So China backed both North Vietnam and Cambodia, but reunified Vietnam invaded Cambodia and then China and Vietnam have a border war. Weren’t they all communist brethren? Can someone help explain Sino-Viet-Cambodian relations between 1970-1989?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Found an Ottoman(?) document, would appreciate any help with translation.

Hosted on imgur

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Why didn't Native Americans in North America create kingdoms/empires like Natives in South and Central America (Maya, Inca, etc.) did?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Can we trust medieval allegations of crypto-paganism, black masses, orgies, paedophilia, host desecration and atheism?

This question is partially inspired by the AskHistorians podcast AskHistorians Podcast 151 - Medieval Atheism with Keagan Brewer. Other inspirations for this question include:

  • Allegations that various European rulers were active practitioners of pagan faiths long after Christianity took root in their realms, such as Byzantine Emperor Alexander and King William II of England.
  • Allegations that Henry IV, Holy Roman Emperor attempted a black mass on the naked body of his 2nd wife, Eupraxia of Kiev.
  • The aforementioned Henry IV allegedly joined a Nicolaitan sect, which involved obscene rituals such as orgies. His son, Conrad II of Italy, allegedly started a revolt against his father out of disgust after being encouraged to join in on an orgy.
  • Allegations that Stefan Milutin, King of Serbia, allegedly married the 5-year-old Simonis Palaiologina, then raped her before she reached adulthood, damaging her reproductive organs and preventing her from any childbearing.
  • Allegations of Host desecration by various groups.

The allegation of host desecration has frequently been levelled at the Jews. This is likely due to antisemitic scapegoating instead of genuine cases of Jews going out of their way to desecrate the Host.

This makes me wonder how true the other claims are. Do they have any basis in reality, or are they nothing but slander and scapegoating? For example, were medieval allegations of atheism merely the result of people just trying to ruin the lives of people they hate by accusing them of atheism?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Is there any truth to the claim that Europeans used to eat Egyptian mummies?

Recent news of newly uncovered mummies reminded me of this claim that i have previously seen on twitter before and was wondering if it's a misinterpretations of something factual or if it's actually real.

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Why would commanders in Early Modern Europe accept pitched battle?

Early Modern European armies were by and large composed of professional soldiers who were difficult to replace owing to the time and cost of training and maintaining them long enough to become effective. Battle would risk the loss of many soldiers, and thus immense costs and the possibility of creating a window of vulnerability that other powers could exploit. Thus commanders might be reluctant to offer pitched battle for fear of irreplaceable losses.

If one army had chosen terrain or manipulated the circumstances such that they would be advantaged in pitched battle, their opponents would usually understand that they were at a disadvantage and could use a variety of techniques to decline any offers of battle when they were in a bad position.

Yet there were still battles in Early Modern Europe. Why did armies ever accept their opponents' offers of battle?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

During the Polio epidemic of the 1950's, was there a significant percentage of the populace who considered it a hoax due to its high rate of asymptomatic cases and low mortality rate?

Basically, I'm asking for a direct comparison to whether the populace of the USA treated Polio with the same regard that modern people treat Covid with skepticism.

1 Answers 2020-10-05

How did the USSR react to JFK's Assassination?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

The City of Rome already had a population greater than one million in in ancient times but without current means of mobility. So was the city actually one cohesive city or was it more like many cities next to each other where the people stayed in their part of Rome?

And if it really was one a large city, how was mobility made possible? Was there any public transportation?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

So do we have a rough estimate on the percentage of people that survived the 16/25 years of the Roman Republic/Roman Empire legionnaire servitude? Was the survivability of soldiers on the field worse or better than in modern warfare?

This has troubled me a lot, i tend to think that ancient battles were bloodbaths in such a manner that they cant even compare to battles today (hacking and slashing face to face compared to aiming down the sights) and that the fatality rate was much higher, so how come that any of the legionnaires survived the 16/25 years of servitude?

Was it like just a small percentage and also given the lifespan, if the lifespan of a roman citizen at that time was approx 50years, how long did they have left to live if they got out of the army after a full term?

Also please forgive me if i was wrong in some of my assumptions, thats why im asking the experts here! Thanks a ton!

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Whats the historiographic legacy of Marx?

That is, how influential was his “historical materialism” and ideas about class struggle to the work of subsequent historians? How dominant was the “great man” theory of history before his time and how common was it to take a material, economic or otherwise structural approach?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

I'm a 19th-century U.S. farmer, living in a like-minded community days away from any real state authority. But recent settlers from a new ethnic/religious group have moved in and are starting to use OUR land, OUR water, and OUR resources. Is there a way to settle this, or does it get violent?

Conflict between groups over natural resources in rural areas is one of the leading causes of violence in post-colonial countries. The really tricky thing is that the authorities that might solve these conflicts (the government) are often not very involved in rural areas, so things can get out of control very quickly. I am curious if anything similar happened in the history of the U.S., given its large agricultural base, waves of new immigrants, and the scarcity of government involvement in its Western areas.

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Are there records of people in medieval times mining radioactive ore and getting radiation sickness? If so, what did they interpret it as, since radioactivity was unknown?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Jewish-Black relationships before and during the civil rights movement

Hi there! I’m a high school student who is currently writing a senior paper on Jewish history. The topic I’m specifically writing on is the relationship between Jews and African Americans during the civil rights movement and immediately prior. Some questions I’m hoping to answer are—were jews majority pro or anti the civil rights movement? What actions did they take to further or halt the movement? Did the Jewish experience with oppression add to the Jewish motivation in the movement? What did the public think of the Jewish impact in the movement?

Currently I’m in the stage of reading my sources and taking notes on them. My sources are listed below:

Clark, Kenneth B. “Candor about Negro-Jewish Relations.” Commentary 2, no. 2 1946: 8-14.

Dinnerstein, Leonard. “American Jews and the Civil Rights Movement.” Reviews in American History 30, no. 1, 2002: 136-140. doi:10.1353/rah.2002.0008.

Dinnerstein, Leonard. "Southern Jewry and the Desegregation Crisis, 1954–1970." American Jewish Historical Quarterly 62, no. 3, 1973: 231-41. http://www.jstor.org/stable/23877999.

Fiebert, Martin. “Collaboration and Conflict. Five Phases in Jewish and Black Relations: An Examination of Tensions Between the Two Communities from before the Civil War to the Late 1990's.” International Review of Social Sciences and Humanities no. 1, 2011: 90-121.

Friedman, Murray. What Went Wrong?: The Creation & Collapse of the Black-Jewish Alliance. New York: The Free Press, 1995.

Glazer, Nathan. “Negroes and Jews: The New Challenge to Pluralism.” Commentary 38, no. 6, 1964.

Hardy, Rachel. “African American – Jewish Relations in the 1960s: Struggling to find Common Ground.” Charleston: College of Charleston. Chrestomathy 10, no. 8, 2011: 1-26.

Kristol, Irving. “The Political Dilemma of American Jews.” Commentary Magazine, 1984.

Lang, Kurt and Lang, Gladys Engel. “Resistance to School Desegregation: A Case Study of Backlash Among Jews.” Sociological Inquiry 35, 1965: 94-106. doi:10.1111/j.1475-682X.1965.tb00593.x

Mohl, Raymond A. "‘South of the South?’ Jews, Blacks, and the Civil Rights Movement in Miami, 1945-1960." Journal of American Ethnic History 18, no. 2 (1999): 3-36. http://www.jstor.org/stable/27502414.

Schultz, Debra L. Going South: Jewish Women in the Civil Rights Movement. New York: New York University Press, 2001.

Svonkin, Stuart. Jews Against Prejudice: American Jews and the Fight for Civil Liberties. New York City, New York: Columbia University Press, 1997.

I’m posting here with a few questions I’m struggling to answer, and with my school on break, my professor is unavailable.

  1. Some sources are hidden behind a paywall, specifically for me, Commentary Magazine and some JSTOR articles. How can I access them without paying because my professor specifically noted to not pay the paywall on this assignment.

  2. What is the most effective note taking strategy for these sources?

  3. Are there opinions I should have prior to thoroughly reading these or do I go in without prior convictions?

Thank you so much in advance Historians of reddit!!!

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Cold War historians- Was there an equivalent protective services specifically for the Soviet Premier, their families and staff, etc., as there is in the United States with the Secret Service?

I have been scouring the internet for several hours and cannot find any mention of any specific agency or division of a security agency within the USSR that was specifically meant to guard the Soviet leaders. But I can't imagine that there wasn't one.

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Where do all the rituals and texts of modern catholic mass come from?

For reference I am Italian, went to mass the other day and was wondering when the whole schedule of a catholic mass was decided ne the things the priest says.

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Why did Augustus have only one child?

I understand that there hadn't been primogeniture, and the desire for a male child wasn't the same as, say, medieval Europe, but Augustus was the wealthiest person in Rome, and lacked good male heirs after the deaths of Marcellus and his grandchildren. Did he try to have additional children, but could not? Certainly Livia was capable of bearing children (Drusus, Tiberius)

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Why did people stop wearing hats?

If you look at older black and white photographs of public spaces in the USA, like this one, you can see that hats were once much more common than they are today. What happened?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Historians are sometimes charged that they ignore homosexuality, bisexuality, and transgenderism in history or hide evidence. Has anyone explored the historiography of the sexuality in historical persons and is it true that it is ignored? If it is then why?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

If Japanese sea trade was so successful in the early 17th century, why did the Tokugawa shogunate decide to end it?

Japan has a reputation of hostility to foreigners and outside trade. But I recently learned about its brief period of openness under the Tokugawa shogunate from 1600 to 1636. There were waves of Japanese migration throughout Southeast Asia and a rise of successful Japanese merchant fleets.

In his chapter in the Cambridge History of Southeast Asia, Leonard Andaya writes "A measure of the importance of this Japanese trade was their export of silver. Between 1615 and 1625 an estimated 130,000-160,000 kilograms of silver was sold, amounting to 30-40 percent of the total world output outside Japan." (He cites Seiichi Iwao's article 'Japanese foreign trade in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries' which I was unable to find).

It seems like Japanese traders saw fairly quick and dramatic success. But after 1636 we see trade drastically limited to a few foreign merchants in Nagasaki. I know many other countries saw foreign trade as an attractive and easy source of taxation. How could the Tokugawa shogunate turn down such a potentially lucrative revenue source?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

The Battle of Camnlann is said to have happened around 537. Extreme weather events happened around 535-536. Could there be a relation between the weather and war breaking out in England and Ireland?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

Do court eunuchs deserve the bad reputation they get in medieval China?

In many Chinese secondary school textbooks, the conflict between eunuchs and scholars in medieval China is a recurring theme. And in most occasions, court eunuchs are demonised as corrupt, power-hungry and out for personal gain, while scholars are portrayed as defenders of morals and the staunch guardians of the dynasty's long-term stability. Has there been any challenges to this popular perception, especially considering official court histories are written by the scholars themselves?

2 Answers 2020-10-05

Why are many older Horror novels framed as 'Stories within stories', And how far back does this trend go?

I'm thinking specifically of books like 'Call of Cthulu', 'Jekyll & Hyde' and 'Frankenstein' which both have the main plot told by a character recounting what they heard from a different character who witnessed the events, aswell as stories like Dracula with unconventional framing. When did this style become popular and when was it replaced with modern story framing? Is it limited to horror?

Sorry if this is the wrong subreddit for this, I don't know if there's a good 'AskLiterature' sub or anything.

1 Answers 2020-10-05

A vomitorium was not, as commonly believed, a room where rich Romans went to induce vomiting in order to eat more, but rather a high-capacity entry/exit into/from a theatre. But how did the notion that vomitoria were for vomiting in come about? Was it purely a matter of mistaken English etymologies?

2 Answers 2020-10-05

What was it that made Mansa Musa so much richer than everyone else?

Mansa Musa is generally regarded as the richest man to ever live my a massive margin. But where did his wealth come from, and what did he have that other powerful/rich rulers didn't?

1 Answers 2020-10-05

1066 / 7255

Back to start