Saving Private Ryan gives a visceral and bloody account of what happened on D-Day. Death and suffering. Bodies everywhere. But actual photos from D-Day are typically very polished and show few if any bodies. Why the discrepancy? Which is more accurate?

1 Answers 2020-06-06

When did we go from "indentured servitude " to slavery?

I was wondering when we went from kind of owning people during the crusades to the slavery we saw during the Trans-Atlantic Trade. is there an in between there? also what about "court" during say Elizabeth 1 rule, was slavery a thing?

sorry if this is worded a bit weird. I'm a bit unsure of what the difference is between the slaves during those times.

1 Answers 2020-06-06

My little sister is doing an essay and used this photo as a visual reference. She has spent ages translating it but needs the source in order to use it in her school protect. Can someone help?

I thought I'd ask you guys. By the way she translated it as “working soldiers of the armed forces, countries demand immediate peace. Long live the soviet power. Kadets are enemies of the people, they have no place in the constituent assembly.”

https://imgur.com/a/9SrxuSc

2 Answers 2020-06-06

When exactly was the V sound (ヴ) introduced to Japanese?

1 Answers 2020-06-06

Did the Mughal Emperors have severe drinking problems?

A book I read (published in the 70s) claimed the above, stating that two of Akbar's sons drank themselves to death and that Jahangir was essentially a high functioning alcoholic.

It seems plausible, but equally could be propaganda (Safavid?) designed to portray them as bad Muslims.

1 Answers 2020-06-06

Where did the Japanese use tanks in WW2?

Recently I googled about how the Japanese 3000+ tanks during the period from 1931-1939. Yet I dont really hear about Japanese tanks used in combat. Where did they use their tanks?

1 Answers 2020-06-06

Why is "Smith" the most common English surname?

I thought the many variations of smith's, but mostly blacksmiths weren't that common back then, and that a village usually only had 1 of 2, but why is it the most common surname then?

1 Answers 2020-06-06

How much of a reformist was Louis XVI?

This is something that rather confuses me, I've heard people say that he was very hopeful of passing reforms to get France through the crisis they faced during his reign, but then I hear other people say that he refused any sorts of reform.

Which is it? I've actually heard some say that he was okay with reforms, so long as his divine right to rule wasn't challenged, as was the case during the French Revolution.

1 Answers 2020-06-06

How does the One-Drop Rule features on the American high school curriculum?

For clarification, I just found out that US conception on how race is perceived was not generated through natural societal interaction, but actually constructed through laws and governance.

2 Answers 2020-06-05

Was the Exodus real?

Is the Exodus considered a historical event? Did Moses exist? What does Egyptian History have to say about it?

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Were the Stock Market crash and the Great Depression really the trigger point for the New Deal or just an excuse FDR used to get it passed?

This question has two parts or concepts within it, and it comes in the context of the latest numbers from the stock market indexes and the unemployment numbers. While we're currently in the middle of an American Recession, this the strongest rally of the stock market indexes in a 50 day period. At the time same time, the latest unemployment numbers, while not as high as estimated, are clearly very high, higher than during the Great Depression, with millions of Americans out of work. In this context, what is the relationship between the stock market and unemployment?

The first question/concept is, while in popular historical imagination, fuelled by stories of Al Capone and the Great Gatsby, the 1920s in American culture and history is remembered as a time of great prosperity and revelry, a party of riches that no one thought would stop. This may have been true for one section of society, as the stock market and its gains refused to stop growing, but the average American during that time was rural, poorly educated, highly likely to die from any number of diseases at a young age, and lived a life of penury and dire poverty. What I'm trying to figure out is, was the New Deal necessary for most Americans even without the 1929 Stock Market Crash and subsequent Depression?

The second question/concept is did the Stock Market crash lead to the Great Depression and its consequences for quality of life and unemployment for the majority of Americans. Again, the Crash certainly affected the new rich strongly, but did it impact employment and qualiy of life for most Americans significantly?

Finally, to put it in historical context, how bad is the current recession and its effects on unemployment relative to during the Great Depression? Which was a worse time?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-06-05

At what point was it abundantly clear the United States was going to enter armed conflict in the civil war?

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Why did the Lithuanian nobility elect Alexander instead of his older brother John Albert to be Grand Duke of Lithuania?

John Albert had become King of Poland in June 1492. Only one month later the Lithuanians elected his younger brother Alexander to be Grand Duke. Their father,Casimir IV, had ruled with both titles.

Why the desire to split the rulership?

1 Answers 2020-06-05

How common was PTSD during the crusades? Did it shape the interpretation of hell?

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Where, how, and when were playing cards invented. What are the origins of the four suits (why harts, diamonds, clubs, and spades specifically)?

This question refuses to the standard playing card deck seen in casinos and on kitchen tables across America. Consisting of 4 suits of 13 cards plus a high and low joker that will be included or excluded depending on the game being played.

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Do we have records on the linguistic evolution of Malay languages?

I ask this because Ferdinand Magellan's translator Enrique of Malacca spoke the Malay language, which also happened to be the language spoken in Cebu and Mindanao when they visited in 1521.

My family is from the Philippines, and I speak Tagalog. Tagalog has a low level of mutual intelligibility with other dialects of Luzon (e.g. Ilocano, Kapampangan ), and even less with dialects of other Philippine islands (e.g. Ilonggo, Cebuano ). While Philippine languages are still Malay languages, even when not counting the European influences, they have very little similarity with present-day Bahasa Malaysia and Bahasa Indonesia.

How did Malay languages diverge so much in less than 500 years? If so, do we have records on their evolution?

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Books for the Viking age on warfare and history in general

Hello all, I am currently going to be writing a paper to use as a writing sample (around 20 pages) for my masters applications. The paper is going to revolve around the Vikings and their warfare detailing the unique history of it. Currently I have 13 books which are listed below and would love some input on if I am missing any or should replace/remove any. Thank you in advance

(Warning not in a citation format):

Northmen: The Viking Saga 793-1241 by John Haywood

Viking Hersir 793–1066 AD (Warrior) by Mark Harrison

Weapons of the Viking Warrior by Gareth Williams

Swords of the Viking Age by Ian Peirce

Viking Weapons and Combat Techniques by William R. Short

Valkyrie: The Women of the Viking World by Jóhanna Katrín Friðriksdóttir

The Vikings and Their Enemies: Warfare in Northern Europe, 750-1100 by Philip Line

Viking Art of War by Paddy Griffith

Vikings at War by Kim Hjardar

Viking Warrior vs Anglo-Saxon Warrior: England 865–1066 (Combat) by Gareth Williams

The Oxford Illustrated History of the Vikings by Peter Sawyer

Vikings: The North Atlantic Saga by William F. Fitzhugh

The Viking World (Routledge Worlds) by Stefan Brink

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Did people question witch confessions at that time?

We all know torture was used to make people give false confessions for which they were then punished or executed. We now know, comfessions given under torture have no value.

I'm curious though if there were people back then when this was being done, who questioned confessions gained like this?

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Why did Alexander push *so* far to the East before even thinking about the West?

One thing that always strikes me when I look at maps of Alexander's empire is how his original capital in Macedon is almost at the extreme Western end of everything. His conquests took him very far East, but his Westernmost border never pushed that far beyond his starting point at all. This seems counter-intuitive, as you'd imagine the sphere of his control would naturally radiate outward in all directions from its center of gravity. I know he had designs on the West, but I'm wondering why he extended himself so far in one direction before even considering a Western campaign.

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Why does Belgium Exist?

Belgium is one nation divided into 3 distinct regions; the largely Dutch speaking region of Flanders, the largely French speaking region of Wallonia and the bilingual Capital Brussels. Their is also a small German speaking region in the East/South East.

These regions all have individual governing bodies, with the power shared equally between them, I believe.

I have heard in numerous instances that there is great rivalry, and perhaps disdain between the French speaking region of Wallonia, and the Dutch speaking region of Flanders. Flanders holds much of the industrial factories and harbours, and is often considered to be quite wealthy in relation to the agricultural heartlands of Wallonia.

My question is simply, is there a call from the respective peoples to join the nations of the languages they speak? This would end the nation of Belgium and would result in expanded territories for France and The Netherlands, (Maybe Germany also). Or is it sort of a sibling rivalry, where their love for one another is hidden with petty arguments, and they both realise their is strength in unity.

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Are 'celebrity chefs' harbingers of societal collapse?

A few days ago this comment from the /r/collapse subreddit received a lot of attention.

I read that throughout history, when an empire gets to the point of having celebrity chefs, it inevitably begins its downfall. Apparently this happened all the way back to Roman times. It's not a matter of cause and effect; celebrity chefs don't have a common thread of inciting violent empire-ending revolutions.

Rather when there is a common cause: first an empire allows its ruling elite to amass enough wealth as to allow "celebrity chef" to exist, then those ruling elite use their money and power to rewrite the laws in such a way as to propagate their own wealth even at the expense of the citizen's needs. At that point the empire becomes underfunded, as all of the wealth is captured by the ruling elite.

The poster goes on to describe the mechanisms by which this happens. Other than saying 'all the way back to Roman times,' they don't give much historical context though. Is there any evidence of this occurring in your area of expertise?

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Questions about governance in 19th century England

Hi! I'm writing a book set in 1830s Cornwall, and I need some help figuring out who would be in authority locally, who would do the policing, how the judicial system worked, etc. If anyone is familiar with these topics, please DM me. Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-06-05

In a 1990 interview with Playboy Magazine, Donald Trump repeatedly argued that the United States was viewed as politically and economically weak. How was the USA's position actually viewed by our allies and trade partners in 1990?

The interview on playboy.com.

Various quotes:

Our country is right now perceived as weak … as being spit on by the rest of the world—

I like George Bush very much and support him and always will. But I disagree with him when he talks of a kinder, gentler America. I think if this country gets any kinder or gentler, it’s literally going to cease to exist.

Weakness always causes problems.

We Americans are laughed at around the world for losing a hundred and fifty billion dollars year after year, for defending wealthy nations for nothing, nations that would be wiped off the face of the earth in about fifteen minutes if it weren’t for us.

1 Answers 2020-06-05

Why did people writing in the past capitalise so many words, seemingly at random?

Were there simply no rules regarding capitalization or were the rules different?

An example, John Adams writing about the Boston Massacre.

The Part I took in Defence of Cptn. Preston and the Soldiers, procured me Anxiety, and Obloquy enough. It was, however, one of the most gallant, generous, manly and disinterested Actions of my whole Life, and one of the best Pieces of Service I ever rendered my Country. Judgment of Death against those Soldiers would have been as foul a Stain upon this Country as the Executions of the Quakers or Witches, anciently.

As the Evidence was, the Verdict of the Jury was exactly right. This however is no Reason why the Town should not call the Action of that Night a Massacre, nor is it any Argument in favour of the Governor or Minister, who caused them to be sent here. But it is the strongest Proofs of the Danger of Standing Armies.

1 Answers 2020-06-05

What is the history of black massacres in America?

Hello I am a Asian immigrant to America. I did not grow up in the school here. I want to educate on the issues black Americans have faced in history. When I ask people told me the Tulsa Race Massacre, but I do not know what else happened in America. What else has happened? Did more things happen? I know some history of slavery and some of Civil Rights. It is easy find that history but it is not easy to find other information at my library. What should I read or watch to learn more about this? Did anything similar happen to Asians in America? I know about internment camps but that is it.

1 Answers 2020-06-05

1292 / 7255

Back to start