[ANCIENT EGYPT] Would Coptic speakers have been able to understand Middle Egyptian?

I’ve always perceived the New Kingdom as having been “separated” from the cultures of the Middle and Old Kingdoms. Would Coptic speakers have been able to understand Middle Egyptian speakers?

Compared to how modern Greeks can understand the ancient Greek that was spoken and written 3,000 years ago; how would Egyptians compare?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

In prefirearm warfare, particularly with medium-heavy infantry formation like the romans, how deep were lines of battle?

The reason for this question is I’m currently doing some mild world building and am working on the military at the moment.

I’m aware that for something like the phalanx the lines could get fairly deep but I can’t seem to find anything on more flexible systems.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Except for the Bible, do historians attribute all ancient documents in Greek to the ancient Greeks?

We know that Alexander the Great tried to change the language of his empire to Greek, and as a consequence all documents of civilizations he conquered were translated into Greek. So do historians and archaeologists consider this when they discover documents in Greek in Egypt, Levant, or even in Greece itself?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

At the battle of Agincourt. King Henry V ordered the execution of the French prisoners? Logistically how would they have handled such a mass execution?

I can't imagine 700+ men(some number I saw in another thread) going willingly to their deaths. And it's not like they had firearms available like a more "modern" mass execution.

Was there resistance to this command? Did any of Henry's soldier or advisors object?

2 Answers 2020-10-09

In the movie Apollo 13, during the re-entry scene, a shot shows the crewmates of the USS Iwo Jima cheering on the deck of the ship with the Apollo's Command Module at a fairly close distance. Were the recovery ships really this close? How precise were the estimates for where the capsule would land?

I'm referring to this specific shot from the movie. The capsule looks quite close to the ship, so it makes me wonder: how accurate were the calculations to allow the recovery aircraft carrier to be this close to the landing zone?

2 Answers 2020-10-09

How did the former Allies view the rise of the Second French Empire?

Napoleon wreaked havoc on countries like Prussia, Austria, Russia, Britain and others during the Coalition Wars in 1797-1814. These same countries spent uncountable blood and treasure to remove Napoleon I as leader of France. When Napoleon III declared himself President for Life and subsequently Emperor, were any of these same powers worried? Or had historical memory of the Napoleonic Wars faded enough that they didn't care? Or are there other factors involved? Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-10-09

How much autonomy did Canada have regarding its military policies during WWII?

I'm asking about Canada because I'm Canadian, but feel free to discuss other British colonial possessions like India or South Africa, because the concept is the same.

I'm wondering if Canada was able to set their own policies with regard to conscription, arms manufacturing, etc, if Britain controlled the whole process, or some combination thereof.

Also, did Canadian officers have any control over the battles they participate in? I'm thinking specifically of Dieppe where Canadians were slaughtered in a half-hearted D-Day attempt. It seems like the British just sent their "expenadable" colonial soliders to die probing defences. Was this the case at all, or did Canada have a bigger role in choosing where to commit soldiers?

I've touched on a few subjects, any elaboration about anything would be greatly appreciated! Thanks for reading.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Was Ulysses Grant a liberal or a conservative?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Why did Albania side with China in the Sino-Soviet split?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

What was life like in the Crusader Kingdoms?

Say for example I was a soldier in the First Crusade and have decided to make a life for myself in Jerusalem. For almost 90 years the kingdom was held by Christians which means 3 generations of people could have been born in the area. Does my Western Culture start to dominate or is this still very much a 'Middle Eastern' place to be? Is there an influx of migrants from the West during these 90 years or is it just soldiers/pilgrims? And do they/their descendants decide to stay when the city falls back into Muslim hands? If I'm born in the city, do I have any idea what life would have been like back in the West and do I yearn for it?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

After WW2 what were the social consequences, if any, for Germans who had openly supported the Nazis during their rise?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

How and when did "Caucasian" become "White"?

Edit: for clarity, and I should have said this before, my question is more about when the term "white" came into common usage to identify Europeans and/or people of Caucasian ancestry.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

What did other countries use before degrees celsius? (excluding the obvious Fahrenheit)

Just examples of other cultures methods of measuring temperature. Also would be interesting to know how celsius became the standard for nearly every country (except that one).

Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Are there any infliences from the greek mythology in the old testament or generally in the Bible?

Like any concepts or storys maybe? I heard, the bible stole from some other religions too but I am specifically interested in the greek mythologie.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

What did swords look like after battles?

I saw a pretty interesting video of a samurai cutting some bamboo and it made me think about what swords look like after battles. I mean we have all these swords that are super sharp today and competitions where they do what I saw in that video, but you don't see people fighting with their swords. I mean like we see in the movies, the swords can't be that sharp after smashing a couple other pieces of metal edge on. Maybe swords back in the day where much harder and less sharp or something. But we see movies of medieval times where people will battle maybe upwards of an hour with their sword smashing people and stabbing people. How realistic is that? How long would it take to fix the sword afterwards? I suppose too it was a natural progression to the times of the "musketeers" or whatever (I can't presume to guess the years), we're swords were more for poking than slashing. Where am I completely wrong?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Scurvy and cider?

I’ve been reading Shōgun, and one scene addressed the issue of scurvy, saying a limiting factor on voyage duration was the amount of fresh fruit a ship could keep good.. and that extracts/tinctures/etc went rancid after a few months. I read the Kingsbridge Trilogy last week, and it seemed like everyone used sour apples to make cider. What I’m wondering is, why didn’t sailors just drink cider instead of grog, or in addition to it, since it seems like as it’s made from apples, cider should prevent scurvy? Or is the concentration of nutrients diminished in the fermentation process (for hard cider)?

Edit: Well, I answered my own question... or rather, the ship’s physician (James Lind) of the HMS Salisbury answered it for me.

“After the oranges, Lind observed that apple cider had the most beneficial effect on the seamen. Although the sailors on apple cider were not well enough to work, their gums improved somewhat, their weakness abated slightly and their appetites improved. Apple cider has a tiny amount of vitamin C, which caused moderate improvements in the men's health, but not enough to cure the disease.”

https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/wellness/1997/06/10/how-scurvy-was-given-the-heave-ho/2f0ed7c5-094a-429e-a514-9af894aeb9ce/

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Where were French troops when the allies were liberating France?

I know the nazis occupied the country and I assume they had soldiers under control and without weapons, but couldn't the Allies have freed / armed them? Whenever I read (not that much tbh) about the British and Americans fighting in France I don't see many mentions of the French, except for some support provided by the resistance.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

How did people in ancient armies know who was their enemy?

I'm curious how armies in the BC era knew who was their enemy and who was their friend? I know some larger empires like Rome had uniforms but smaller kingdoms surely did not or could not afford to outfit all of their soldiers with a uniform. Is there any documented cases of friendly fire in ancient times?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

How Was Ken Burns' THE CIVIL WAR Received By Historians In The 1990s?

I know that the PBS special on the American Civil War was a popular success during the 1990s, but what was the scholarly assessment?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

How did Marx's conception of Asiatic mode of production fall out of favor with historians and social scientists? Who were the first authors that challenged the thesis and what reaction did it generate?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

What was the Battle of Singapore like for Singaporean citizens?

I can't seem to find many anecdotal stories or detailed descriptions of Singapore's POV so I would greatly appreciate it if someone could help me.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Many people say that the way the Soviet Union drew its borders has led to many tensions in its borders after the USSR was dissolved. What was with the way that the USSR drew its borders that led to so many tensions around its borders and did they know that ethnic conflict was going to happen?

After the USSR dissolved, there was a lot of conflict that had happened due to the messy ways that the Soviet Union destroyed its borders to the point where conflict has gone everywhere from Transnistria wanting to have its own republic to the Nagorno Karabakh region which has had its fair share of wars and conflicts. In 1990, there was even a conflict between Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan over two cities.

Of course I don't want to touch around political events today. I wanted to learn more about the historical reasons why this is the case. What was the Soviet Union thinking when it was drawing its borders and did they consider the possibility of ethnic conflict between republics during its lifetime?

1 Answers 2020-10-09

How were the effects of the Columbian Exchange felt in Asian societies?

I’ve come across a lot of stuff about the role of the potato in demographic spikes (and as precursors to industrialisation) across Europe following the colonisation of the Americas, and am wondering if a similar effect was felt in Asian societies, and if not, why it wasn’t.

1 Answers 2020-10-09

Friday Free-for-All | October 09, 2020

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

10 Answers 2020-10-09

Why do so many Russian surnames seem insulting or negative?

"Khrushchev" comes from khrushch, the cockchafer, one of the biggest pests in Europe. "Zhukov" comes from zhuk, meaning beetle. "Gorbachev" comes from the word for hunchback. The notorious executioner Vasily Blokhin's last name comes from blokha, a flea.

"Tolstoy" just means fat/plump. "Gorky" is the adjective "bitter." According to this article, "Chekhov" comes from an old world for sneeze, "Bulgakov" comes from an old word meaning restless/chaotic, "Sholokhov" refers to smallpox scars, "Nabokov" comes from the word "lopsided," and "Bunin" comes from a word for an arrogant/selfish man.

Other somewhat common Russian surnames include "Komarov" from komar or mosquito (!!), "Morozov" from frost, and "Durov" from dur, "fool." "Bezobraznov" and "Nekrasov" both come from different words for ugly.

Were these names imposed on peasants or did they pick them themselves? Did they come from the nicknames of prominent ancestors, or was it some sort of superstition to ward off bad luck, and if the latter did positive surnames also come from the same time or later? How long have surnames been in use in Russia? Are these insulting surnames more commonly found in certain classes or regions? Did they ever acquire any sort of stigma?

3 Answers 2020-10-09

1059 / 7255

Back to start