What role did American news/media play in the outcome of the Vietnam war and the subsequent change in the American perspective of war?

I'm starting a project having to do with this topic, and as I don't have much background knowledge in this area, it'd be great if you could show me some directions in which I could start going. One thing that seems to be a common theme is how news reporting changed from the beginning to end of the war. Also, what it had to do with anti-war movements and how we now think of wars as unfortunate rather than an opportunity for glory. You don't need a complete answer, any ideas that I could look further into would be great. Thank you!!

1 Answers 2020-09-08

Is Ken Burns Civil War worth watching today?

I've seen some of his other documentaries, like The Vietnam war and have recently been interested in learning more about the American Civil War. I am aware there are issues in terms of accuracy and perspective regarding The Vietnam War, although I found it very very interesting and engrossing despite keeping that in mind.

I was thinking of watch his Civil War documentary, but before making the time commitment, is it worth watching? I'm not American so I haven't really grown up with much beyond a few pages in a textbook on the subject. Will I learn valuable information about the conflict, or will it mostly give me a misinformed picture of the conflict? Or perhaps somewhere in between (ie. it seems like I won't learn a lot about the nuance of the political situation in both North and South, but the information on battles themselves and military is decent)?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

How did Sigmund Freud’s mother react to his theories?

Inspired by this post from r/historymemes, I looked up his mother and discovered that she lived long enough for his theories to be promulgated. Is there any record of her reaction to the, shall we say, uncomfortable extrapolation?

2 Answers 2020-09-07

The War of the Triple Alliance began when Paraguay declared war against both Argentina and Brazil simultaneously. What made Paraguayan leaders think they had even a remote chance of winning a war against two countries so much more powerful than itself?

They declared war on Uruguay too, but that's much less of a factor.

1 Answers 2020-09-07

What were the main reasons for Britain to not nationalise the East India company's assets years earlier than the India Act 1858?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

MLK says, "For years now, we have heard the word 'Wait!'...this 'Wait' almost always means 'Never." When did black civil rights leaders first start getting told to "wait"? Why?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Books/Documentaries on Medieval Russia

I’m really interested in medieval Russia or the period of Ivan the terrible and before, but I’ve had a hard time finding resources around that period. Does anyone have any recommendations?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

How were the Uighurs (and other non-Han peoples) treated in Qing China? Did their lot improve or decline once the communists took over?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

When did the Greeks (Byzantines) stop seeing themselves as Roman, and instead Greek?

I've read many times that the citizens of the Byzantine Empire, despite being referred to as Greeks by foreigners, and speaking Greek, considered themselves to be Roman. Greeks now identify with their Hellenic heritage. When did this change take place, and what exactly prompted it?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

How did the Spanish Civil War interact with the 1936 Berlin Summer Olympics? If Spanish athletes were sent, which government did they represent?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Why did Israel side with the West during the Cold War?

On January 1945, the Red Army liberated the Auschwitz concentration camp. After WWII ended, Soviet minister of foreign affairs Andrei Gromyko — otherwise infamous for his obstructionism — approved the 1947 UN partition plan for Palestine. In the ensuing war, Czechoslovakia provided the Zionists with military equipment while the US didn't. And when the state of Israel was finally established in 1948, the USSR was the first country to recognize it.

Yet, Israel never aligned with the Soviet Union — quite the contrary. This enraged Stalin, who brutally turned not only on Israel but also on Jews in general whom he now suspected of disloyalty. By the '50s, Israel was so solidly anchored in the Western camp that it staged a joint invasion of Sinai with France and the UK in response to Nasser's nationalization of the Suez Canal. From then on, the Eastern Bloc would align with Arab states and endorse aggressive anti-Zionism until the bitter end.

My question is: why? What exactly motivated Israel to seemingly ignore and eventually turn down Soviet courtship?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Was America responsible for Nazism?

It is implied in this comment by a German who I know are taught the truth about the Holocaust. So, is the US responsible for Nazi's especially by coining the word untermemchsen?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

How were Medieval castle-towns governed?

My understanding is that smaller urban settlements tended to be administrated by the ecclesiastic officials or sometimes local landed aristocrats, and as they grew their larger populations and richer economies put the urbanites in better positions to operate with greater autonomy from the local powers (usually supported by a royally backed charter filled with "liberties" in exchange for providing military labor and paying hefty sums of money to their monarchs). But it seems like castles provide these lords with what were in effect citadels from which they could dominate an urban population to extract taxes and manpower for themselves and their ventures. Did castle-towns ever receive charters or other forms of autonomy? Were they stirred up and supported by outside powers to undermine the castles at their center, or were their interests too closely bound to set townspeople and garrisons against one another? Did castellans have to keep building up their castles to dominate growing towns and prevent the encroachment of royal authority and urban autonomy?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Dress code of catholic priests in the 1950s and military medals

In the BBC series Father Brown, which takes place in the 1950s, the eponymous catholic priest is shown on multiple occasions wearing military medals he had recived for his service in WW1 (before he became a priest). He either pinned them to his cassock picture or his stole. Would a Catholic priest have been allowed to do this? And if so, how common was it for priests to wear medals with liturgical/clerical clothing?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Why did soldiers in the American Civil War wear kepis instead of helmets?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Why is there no source for the manhours that went into the production of a WW2 plane?

My fellow modders and I are creating a mod for Hearts of Iron IV that besides other features tries to get as close to historical WW2 production numbers as possible. For tanks this has been rather easy, and the same is true for ships and other equipment like rifles or artillery pieces. We largely rely on the publications of Paul Kennedy and Mark Harrison, who even replied to our emails and helped us tremendously.
Now we are beginning our work on the various aircraft and we quickly came to the realization that while we have quite accurate numbers for the monetary production costs, overall production capacity and output, we don't have any actual manhour statistics. That is quite contrary to what we encountered with especially tanks, but also more or less any other equipment. This seems to only impact planes which is kind of surprising. It also makes it almost impossible to smack a number on a single plane and call it "production cost/time".

Now the question is, is this just an oversight on our end and have we just failed to find the proper source yet? Which would be not too surprising since we are all amateurs, but on the other hand we are all experienced with online archive research. I have found around a dozen papers on the Luftwaffes production numbers for WW2, why it failed yadayada...but none of the papers mentioned any exact numbers how long it took to produce a plane of any kind, how many people were necessary for it or anything like that. Finding such information for something like the T-34, the M4 or the Tiger is pretty easy in comparison. So why is that, and does anyone here actually know one or multiple sources?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Where does the "Yee-haw", commonly uttered by cowboys in varying types of media, come from? Was it a phrase that many used?

If so, how or when did it fall out of use, since nowadays a good old yeehaw is rarely yelled. If not, why and when did it start becoming such a stereotype associated with the 'Wild West'?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

How did the citizens of the US view communism before the red scare of the 1950s?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

What are the chances Christianity was created by Roman Emperors?

I saw claims by people that christianity was just a product of the roman empire, that it was created solely so they can write prophecies about new emperors in the new testament so people can worship them, to calm down jews who waited the messiah, and they claim the NT has some pro roman stuff, how they lied about presecution yada yada. This theory has been proposed in this book:

https://www.amazon.com/Creating-Christ-Emperors-Invented-Christianity-ebook/dp/B01LRP3EDG

Allegedly, they gave archeological evidence for their theory which they claimed to be "irrefutable" (some claims can be seen in the short preview of the book). So I wanted to ask historians, what are chances this is true, if there are any chances? Thanks.

1 Answers 2020-09-07

Why is it difficult to determine in letters from 200 years ago what was just more common flowery language between men and letters between men in love?

When there is speculation based on letters about people like Lincoln (and Joshua Speed) or Hamilton (and John Laurens) being in love, its often said how men were much freer in how they expressed feeling even in platonic friendships, and were more flowery (a favorite descriptor Ive seen) in prose. But aren't there enough examples of non love letters to be able to distinguish ones that more can be read into? Interested in what makes it so complicated.

1 Answers 2020-09-07

How did workers during the Industrial Revolution work 16 hour days?

We read a lot about the miserable working conditions in the 19th and early 20th century.

One thing I’ve always wondered is how a 12 or 16 hour day involving manual labor is even done? How could one work at a place like a steel mill for years on end under those conditions?

I’ve seen arguments that this mode of work was relatively new, as peasant farmers worked hard but had many punctuated breaks and off time during parts of the year.

Would a miner literally be wielding a pick for the entire time? Did workers sneak breaks and meals? After several hours, did the pace of work drop off and were employers okay with it?

My question revolves specifically around working conditions in the US, Canada, and Western Europe during this period.

1 Answers 2020-09-07

AskHistorians Digital Conference: Registration for the keynote address is LIVE!

Can you believe it’s only 8 MORE SLEEPS TILL THE FIRST-EVER ASKHISTORIANS CONFERENCE???

Ahem.

As many of you know, next week AskHistorians will be hosting the first scholarly conference ever held on Reddit. We are, as keen-eyed readers may have picked up on above, slightly excited about it. Preparations are already well underway – the panels are being recorded, the networking events planned and the exclusive conference swag is all ordered.

Today, we’re very pleased to announce the full schedule of events for the conference. Starting with a fantastic panel on Indigenous histories and finishing with a bang with nation building and conflict, we've got a full programme of panels and live events across the three days of the conference. Each panel video will be accompanied by a live AMA here on r/AskHistorians, so be prepared for a whole new wave of historical content hitting the sub each day!

We're also delighted to now be able to invite our readers to register for our live keynote address by Professor Alex Wellerstein – or, as AskHistorians regulars might know them, u/restricteddata. The keynote itself will take place on 15 September at 1:00 pm (ET).

Prof. Wellerstein is a leading historian of nuclear weapons and technology, and has shared this expertise across many scholarly books and articles, as well as venues like The New Yorker, Washington Post and, most recently, Netflix. We think it’s incredibly fitting that our first keynote will be delivered by a scholar who not only has such an outstanding track record as a public historian, but is also a longstanding and valued member of the community.

The keynote itself will be about what U.S. Secretary of War Henry L. Stimson called the “new relationship of man to the universe". Stimson was reflecting on what the invention of the atomic bomb meant, several months before its use at Hiroshima. But what would that relationship look like, and who would define it? Over the course of the keynote address, Prof. Wellerstein will discuss the emotions, calculations, actions, and reactions that unfolded as countries imagined what a world in an atomic age would look like, vacillating between apocalyptic fears and utopian dreams. Whatever nearly everybody agreed on was that the world would never be the same — but nobody was sure about what "the new world" they were entering would actually be like.

Want to know more? REGISTER NOW to reserve your place!

Please note that while space for the live talk is limited, the talk will be recorded and made freely available afterwards. Can’t make this time, but still want to join in for a live event? You can also register for our conference networking sessions held across each day of the conference!

As always, feel free to leave comments, questions and suggestions in the comments, and we look forward to seeing you all for the conference next week!

4 Answers 2020-09-07

Around 6 Million Jews were killed during the Holocaust. But who counts as a Jew? The Nazis defined people as Jews who were self identifying as e.g. Christians. Are those people who weren't Jews but defined as Jews by the Nazis based on their racial categories also included in this number?

1 Answers 2020-09-07

In "Kingodm of Heaven", the movie, Saladin offers a cup of water with ice to the king of Jerusalem. How in that period (1186) and in that place (Palestine) they were able to "create" and keep ice?

2 Answers 2020-09-07

How do you refute a Holocaust denier?

I have recently watched a certain historian video about David Irving and his lies, and as always when the name of Irving gets dropped a bunch of Nazis and Nazi apologists show up in the comments. I know its either blind delusion, hatred, or justification and battling someone in the comments of youtube is like rolling in the dirt with pigs, they like that. However those are real existing people behind those comments and they are probably around us.

How do you actually skillfully refute those people that claim Zyklon B was just used for delousing, and that Possener Reden never existed and that Hitler was actually against genocide of the Jews?

I thank you in advance and hope this is the right channel.

2 Answers 2020-09-07

1108 / 7255

Back to start