Sparta

I was hoping someone might have material showing what happened to the remains of the "300", and if the remains of Leonidas ever actually made it back to Sparta, or if they are still there?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

I’ve always wondered how we know so much about Sumerians considered to be the the creators of civilizations as we know it yet know nothing about who inhabited Teotihuacán a more recent civilization.

1 Answers 2020-01-09

How much nicer would the environment have been during medieval times in places like Europe?

Recently I stumbled across this idea of 'Ecological Amnesia' that basically states that over generations we forget about how much better the environment actually used to be. For example, I'm used to walking into a park and maybe only hearing 3-5 birds tweeting, but my grandparents would find it strange that there aren't 10 birds tweeting.

This made me think, how much better would the environment have been for a peasant living in medieval Europe? If they travelled to our time period and walked around a forest, would they be freaked out about how few fauna and flora there are?

3 Answers 2020-01-09

How did medieval calligraphy become synonymous with 90's LA gang culture?

Was watching a play-though of Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas and I noticed even the title of the game is written in this flowing calligraphy. How did this type of text associated with 16th century Christian monks become synonymous with 90's gang culture in major US cities?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

When did hand to hand weapons (swords, pikes) become fully replaced by firearms for a standard infantry soldier?

I would like to know the approximate frame of time in which a military would no longer issue it's rank-and-file soldiers weapons specifically for hand-to-hand combat, such as pikes and swords. (I'm not counting bayonets in this, since I know bayonets were standard issue and are still used today).

For the purposes of this question, let's not count officers carrying swords or sabre-wielding cavalry either. I am aware of the existence of the pike and shot style of combat, but a significant component of this tactic would be soldiers whose main weapon was a melee weapon such as a pike or halberd.

For further clarification, I'm thinking more of European armies when posing this question although I'm open to answers that pertain to armies from anywhere. At what point in time did armies no longer issue pikes or swords to its regular infantry?

2 Answers 2020-01-09

What was the extent of the US government's relation with the Khmer Rouge?

I read that during the Cambodian-Vietnamese war, the US government preferred the Khmer Rouge government over the Vietnamese occupying force. I know that the US recognized the Khmer Rouge in the UN. For example, the journalist John Pilger claims that Singapore helped the US funnel arms to the Khmer Rouge .I also know Zbigniew Brzezinski denied that the US supported them in any way. Is there any type of consensus among historians about the extent to which the US government supported the regime, if at all? Any links to sources are welcome as well.

1 Answers 2020-01-09

British naval doctrine

May be too simple a question for this sub, but it’s bugging me. I remember reading or hearing about a British doctrine in which the Royal Navy was expected to be more powerful than the next two navies. What’s the doctrine called or did I make it up?

2 Answers 2020-01-09

interesting historical mathematicians/math related history

i have to write a thesis on 2 subjects (self chosen) which is history and maths, but im stuck trying to find an interesting person to write about that is both not too complicated math whise and relatively easy to link to the historical period he/she lived in. my thoughts currently are Ramanujan (but his math works might be a bit too complicated for me) or maybe some anchient greek mathematicians (but those are a bit overdone) another option is to maybe do it on something like the enigma machine which is easy to link math to history with. so please hit me up with any interesting subjects you guys know of, just name is fine.

1 Answers 2020-01-09

What is postmodernism?

I appreciate this is complex but I am struggling to understand in full a solid definition of postmodernism. My go to would be Lyotard, that it is a critique of the modern, not a historical epoch, and a rejection of meta-narratives. Yet still, I only feel about 60-70% sure what this exactly means. Any help would be greatly appreciated

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Were my ancestors slave traders?

Hi all,

My father is a white South African and married a Dutch woman, resulting in me, also white. When I tell people I am South African the question ‘why aren’t you black’ or ‘where are you really from?’ pops up quite often.

My last name is possibly German, if you view the word separately, but I can image that in 1650 it was a Dutch last name as well. Right now it’s just a South African last name.

My main question is what is the chance that my ancestors where slave traders? I often tell people as reply to the questions above that my ancestors might have been slave traders from The Netherlands, but no one has a clue. It would be nice if I could give these people meaningful answers instead of a vague answer.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Was Buddhism in Japan before the Kamakura period purely an elite religion?

Repost of interesting question by u/LaBitedeGide

"I was reading Shin Buddhism: An Introduction by Takfumi Hirose, a Shin Buddhist priest and former professor of Buddhism at Gifu Shotoku Gakuen University. He claims in the book that before the Pureland Buddhist preaching of Shinran (founder of his branch), Buddhism was purely an elite religion. However, I have also read that from the time of the Emperor Tenmu, it was a requirement for every house to have a Buddhist alter and every region to have a Buddhist temple where sermons and festivals occurred. Is this claim a sectarian jibe at pre-existing religious structures or was popular Buddhism really non-existant before Shinran?"

1 Answers 2020-01-09

During the Age of Sail what happened to those who died on board?

Were there coffins? Were they thrown overboard, cremated? Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Were oysters accessible to Americans who lived 100+ miles from the ocean in the 1800's?

I found oyster shells near an old stone foundation in Western Massachusetts about 5 years ago. The foundation is about 15 miles from Catamount https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catamount,_Massachusetts , a village that existed from the late 1700's to about 1900.

The foundation I found appeared identical in construction and size to the ones around Catamount. 2.5-3ft high walls, almost entirely made of rounded stones. There is also a small section of colonial road that still exists that is roughly between the two areas, so I believe they are from the same time period.

I found this foundation when I was on a pretty epic off-trail hike with a friend after Hurricane Sandy. Maybe 3 feet away from the foundation my friend found a piece of what looked like oyster shell, next to a little mound of rocks and soil. We dug through it and found at least 6 shells, a small chunk of crumbly rust and some tiny shards of glass. These looked exactly like oysters to me. Pearl/purple on the inside, barnacled on the outside.

This was before we had smartphones, so I had printed Google Earth views and a compass, so I guessed where we were, marked it on the map, and we hiked out roughly the way we came.

We went back once, to get a sense of how remote the place was. It was roughly 5 miles from the nearest road, but that approach had all kinds of obstacles.

I just can't imagine that someone bought oysters, bushwhacked for hours to eat the oysters at this foundation and leave their shells.

Did I find oyster shells from the 1800's?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

World War 1 veterans famously and frequently suffered PTSD, but did any of the generals or commanders suffer from it after realizing how many deaths their orders were causing, often times for no strategic gain?

I recently relistened to Dan Carlin's "Blueprint for Armageddon" and he does touch on how many of the troops suffered from "shell shock", or as we now know it a form of PTSD. And of course we have quite a bit of knowledge about PTSD from all subsequent wars.

But I'm curious, especially with WW1 and the nature of the battles sending thousands and thousands of troops to their deaths to gain a few inches of ground at a time, or sometimes just trying to kill as many people as possible as a metric for victory, did the commanders or generals ever become overwhelmed and suffered from any form of PTSD as a result of their orders?

For example, at Verdun there were something like a million casualties with no tactical or strategic advantage taken by either side(please correct me if this is wrong). I cannot imagine being the person ordering those soldiers to their deaths on such a scale and not being deeply effected by that for the rest of my life.

2 Answers 2020-01-09

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | January 09, 2020

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2020-01-09

At the peak of the Warlord Era in China, how many warlords were there/were estimated to be active?

I’ve been looking deep into Chinese history from about the 1890’s to 1949, and I find it hard to get a scope on how many warlords there were during the Warlord Era. I can reliably find info on most cliques (ie; the ones in the major provinces) but I’m assuming there have to be some more “minor” warlords that weren’t totally lost to history.

1 Answers 2020-01-09

How has historiography about Al-Andalus changed over time?

Today, the popular perception of Al-Andalus is that of a tolerant centre of arts and learning. But I can't imagine that this is what 15th century Spanish academics and public alike would have viewed the Moors. How has perceptions of Al-Andalus evolved? Furthermore, what's the current academic discourse among historians regarding Al-Andalus?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Could anyone provide information regarding this historical family coat of arms? Northern Italian roots, possible links t nobility.

I recently came across this family coat of arms. I wasn't able to find anything online and I think any information would be in Italian (which I don't know).

Does anyone have any information regarding the coat of arms or any history of the Delceppo name? And the phrase at the end of the first line: conti de Bayrols or count of Bayrols. I wasn't able to find anything about that or about Bayrols. Any information would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Do non-English speakers refer to historical eras (such as the Victorian era) with their own previous monarchs? What other naming conventions are used if not these?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

How many blacksmiths would be in a castle? To smith all the weapons and armor.

2 Answers 2020-01-09

Did The African Slave Trade Lead To An Enduring Liquor Trade Between Europe and Africa?

I had read that one of the main trade items involved the European "purchase" of slaves in Africa was alcohol in one form or another; was liquor still a major commodity after the slave trade was abolished?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

I recently watched a video of a modern Balearic slinger, and his sling made a distinct whip-crack upon every release, was this style in common use in the ancient world?

I recently watched a video of Luis Pons Livermore (@1:04), a modern Balearic slinger, and with the style of sling he was using in the video, it made a whip-crack sound upon every release of his sling.

The video made a big difference in how I viewed slinging in war/combat, compared to how I pictured it from various mentions of slingers that I've heard over time; much, much scarier than I typically imagined it!

I was curious though, I don't think I've ever heard it mentioned that slings made a typical whip-crack noise. In ancient war with a lot of people potentially using slings in the same area, I can imagine that it would have had a very distinct sound if they had all been making rather sharp sounding whip-cracks; distinct enough to be mentioned in historical accounts etc.

The sling pictured in the video seems to be a rather short-range sling, I assume there's an infinite variety of slings you can make/adjust for different ranges etc.

In ancient war, were slingers typically used as short-range direct-fire, or long-range 'lobbed' fire, or a combination etc.?

If short-range slinging was in use during war/combat, is it know if the slings made the same distinct whip-crack noise as the one in the video?

EDIT:

Just for more detail, this appears to roughly be the style of sling that Luis uses, based off an old comment he made on the slinging org forum.

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Why is there little to no historical reference, such as photos, of Mexico and Mexican soldiers during The Second World War?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Why is Diocletian's Roman Tetrarchy is important?

When you see a relatively condensed explanation of Roman history a lot of time between the establishment of the empire and the adoption of Christianity is ignored. There were plenty of civil and external wars and changes in politics and economy but they aren't considered that important. However, you always hear about Diocletian. And I fail to grasp why is he the most important person in 3 centuries. He made a grand reform but it didn't outlive him, didn't it? So what am I missing, why is he considered so important?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

Were any citizens of Allied nations (including the USA itself) killed in the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki? If so, what were the reactions of those countries' leaders?

If the USA didn't warn the cities in advance of the bombings, then almost certainly some non-Japanese people were caught in the blast, right? Were any of them from Allied countries? How did their leaders react to the USA's murder of their citizens?

1 Answers 2020-01-09

1576 / 7255

Back to start