Were vikings who grew old and died of old age seen as disgraces, since they did not die on the battlefield?

Since, as I understand, the greatest honor for vikings was dying in battle and going to Valhalla, it made me wonder the above question. Were old Vikings regarded as heroes, "normal" or instead disgraces since they did not die an honorable death in battle?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Why didn't American colleges and universities close down in 1918?

I've been doing some research on institutional responses to the Spanish flu. 40 out of the country's 43 largest cities closed their public schools. Tons of public celebrations and gatherings were cancelled. Universities are hubs of young people, aka the people most vulnerable to the Spanish flu. While some schools did unroll some more or less strict guidelines, not many schools sent the kids home. Why is that?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Is the effectiveness of the naval blockade on Germany in WWI overstated? Was German society's breakdown in 1918 due more to economic mismanagement by the military rather than the closing of maritime trade by the Royal Navy?

Just read this argument, which says that foodstuffs from outside Europe would have been closed anyways (Canada, Australia, New Zealand, America eventually and Argentina). There is also the point that the German merchant marine fleet was too small by the time the war started, insurance from London was unavailable, and there was little way to communicate via cable for orders.

Reading this in Cambridge's history of the naval war in WWI, which points the finger at Ludendorff's decision to take draught animals for his spring offensive that killed the harvest (and Poland, Hungary and Ukraine not really in any state to deliver food).

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Did E. E. "Doc" Smith invent the combat information center?

I read somewhere (probably TV Tropes, so) that what we would today recognize as a CIC (a centralized hub away from a ship's bridge for coordinating and directing a battle) was first described by Smith in his Lensman books, which went on to inspire their implementation in modern warships.

As a concept, the CIC seems like something that would arise organically from the needs of increasingly complex engagements, but Smith was writing directly before WWII and I believe he did government work in chemistry, so it's possible he was in contact with folks who would go on to implement the CIC as we know it. Can this one author really be credited with something that has become such a staple of our image of naval engagements?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Books

As an aspiring archaeologist, what important books would you recommend I read if I want to learn up on the different cultures within the cradle of civilization. I'm already plan on getting Histories by Herodotus, The Book of the Dead, and the Epic of Gilgamesh.

1 Answers 2020-12-10

If I were a citizen of the roman republic, how would I have gotten a new haircut?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

In the movie The Death of Stalin, it is portrayed how Georgy Zhukov gets involved in the power struggle after Stalin's death and Beria's execution/arrest. How much of it is true?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Have any past election results in U.S. history been in dispute?

With the last two presidential elections in the U.S. being in dispute (I.e. Trump winning because of Russian involvement or Biden winning because of Chinese involvement) I was curious if any local/state/national elections in U.S. history have ever been in dispute before where large numbers of people don’t believe the election results are valid.

I apologize if this breaks the <20 year rule but I am more curious about elections prior to 2000 (as that one was decided by the Supreme Court)

1 Answers 2020-12-10

How exactly were color TVs advertised on black and white sets?

What kind of campaign was used? And in general, did people buy them in color for the novelty, or did they need proof or examples that the color version actually looked good?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Did romance languages like norman french or latin influence the english language right down to the core, even changing the basics?

I know that there was a large influence on English by norman french and to a certain extent by latin itself on vocabulary and pronounciation. But did it also change grammar, syntax etc. ? For example if you take the word 'go' (or 'to go'), the past tense of it is 'went', making it an irregular verb and basically replacing 'go' with a completely new word in the past tense. That is very unlike most other germanic languages (eg in german 'gehen' -> 'ging')

So did this come from the latin 'venit' which does roughly mean the same? Especially since pronounciation of classical latin 'v' is kind of similar to the english 'w', at least at the beginnig of words.

1 Answers 2020-12-10

In 1953, German public opinion polls on Denazification showed that 87% of Germans were against the denazification of POWs recently released from Russia. Why is that?

I did this in class today, my answer was that the POWs had suffered enough in Russian camps, so Germans did not want them to be bothered/make them also feel harassed at home. What were German attitudes over denazification overall?

Source: Elizabeth Noelle and Erich Peter Neumann, eds., Jahrbuch der offentlichen Meinung, 1947-1955, Allensback 1956, p. 142.

edit: image link of source https://imgur.com/590Huhi

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Why mind sports such as chess or go have men and women playing different categories if the player's physical attributes are irrelevant to the game?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | December 10, 2020

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

14 Answers 2020-12-10

How far did civilization regress with the collapse of the Western Roman Empire

I've always been fascinated by the idea that invading barbarians brought about the 'dark ages'. I was interested if there are any books that deal with western europe in the early medival period and challenge the assumption that technology, civilization and culture regressed.

Thanks in advance for any suggestions of research.

Edit. Early medieval rather than early dark ages.

2 Answers 2020-12-10

What’s the general consensus on how Ivarr “The Boneless” got his nickname

I know there’s a few theories about Ivarr’s nickname. The obvious and one depicted in the show Vikings was that he had a bone disease that rendered his legs useless. However, I’ve also read that “boneless” was referring to his impotence. Some also think it was a simple mistranslation over time and “Boneless” isn’t the correct nickname at all.

So, is there a general agreement among historians on the most likely meaning behind the name?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

When the Dutch created massive new land like the Flevoland polder, how were farms and plots of land assigned?

Doing a lot of stuff on Roman land assignation during the Republic recently got me thinking on how this was handled during modernity. When such new tracts of land were created, how was the land assigned, especially farmland? Was there an auction, did the land just go to the highest bidders, or was there an effort to give land to 'farmers in need', so to speak? Couldn't find anyhting on wikipedia on that matter.

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Nobility during WWI

Hi, i'm from Italy and i come from a really high-grade nobility family from the south of Italy.

I'm studying some history of my family and i realised that the father of my grand father was born in 1899. Here in Italy, these boys who were born in 1899 were the ones who saved the country during the horrible war with Austria, enrolling in 1917 when they became just 18 years old.

I wanted to know what was the role of noble borns during WWI, i know that his sister was an important red cross volunteer and she died on the front, she had a medal for this. But i don't know anything about her brother Paolo, my grandfather's father.

It would be a great honour to know if he served for the army as a '99 boy since this generation is highly rewarded with pride.

During the history of my family, many ancestors had military grade in chivalry and command. My grandfather also was enrolled in WWII as anti-aircraft artillery, but rapidly dismissed for political reasons or for illness.

Thanks for the help!

2 Answers 2020-12-10

Are there theories as to why so much of Enlightenment political thought (for examples Hobbes, Locke, Smith) emerged out of England in the 17th and 18th centuries? Was there something distinctive about how openly these subjects were permitted to be discussed in the public square?

...or is this an Anglocentric misconception on my part?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

The Death of Yugoslavia Ep.1

I have a ton of questions! Hoping someone could give some clarifications on The death of Yugoslavia Episode 1. So my first question is.. why was Ivan Stambolic suddenly seen as a a dictator after the Kosovo incident and I wasn't exactly clear what it is they where voting for. Wasn't Milosevic the one who went against communist party guidelines? Also why did Milosevic's nationalist ideology gain so much traction within a communist country? Also there was a segment about these (I may be wrong ) magazine publishers . I wasn't clear exactly what the point of the segment was ? And my final question is when its talking about serbia, Kosova, croatia, slovania, bosnia, and montenegro are these all part of one country ? It seems they all have there own governments ?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Why didn’t starving sailors during the Age of Exploration fish during voyages to survive?

It seems like there’s a lot of accounts (for instance Magellan’s voyage across the Pacific) where the crew find themselves in dire straits eating rats and ox hides. I’ve always wondered why they didn’t simply fish for food to supplement their stores? With the bounty of the ocean how did it get to the point of starvation. I’d imagine I’m missing some simple point here but I’ve always wondered and I was hoping someone could finally answer this little question I had. Thank you!

2 Answers 2020-12-10

Why is the Tale of Genji widely considered the first novel?

I was taking a Classical Japanese course where the professor mentioned that many considered the Tale of Genji to be the world's first novel, and vague google search results seem to agree with this statement. But I was also taking an Ancient Novels course and most of the novels covered in that course predates Murasaki Shikibu (i.e., works by Longus, Heliodorus, Chariton, etc.). In Collected Ancient Greek Novels edited by B.P. Reardon, Reardon states, in his introduction to Callirhoe, that the work, being from the 2nd century A.D., is considered "the first European novel." So I was wondering why the Tale of Genji from the early 11th century is often touted as the first novel ever?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

What are some good resources to find information and diagrams of the uniforms of La Grande Armeé during the 1812 Russian Campaign?

I’m doing research for some art projects. Specifically I’m looking for illustrations of the the fusiliers and the foot artillery uniformes, as well as what their winter equipment was. I’ve searched on Google for this, but the results were inconsistent and dubious.

1 Answers 2020-12-10

"BC" is used widely in the secular West to separate one historical era from another. How does anyone know if Christ was real and, if so, when he was born? Ancient texts may claim of these things, but are they really treated as definitive sources?

The dates of their births and deaths of ancient Greek philosophers were always estimated and considered secondary, while their ideas were emphasized. But one of Christianity's major accomplishments was convincing a huge swath of the population that Christ was born in the year 0, and that everything after that counts upward.

Using BC or BCE as a mark of denotation between "then" and "now" seems shockingly religious given its ubiquity in many inquiries into history as well as defining our current year. Yet I see this in articles about history, archaeology, climatology, and so on.

Do academic historians give the alleged year of Christ's birth any credence? If so, how so they justify it?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Operation Lionheart Size

The British held a military exercise during the Cold War in 1984. It mobilized over 100,000 troops and is the largest British Army exercise. This hasn't happened on this scale again. Why is this? Could something like this happen again?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

Did Native Americans of pre-contact California find and value gold?

I would assume Native Americans living in the region that became the center of the California gold rush had encountered gold nuggets and flakes in rivers and streams, but I've never heard any reference to California's gold until 1848. Did they exploit this resource? Did they value it aesthetically? Was it a trade good?

1 Answers 2020-12-10

963 / 7255

Back to start