The famine in Kazakhstan from 1930-1933 is estimated to have killed off 25% of their population. What were the primary causes of such a devastating famine? How did Soviet authorities react to it?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Letter from St. Bernard to Abbot Suger of Saint Denis (HIS 101)

Hello all! I am trying to find any information regarding a letter from St. Bernard to Abbot Suger of Saint Denis about a duel between Lord Robert (of Deux), King Louis VII's brother and Lord Henry (son of the count [Thibaut II of Champagne]) following the Second Crusade. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Why did the Danes rescue the Jews?

It is a well known story that due to an organised evacuation of Denmark's Jews to Sweden and the intercession of the Danish Government on behalf of Danish Jews in concentration camps, 99% of the Danish Jewish population survived the Holocaust. However, I have never been able to pin down WHY this happened. From the highest levels of government down to low ranking civil servants and fishermen, Danes, with exceptions, actively cooperated with the evacuation and protected the Jews. What was special about Denmark which led to this organised and successful effort when other other occupied European countries failed so utterly?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Why was Washington admitted to the Union so much later than neighboring Oregon (1889 vs 1859)? (second attempt)

My understanding is that they were settled and established almost simultaneously (with Oregon being slightly earlier). I would have expected maybe a difference of 5 to 10 years between each being granted statehood (since Portland was founded 6 years before Seattle), not 30 years.

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Who was the first president in history and how established was the role and the figure before the Americas started to use it?

Just asking because even thought I'm not a scholar, I like to know about history and politics.

1 Answers 2020-12-12

I found a specific case study in Kraaft-Ebbing's Psychopathia Sexualis that I would like to further research. How does one begin such a thing?

I guess this is more a question of process than one seeking direct info.

I found a copy of the Psychopqathia Sexualis while helping a friend move a few years ago, and almost by happenstance, I opened it to a case-study describing what is almost indisputably a trans woman. Being trans myself, my heart breaks every time I read and re-read her account, knowing that she never had the opportunity to live the life I do now.

Her account is Case 108, here.

I can't help but want to know more about her. Who was she? What happened to her? What was even her name? But I'm no historian, I have no idea where to even begin? The only thing I've thought of is to try to figure out which edition of the book she first appears in? Should I reach out to like, a local univeristy history dept? Are there any book on the historiography of sexology I should look up?

Also, I guess a question I shoudl ask myself, is there any chance of actually uncovering her name or is this a wild goose chase?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

The role of the media in the vietnam war

Does anyone know books which are about the role of the media in the Vietnam war? (Dutch or English books) I need it for research I need to do for school. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-12-12

How much did meat cost during the Middle Ages?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

How was Christmas celebrated during the Middle Age?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Did people people in earlier epochs write science fiction books? What was the first science fiction book and what was science fiction for them?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

How did Islam spread to Indonesia?

How did Islam arrive in Indonesia? When did the Indonesians start converting? Was it spread due to invasion, Arab settlers or something? I'd like to know everything about this subject thank you. Please tell me other notable things about this

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Have any state’s election results ever been thrown out?

With Trump trying to throw out multiple states votes for the election it got me thinking, had that ever happened before? Like has a state’s election not been counted in the electoral votes? It seems unlikely to me as that would have a range of implications but I can’t find any information on it besides what’s currently going on.

1 Answers 2020-12-12

What do we know of the anarchists in the old Soviet Union?

Anarchists played a big part in the Russian and Ukrainian revolutions, forming militias, newspapers, and soviets. Free Territory of Ukraine was crushed, some anarchists converted to Bolshevism, anarchists are repressed. Then Stalin appears and dies in the 50s and a gulag rises to revolt and the rebels fly the black banner of the Makhnovists to spite the Soviets.

Then what? What comes next? I found this intriguing Interview with Soviet Syndicalists conducted in 1991 and a little before the fateful collapse of the Soviet Union.

What happened in between? Who were the anarchists in the old Soviet Union, how did they organize, and what did they do? Did they see themselves as the successors of the Makhnovists? Or something else? What did they believe? (Individualism? Anarcho-communism? Platformism?) What did the Soviet authorities think of the anarchists? Do the Soviet archives tell us anything?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Did napoleon Bonaparte actually say "God is on the side with the best artillery"

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Why were there no Jews in England until after the Norman Conquest?

I remember reading in James Campbell's essay "Was it infancy in England", that traditionally historians, implicitly or explicitly, assumed that there weren't any Jews in pre-1066 England on the presumption that late Anglo-Saxon England was too economically backward to have any need for Jewish credit. Since the 1970s that position has become increasingly untenable - 10th and early 11th century England seems to have been above the Western European average in terms of urbanisation and to have had an already very monetised economy and thriving trade with Flanders and Ottonian Germany - and so as Campbell suggests, there must have been some kind of royal decree preventing Jews from coming in that William the Conqueror and his successors revoked that simply hasn't survived to us. Still, there's no way of proving that so what are the other possible explanations for the apparent absence of Jews in pre-Norman England. Then there's also the question of whether there were any Jews in Roman Britain, given that there were quite a few Jewish communities in Gaul and trends in recent scholarship have also argued that Roman Britain, especially in the 4th century AD, was a lot more cosmopolitan and a lot less of an underdeveloped imperial periphery than historians have traditionally assumed. If there were, then why did they apparently disappear after the Roman legions left.

1 Answers 2020-12-12

How was the DDR army intergrated in the Bundeswehr?

  • What happened to the equipment?
  • Did soldier had to go through new trainings?
  • How different were the two armies? was "ideologial" re-education required?
  • What happened to the higher ups?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Did the Columbian Exchange influence cuisine across the Pacific Ocean?

Discussion of foodstuffs and the Columbian Exchange typically focuses on trans-Atlantic trade, following the introduction of plants like potatoes and tomatoes to Europe, and the flow of livestock to the New World.

Did the globalization of food resources dramatically alter or influence cuisine in communities across the Pacific Ocean?

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2020-12-12

Is it true that the Americas had very few tin deposits.

I saw something on an alt history forum that stated than one of the reasons the bronze age and iron age was so different between the Americas and Europe was that the Americas had many copper deposits while Europe had few but the Americas had few tin deposits while Europe had many.

I have also heard that apparently the Inca were experimenting with iron upon the arrival of the Spanish and that the pacific coast cultures had iron.

I would like to know if there is any validity to this and if there are any good sources for this?

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Hanukkah, despite being a relatively minor Jewish holiday (indeed it is a festival, not a holy day), has, in the broader culture, become "Jewish Christmas," even though religiously it's not nearly as important as Christmas.

What's the history behind this change in the way Hanukkah is viewed? When did it go from being a minor holiday to one of the few that gentiles recognize? Where did the whole presents thing come from - is it from gelt? Or is it because Jewish kids were jealous of their Christian neighbors every December?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

Argentina Economic History Book

I'm really struggling to find a good history of Argentina in English. My ideal history would:

- Focus on economics

- Ideally have an update for Macri's time in office

- Be in English

Does anyone have any suggestions? Thanks

2 Answers 2020-12-12

What is / was it like being a certified historian and is it a viable career path in the modern day?

I suppose this is more of a meta /Historiographical question but I think this is the perfect community to answer this. How viable is a career in history, and while on the topic, how has the role of historians developed through out history? Have historians always been valued in their society or is that a more recent development? Or perhaps was there a case where historians were appricated more in the past?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

During the French Revolution why did the French army not save the King?

I've read John McPhee's *liberty or death * and listened to the revolutions podcast but I'm still unclear about why there was never any Royalist uprising from within the French army.

I understand that there was a fear of the army crushing Paris early on, a whole lot of French officers ended up emigrating and that problems with Bourbon loyalties in the army, like officers say wearing a Bourbon uniform, was a common problem from time to time long after the assembly took control of the country but the army never led any kind of armed revolt.

Eventually the problem solved itself as the army became filled with post revolutionary soldiers but I don't understand why no general ever successfully martched on Paris before then.

(Dumouriez is the only attempt I remember but this is quite late by thinking. Why not earlier than him.)

1 Answers 2020-12-12

David Irving - Can you trust anything that he wrote?

Hi there, I just finished reading Irving's book 'Churchill's Book'. As much as I dislike Irving as a person, the book is very well written, enjoyable and after double-checking parts, it seems well researched (Besides the focus, which seems to be pure speculation rather than fact). From a historian's point of view, can you trust anything he wrote, is he still referenced by historians? Btw, I am not defending Irving, but I am aware of his Holocaust record and tho much of what he has written seems to be nonsense, some things he has said have been backed by Franciszek Piper and other scholars. But back to the question, what do Historians think of Irving?

2 Answers 2020-12-12

Why were there still peasants in early-mid 20th century France and Italy? Didn’t Napoleon put an end to such slavery systems ?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

What would have likely happened if a white woman in pre-civil war Southern United States delivers a half black baby?

1 Answers 2020-12-12

960 / 7255

Back to start