. The thread doesn't seem to cite any scholarly sources, so is there any grounds to what the author claims?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

What is the difference between feudalism and medieval Europe?

You can use the term feudal to describe a pretty specific and global era in history (minus the Americas) that sandwich between the dark ages and the renaissance, a time of swords and peasant farmers.. but why do we never use the term medieval the same way, is there something specifically European that the term captures which was absent from say China?

1 Answers 2022-10-07

During and after the American Revolution was there any attempt to democratize clothing?

Did fashion change in the United States after the Revolutionary War in a noticeable way? Was there a rejection of symbols of aristocracy (were there sartorial signs of aristocracy?)? Did a humble style take hold or did it simply continue as it was before 1776?

1 Answers 2022-10-06

United States of America bought Louisiana from the French. Who did the French buy it from?

More specifically, how did something that was "owned" by Natives become owned by Europeans? What was the process like?

1 Answers 2022-10-06

Could Apostle Paul have been a Roman agent-provocateur?

"Operation Messiah" (link to journal) examines the idea that Saul of Tarsus/Apostle Paul was "an agent-provocateur working for the Roman administration in Palestine and various other parts of the Empire".

However, the article seems to mostly explore the vein of plausibility, mainly making the case that Saul could have been an agent and not focusing on determining if he actually was.

That being said: is there any historical support for either question? To what extent is this theory plausible, and is there any actual support for this theory outside of the realm of plausibility?

1 Answers 2022-10-06

Did kids bullying kids in the 1800s? If so what form did it take?

Is bullying a 20th century thing? Or say in the 1800s what were kids bullied for? Was it verbal or physical or both?

1 Answers 2022-10-06

Greeks identified as Romans during Byzantine times, but after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire, newly-freed Greece went with a Hellenic identity rather than a Roman one. Did the English and the French push a Hellenic identity, or was it Greek-driven? Was anyone pushing for Roman identity?

1 Answers 2022-10-06

96 / 7255

Back to start