How far did the Canadians travel in ww2

In ww2 the Canadians helped in the Normandy landings, landing on juno beach. I would like to travel by foot (camping) the distance the Canadians travelled from juno beach to their furthest point in Germany or wherever the Canadians stopped (this is only the soldiers who landed on the beaches of Normandy, this doesn't include Canadians who where in Italy).

So how far would i have to travel if i followed the steps of the Canadians to their last captured territory (assuming the Canadians did not make a straight line to Berlin)

Thank you to all who take the time to help me with this question.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Armenian Genocide denial sometimes involves claims that Armenians often attacked Muslims in Eastern Anatolia. What was the true extent, and context, of armed Armenian insurgence against Ottomans/Muslims/Turks leading up to the events of 1915?

I hope I have phrased this question correctly.

I'm Turkish and hence grew up surrounded by Armenian Genocide denial. Now I want to piece together the historical context of these events, for my own sake, because I want to understand (and to some extent, reconcile) the global historical consensus on the topic, and the culture and ideology I grew up with. I'm pretty ignorant when it comes to historical knowledge, and whatever resource I can find on this matter always feels a bit incomplete to me.

As far as I understand/ can convey, Turkish denial of the genocide rests heavily on the characterization of the mass deportation of Armenians as a kind of self-defense response to Armenian insurgency in the area (coupled with their support of the invading Russian military). I want to understand the origin of this claim. I've looked up some threads on this forum pertaining to Turkish denial, but I have not found as much on the veracity of Turkish claims of Armenian assault as I would like. (This is not an attempt to question the presence of other intents/motives.)

I want to understand to what degree the Turks/Muslims in the area were endangered by Armenian assault, and what the nature of Armenian armament was. The notion that mass deportation was self-defense does not sit very well with me- ultimately, the conflict ended in Armenians as pretty much an entire demographic being displaced from the region and massacred; that heavily implies to me that Ottoman militia was vastly more powerful than Armenian forces, so there must have been a more... humane, less drastic outcome that would've ensured Ottoman territorial integrity anyways. (I assume that is what the Ottoman Empire wanted.)

I want to list some more detailed questions in the hopes that it will convey the kind of information I seek a touch more clearly. I do not expect answers to all of these.

  1. Was Armenian insurgency provoked by previous instances/attempts of ethnic cleansing by Ottomans, and was the primary motive Armenian independence?
  2. If there were previous attempts at genocide, were there retaliatory attempts against Turkish communities?
  3. Is there any estimate of Turkish losses to Armenian combatants?
  4. Was there large-scale Armenian mobilization, or is Armenian separatism more so a phenomenon exaggerated by Turkish history as a scapegoat for lost Ottoman influence in the area?
  5. Especially considering the presence of Russian forces in the region (who, as I understand, were there to protect Christian interests), could the conflict in (North?-)Eastern Anatolia be classified as mutual ethnic cleansing/genocide?

In summary, I want to learn more about the extent of Turkish/Ottoman loss and suffering sustained in combat against Armenians in the conflicts that led to the Armenian Genocide.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Why did the Carolingian kings lose power in West and East Francia?

I understand why the Carolingian Empire collapsed, but how exactly did a powerful and famous dynasty come to lose power over much smaller and easier to manage domains? In both kingdoms, nobles simply stopped respecting dynastic succession and elected their own successors to the kingship. To me this seems to display the lack of power the dynasty had in the 10th century, and I'm wondering how it was weakened to this point.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

How did Americans become so individualistic and self-centered?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Why is it that coins are made out of a more expensive material, but are used for lower value denominations?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Was the Cold War a much Scarier time to live in than Now?

If we were to discount the reaction to the close calls of the Cold War (Cuban Missiles, Able Archer), was the rest of the conflict a scarier time to live in (American or not) than now? Was Nuclear war always seemingly inevitable or were there hopes that the whole situation could one day diffuse?

Also is the Covid pandemic less scary than the average day in, say, the 1960s or 80s?

(And if I, the perseverating poli-scientist I am, freaked out over North Korea or Iran, how often would the cold war have given me panic attacks?)

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Herodotus calls Athena and Poseidon as Minerva and Neptune in Histories book 8.55. Rome was insignificant at that time. Why is he referring to Roman names?

The relevant text is:

"I will now explain why I have made mention of this circumstance: there is a temple of Erechtheus the Earth-born, as he is called, in this citadel, containing within it an olive-tree and a sea. The tale goes among the Athenians, that they were placed there as witnesses by Neptune and Minerva, when they had their contention about the country. Now this olive-tree had been burnt with the rest of the temple when the barbarians took the place. But when the Athenians, whom the king had commanded to offer sacrifice, went up into the temple for the purpose, they found a fresh shoot, as much as a cubit in length, thrown out from the old trunk. Such at least was the account which these persons gave. "

I found it weird because he called the earth-born by its Greek name and then called the gods by their roman names. Furthermore, I am especially surprised about the use of Minerva rather than Athena because the Greeks did not like the fact that the Romans made Minerva extremely passive and no longer in warfare.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

what is the average travel speed during the middle age?

i am a average peasant with a bit of wealth, i would either taking a boat or travel on road to see a very important person. how much time would i take to travel?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

When did we start using colours to describe race?

Yellow, white, red, black, etc.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Which surnames (or even first names) are entirely North American (USA) in origin?

Most names that citizens of the United States carry are names brought with them from their countries of origin.

Are there any surnames which were created in America?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Are there any books on Stalin's Purges which use modern evidence from recently opened Soviet archives?

I'd also like them to be as unbiased as possible.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Does Jesus Mythicism/Do Christ-Mythers go all the way back to the Second-Century as some mythicisists state?

Hello historians! I stumbled upon some posts (Both from Reddit (r/DebateAnAtheist to be specific) and the internet in general) that there were people who argued against the fact that Jesus of Nazareth existed. I was wondering if such a fact is true as I am just a layman. I figured that r/AskHistorians would be the best place to ask such a question.

SCOURCES:

https://vridar.org/2019/03/05/justin-martyr-answers-a-second-century-jesus-christ-mythicist/

https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateAnAtheist/comments/fi0uk2/did_jesus_really_exist_is_there_really_a/

"Jesus mythicism is not an invention of the internet age - it is an ancient game. Early christian apologists (in the 2nd century I think) had to deal with that particular charge already.

There are - very broadly speaking - two different types of Christ mythicists: Wacky unscholarly internet folks who make a lot of parallel myths, astrotheology and number games; and highly intelligent, trained people, some of whom have a lot of love for the bible - I'm mainly thinking about Robert M Price, but Richard Carrier falls into that category too (though I hate his arrogant ass I must say). So the whole thing is deceptively easy to strawman.

There are, of course, a LOT of highly skilled, venerated professionals in the historicist camp - Bart Ehrman probably the most well-known name. My admiration for him, for his passion and his dedication and knowledge - won't be blemished by the fact we disagree on Jesus' existence.

I think it matters a lot when you're able to put a number on your confidence. I'm about a 70% mythicist. There is no need to fully commit to one side. Both theories have a lot going for them and a set of problems, it's just that, with my current knowledge, the scale tips slightly towards mythicism.

Caesar existed. There is scholarly debate about Alexander's existence for much the same reasons as Jesus. With the Buddha, there should be debate, but there isn't. The point being, we should'nt lower the bar so we can allow Jesus, but keep it high and doubt the existence of those other guys."

(As you can see, the first point of this comment from the said post in r/DebateAnAtheist strikes me as odd)

PS: I'm sorry if I'm asking a question regarding a topic that is talked often in this sub. I just want to know the stand of historians regarding this detail. :))

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Was there a similar movement calling the Spanish Flu "A Hoax"?

Were there people in 1918 "protesting" the Spanish Flu, and claiming it was a hoax? Maybe in rural areas where it wasn't so common?

The ability for some people in 2020 to claim the 2020 hoax is so wild to me, that I feel like no one could ever arrive at the opinion without the massive info/disinfo/communication ability of the internet. But if there was a similar movement of mass denial in 1918, then obviously my hypothesis is false.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Beastly behaviour: The Beauty and the Beast

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Did Japan have animals like Bison that were roaming but were eventually eliminated as civilization grew?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Mitsubishi logo history in WW2

Hi r/askhistorians, I wanted to ask about the history of the Mitsubishi logo and WW2.

I’ve been told by others in the past that the Mitsubishi logo is supposed to be a reference to the propellers of WW2 military fighter planes which they had engineered in order to attack and subjugate neighboring eastern Asian countries as well as Pearl Harbor. I know someone from the X gen who grew up in a military family who refuses to ever buy a Mitsubishi car for this reason.

Is this true or is this just a myth? If it’s a myth, what’s its real history? Is it really accurate to compare the Mitsubishi logo to the logo of the Luftwaffe from Nazi Germany?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

What were the main characteristics and problems of patriotic sentiment in Russia and Austro-Hungary before the World War First?

what title says

its urgent pls

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Is there any instance throughout history of someone being killed/executed for a particularly bad pun or joke?

2 Answers 2020-04-30

Tiger I Panzergrau color with grossdeutschland (white helmet markings)

I been endlessly searching for photo references on this subject for my scale modeling hobby and I want my models to be historically accurate as much as possible. So I got really desperate to ask if any Tigers exist with the same description?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Recommendations for widely-available history documentaries for curious under-10 year olds?

Any recommendations for reputable history documentaries suitable for curious under-10 year olds? Schools aren't back for while yet and the current obsession with biology is reminding me why I didn't take that subject in my senior years high school. Really reminding me. I feel it is worth trying to prompt a change in obsessions.

Ideally the documentary won't assume knowledge of timelines in a broad sense. But long words and technical jargon are in no way a barrier.

If a particular geography is helpful, then New Zealand and the broader Pacific region.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Are we all currently part of a 'thousands of years long' struggle between the original Sumerian cities and their offshoot clans/civilisations?

Under the "overall rule" of:

  • An also known as: Anu/El/Ahura Mazda/Brahma and his "Anunnaki also known as: Neteru/Nephilim" people, from Nibiru also known as: Sirius

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  • Ea also known as: Enki/Era/Ptah/Shiva/Dagon's original "civ/cult/clan"

And his offspring = (Ningishzidda also known as: Toth/Kulla/Vishnu) + (Marduk also known as: Amun/Amon/Aton/Ra/Ravana) + (Nergal also known as: Erra) + (Adapa also known as: Adam/Hanuman) + (Ur-dukuga--->Adad-apla-iddina)

And its offshoots = {Dogon's} [IRAQ + EGYPT]

"vs"

  • Marduk also known as: Amun/Amon/Aton/Ra/Ravana's "rebel civ/cult/clan"

And his offspring = (Nabu also known as: Nebo) + (Ninlil also known as: Isis+Osiris also known as: Asur--->Zoroastra also known as: Zarathushtra)

And its offshoots = {Persians} [EGYPT + BABYLON/BAGHDAD] [MARS]

"vs"

  • Enlil also known as: Elil/Nunamnir/Hadad/Ishkur/Rudra's original "civ/cult/clan"

And his offspring = (Nannaralso known as: Sin/Min--->Innana also known as: Ishtar) + (Ninurta also known as: "Nisroch")

And its offshoots = {Kassites} + {Andeans} [ISRAEL + BABYLON/BAGHDAD + PERU]

"vs"

  • Innana also known as: Ishtar/Astarte's "civ/cult/clan"

And her offspring = (Lulal)

And its offshoots = {Uyghur} {Yamnaya} [INDIA + TURKEY]

with

----> BONUS ENTRY: Sargon of Akkad's "Empire"

And its offshoots = {Incas}

and as "intermediaries/neutrals"

  • Ninmah also known as: Ninti/Ninharsag/Neith/Mami/Shala/Shakti/Adi Parashakti's original "civ/cult/clan"

And her creations also known as: "lulu amelu/men" = (Adamu) + (Ti-Amat also known as: Eve)

And its offshoots = ? [SINAI]

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All possibly vying for their "divine" right to rule the Earth's lands, and its subsequent peoples.

The "Unifying" Logo of all civs:

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Is Chris Stewart's "A History of China" podcast dangerously credulous

I've been listening to this recently, with some amount of scepticism as this seems a huge swath of history to cover accurately, and have been confused with his explaination of the Partition of Jin, where he seems to accept without question, people eating their children during a seige, a rising commander being absolutely blind to potential disloyalty and honest to goodness drinking from enemies skulls. Which at least to me all feel like artistic flourishes to a story which weren't neccessarily true.

Is he correct to accept those accounts of what happened? If the historical consensus does not take those literally, how concerning is it that he goes against this hypothetical consensus? I'm listening as a hobby, so am not looking for academic depth, but obviously don't want to learn things that are factually wrong.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Are Anatoly Dyatlov and Igor Dyatlov related?

Just wondering as I noticed the infamous Chernobyl director and the leader of the doomed hiker group named after him aka Dyatlov pass have the same last name. Are they related in any way or just a coincidence of same last name?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

Executed Football/Soccer Team.

This may be removed for a few reasons, I'll give it ago anyway.

I remember reading about a football/Soccer match that happened in the last 100 years probably during ww2 where the occupied Country won a match against the occupying forces and were all 'disappeared' did I make this up? Help please.

1 Answers 2020-04-30

What scientific advancements happened, and what things were invented in the Middle Ages in Europe?

How much did scientific advancement and inventions decrease in the Middle Ages? Has anyone counted the number of advancements and intentions of the Middle Ages? Have they been compared to the number in Antiquity?

1 Answers 2020-04-30

1371 / 7255

Back to start