How did Mongols treat cities that instantly surrended?

Did they spare them? Or were they merciless anyway?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

The band of brothers mini series on hbo depicted allied troops stealing property. This breaches the Geneva convention what happened in post war Europe to reconnect property?

What efforts where made in a post war Europe and present day to reconnect property, paintings, wine, and more to the rightful owners where possible and what punishments where given to those on the allied side who where caught stealing?

(It breaches army law and the rules of engagement, was it enforced?)

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Early English colonies in N America had high death tolls. After the "starving time" in Jamestown, only 60 of 500 colonists survived. After the first winter at Plymouth, only half survived. Did the colonists perceive their experiences as traumatic? If so, how did they deal with it?

3 Answers 2020-04-28

Why are European medieval illustrations so primitive looking?

It's not like the art of good illustration was invented during the Renaissance or something. I have seen, for example, Roman wall paintings that are well executed. Yet, in European sources, such as Bibles or martial treaties, the illustrations are almost child like; flat, weird perspectives, the most ridiculous expressions on people being cut to pieces and so on. Why is it that?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Are there any Soviet Union based channels on Youtube?

Hi. I've never shared anything on Reddit so I hope I'm doing this right. I would like to know if there are any channels on Youtube that cover the life in Soviet Union or at least Some the major events or it's History. I know about the Ushanka show and Wolfieexplains ( https://youtu.be/nb21Qec_PC0 ). So are there any other channels like this? Thanks.

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Where can I find primary sources for my research?

I am an undergrad student researching on the bubonic plague in San Francisco from 1901-1906. I am not a history major and the only person I know from that department is my research mentor. She and I have used all of the resources my university has to offer and I could only find newspaper articles from there. I need more documents, ideally government documents or medical documents. It would be very helpful to find notes/reports from the doctor who discovered that the plague had reached San Francisco or diaries from people living during the plague. I don’t know who I should contact to find anything like this. Should I try to find some historians who have specialised in this, contact the local government, libraries or universities and which ones?

3 Answers 2020-04-28

Did midievil soldiers suffer from mental health problems such as PTSD after battles? If so, How were those conditions viewed public in those times?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Did beach landings in the Pacific Theatre help prepare the American military for D-Day?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

At the time the Iliad was composed, was it really common or possible for a city to be held under siege for 10 years? Is the nature of the war as described familiar or fantastical to its audience?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Soviet propaganda often depicted the USSR as a tolerant country without racism and criticized the US for Jim Crow laws. To what extent was the Soviet ideal of a racism-free society true? How freely of racism could a non-white person live in the USSR?

A common theme of Soviet propaganda against the United States was its critique of racism in US society and it liked to portray itself as a racially tolerant society, a diametric opposition against the US. The Soviet film The Circus is a famous example that tells the story of a racially mixed American couple finding refuge and acceptance in the USSR.

But my question is that, while this is all propaganda, how true was this Soviet self-deal of a racism-free society? In other words, how freely could a black person or any non-white person live in the USSR without the bounds of racism?

3 Answers 2020-04-28

Difference between "scholar-gentry" and "landed aristocracy" in Sui-Tang-Song China

I didn't see any questions on this topic. I've read some histories of China and they mention that during the Tang the scholar-gentry supplanted the landed aristocracy as a result of the reinstatement of the examinations and attempts to break up the great estates. However, they don't go into details on the practical differences. the scholar-gentry still own large tracts of land that they passed down to decedents, right? Was the lack of a title the difference? What differences would there be between the fate of a lazy son of the scholar gentry and a lazy son of the aristocracy?

2 Answers 2020-04-28

How effective as a 1700's and 1800's Musket with a bayonet attached as a melee weapon vs things like swords and spears?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

In the USSR after WW2 for every 10 women there were 7 men (20-30 years). How did this massive imbalance between the genders effect dating and family life?

In particular are there any accounts of women having massive problems finding husbands? Or men having an easy time finding wives?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

How exactly was Caesar’s army so fast?

This is something I hear often when I’m listening or reading about Caesar’s campaigns, and I see it even thrown out there as his main focus and strategical advantage. But, I haven’t yet heard specifically what Caesar did that allowed his army to be so fast. The make-up of his army wasn’t especially different from an average Roman force to my understanding, so what was the variable that allowed Caesar to move so quickly?

1 Answers 2020-04-28

Did Wu Zetian really demand that foreign diplomats perform cunnilingus on her in in open court as a show of obedience--or is this a myth?

The only 'sources' for this story I've been able to find are blog posts, reddit posts, and an ebook. This fact is so ludicrous and entertaining that I feel like confirmation from some reliable source would be great. An oft cited Reddit post claims that "Empress Wu Zetian of China made people eat her out if they wanted to talk to her. Even when menstruating. If they couldn’t make her cum, she wouldn’t listen to him. She called it ‘Paying homage to the Lotus Stamen’."

I've come to the experts for Guidance...can't wait to see if this is true!

1 Answers 2020-04-28

The 1950s teenager as a consumer

Please could anyone suggest some books/articles etc on how consumerism shapes identity and behaviour? I have my own ideas but be interesting to read up on existing historiography. Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-04-28

What other cultures and mythologies talk about a worldwide flood? (Besides the bible)

My wife has been doing a ton of research on this and I too am interested in an expert opinion. More cultures and people having it in their lore seems to reinforce something like that happened at some point.

3 Answers 2020-04-28

How true is the assertion that WWII Imperial Japan's Emperor Hirihoto/Showa Emperor explicitly signed off on the three all' and further questions on the nature of the emperor.

This was a scorched earth policy (kill all, loot all, burn all). Wikipedia mentions one historian, Mitsuyoshi Himeta, who claims that, but some internet and library searching has failed to unearth any other historian who agrees with him. My impression is that the claim is an explicit order, and I haven't been able to find work explicitly refuting that. Also, isn't the precise nature and role of the emperor unclear? I've heard contradictory claims and evidence, and like with a lot of other parts of history, it has gotten politicized and used as a tool/weapon for nation building and for points against others. As is usual, nationalists make me very frustrated. Some characterize the emperor as another evil person debating the final solution at the Wannsee Confeference, whereas others paint him as a victim like a bird in a cage. My impressions are that its a bit of both, as when the military coup happened, after the brief period of a pseudocompromise between the civilian government status quo and fascist military regime, the emperor was taken hostage for his own protection (reminds me Dong Zhuo during the fall of the Han Dynasty, and those stories were popular in Japan), and used as a symbol for power (mirroring the Shogunate?), but he wasn't an idol victim and was trying to negotiate and make the best of it, and had his own ambitions for himself and Japan, some of which didn't contradict and even agreed/overlapped.

1 Answers 2020-04-28

In World War 2, what happened to US embassy staff in Japan and Germany, and Vice versa?

what happened to US embassy staff in Japan and Germany?

And what happened to German and Japanese embassy staff in the US?

1 Answers 2020-04-27

What changes did Stalin bring to USSR economic policy with the Great Break?

1 Answers 2020-04-27

Why did the United States want to assimilate Native Americans?

1 Answers 2020-04-27

What's the latest thinking on what constituted seiðr in Norse society?

I know this is a much-debated topic in the scholarship, so I'm looking for some pointers on what to read to get the most up-to-date theories. Preferrably anything that's accessible online via Shibboleth since it's not possible to get to libraries right now, but if not that's fine too.

1 Answers 2020-04-27

What did Samurai do with broken swords?

I know that Samurai viewed their sword as an extension of their own soul. What did they do with a broken sword. Did they reforge it? Did they get a new one and that became their soul?

1 Answers 2020-04-27

Was there ever any Roman interest in exploring the Atlantic Ocean to the West? If not, why not?

1 Answers 2020-04-27

Last Minute Term Paper Help?!

Hi Reddit historians. I have a term paper due in less than ten hours on the 1970's Stagflation Crisis. We're supposed to talk about the causes, and then analyze the actions taken by the government. Do any of you have a good (.gov or .org or another source my teacher would deem trustworthy) source that I can cite that discusses the US responsive policies? I'm having trouble finding cite-able sources.

1 Answers 2020-04-27

1378 / 7255

Back to start