How complicit were the other members of the Axis Powers in the Holocaust? Were they onboard with Nazi Germany’s eradication of of undesirables? Or were they disgusted by it, if they knew anything at all about it?

2 Answers 2020-02-09

How did the battle of Stalingrad last so long (5 months)?

As someone who’s very uneducated when it comes to war in general, how did the battle last so long? Was the city just extremely massive? Did the soldiers retreat from the city to sleep and send another wave in during the night? How could a battle possibly last for that long?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

What would a day at the University of Oxford look like back in 1096?

2 Answers 2020-02-09

History Master’s vs PhD

High school: 3.98 GPA Community College: 3.7 GPA University: currently all A’s

Hello all! I’m a community college transfer in my first semester at a university. My end goal is to become a history professor, so I’m deciding whether getting a master’s first and then a PhD. I’ve done a lot of research on funding and how that works, so I know a master’s likely won’t be funded unless I work as a TA or something. Really, I’m wanting to know how difficult a history master’s is vs a PhD. One of my history professors told me that getting his master’s was really easy because all he did was read and write papers (my two strengths) and he didn’t have to worry about all the exams all the time. I was just wanting to know if this is universally the case for most people and if I should do this or go straight from undergrad to PhD. My main worry is that I’m not smart enough for a PhD, but maybe I am. I’m really not sure. Any advice or firsthand accounts would be awesome!

EDIT: For what it’s worth, I am in the USA and I’m mostly interested in 20th century US (and I’ve found recently I’m really loving colonial America too).

Note: Please don’t try to dissuade me. I know all about the job market, but this is 10000% my passion and I’ve never enjoyed anything other than history.

3 Answers 2020-02-09

Given that the Ming dynasty was founded by rebels influenced by the White Lotus religious movement, why didn’t their subsequent rule take on a more strongly sectarian nature?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

What did villages in the Roman Empire look like? Did peasants live in huts or in houses? If they had houses, what did they look like? Many European villages today have houses from the medieval era - did Roman villages have sturdy houses that lasted into the Medieval era?

I'm curious about anywhere in the Empire. And regarding huts vs houses, I'm considering huts to be something tiny that's built with the intent that it'll be torn down and put back up again when it gets leaky rather than something built with the intent of being a permanent structure for generations.

2 Answers 2020-02-09

How accurate is this comment about Marie Antoinette being more or less a scapegoat during the French Revolution?

https://old.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/f0sg80/whats_a_fact_you_know_that_almost_everyone_is/fgytjfk/

1 Answers 2020-02-09

How tenuous is the relationship between Valentine's day and Lupercalia?

Is there some, if any evidence, for it? Or is it just a complete myth that's become 'common knowledge?' Asking after reading this NPR article. https://www.npr.org/2011/02/14/133693152/the-dark-origins-of-valentines-day

1 Answers 2020-02-09

What are the best resources for transcriptions of speech from the working class people of Victorian Britain?

What I'm looking for are transcripts of conversations or monologues from the working populations of England. Most of the resources I've found are of middle and upper class people in this period. Ideally I'm hoping for interview transcripts because then I'd be able to observe the more colloquial conversational language.

What I've been able to gather so far is the occasional quote here and there from coal miners but I've gathered what amounts to less than a few paragraphs worth. My preferred location of interest is the North East of England but I'm aware that this is a very ignored location in British history, especially with regard the working population, so ultimately I'd be happy with whatever I can get.

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Horseback Mongolians with swords in northern Germany at the end of WW2?

A very credible friend, retired businessman, shared this story: in 1945, right after Germany lost the war, he (age 8 at that time) was hiding in a Vineyard (northern Germany by the coast) with his mother, and other women and children. He remembers that the allied forces came in - the first to come in were Russian soldiers on horseback with sheathed swords. They raped the women there.. soon after, Russian soldiers with tanks came to town (downhill from Vineyard), and occupied his family home and that of others in town. He He recounts how when, his mother and his brother and him approach their own home, the Russians shot a machine gun over their heads to keep them away. History buffs: is there any record of Mongolians on horseback coming to Germany/Austria toward the end of WW II?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Why didn't the Allies act against Soviet Union?

Why did the Allies only act against Nazi-Germanys aggression and not against Soviet Unions aggression against the baltic states, Finland and Romania?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Why didn’t the American forefathers outlaw slavery when writing the constitution? Was it due to greed, losing support for the revolution, or that they thought slavery would end by itself.

1 Answers 2020-02-09

According to Marx, Socialist revolutions were supposed to originate in wealthy, industrialised and urban states like the German Empire. Why then did almost all Socialist revolutions happen in states that lacked these conditions, like Russia?

And how did the lack of these "necessary" conditions change the nature of the revolutions and the subsequent governance?

2 Answers 2020-02-09

Is Reddit an ok thing to cite an a historical research paper?

I'm about to start my first historical research paper. It's about diversity in media. How our attitudes about it have changed since the 1960s, or have they really changed and are we are just as upset today as we were 20 years ago? One of the things I'm going to defend is Apu from the Simpsons, and there is a really good comment I found on Reddit about it. I will pm the user to ask for permission, and my teacher asked me to find it again.

I know Reddit may sound unreasonable, but it's something you can easily prove or disprove as long as you know a little bit about the content in question.

Here's the link to the comment thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/television/comments/cvo945/the_simpsons_creator_confirms_apu_wont_be_written/ey60be3?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

2 Answers 2020-02-09

Would it be correct to say that Laissez Faire economics lead to Nordic prosperity in the 1800-present?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

books like 1493/guns, germs, and Guns, Germs, and Steel but about the silk road/ euro-asian connection

Hi yall, does anyone know of books like 1493 by Charles Mann or Guns, Germs, and Steel but focused on the silk road/ indo-chinese-eurpoean-african relations and their

I found 1493 to be told through a bit of a eurocentric lens so that was a bit jarring but loved
the layerings of culture stories of interconnectedness (like the history of root vegetables, or the reliance on bat shit for some empire).

The question is also inspired by reading this wiki page on greco-buddhism, it left me wanting to know more about the different influences and cultures that have arisen through this economic intermingling.

2 Answers 2020-02-09

What did people think the earth looked like from space before we sent satellites and people up there to take pictures?

Do we have any artist's renditions of what they thought the earth looked like?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

What do we know about US slave breeding programs?

(also posted at r/askhistory)

I recently read America's Breeding Farms: What History Books Never Told You, a Medium article by William Spivey. He claims that Virginia's chief export was slaves and that people ran jail-like farms where women were raped to produce children to be sold. I do not see sources on that article.

What do we know with sourced material about slave breeding programs in the antebellum USA?

2 Answers 2020-02-09

How were cities illuminated before the light bulb?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Why do translations of poems/epics from different languages still rhyme?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Early in the 15th century, the Tudors apparently were staunch enemies of the Lancasters. How did they come to support and even perpeatuate the Lancastrian cause in the War of the Roses?

2 Answers 2020-02-09

William of Normandy invitation to the Jews of Rouen - Source?

I'm trying to find evidence of William the Conqueror's apparent invitation to Jewish lenders and merchants into London/Oxford.

Many secondary sources say this can be found in William of malmesbury... But I cannot find anything of the sort. I can find William Rufus hosting debates between jewish and Christian clerics... But nothing about an invitation or anything that speaks to motivation... Where are these secondary sources getting this idea of an "invitation"?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Did the Bauhaus movement have Nazi sympathizers in it?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Were the people’s of Europe and North Africa aware of just how large the Mongol Empire at the time of its conquests of fall?

I’m curious as to how knowledgeable the Europeans and North Africans were of the size of the mongol empire that threatened at the time of its conquests through til it’s collapse. They would’ve known about China so would they have known that the same country that had conquered and ruled China was now threatening the holy lands and the Kieran Rus?

1 Answers 2020-02-09

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | February 03, 2020–February 09, 2020

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2020-02-09

1524 / 7255

Back to start