The communist regime in East Germany preferred “socialism” to “communism” when talking about the GDR. Were they deliberately avoiding “communism”? If so, why?
1 Answers 2020-03-06
Today:
You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.
As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.
12 Answers 2020-03-06
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I'm pasting a description of No Useless Mouth below. I hope that this AMA will be part book club, part regular AMA; the book is Open Access (free for readers to download) here: https://cornellopen.org/9781501716126/no-useless-mouth/, so if you've had time to read it, I'd love to answer you questions about the book. If you haven't had time, that's totally okay, too. I look forward to answering your general questions about Native Americans' and enslaved peoples' experiences with food and hunger in the mainland British colonies, Nova Scotia, and Sierra Leone from the 1750s to the 1810s. Here are links to two podcasts I've appeared on recently if you want a quick intro to this material:
—
In the era of the American Revolution, the rituals of diplomacy between the British, Patriots, and Native Americans featured gifts of food, ceremonial feasts, and a shared experience of hunger. When diplomacy failed, Native Americans could destroy food stores and cut off supply chains in order to assert authority. Black colonists also stole and destroyed food to ward off hunger and carve out tenuous spaces of freedom. Hunger was a means of power and a weapon of war.
In No Useless Mouth, Rachel B. Herrmann argues that Native Americans and formerly enslaved black colonists ultimately lost the battle against hunger and the larger struggle for power because white British and United States officials curtailed the abilities of men and women to fight hunger on their own terms. By describing three interrelated behaviors—food diplomacy, victual imperialism, and victual warfare—the book shows that, during this tumultuous period, hunger prevention efforts offered strategies to claim power, maintain communities, and keep rival societies at bay.
Herrmann shows how Native Americans, free blacks, and enslaved peoples were "useful mouths"—not mere supplicants for food, without rights or power—who used hunger for cooperation and violence, and took steps to circumvent starvation. Her wide-ranging research on black Loyalists, Iroquois, Cherokee, Creek, and Western Confederacy Indians demonstrates that hunger creation and prevention were tools of diplomacy and warfare available to all people involved in the American Revolution. Placing hunger at the center of these struggles foregrounds the contingency and plurality of power in the British Atlantic during the Revolutionary Era.
9 Answers 2020-03-06
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I would like to learn about the Mediterranean trade between 1200s-1500s. The trade routes, things they traded, different nations having different policies about trade like republics and monarchies. Effects of constant war. How different cultures got effected because of trade. Actual income for the different jobs in the field like a regular sailors, Advisers, merchants etc. I know its a lot to cover so Im looking for books and other resources.
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I'm a person of Native-American ancestry, and while I don't consider myself one because I'm mixed, I've always had an interest in Native-American culture and just tribes in general. Me and my family were talking about things we'd like to study, and I brought up history-- this eventually led me to wonder if there were any fields on the history of Native-Americans or indigenous peoples, and I was eventually led to etnohistory. I've never heard of it before, and my family says that neither have they.
I'd really, really like to know more about this specific field and I'd like to hear from someone who has seen/done it firsthand.
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I was reading up about Goldie and the Gingerbreads, who are claimed to be the first all-female rock & roll band signed to a major label, and the claim was that all-female bands were considered a gimmick up until this point. Is that accurate? Was the music industry (or the music-consuming public) biased against women in rock?
1 Answers 2020-03-06
1 Answers 2020-03-06
1 Answers 2020-03-06
Since the 1980s, specialists in Chinese history have largely rejected the idea that the Opium War should serve as the watershed from which 'modern' Chinese history begins, as part of a general move towards a more Asia-centric understanding of the dynamics of the Ming, Qing, Republican and Communist periods. Alternative candidates for the beginning of the process of Chinese 'modernity' have, for instance, included the outbreak of the Taiping War in 1851 and the Qianlong-Jiaqing transition in 1796-9. My cursory understanding of 19th-century Japanese history, however, seems to suggest that Western influence is afforded a far higher role in contemporary assessments. Is it just that I'm forming this impression from outdated and/or pop-history-leaning views on Japan (similar how to a Eurocentric view of Chinese history remains common in popular spaces despite its rejection from academia) or is there genuinely a significant and current historiographical difference?
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I did a ctrl-f search on the askhistorians book-list with no luck so I decided to make a post.
I've held a particular interest about eugenics for some time now and was hoping you incredibly knowledgeable folks could provide some book recommendations so I could learn more about the history surrounding the topic.
I'd like to tag /u/restricteddata in particular as their posts regarding this subject is what initially sparked my interest.
2 Answers 2020-03-06
1 Answers 2020-03-06
growing up I was given the impression that Hubert hoover was a laissez-faire capitalist who caused the great depression and tried to do nothing to end it. however, reading more about him in the book "America in the Twenties: A History" by Geoffrey Perret has totally reshaped my view on him. to me, he seems less like some sort of libertarian smuck who just told America to be rugged individuals and then pissed off for 4 years and more a hard-working and intelligent man who had the potential to become one of America's most effective presidents only to enter the oval office at the worse possible time because of factors far beyond his control. I am well aware that he made some major mistakes like accepting the farmers demands for the Smoot–Hawley Tariff Act and his failed government schemes to give private enterprise the tools to self regulate, but overall he gave it his all to fight the depression, the problem was that his 'all' wasn't good enough nor would anyone elses if they were put in the same position as he was.
but id like to hear this subs opinion on the matter.
1 Answers 2020-03-06
Belongs to a coffee set made in the Soviet Union, likely during the 50s. What do the markings pertain to?
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I've seen many fascinating questions being posted on this sub, and eagerly opened it looking for conversation regarding the topic. What I typically find are nothing but [Deleted] posts. I've made it halfway through fascinating responses (with references) only to get booted due to moderator deletion. My question is: What are the historical number of redditors leaving such poorly moderated subreddits due to overly zealous moderators?
5 Answers 2020-03-06
To better set up the scenario, the eight coach cars would be something like a D-Zug coach car, adding up to roughly 340 short tons or 308,442.812 kg. Although a real on-duty train would have a baggage car, it shall be removed from the equation for simplicity’s sake, as I could not find the weight of a baggage car from this decade.
Ignoring the varying altitudes of the tracks, changes in track gauge, or border patrol (causing irregular fuel consumption), let’s set the route from Paris to Rotterdam to Berlin to Breslau (Wrocław) to Lemberg (Lviv) to Kiev using this map from Jewishgen.com published in 1910 (http://www.heritage-history.com/maps/lheurope/eur051.jpg). The train will not stop, let alone refuel, at any of these destinations (if the train even reaches them all) or anywhere else. How far will it go?
Note: Could answers please include a common locomotive that was widely used in one of the current countries (like Prussia) and/or the locomotive with the best endurance up to that time (1910)? Otherwise, put any other locomotives you know about from 1910 (or earlier) to the test.
Another note to Moderators: I would not consider this alternate history or something like that, as it deals with actual railroads, actual locomotives, actual train cars, etc, that are put through a route that actually existed (with small modifications to make things easier to understand). Thank you, Moderators, for all the time you spend and effort you assert.
UPDATE: Thank you, Brickie78, for your answer. Others are encouraged to process other trains, so that an average can be produced. I would prefer trains from 1910 or before that year, but Brickie's answer did help create a good 'common locomotive' answer.
Thank you to all responders!
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I think of Pyrrhus for his phyric victories against the Romans, which clearly weren't all the great. Earlier on he had some victories among the The Diadochi, but they certainly didn't seem to be anything particularly spectacular compared to the achievements of Alexander.
But he must have done something really fantastic to be ranked by Hannibal so highly. What are we missing about Pyrrhus?
1 Answers 2020-03-06
As it’s the 250th anniversary of the Boston Massacre, I am wondering if the killing of Crispus Attucks, a man of African and Indigenous descent, was racially motivated. From what I understand, the British soldiers opened fire on hecklers, and Attucks was the first of 5 killed. Was his death being first coincidental or was his race a factor in the British opening fire?
1 Answers 2020-03-06
I would also like to ask, are there examples in American history where such a thing was done? From what I understand, after the conclusion of the civil war many freed slaves went back to working on plantations for very little money and accumulated debt, essentially becoming indentured servants.
1 Answers 2020-03-06
1 Answers 2020-03-06
Obviously at the time, 1880's Japan likely would not be able to venture further than India or Russian Central Asia. However, would a united Asian Pacific be able to defend its sovereignty and interests like the United States's Monroe Doctrine and later Good Neighbor policy?
2 Answers 2020-03-05
I had a teacher in high school who had a world map with the south pole at the top of the map, to show that north being up is just a social convention and not some physical property of the universe. When did this convention come about?
I suppose humans have always had some sense of direction due to the movements of the sun, but why see the sun as moving side-to-side instead of top-to-bottom? Are there any historical examples of maps where the text does not correspond with north being up?
1 Answers 2020-03-05