I’ve recently learned there were a large number of Jews in Georgia in its founding years. What enticed so many Jews to come over, and how did they deal with being the antisemitism they’d have endured?

2 Answers 2020-07-05

Was the Roman Empire the political experiment of Greek philosophy?

I know that Aristotle and Plato play undeniably instrumental roles in recorded philosophy. However, I feel like Plato’s writings influenced Rome ever since they took Greece, mostly because Rome just absorbed everything and made it their own. No copyright laws in ancient conquest ;) Is it possible that the Roman Empire was the manifestation of Plato’s Republic? I know that he has split the state is symbolism to teach the tripartite soul, but was the Roman Empire have been that Republic? If so/not so, could you please expound on the historical contexts of application?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Could a person who was born in the Confederacy later become President of the United States?

I presume confederate citizens were repatriated after the Civil War, however wouldn't the people who had been born in the Confederacy be later considered to have been born in a foreign country? Did this ever come up as a controversy during a presidential campaign?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

What were the reactions of Christians who didn't go on the First Crusade to it being called and its success?

Do we have any sources of what Christians (especially in the nobility) who didn't go on the Crusade thought of the First Crusade? Also, what did people think when it was a success? Were people surprised that it was successful? Were there celebrations etc.? Were there different opinions based on different political, religious, or philosophical perspectives within Christendom?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

[META] I can’t seem to find the lino to donate to the fundraiser for the symposium, has it been taken down?

3 Answers 2020-07-05

Was mercury at all effective in treating syphilis?

Mercury used to be used to treat syphilis and, as far as I know, was also commonly used to treat other ailments. While this treatment certainly wasn't nearly as effective as modern medicine, was it effective at all? Would a person treated for syphilis with mercury fair better than someone not treated at all?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Where can I find schematics on the interiors of Egyptian tombs?

I'm specifically looking for the internal structure of tomb TT 353, and some tombs have schematics on wikipedia, but not this one, and my Google-fu is seriously failing me here. This one of King Tut's is similar to what I'm looking for.

Any help, assets, or on insight on the matter would be greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Did Nazis label themselves “fascists” or did others apply that label to them?

I’ve been thinking about fascism, and why it’s so difficult to define and pin down, and I think part of the reason is hardly anybody openly describes themselves as fascists. It’s a label derogatorily (righteously, but derogatorily) applied to those who’s confluence of racism, nationalism and hardline law and order inclinations begin to resemble fascism. Or, perhaps put otherwise, there are card carrying communists just about everywhere in the world, but nobody is a card carrying fascist. It seems to be an ideology people slip into out of fear/greed/stupidity and not an espoused belief system (again, as opposed to communism, socialism, capitalism, liberalism and conservatism).

But I don’t know if this has always been true throughout history. So I ask: did the Nazis— or any far-right political party— openly consider themselves a fascist party/movement?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

How far back in time could, I, a Modern English speaker, go and still understand those around me and be understood.

I'm guessing that I wouldn't appear a complete foreigner to someone like Shakespeare. But how about Chaucer, or the writer of Beowulf. When did Modern English in an understandable form by a current living layperson come about?

2 Answers 2020-07-05

People often act like Hitler and Stalin were two sides of the political coin- one a right wing dictator and one a left wing dictator. How accurate is that?

It seems to me that the dictatorship in Nazi Germany was quite in line with the desires of the people and system supporting Hitler- basically, people in the preferred group had rights but nobody else did (though that’s a simplification obviously). Meanwhile, it seems like Stalin’s dictatorship was not really a logical outcome of the ideology he claimed to represent (I.e. a communist system wherein all products of the economy were shared). Is that accurate? If not, how am I thinking about this incorrectly?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Our high school history teacher used to tell us that the greeks didn't need/strongly believe in their religion/myths and only had them as a certain 'spice' in their daily lifes,is that true?

  • they were far smarter than to believe in such childish tales,so they made them to not be bored and to prove they could create such stories?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

What brought down the Mycenaean civilization?

A lot of theories exist regarding the Bronze Age collapse in Greece: the Dorian invasion, climate change, overpopulation, the Sea People, internal strife/uprising. If I am not mistaken, the Dorian invasion is now rendered the least probable cause for a variety of reasons. The destruction of palaces shows a southern trend (from Thebes to Pylos) in a 70-year period. Scripts from Pylos state they were preparing for war, but without specifying the enemy. Could anyone elaborate on the causes of the collapse? I find it wildly intriguing.

1 Answers 2020-07-05

How did industrilization in the Soviet Union differ from the West.

In terms of the causes, means, duration and results.

Thank u for your time.

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Why when talking about The Roman empire nowadays, The Eastern Roman (Byzantine Empire) empire is not mentioned as much?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Was the Third Reich angry about the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor because it led to United States involvement in WWII?

Basically what the title says, my question concerns the reaction(s) of Hitler’s government. Did anyone in the German government express anger or frustration because of the actions made by their Japanese allies? Prior to the Pearl Harbor attack, the United States was not directly involved in the fighting. This preemptive attack was designed to neutralize the U.S. naval forces, would it logically follow then that Germany would express consternation for committing a largely unprovoked attack against the United States?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Why were there imageries of globes in the classical world?

Mary Beard in SPQR alludes to a a number of contemporary statues of Roman generals holding globes, including a colossal statue of Pompey currently in the Palazzo Spada in Rome, as a symbol of Romans as world conquerors. Were the ancients not flat-earthers?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

I once heard that 'the typical American worker works more hours (per year) now than during the Middle Ages'. Is this true? How many hours per year would a typical serf in, say, 12th Century England, spend working?

The idea was that in the Middle Ages, there were far more religious and feast days than legal holidays today, a lack of work during the winter months when the fields lay barren, and the typical worker would not spend a full eight+ hours every day of the week ending to crops and livestock. Taking an average of 2,000 hours (50 weeks at 40 hours per week) for a 'modern American worker', is the meme I saw utter rubbish, or is there some truth to its claims?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | June 29, 2020–July 05, 2020

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

5 Answers 2020-07-05

British perspective on American Revolution.

What is Britains perspective on the American Revolution? I heard that they dont really teach about it in their schools like we do in the U.S.. It makes sense since they have longer history than we do and it was more impactful for us than them. I was just wondering what the differences are between what the U.S. says that happened and what the British say happened. Resources would be great to reference too if you know of any.

1 Answers 2020-07-05

How come advanced ancient civilizations were formed by the Greeks, the Romans and the Phoenicians without relying on large river systems?

Other advanced ancient civilizations have relied on large river systems, for example:

  • Mesopotamian civilizations rely on the Euphrates River and the Tigris River.

  • Egyptian civilization relies on the Nile River.

  • Indian civilizations rely on the Indus River and the Ganges River.

  • Chinese civilizations rely on the Yangtze River, the Yellow River and the Pearl River.

In contrast:

  • Pella, the capital of the Macedonian kingdom, was situated on the non-navigable Vardar River.

  • Ambrakia, the capital of the Epirote kingdom, was situated on the barely-navigable Arachthos River.

  • Sparta was situated on the non-navigable Evrotas River.

  • Rome was situated on the barely-navigable Tiber River.

  • Etrurian cities were built in the basin of the barely-navigable Arno river.

  • Utica was built on the barely-navigable Medjerda River.

  • Tyre, Byblos, Syracuse, Athens, Carthage, Thebes and Knossos were not built near rivers.

It also makes me wonder why:

  • Ancient Greece's most powerful civilization didn't arise on the Haliacmon River or the Maritsa River.

  • Ancient Italy's most powerful civilization didn't arise on the Po River or the Adige River.

  • Ancient Phoenicia's most powerful civilization didn't arise on the Orontes River.

1 Answers 2020-07-05

When and why did duels stop being a commonplace thing? Were they as common as pop culture suggests?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

It's been speculated that a Muslim poet and diplomat visited the court of Turgesius, a Viking chief active in Ireland in the 9th century. How would such a visit have taken place; how did these people from markedly different cultures have communicated; and what would they have discussed?

The incident I'm referring to is a potential visit by Yahya ibn al-Hakam al-Bakri al-Jayyani, speculated in Nizar F. Hermes' book The Moor’s First Sight: An Arab Poet in a Ninth-Century Viking Court (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014). Granted, I appreciate this particular encounter may not have happened, but any information on how these visits manifested themselves would be massively appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Why did reform and transition to capitalism lead to collapse in the USSR under Gorbachev but succeeded in China under Deng Xiaoping?

What are the factors that lead to this divergence in outcomes between USSR and China?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

How did some slaves earn money in the pre Civil War in the United States to purchase their freedom?

Since they are slaves and are unpaid, where would they get the money to purchase their freedom? And was there anything stopping a master from just taking the money and keeping them enslaved since they are his "property"?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

Is the book “At Home” by Bill Bryson really accurate?

1 Answers 2020-07-05

1232 / 7255

Back to start