How do you think happenstance in the sources available to you affects your view of the past? (Question for everyone but it'd be helpful to know commenters' backgrounds.)

For example:

One of my main interests is aerospace history and my favorite airplane is the Mitsubishi A6M (Zero). It was a brilliant design, stretching the limits of Imperial Japan's industrial capacity and maintaining air superiority in the Pacific until poor personnel management on the IJN's part started compromising operations and only being consistently bested, when the US deployed counterparts of twice the horsepower, twice the weight (due to limitations in material availability and engine power, the A6M lacked self-sealing fuel tanks, armor, and had a low "never exceed speed," i.e., the top speed attainable in a dive, without risking structural failure, dives being a major part of dogfighting), and roughly six times the firepower, to the extent it can be quantified. (And radar, which Imperial Japan never quite grasped the capabilities of, to the best of my knowledge, though that's something I need to read more about.)

But my main source on the design of the A6M is a memoir written by Chief Designer Horikoshi Jiro (family name first), which just so happens to have been translated into English. ("Eagles of Mitsubishi" - great read; out of print, unfortunately.) I'd probably still be impressed by the A6M, if I hadn't read that book, but I'm not sure it'd be my favorite design. And what if a different engineer had written a memoir about their airplanes?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Is there a History of science experiments?

Point me to where this can go if its in the wrong place.

I've been thinking about how humans seem to know so much about the world and how we have gotten to the point we have and I am curious if there is a list anywhere or if there is a source that explains(or how I may try to replicate myself) the science experiments from the past.

I'm thinking of any field, optics, motion, light, etc.

I'd love to do some of these experiments with my kids but haven't found a good source on how they went about actually doing them.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Doctors of AskHistorians - how did you fund your PhD?

I've just been rejected for a pair of PhD opportunities I applied for, and when I have suggested topics to Universities, specific historians or research councils i've always been told "nice idea but it needs to be funded"

Beginning to lose hope! I'm in the UK and specialise currently in modern history and Wales.

1 Answers 2020-03-28

What did various socialist philosophers of the time think of the rise and fall of the Paris Commune?

What did various socialist philosophers of the time (Marx, Engels, Bakunin, Kropotkin, ECT) think about the rise and fall of the Paris Commune (was it good? Why it failed? ECT). Just wondering.

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Readings and documentaries about the atomic attacks in Horoshima and Nagasaki

Hi everyone, I'm starting a research about the atomic attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, so I'm looking for sources which deal with this subject, they could be not just books but also podcast, movies and so on.

I would like to have a full view about it so even if you feel to suggest things that are partly fiction that would be still good to me. Personally I'm particulary interested about to learning more about how life was before and after the bombs in those city so if there are direct testimonies somewhere that would be awesome. But as I said the social side of it is not my only interest so you can share whatever you think it will helps better to understand the facts from different points of view.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Odd object in Cairo museum.

While being addicted to Egypt documentaries and history in general I stumbled across this object located in a predynastic exhibit among other objects such as bone needles. https://prnt.sc/rkgp4o. What kind of knowledge did these people possess to craft such an object and why's it the only one of it's kind? PS;, in my research I actually couldn't find anything at all on this object, any information pertaining to it would be much appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Why didn't Romans levy more people during the migration of the barbarian tribes?

My level of understanding is this: before Marian reforms Rome relied on levies and had no professional army. After Marian reforms they had professional army with paid soldiers.

However, if the barbarians were a treat and the professional army was not enough, why they did not levy more men from the province of Gaul to stop the invaders? Wouldn't people be willing to be in the army to protect their villages and hometowns? Or was the ruling class to hesistant to do it since it would be like admitting inability to "do their job" and protect the borders?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

WW2 Eastern Front - Russsia's carrying out of orders to fjord river

Hi,

I was listening to a Podcast on the Eastern Front of WW2 and the presenter, Dan Carlin, said the following. I was wondering if there was a source for the river in question, accounts or diaries detailing this event. If this has already been answered, let me know, Reddit isn't the easiest source for searching.

Crossing in question

The regimental commander has maps and orders from above, while I have nothing but a rifle, a pistol, and an entrenching tool. As such, they have the burden of giving orders, while I must see those orders enforced. Somewhere up above a general looks at a map and it seems reasonable to him to change the front line. He sends down an order.

"At such and such a point, move 5 kilometers forward." Well, as luck would have it there turns out to be a river just at that point, the White Sturgeon. It's deep and swift, in open terrain. It would be convenient and relatively safe to dig some trenches and sit behind this natural obstacle. But an order is an order, and I can't say that it's technically impossible to cross here, even though from a sane man's point of view it is indeed impossible to cross; we have no boats, nor planks, nor are there nearby trees to cut into rafts.

Another predicament lies in the fact that all the soldiers in my regiment come from the steppes. Not only can they not swim, but I'd wager that they've never even seen a river in their entire lives.

I relay the orders to advance the front to the men under my command. Looking confusedly at the rushing river and each other, one of the slant-eyes that speak Russian says "Comrade Lt. Sir, I can't go in the water. I don't know how to swim." He looks back at the others, and they nod their agreement. I know that it's better to drown a soldier than to show irresoluteness or insubordination to orders given from a commanding officer. Even if they all have to drown, it's better than what could happen to us all if we disobey an order. Besides, I already reported to the Major upon receiving the order that there are no boats. He told me to do it anyway. Steeling myself for what I must do, I pull out my service revolver, cock it, and point it at the face of the cucumber in front of me. "Get in the water you son of a bitch! I'll give you to the count of 3 to get in there, or you'll never go anywhere else." The soldier starts sweating. With a worried look on his face he glances from me to the other men. I shove the gun into his face and yell for him to hurry up. He quickly turns and hustles to the river bank. Holding his pack up above his head in one hand and his rifle in the other, he steps into the water, evidently trying to wade across. Of course the strong current immediately seizes him and carries him down the river as he ineffectually thrashes about. He disappears under the water and is swept downstream, apparently drowning. Some of the others don't speak Russian, but they understand when I point my pistol at them that they must also wade into the river. All the rest of the cucumbers that I force into the river drown.

I walk into the Major's tent, where he sits examining lists of supplies, equipment, and other such logistical paperwork. He looks up at me as I enter. "What do you have to report Comrade?" "Comrade Major, there are only 5 men left in my company."

"WHAT!? What did you do to them!? I didn't hear a single shot!"

"They all drowned crossing the river, Comrade Major.''

"What do you mean 'drowned'!? I'll shoot you right here like a dog!"

"As you will Comrade Major, but I did report to you that there were no planks or logs to be found in the area, that the river is deep and swift, that it can't be forded. You told me to stop arguing and to just obey orders."

"You blockhead! What a stupid way to destroy a whole company!"

The Colonel arrives shortly in a groundcar. "I gave you five hours to cross the river!" he shouts as he enters. "Have you carried out the order!?"

"No, Comrade Colonel, we've sustained heavy losses."

"Losses?" .."Well. That's fine. If there weren't any losses our heads would roll. What happened? Everything's quiet, I didn't hear a single shot from over here. Did they all get knifed or what?"

"No. Drowned. The company that was to cross over were all slanteyes. Never saw a river before. Naturally they drowned, since there was nothing to float on."

"You son of a bitch! Why didn't you take some pontoons? We've been dragging a whole transport of pontoons around! I could give you as many as you want!"

"I no longer need them Comrade Colonel. There are five cucumbers left in the first company, ten in the second, maybe twenty in the third. There's no one left to cross." The Colonel ponders for a moment.

"Well, you'll just have to cross anyway. What counts is the fact that the order has been carried out, even if only one man makes it."

Source: Dan Carlin's Hardcore History "Ghost of the Ostfront" Ep. 3

Thanks to u/DefiantGoat for writing down the whole paragraph from Hardcore History.

2 Answers 2020-03-28

Sephardic Jewish History in Romania

Hello,

One side of one of my grandmother's family emigrated to the US from Romania in the late 1800s/early 1900s. My grandmother always claimed that some of them were descended from Spanish Jews who fled the Inquisition in the late 1400s/early 1500s, but some of my family never really listened to her. They were from a little north of Bucharest (Ploiesti) and also around Focsani. As I understand it, there actually were Sephardic Jews living in these areas for a time. Learning this made me completely re-consider the fact that should might be correct.

I showed some pictures of this side of my family to my friends from Portugal, Spain, Mexico, etc and they have said they look completely and utterly Spanish and Portuguese. I also often get "mistaken" for Spanish, Mexican, etc (as well as other things like Palestinian, Lebanese, Moroccan, etc) even though I am supposedly Ashkenazi Jewish. We also have a picture of who would be my 4th great grandmother from this line and her name is the Yiddish form of the name Esperanza. I'm not sure if that is a sign or not.

I'm curious if anyone knows the history of Sephardic Jews in these areas I listed above as well as some resources on how to possibly see if it relates to my family as my grandmother claimed.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Sources on female Druids

Hi guys! I’m writing a research paper about Druids, and I am so fascinated by the mystery surrounding so much of them. I’ve read many pieces saying that female druids were important, but I’m having trouble locating sources. Could anyone help?

2 Answers 2020-03-28

After the Great Leap Forward and subsequent Cultural Revolution, why did the Chinese call the Soviets 'revisionists' after their relationship split?

I vaguely understand what the term means, but 'revisionist' is also a term attributed to historians who oppose the 'traditionalist' view that the Cold War was the USSR's fault (at least I think so, might be wrong). So are these two words being used in the same way here? Because that would not make a lot of sense.

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Why had the Soviet Union interest in occupying the Oblast Kaliningrad?

I'm finding out more about eastern Europe at the moment and found myself interested in this question since it seems at the first glance to me that Kaliningrad didn't have much of a Russian background and the exclave situation seems to me not that super attractive.

The easier access to the Baltic Sea and being away from Germany only about some 500+km seems to be for sure a reason but I would appreciate some more in-depth information on this.

Looking forward to all your answers! :)

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Was Lincoln's Gettysberg Address contain critique of the Confederacy? What is the goverment "of, by and for the people" that is under threat?

The final sentence of the Gettysburg address seems to contemplate an existential threat to the existence of the United States of America:

It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us—that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion—that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain—that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom—and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.

So, my reading of this is that the government Lincoln refers to here is the US of A, of course.

So suppose that the CSA defeats the USA in the civil war-- or at least fights to a peace. That would leave the CSA existing as a country, with its constitution largely a copy of the United States Constitution, except that it institutionalizes slavery.

So the CSA, as a representative democracy, is arguably a government "of, by, and for the people" insomuch as the United States was originally founded as one, only enfranchising free white males as voters. Neither countries are monarchies, for example.

Is Lincoln saying that the CSA, by instituting slavery, cannot be a democracy? How could the United States be considered to be such a government, with its three-fifths compromise, and free- and slaveholding-states compromise?

2 Answers 2020-03-28

What was the reaction to the Beatles’ “Back in the USSR”?

Thinking about it, this song seems so wildly cheeky and/or weird. It’s overtly in support of the UK’s Cold War enemy and (sort of?) in the style of The Beach Boys (the chorus harmonies).

What was the reaction in the U.K., USA, and among The Beach Boys to this song when the White Album came out?

Edit: typo and thanks for the gold!

2 Answers 2020-03-28

Why did the wealth disparity between the richest 1 percent and the 99 percent go down in the early 20th century in the West?

I have found information suggesting that wealth inequality declined in the early 20th century.

I have found a 1977 article which can be found here on Jstor that states this may well be misleading. "From the disparate data, the unwary may conclude that wealth is much more equally distributed in this century than in the 19th."

Take a look at this image. The idea appears to be that the apparent decline in relative wealth of the richest 1 percent in the 20th century is misleading somehow.

What precisely happened to the wealth disparity in the early 20th century? Why did it go down, at least on paper?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Saturday Showcase | March 28, 2020

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

2 Answers 2020-03-28

How are instances of apparent nominative determinism in early Chinese writings about the past to be understood?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Considering that most slaves were barred from reading and writing in English, was there any proliferation of written West African languages among slaves in America?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

What characteristics made Sparta an environment where women could be so much more powerful, confident and autonomous than in other states of the ancient world?

This video describes Spartan women as being highly liberated and autonomous for their time in history, that they wore revealing clothes and often did sports naked in the presence of men. He also says that women in Sparta were permitted to have two husbands, so that their children could have two inheritances. What features of life ancient Sparta would have made this female empowerment possible? Was it simply the absence of men, since men were away fighting wars?

2 Answers 2020-03-28

What were the other motivations for the Civil War besides slavery?

You’d imagine there’d be other motivating economic factors. I’ve always wondered

1 Answers 2020-03-28

What was the role and significant/influence of crystal meth on the Wehrmacht during the Blitzkrieg campaign in 1939-41?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Due to the rise of gender segregated bathrooms, in the late 1800s/early 1900s in America, and the racially segregated period of America..., were there 4 bathrooms? (1 black female, 1 white male bathroom... etc...)

A If there were not such bathrooms, where did people do their business?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

How do historians interpret Primary Sources such as manuscripts or Past writings and Authenticate what is written on it for its truth-fullness ?

I wonder in future when we are all dead after a "Pandemic" and a new Civilization of Homo Sapiens evolve (Like us vs the Egyptians, or Indus Valley People, or Mayans ), and they crack our English Code and learn about our History from our books , how are they going to distinguish from what are authentic Scientific Writings , or what are just pure plain fiction , like Harry Potter Series ? There is nowhere written in Harry Potter that its a work of fiction. Future people may interpret there existed Magicians and Witches, without any way of verifying otherwise.

On the Reddit with all the Communism jokes and usage of terms like Comrades, is it possible future people while reading Soviet history, are going to get these communism jokes are sarcastic or they are going to interpret it as a hidden organisation like the Hydra in Captain America : Winter Soldier

1 Answers 2020-03-28

WW2 had numerous pieces of propaganda aimed at stopping from accidentally disclosing confidential information ("loose lips sink ships" etc.). Do we have a confirmation of either side gaining vital information sure to people failing to observe this?

1 Answers 2020-03-28

Is there any value in “historical mapping videos” like the ones made by YouTubers beyond simple entertainment?

Videos like these: https://youtu.be/NzKejJIwieE

2 Answers 2020-03-28

1441 / 7255

Back to start