How did some fairly sophisticated empires maintain control over their territories without ever developing a proper writing system?

I was thinking of the Mesoamericans (except the Maya), the Incas, and the various states of West Africa (currently reading the UNESCO General History of Africa). How did kingdoms and empires like them do things like long-distance communications between local officials far from each other, or maintain accounts to note the taxes and tribute being collected?

1 Answers 2020-02-05

We know that witch-hunting was popular in a lot of European Christian nations, but did hunting witches historically happen in other places, for example Muslim or Asian countries, as well?

You often hear about Christian witch-hunts and how hundreds of thousands of people were executed over those kinds of accusations. Was it a phenomenon which was isolated to Europe, or did other cultures also do similar things and at a similar scale with regards to accusing and executing people accused of witchery, magic, and sorcery?

1 Answers 2020-02-05

What Is The History of Women's Clothing Not Having Pockets?

This is maybe a bit broad, but I'm curious how in Western clothing in the 20th century we've arrived at a place where a lot of mass-manufactured women's clothing doesn't seem to have "real" pockets.

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Primary sources in English on Famine in China

Hi there,

I am in search of a primary source on famine in China to assign in class. Curriculum is in English. I normally rely on the Fordham Uni primary source depository - but nothing on famine.
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Why did the "Scramble for Africa" occur so late?

European countries had significantly greater military and economic power than African peoples for decades before the actual "Scramble for Africa" in the 1880s. Where there technical limitations that discouraged conquest before that, or was it more to do with a change of policy/priorities amongst the colonial powers?

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Caesar destroyed the Veneti, a Gaulic tribe on the coast of France that had huge sailing ships. How far could the Veneti sail and did they discover any uncharted lands in their travels?

1 Answers 2020-02-05

An ancestor of mine emigrated from Luxembourg to the United States in the mid-19th century. His last name was French and his family background was in Lorraine. How common were French-speaking immigrants from or near the Low Countries in the US in this period?

2 Answers 2020-02-05

Egypt is said to have been "colonized" by British, due to being a British protectorate. Afghanistan was also a British protectorate from around 1880 to 1919. Why isn't Afghanistan described as being "colonized"? What made Egypt and Afghanistan different in terms of being a protectorate?

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Did ancient Athens have a law against prosecuting someone for their decision as a juror?

Was there a law against or for it? If for, how did they get people to participate? If not, was this ever notably abused?

I was wondering this when my European history teacher was talking about ancient Athenian government and he didn’t have an answer, so I though it would be a good idea to ask here. Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Was elopement as bad as they portrayed in Pride and Prejudice with Lydia?

In Pride and Prejudice, Lydia’s elopement was literally the end of the world before Mr Darcy’s intervention.

Why elopement such a bad thing as portrayed during the that time period?

1 Answers 2020-02-05

The True Whig Party controlled Liberia from 1878 until its violent overthrow in 1980. How did it hold onto power for over a century, and what factors led to its downfall?

Secondary question (leaning more to the polisci side): was the True Whig regime the first one-party state in modern history? To what extent was its rule authoritarian?

(reposting this question due to its relevance to this week's theme as well as due to lack of response earlier)

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Why did glass cockpits such as those found on the HE-111 and B29 disappear almost completely from post war bombers?

1 Answers 2020-02-05

How did the Mongols field so many horses and men?

My understanding of this is poor, but it seems that horses in Medival Europe and other Agrarian economies were expensive because of insufficient pastures for horses which begs the question how were the Mongols able to field such large cavalry and reserve horses (like 5 horses per person by some accounts) Also I'm told that the Mongol army sustained it self on campaigns by hunting how was there so much game around towns???

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Could commoners buy their way into Landed Nobility in Holy Roman Empire in the Medieval ages?

2 Answers 2020-02-05

Frank Naming, Heraldry, Banners, and Coat of Arms

I am very interested in the early medieval Frankish way of life and their history, from Clovis to Charlemagne to all of the Pepins. One thing that seems very mysterious is much of their language and identification. I understand that many names of Frankish leaders are clumsiness of Frank words for things like spear or light or warrior, but those seem to only be first names and mainly for nobles. I am curious about the family names of Frank people, whether peasant names had significant differences from noble names and if noble houses had some kind of symbol or banner like a proto-coat of arms that represented the family.

1 Answers 2020-02-05

If the Soviet Union used money only as a way to control demand as well as bookkeep and also set he prices and wages, how did the state budget work then? How did the state "make money"?

Ok so please bear with me if this question sounds stupid, my economic understanding isn't that high.

In a normal market economy the state implements taxes to siphon off some of the money circulating in the economy and use that to finance its budget, right? This works because the money is a universally accepted exchange good, both domestically and foreign, and if the state were to try and print more money it would cause inflation, so they dont really control it directly, more indirectly. It has real value.

In the Soviet Union however, everything was state owned and money for private individuals only served to control demand, for example by making consumer goods very expensive so that the demand of them plummets and the state can focus on more "important" areas of industry. And money for enterprises only existed to bookkeep the inputs and outputs and pay the workers, whos wages were set by the state. And as far as I know the Soviet Union also has taxes which it then uses to finance its budget.

So if money serves no other function than the one described above and the value of the money is entirely controlled by the state, how did the budget work then?

The money, because wages, prices and the money itself is entirely controlled by the state, has no real value, be it domestically or foreign. If their state budget needs 200 million more roubles to meet their needs, why not just make the wages bigger and thus your tax income? See my point? In fact why a budget at all? The state controls every economic aspect. They dont have to buy tanks from a private supplier, they are the supplier. Just... build them.

I dont know if anything im writing makes sense. I hope you understand what I am not understanding.

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Why did the Confederacy listen to the Emancipation Proclamation

When Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation, it freed all slaves in the confederacy. If the Confederacy were their own thing, why did they listen to a rule from the federal, union government? Sorry if this is a dumb question

1 Answers 2020-02-05

Has a US president ever came out and said the state of the Union is bad in their SOTU address? Has any president been notable for brutal honesty when addressing the public?

2 Answers 2020-02-05

What kind of training did a Spanish conquistador receive?

How long did they have to be trained before they were deployed?

How long were they trained in musketry, swordmanship, lancing and hand to hand combat (if any)?

What kind of diet and exercise regiment were they put through?

1 Answers 2020-02-04

Has a prominent royal family ever had twin heirs to the throne? If so is the first born twin the rightful heir?

1 Answers 2020-02-04

Announcing the Best of January Award Winners!

Another month is in the books, and the votes have been tallied.

For the month of January, the 'User's Choice' vote bestowed the honor upon /u/jollydevil6, for their answer to "How did Carthage raise an army? If they near-solely used mercenaries, did they ever actually raise forces of their own? [Attempt#2]"

The 'Flair's Choice' in turn handed this month's laurels to /u/itsallfolklore, for their riveting discussion of "A lot of Americans talk about pride in their Scottish heritage or Irish heritage, but their seems to be very little talk of Welsh heritage. Why is this?"

For this month's "Dark Horse" award, which is given to the combined vote for best answer by a non-flaired user, we ended up with a dead heat, so we're giving out double honors to /u/youngmarshall for their response to "The Kingdom of Dahomey had a standing corps of all-female warriors who were feared in battle. How were they formed? Was this unique in 19th century West Africa or was there a larger tradition of "Amazons" in the region?", and /u/savageson79 who jumped in on "The Incas were able to construct one of the "greatest imperial states in human history" without money or markets. How did the Inca Empire function without money?".

The "Greatest Question" award, bestowed by the mods for a question we find to be unique, insightful, or highlighting a less trafficked topic this month goes to also resulted in a tie, but much less of a problem, as /u/j2quared had both of the threads most voted upon in our poll with "I'm an African man who was invited to go to school in the Soviet Union. What's my daily life like? How am I treated? Am I touted around like a piece of propaganda?" and "What sort of relationship or influences existed between the activism of the Black American and LGBT+ communities in '60s-'70s America?". Unfortunately they didn't get an answer, but hopefully someone might still be able to give them a second look.

Finally, the January 'Excellence in Flairdom' award goes to /u/DeVerence! In our ongoing effort to revamp the AskHistorians booklist, DeVerence has emerged as one of our paladins. The World War I booklist is unrecognizable from what it was, in the best of ways. Thank you, DeVerence for your leadership on this effort!

As always, congrats to our very worthy winners, and thank you to everyone else who has contributed here, whether with thought-provoking questions or fascinating answers. And if this month you want to flag some stand-out posts that you read here for potential nomination, don't forget to post them in our Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check them out here!

4 Answers 2020-02-04

Do we know if the Trojan Horse was real?

It just seems too ridiculous. Do we have any evidence that it was real? Or is it considered to be made up or an embellishment?

1 Answers 2020-02-04

What happened to Jewish ghetto leaders after the ghettos were liquidated? (Nazi Germany)

What was the fate of co-operative and un-cooperative Jewish ghetto leaders after the ghettos were liquidated?

1 Answers 2020-02-04

Movies like 'Lean on Me' and 'The Substitute' make late-80s/early-90s urban high schools seem like anarchic war zones. Was this really a problem anywhere at the time?

1 Answers 2020-02-04

When did the idea that the brain, and not the heart, is the organ of thought appear in the Near East?

It is recorded in the Talmud (Yevamot 9a) that Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi insults his student Levi for a poorly-thought-out remark he had made by saying, "It seems to me he has no brain in his head." While the text of the Talmud was finalized in the 5th century, this quotation would supposedly have been spoken in the late 2nd century.

However, I know that in the Ancient Near East, as evidenced in numerous places in the Hebrew Bible, as well as in Egyptian texts, it was believed that the heart was the organ of thought in the body.

So when did the idea that it is the brain rather than the heart that is the organ of thought first appear in the Near East, and is its appearance in a quotation from the late 2nd century anachronistic?

1 Answers 2020-02-04

1532 / 7255

Back to start