The Allies didn’t need to land in Normandy to win WWII. The Russians were already pushing the Germans back and would have eventually defeated the Germans anyway. However, they wouldn’t have stopped at the German border. We landed in France to prevent them from conquering all of Europe. True??

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Did the threat of nuclear escalation during the korean prevent later conventional conflicts between the west and communist powers?

The assumption of a no first use nuclear strategy during the cold war, with the caveat that NATO would use nuclear weapons in WW3 in order to scare soviet planners into leaving the west alone, seems to have arisen after the 1950s. However, nuclear escalation was present as a strategy by policy planners in the US during the Korean war and calmer heads prevailed. Did the fear of either side pushing their luck prevent open conflict with the west from China and to a lesser extant the Soviet Union after this conflict?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

How were medieval guilds organized? Were they ever divided by type? Were they just a collection of fraternities, or was there ever a governing body that managed them all? How did such an organization function, if it existed?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

How did racial segregation work on aeroplanes?

I know that a lot of the time, minorities couldn't afford to fly, so segregation wasn't that big of a problem. But those who could fly, how did it work? Was there a separate section in the plane and airport? If they were separated, how did it work on International flights, where racial segregation wasn't inplace in one of the countries?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

How could soldiers recognize the enemy on the battlefield during the medieval ages?

I don’t have much knowledge on medieval war but when I see movies or re-enactment shows, many of the soldiers are dressed in peasant clothes with no clear identifying uniforms or colors being worn. Is this accurate? Did the common foot soldier not wear a uniform and if so, how could they tell who the enemy was if there were hundreds or thousands of people in close quarters combat on the battlefield?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

What has been the reaction among other historians to the claim Nicholas Lambert makes in “Planning Armageddon”, that Great Britain initially planned and began to implement a strategy to collapse the German economy at the outbreak of WWI?

Is it generally seen as good revisionist scholarship?

Has his argument effected the how we understand the British blockade?

Is the book worth reading?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Why did everyone used to wear hats?

Why did everyone used to wear hats?? I’m watching a video about events in the late 1800’s, there was a huge crowd shot and EVERY man had the same hat on. Must have been thousands of people.

Why did everyone wear hats? When did it stop? What were some things you could tell about a person by their hat choice?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Did US-led coalition really expect thousands of casualties at the start of Desert Storm offensive in 1991?

It's a quote from a movie 'Jarhead': 'We expect as many as 30'000 casualties the first day'. Was that really the case or just 'inspiring' pep-talk from the sergeant?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

How do we know the pronunciation/syntax for dead languages?

I’m watching a movie about ancient Egypt and one of the characters says I can read and write ancient Egyptian, which begs the question for me, how do we know pronunciation for any ancient/dead languages? Seeing as we had to use the Rosetta Stone to translate Egyptian hieroglyphics how would it be possible to figure out what the hieroglyphs themselves sounded like or are we just kind of guessing?

2 Answers 2020-10-10

Please help me identify my friends knife

Hello all,
My friend recently showed me a knife. He was told that his grandfather received this knife from either his father or grandfather in France.
It looks expensive and considering the age of the knife I'm wondering if it was a reward for something (military service or something else along those lines) or if it was simply an expensive gift.
The design is the same on both sides, I can see no text, numbers or specific designs (coat of arms, initials, unit designation or anything).

Again, please help me, I'm going mad not knowing ^_^

Photo of Knife and Scabbard

3 Answers 2020-10-10

How far back could one go in England before being unable to understand what they were saying? Asking for a time traveling friend. Note: I was watching a series on the Tower of London and was surprised when they showed a note from Elizabeth I and I could clearly read and understand it.

2 Answers 2020-10-10

Who or what was responsible for civil order before the police?

Specifically thinking about the UK in the early 19th C and the years before Sir Robert Peel established the "first police force"?

2 Answers 2020-10-10

How come European countries with “honor guards” such as the UK’s red coat soldiers are typically dressed from the same era?

It seems they all prefer the napoleonic uniforms. Why is this the preferred military dress? Like why not from another time period? When was this decided?

I’m a US citizen living in Denmark and during a walk today a group of soldiers in dark blue traditional dress matched past me and got me wondering.

Thanks.

1 Answers 2020-10-10

How far were the landing craft from the beaches on d day and how long did it take to reach the beaches?

I've been on off looking for that info for a while and been unsuccessful, so hopefully someone here knows how far the landing craft had to travel from their launch ships to the beaches and the time it took to reach them. Movies and video games always make it seem like a very fast affair, like max 90 seconds but that seems unrealistic, so hopefully someone here knows this

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Following the US civil war, many confederates fled to Brazil and even founded their own city. Do we know if any of these kidnapped/brought their slaves with them and if so, what happened to them?

The Confederados fled to Brazil, invited by the Brazilian emperor who had v supported the south during the war. He offered them tax breaks and quick citizenship. Some numbers go as high as 20 000 ex-confederates arriving in Brazil from 1865 to to 1885, although it is unsure how many people went back to the states again.

But it did make me wonder, since the major reason for the war was slavery - do we know if any of these ex-confederates brought their supposed-to-be-free-by-now slaves? Do we know anything at all about what happened to them?

2 Answers 2020-10-10

Help identifying this image of a soldier in trews?

I'm trying to trace the source of this image,
https://imgur.com/a/uhVurMt

which depicts a soldier wearing what looks like trews. I received this image with no metadata via message, the person who sent this to me has no idea either and the usual reverse image searches don't show anything that fits.

I'd appreciate any help possible, since I'm not Scottish and I don't even know where to begin with military tartans. Thank you.

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Were Roman soldiers more likely loyal to their generals or to Rome? Also how much effort was put into propaganda to keep them loyal to Rome?

I understand the concept of a state was not fully developed during this period, but how did Rome hold itself together?

From my naive point of view it seems that wealthy individuals were often able to raise armies and initiate civil war. Were Roman soldiers just more loyal to the men who paid them? Also was there any wide spread effort to ensure loyalty to Rome through propaganda?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Why did the Scandinavians forget about the SKraeling (Inuit Peoples) after Viking Contact? Or did people in Iceland and Norway maintain contact with Greenland?

My question is very simple.

Did Scandinavians, the descendants of vikings, simply forget there was a weird "race" of people living in Greenland? What about Icelanders? Did they know about the Inuit in Greenland? Why did this not lead them to realize there was a whole other continent of peoples?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Lenin’s “New Economic Policy” after the ravages of the Russian Civil War allowed for limited private enterprise & profit-making. Is there any evidence that Lenin knew that strict central planning had major, insurmountable flaws?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

There seemed to have been no power rivaling Kublai Khan and his Mongol-Chinese Empire in the East. What led to the eventual Khanate collapse and the return of purely Chinese dynasty’s?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

To what degree did Washington's decision to step down after 2 terms have to do with his desire to encourage future presidents to do the same vs. other potential reasons, such as he was exhausted from leadership or just wanted to enjoy the rest of his life away from the constant struggle of politics?

The question pretty much says it all. The American history i was taught (I'm American, by the way), teaches exclusively the former, but it seems unlikely that there weren't at least a couple other reasons that played a role to some degree.

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Alexander the great's battle at the Granicus river.

I just read Peter Green's book about Alexander and in that book he says that Alexander crossed the granicus river in the middle of the night with the fires still lit at the camp. He did that according to Green so that the persiens didn't notice the crossing. So according to Green Alexander crossed the river at night and than fought the battle on flat terrain against the Persians. However almost all other sources like wikipedia says that Alexander charged them head on and attacking them while crossing the river.

My question is which one is correct. Green's battle seem a lot more like something Alexander would do. He was considered to be the best commander who ever lived by a lot of famous commanders like Napoleon, Caesar, Hannibal etc. Which make me think that green's version is a lot more accurate for a commander with that reputation. Which one is correct? What do the original sources about the battle say?

1 Answers 2020-10-10

Why did everyone stop using battleships?

In both world wars who had the biggest guns on a ship was insanely important, it was a race to make the biggest battleship with the most, biggest guns,

Nowadays basically no navy has battleships in active service, what happened that made everyone ditch the idea of big gun on big ship = good?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Why don't we have atomic powered transportation?

I've been reading the book The Exploration of Space by Arthur C. Clarke and as he was talking about types of fuels, he mentioned atomic powered rockets. And now I'm wondering why we don't have atomic rockets and other transportation? Is it impossible to scale down a nuclear reactor to a usable size? Was there too much stigma against atomic power after events like 3 Mile Island and Chernobyl? I'd be curious to know. Thanks all.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

During 'The Blitz' in the UK during the 2WW, barrage baloons were widely used (per archives) to impede/inhibit attacks on UK cities. Tales also told as to the hight of the baloons implied the likelyhood of a raid/attack (higher baloons meant more likely). How were baloons meant to stop axis planes?

The planes didn't have on board radar to confuse. The planes could collide with the baloons or their tethers (but either seems rather unlikely), so what exactlly was their role? As they can't have been cheap to make and maintain. So they must have had a significant role that I cannot see.

Asking after watching the BBC documentary series - Blitz: The Bombs that Changed Britain.

Facinating series, single bombs (among the thousands and thousands dropped) had a massive impact on Britain, well beyound the local damage - changes to social support / welfare etc. that can be tracked back to the influence resulting from a single bomb.

2 Answers 2020-10-09

1058 / 7255

Back to start