How deep were ancient wells in places like Israel, Egypt, Iraq, etc?

I see that by modern standards a desert well is extremely deep, 1000 feet of more. Where ancient people digging down 1000 feet for there wells?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

What do historians think of the Cäğfär Taríxı or Djagfar Tarikhy? Is it historically accurate? Is it considered to be genuine or is it a forgery?

I came across this interesting historical text called the Cäğfär Taríxı, but it seemingly has thirty different ways of spelling the title. Anyways, this is a compilation of the history of the Volga Bulgars and has some interesting material on their ancient history as well.

However it seems that this text does not come without controversy, as it has a dubious origin story and the original manuscripts, composed in the 17th century, were supposedly destroyed in the 1930s.

I can barely find any information on it outside of fringe websites, but my googling is limited to English, perhaps the story would be different if I could speak Russian or one of the Turkic languages.

So for your steppe historians out there, what is general consensus regarding these texts? Does the historicity of these annals check out? Was it genuinely composed in the 17th century? Or is this a forgery?

Apologies for linking this propagandist pseudo history website here (serious warning here folks), but this was the only place where I could find an English version of the Djagfar Tarihi:

1 Answers 2020-04-28

What were the cultural, societal, and economic impacts of the Great Migrations?

I have found a lot of research on the Great Migration, however, a lot of the websites seem to say the same thing. I am trying to find the lasting impacts of the Great migration on America. I have found a lot about the Harlem Renaissance but that's about it. I'm not looking for anyone to write this for me, but to send me in the right direction of what I should look for or research.

Thanks!

2 Answers 2020-04-28

What was the difference between the NKVD and the KGB?

I see them both referenced as the Soviet Secret Police, whats the difference between the two?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Life in neutral European countries during WWII

Hi,

I saw this post in /r/mapporn (https://i.redd.it/3flcw70abjv41.png) and it got me wondering what life was like in the countries that were not active participants during the war.

Was rationing a thing for them as well?

How much was reported in newspapers about the war?

Was there a general consensus on which side was 'right' or the preferred winner?

Was there a consensus on whether they should join the war and on what side or maybe in a limited context?

Did the war accidently spill into neutral territory in Switzerland or Spain?

3 Answers 2020-04-28

During Napoleonic times big organizational army units were called "XIV Corps". In modern day times we call them "12th Army". The Roman Empire called them "XII Legion". What did the Ancient Greeks, Egyptians, Chinese, etc... call their big organisational army units?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

When exactly did girls start to be able to go to dates?

So I’m watching a lot of period dramas now and am confused every time a girl goes out on a date in the 1920s or something.

When exactly would women start to be able to go out with an interested male without it being socially frowned upon?

Say if you fancied a girl in the 1880s, i don’t suppose you could do much else rather than ask her hand in marriage from her father.

1 Answers 2020-04-28

what was medieval beer like?

How much does medieval European style beer resemble our modern day beer, I've heard that medieval beer was more like modern day mead but with some alcohol, is there any truth to this claim?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Elders of Zion and the holocaust?

Hitler mentions the Elders of Zion in Mein Kampf, and it was used as a propaganda tool by the Nazis. However, I was wondering just how much of an influence the Elders of Zion might have had on what Hitler and Nazi Germany did.

 

Was it a fundamental influence? That the Jewish population with their "Protocols to conquer the world" (as described in EoZ) would need to be eliminated if the Aryan's ever hoped to be in control?

 

Or was it more a case of antisemitism and the Elders of Zion was just another nail in the coffin that Hitler and the Nazi's could use to say "See, I told you so?"

 

Any information or sources are greatly appreciated, thank you.

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Counter-culture social history sources

I am currently researching how I will access counter-culture communes in my dissertations and am struggling to find good primary source collections. I am looking for periodicals, diaries, letters, manuscripts, memories etc. Essentially sources that allow me to access what life was like in these 1960's to 1970's counterculture communes. I am especially interested in UK and US communes as I wish to do comparative work on them. Where can the best collections of commune primary sources be found?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Water Usage on WWII German U-Boats

I've read a few different things about how difficult the living conditions aboard German U-Boats was for sailors during WWII, such as hot-bunking, bland canned food for months on end, and no fresh air for weeks. I'm interested in the fresh water capacity of these subs. Obviously they had to have some fresh water aboard for the crew to drink, but I've read some sources say sailors didn't bathe for anywhere between 3 and 6 months. Does that mean there weren't shower facilities on board and they only bathed in port? Did U-boats have desalination plants to create fresh water? I know it's hardly the same, but could sailors bathe with salt water at least, or was that not an option?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

How did contemporary historians refer to their own and previous historical periods?

In Europe, for example, there's Antiquity, the Middle Ages, Age of Enlightenment, etc., but I'm presuming that a medieval scribe, historian, monk, chronicler, etc. wouldn't have referred to their own time as the "Middle Ages". What terms would have been used to describe those time periods? Are terms recycled?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

What was the Rwandan Genocide’s affect on the economy in the country?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

How publicly acknowledged were Jim Crow laws?

So from what I understand, Jim Crow laws were state laws that, while not explicitly calling for discrimination, were designed in a way that they discriminated against African-Americans. Was it immediately clear to people that these laws were de facto designed to discriminate? How often was this publicly acknowledged? Was it acceptable for, say, politicians and newspapers (or other “official” sources) to talk about or promote the Jim Crow laws as discriminatory, or was it more of an under-the-table thing where people pretended they weren’t (or didn’t even know at all)?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

How did the cultural mixing of happen between the Angles and Saxons?

In the early period of England, we know that a few groups came to England, Angles, Saxons, Jutes, and Frisians. From my flawed knowledge, it seems that all of these peoples eventually congregated into 1 people called Anglo-Saxons, but they are sometimes just referred to as Saxons in some historical sources.

How close in culture were the Angles and Saxons?

Why were their groups the most prevalent of the northern Germanic tribes who moved to England?

What happened to the Frisians and the Jutes?

When and how did the Angles and the Saxons become the "Anglo-Saxons"?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Was there an actual plot to put Trotsky in power of the Soviet Union?

During the great purges Stalin accused many party leaders of conspiring to overthrow the communist state, were any of these accusations founded or were they fabricated?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Why the Reformation in the XVI century didn't spread to Eastern Europe?

Lutheranism managed to expand from the HRE to Escandinavia, calvinism in his different forms made itself prevalent in the Netherlands, Geneva, Scotland and some parts of France, and even England had his own reformation with Henry VIII. But how is it that the reformation didn't expand to Eastern Europe, or, if it did, how is it that it wasn't as succerful there? How did the orthodox churces see this split in the catholic world?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

How did Europeans and Indians communicate?

When I hear stories about the exploration of the New World, I never hear about how the Europeans and Indians communicated. How did they understand eachother? I get that by 1700 the Iroquois probably knew some English, but how did Spanish conquistadors speak with the Aztec kings? How did the Portugese traders speak to the tribes of the Amazon? Did the Indians in Virginia have an English translator? Did the Roanoke settlers learn the local tongue?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

To what extent was "scientific racism" ever considered scientific?

Did Racialist ideas really dominate accademia during the 19th and early 20th century as It is often thought? Or was It just a fringe movement?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

How were nobles/gentlemen of the late modern period prepared to fight and die in duels?

We have this stereotypical image of two men in very nice coats standing facing each other while discharging pistols, unperturbed in the face of possible injury or death.

But how do you get there? Maybe this is a stupid question, but how do you inculcate a youth with the belief that he must be prepared to kill or be killed over matters of honor? Did dads give their sons THE TALK and tell them “Whatever you do, don’t be like your Uncle Fitzhugh and run away like a coward”?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

I have stumbled upon something called "phantom time hypothesis" and it seems as an utter nonsense to me. Are there some facts that support the hypothesis?

It says that two emperors and the pope have skipped and fabricated 297 years. I find it incredibly farfetched and would like to know what has led someone to come up with this.

1 Answers 2020-04-28

There is a weapon depicted in the illustration of the battle of Maldon (991) in St. Mary's Psalter (early 14th century). Did it exist or is it more probably just artistic freedom on the side of the painter?

https://textingatceu.files.wordpress.com/2017/10/23-b-battle-of-maldon.jpg?w=750&h=500&crop=1
The mounted knight on the very left side is holding a weapon that looks like a sword shaped like the top of a billhook. I've never seen anything else like that in other illuminations or surviving artifacts. Did weapons like this exist, is it supposed to be something else or is it more likely just an idea the artist came up with?

2 Answers 2020-04-28

Greece in 482 BCE

I am writing a sequel to my book and one of the characters, Nikolaos, was born in around 482 BCE in Greece. In the first book, I didn't divulge much about his life growing up in Ancient Greece however in this one I would like to look into it more.

I was wondering if any of you knew some good places to find out more information on what life was like back in those times for families and citizens, what the politics were, etc.

Am I correct in think that my character would not have a surname, so he would be called Nikolaos son of name?

What would life be like for a 27 year old man in those times, not affluent as such but not a poor man either?

I'm sorry if these questions are too broad, I'm really trying to educate myself on the matter as much as possible to do justice to the character's history and not spread misinformation. If any of you could help with these queries or could point me in the right direction of resources to learn more I would be very grateful, and if you would like me to be more specific with questions I would be happy to try and word them better.

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Dear historians, what can you tell me about the Holodomor?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Did sending most of Republican Spain's gold to the USSR help or hurt more their war effort in winning the civil war?

The title says it all. From what I understand the Soviets were the only ones who were willing to help Republican Spain, although not for free. On the other hand sending most of their gold away kind of wrecked the economy (as if the civil war wasn't enough).

So I want to know, was it the right choice to pay for Soviet aid with the gold reserves?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

1377 / 7255

Back to start