I'm thinking around the 1700s. You hear of illegitimate children of royalty often but how did they determine this? I.e. What if the child was born to a woman who had been with multiple partners? What if a woman was unfaithful to her husband?
1 Answers 2020-03-28
I am currently reading Navigators and Naturalists: French Exploration of New Zealand & the South Seas by New Zealand author Michael Lee. He mentions about the Duperrey's expedition of 1824 on the La Coquille, which visited the Dutch East Indies outpost of Waigeo. It is mentioned that Malays, Chinese, Europeans and Papuans co-exist with each other, with upper class Europeans adopting Malay and Chinese attire. The French explorers apparently attended a Dutch play attended by Malays, Chinese and Europeans. I am curious to know the full extent of race relations in the Dutch colonial period of Indonesia. Was their racial segregation? Did the Sultans have the same status and power as the Dutch colonials or were they subordinated? Was slavery there entirely racialised?
1 Answers 2020-03-28
I've seen that the Federalists preferred the British over the French as potential allies, and that Jefferson did not hold a favorable view of Napoleon. Are these views correct? Did American politicians want to aid the Revolution? Were there plans to aid Napoleon after the War of 1812 began?
1 Answers 2020-03-28
Did the Habsburgs' reputation for inbreeding result from inbreeding more often than other prominent royal houses, such as the Bourbons, Hohenzollerns, and Hanoverians? Or did their family just had bad luck with the genes they were passing to each other?
1 Answers 2020-03-28
I was doing some genealogical research on my great uncle and after obtaining his military records found out that a book was actually published about the unit he was in during WWII.
Unfortunately, it kind of looks like an obscure book, almost more of a yearbook than a real published book, and I have found zero copies for sale anywhere. I'm not too sure if I should contact my local library or if I'll need to go to a specific archive to find something like this. Here's the book:
https://www.amazon.com/Never-Forget-History-Artillery-Battalion/dp/B072MY1Z4D
2 Answers 2020-03-28
Was it because of the failure of the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests and the beginning of the Special Period in Cuba? How come China, North Korea, Cuba, Vietnam and Laos have remained communist while other Eastern Bloc countries didn't at the end of the Cold War?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
To my understanding, the five monarchs that held the title of Emperor/Empress of India where king-emperors / queen-empress, ruling simultaneously over two territories. Why didn’t the monarch let the Empire of India merge into the British Empire? Bonus question: Why wasn‘t the British monarch‘s title Emperor, since he was ruling over the British Empire, but rather “King of the United Kingdom (at some point Ireland) and the Dominions of the British Commonwealth“ plus Emperor of India. Isn‘t that odd since the title of Emperor is of higher rank than a King‘s yet the monarch was ruling an empire?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
I spend a lot of time behind the wheel and I've listened to a few audiobooks about WW2 but they mainly deal with the war in the west / Africa, and although some give a good overview, I'd like to read something more substantive.
Could anyone recommend any good books for the Russian side of things?
I'm basically looking for something like James Holland's 'War In The West' ..... but for the East.
Thanks in advance!
1 Answers 2020-03-27
For example, would Ctesiphon have possessed similar amenities (such as amphitheaters or bathhouses)? How did the architecture compare? Would a visitor have considered the Persian capitol to be just as impressive as it’s Roman counterpart(s)?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
Dough tends to almost never be steamed in the West, but it's a fairly prominent feature of, for example, East Asian culinary traditions. Almost everything involving flour, water, and yeast is baked in an oven if you're from an anglophone or European country, and steamed buns, or steamed cakes/breads are basically nonexistent. Oven baking seems to be much more accepted among countries with a steaming tradition than steaming is among countries with a baking tradition.
2 Answers 2020-03-27
For example, why didn’t rome nationalize some farms, and use slaves to grow the food there to make it “free” for citizens. I know subsidized brothels were made so most romans could enjoy them, but why not take it further? Why not use slaves to generate wealth and expand the grain dole? With these free “machines” for conquered lands, why not use them to make life incredible for the citizens? Why not build a Utopia?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
I've never understood how any pre landing efforts using planes or even the navy from a distance could lead so much German residence left as to make the actual beach landings a slaughter. please educate me.
3 Answers 2020-03-27
I hope it's okay to ask this question here. I searched the sub and found a few things but wanted to ask again since it has been a few years.
I am working on a podcast outline about the Easter Bunny and its origins. My co-host and I had always assumed it was pagan in origin and then co-opted by Christians but as I've been fact-checking it seems that may not be the case. My role is to do research and present what I find. I prefer academic sources which none of these websites are. I'm diving down the proverbial rabbit hole in a few places but I hope some of y'all would have recommendations as far as sources go.
The podcast isn't an academic one, to the point we have a disclaimer at the beginning reminding people that we are not experts. However, I don't want to present incorrect information.
1 Answers 2020-03-27
I can understand why nations or tribes go to war, they have territory that can be taken and many different settlements, but why would 2 states whose territory spans maybe a few miles outside their walls fight? And what happens when one wins? You can't be a city state made of different cities.
I know these wars happened, like in ancient Greece, but can someone explain the causes and effects to me?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
It seems to me like China had the manpower to deal with the Japanese invasion, it just lacked the industry to produce weapons in a similar proportion as Japan. So why didn't America use its industry to supply China against the Japanese, given how she was positioning herself against Japanese interests?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
Wikipedia states: "As a fascist government, the Kingdom of Italy had staunchly supported Francisco Franco during the Spanish Civil War in his fight against the Second Spanish Republic supported by the Soviet Union. Italy therefore promptly responded to requests by the Republic of Finland for military assistance and equipment for use against the communist government of the Soviet Union. The Royal Italian Air Force (Regia Aeronautica Italiana) sent thirty-five Fiat G.50 fighters, while the Royal Italian Army (Regio Esercito Italiano) supplied 94,500 new M1938 7.35 mm rifles for use by Finnish infantry. However, Germany intercepted most of Italy's aid and only released it once peace had been made.[4] A handful of Italian volunteers also fought in the Winter War on the side of Finland."
1 Answers 2020-03-27
Did any Western or non-Japanese historian apologists attempt to rehabilitate the Imperial Japanese Army and/or Navy's war records during the Cold War, as the Wehrmacht had with the likes of B.H. Liddell Hart and key Allied generals? If not, why did such a myth not arise in the West for Japan?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
I think it's either the Medes or the Persians, I've found conflicting answers of this in my textbook.
1 Answers 2020-03-27
John Adams did not die until over a year into his son’s term as president so I wondered what he thought of his son’s election and his job in office, thank you!
1 Answers 2020-03-27
Several writers in antiquity seem to imply that the Celtic/Belgic states in Gaul were importing almost all of their wine or viewed it as a scarce resource (e.g. Diodorus Siculus writing that Roman merchants "believe that the love of wine of these Gauls is their own godsend" and receive a slave from the Gauls for each jar of wine; Caesar writing that the Belgae are the bravest group in Gaul because "merchants least frequently resort to them, and import those things which tend to effeminate the mind.")
This was surprising to me, given that Gaul included some of the most prominent wine producing regions in modern-day France (my impression is also that there have been large numbers of wine amphorae recovered in Gallic oppida). Were the Gauls really importing all of this wine from the Mediterranean? If so, when did wine production begin in the region?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
I've been reading up about the meeting between Scipio and Hannibal immediately before the battle of Zama and it sticks out to me that when asked who he judged to be the greatest, Hannibal names the two as the top two of all history. Were there any commanders that who he would've known of who could have been in the running?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
Hello /r/AskHistorians!
We are pleased to be testing out the Mass Mailer feature for a new /r/AskHistorians Weekly Round-Up. This is a new Beta feature that the site Admins have been kind enough to allow us to be involved in the testing of. This being the fifth test, there have been a few kinks to work out so far, so we really want to hear your feedback on what you would like to see this feature look like in the future. Not everyone got the mailer, as it is an A/B test, but we welcome feedback from everyone!
We have a brief survey which you can find here that we would greatly appreciate participation on, and also please consider weighing in here in the thread to offer your feedback and discuss things further! If you really don't want to receive this though, there is an option to opt-out, while remaining subscribed to the subreddit, at the bottom of the message you received.
Either go to the profile of /u/ModMessages and click 'Block' OR simply click 'Block User' at the bottom of the message to use one less click
#A Recap of AskHistorians 2020-03-20 to 2020-03-26
Popular This Week: You might have clicked too early, so here are the responses to some of the most upvoted questions from the past week:
Things You Probably Missed: Great stuff flies under the radar every week! Here is a selection of responses the Mod Team enjoyed, but didn't get the attention they deserved:
Features You Might Have Missed:
Features Coming Up:
Plenty more you might have missed though, so as always, don't forget to check out the most recent Sunday Digest or else to follow us on Twitter!
Again, this is a new feature that we are only just starting to test out. How it is tweaked and changed depends on what we hear back from you. We want to know how this feature can better serve our readership. Please participate in the survey, or this thread, to share your thoughts!
1 Answers 2020-03-27
I ve been thinking about this a lot lately. I know that history starts with the presence of written artifacts but were does it stop? Does digital technology and archives interrupt history in the sense that everything will be documented so well that historic study won’t be need after say the 2000? Or will history adapt to the new non material documents and artifacts of our time?
Really curious as to what you think about this! Hope my question is not too vague, I’m coming from an arts background so that happens some times.
2 Answers 2020-03-27
Other questions include:
What breeds of dog did the ancient civilizations have?
Would we recognize those breeds today?
Have the rich always had useless dogs?
Would a Roman recognize a pug as a dog, a descendant of a wolf?
Would a Roman understand any breed of three-headed dog to be Cerberus?
1 Answers 2020-03-27
According to The Invention of the Restaurant: Paris and Modern Gastronomic Culture, most early French restaurants in the 1760s and 1770s were legally suppressed by catering guild restrictions. This is also stated by the other sources I have read, and it seems to be well agreed upon in the historical community. However, despite this consensus, I have been unable to find the actual guild laws that everybody is referring to.
This is pretty sad, because I really want to read some of these laws for myself. Where can I find these laws?
Alternatively, if these laws are no lon ger available, what happened to them? Were the physical documents lost during the French Revolution? If this is the case, how do historians know that these laws actually existed?
EDIT: Quick update -
I managed to find a lead: In The Invention of the Restaurant: Paris and Modern Gastronomic Culture it states "...unregulated purveyors if the 'restrorative bouillons knows as restauraunts - encroached on the rights of the established catering guild (28)".
Footnote 28 states: "Most accounts paraphrase Pierre Jean-Baptiste LeGrand d'Aussy, Histoire de la vie privee des francois (Paris: Pierres, 1782), vol. 2, pp. 213-214. This tale is repeated unquestioningly, sometimes garbled, never supported."
I think if I were to find this document, I would be able to find a good example of a legal dispute, which would hopefully bring me closer to my goal. Unfortunately I have not been able to find Histoire de la vie privee des francois Vol. 2 online, and (according to my university) the nearest library that has it in stock is in France, so the search continues.
EDIT 2: I managed to find it on Amazon, but I can't afford to spend $30 and wait a month on a hunch that this document will be useful to me. However, according to this page, Histoire de la vie privee des francois Vol. 2 is public domain. Assuming this is the case, PDFs are legal and it should probably be available somewhere if I keep searching.
1 Answers 2020-03-27