Dissertations??

Any tips on how to research, and write, your dissertation topics

1 Answers 2022-08-09

Best way to memorize the contents of a history book?

I’m currently reading “The Crusades: The authoritative history of the war for the holy land” by Thomas Asbridge. What is the best way for me to retain the info in this book? I enjoy studying the high Middle Ages and wish to learn as much as possible without forgetting.

1 Answers 2022-08-09

Have any cultures preferred hairy women, or had different preferences than we do now?

I know the most recent history, the last century or so. I’m asking more about leg hair, arm hair, facial peach fuzz, etc than I am about pubic hair. Have any cultures throughout history actually prized or valued body hair on women, or has it generally been consistent in that less body hair is ideal?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

How successfully were East Germans/Soviets able to deal with young people who had spent their whole lives being indoctrinated with Nazi rhetoric?

There's a video I just saw posted on youtube about East Germans being sent to Africa to help train communist revolutionaries, and the whole video I was thinking about what it must have been like for these kids to have grown up with the supremacy of the white race going to Africa to train Africans to fight back against white colonizers. How exactly could these kids cope with spending the most formative years of their life being taught to be Nazis then whiplashing to being Communists?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Why did the size of Japanese armies decline from the 12th to 13th centuries?

In Jonathan Lopez-Vera's "History of the Samurai", the author describes the leading Japanese powers as being able to raise military forces of tens of thousands, and occasionally hundreds of thousands, during the Genpei Wars of the 12th century and the early conflicts of the 13th century. However, during the Mongol invasions in the latter half of the 13th century, the Japanese struggle to raise armies of more than a few thousand to repel their initial invasion attempt in 1274 and were assumed to once again be significantly outnumbered during the second invasion attempt in 1281. Why were the Japanese incapable of raising a significant forces to counter what must have been seen as an existential threat when they were capable of fielding much larger armies in domestic disputes a century earlier?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Why didn't Pompey move back to Rome while Caesar was securing Spain?

In the Civil War between Caesar and Pompey, Caesar made the choice to go to Spain to secure his western flank before moving on Pompey in Greece. Why after having a chance to assemble many legions did Pompey not move on Rome while Caesar was in Spain? Caesar determined that Pompey's army would be more easily defeated as it was an army without a leader, why did Pompey not make the same calculation? Particularly considering that he had the majority of the senate with him to help legitimize his action. #history #Rome #Caesar #Pompey #ancienthistory

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Irish bog bodies and nobility sacrifices in the bronze age?

Online I was reading about Irish history and saw in 2011 archaeologists found a bog body and it showed signs of physical injuries/execution.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cashel_Man

How do we know that the Cashel man was nobility? How were they able to execute the person that was supposed to be in charge? How do we know if he was truly royalty? What would life have been like for a royal person of this period?

I am interested in this subject and excited to learn more, thank you for your help.

PS: I am 17 years old and haven't studied history, I am curious to know what ireland would have been like in the bronze age.

1 Answers 2022-08-08

How did nuclear weapons designers improve the yield/weight ratio of thermonuclear warheads to fit them onto ICBMs?

I am currently reading "A Fiery Piece in a Cold War", which discusses the development of the U.S. ICBM program. In it, the author briefly discusses how Bernard Schriever, one of the key U.S.A.F. officials involved in the ICBM program, went to see John von Neumann at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton (in 1953) to discuss whether it was possible to fit a 0.5 - 1 MT yield warhead into a missile (which would have required a weight < 1 ton). The book notes that both von Neumann and Teller confirmed to Schriever that by 1960, such a warhead would be available. We now know that warheads meeting those specifications were indeed created.

What is known about how nuclear physicists managed to improve the yield to weight ratios of thermonuclear warheads to go from the CASTLE BRAVO SHRIMP device (which weighed > 10 tons) to a warhead weighing less than a ton and yet retaining megaton yields? Obviously, I understand quite a bit is not going to be known. But I was wondering what we do know.

And in case it's not obvious, I would love a u/restricteddata answer :)

1 Answers 2022-08-08

What Works provide an Overview of the Sino-Japanese War (1937) from a Military Policy Perspective?

Hello!

I'm looking to read up on the Sino-Japanese war particularly from a military policy perspective, if possible. A focus on how the nationalists and communists responded to the invasion and the policies, plans, procedures, training, etc. they instituted in order to counter it would be exactly what I'm looking for. If there's no work that covers both parties in one I would have a preference for the nationalist response. If the work also examined the Japanese perspective and their planning that certainly wouldn't be unwelcome either.

I'm not solely interested in the military side of things, so any work with significant political/social insights would again not be unwelcome, so long as it covers the evolving military response. I have a particular interest in the first year of the conflict and any defensive planning taken during that period, any Soviet-style industry transfers, as well as how lend-lease and other allied support impacted the war once Japan went to war with the Allies.

I know this is asking quite a lot for one book, so recommending multiple works is fine! Unfortunately my only fluent language is English, and I know that narrows it down, but thanks to all who might offer some suggestions!

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Why is Caucasian often used as an ethnic term for white people in the USA?

I am British and have never heard this term here but have heard it countless times in American media and pop culture. Personally it makes no sense to me as the Caucuses are barely European so to use their name seems illogical. I’m guessing it has some sort of historical reason for this and I was hoping someone here could shed some light on this.

Thanks in advance

1 Answers 2022-08-08

How commonly used were Anglo-Saxon runes during the Viking Age, if at all?

Furthermore, could a literate Norseman in England read Anglo-Saxon runes?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

What were the temperance movement/prohibitionists reacting to?

The histories I've read of the prohibition movement portray the people supporting it ridiculous for one reason or another. I've always wondered if they were in fact looking for a solution to a real problem (and decided on one that didn't work). How widespread was alcoholism in 19th century America and did it get any worse after the Civil War?

2 Answers 2022-08-08

Discussing getting a new car with my partner. The debate on full electric vs hybrid came up. The issue for most is public charging stations. How long did it take from the mass adoption of cars in the US for the gas station network to get setup?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Thirty-four years after scribbling E = mc2, Albert Einstein wrote to President Franklin Roosevelt to warn him the Nazis were turning his famous theory into a nuclear weapon. How did Einstein know this, and did Roosevelt actually read his letter?

How did word reach Einstein that his ideas were being weaponized by the Nazis? The scientific grapevine?

Also, did the president really read all his mail? Was there someone screening incoming letters for him? Was there a chance Einstein's letter might have been ignored or overlooked?

2 Answers 2022-08-08

Regarding the current discussions around colonial past and decolonization: How do you think we should deal with sources/remains of colonial past?

Hi everybody,

I recently got a job as librarian, managing a library owned by a historical association. We collect a pretty broad variety of mostly older books, which mainly stem from private collections that are given to the association by the collectors themselves or their relatives after their death.

So here´s the thing: I was looking through one of the many shelves of books that haven’t been catalogued yet and stumbled upon a very interesting old book. It is called “Der Freiheitskampf der Buren” (roughly translated: “The Boers fight for Freedom”) and was published around 1900-1903. It is written by a man called Justus Scheibert, who was an officer in the Prussian military and also worked as war correspondent. Roughly summarized, the book is about the “Second Anglo Boer War” (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Boer_War) and includes military tactics and describes how certain battles took place, etc. What sparked my interest, however, is the rather critical and cynical way in which it talks about the war and the British as the imperial force waging it.

Here is a small segment (translated by me) that I think shows pretty well what I mean by “critical and cynical”: “John Bull (I think the author means the national personification of Great Britain here (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Bull)) primarily is a merchantman and his biggest mistake as world statesman is that he is solely guided by his merchant-instinct. The milder system [designed to] turn blacks into “free labourers” is complete nonsense and is based on pure privateering. In order to get free slaves, you have to free people in all countries from their property by acquiring the herds of the blacks. From this follows with mild necessity that the black [man] – without the bolt action rifle needing to carry on its bloody work in a rather scandalous way – has to work for pay for the white [man], to not starve to death. And with this the true and peaceful civilization work (probably meant “work to civilize”) is actuated happily and as requested. Without talented privateers there is no colonization in grand scale. Africa is being civilized by big stock companies to which the British government benevolently has given the rights for privateering, negro-slaughtering, slavery and to equip troops. Therefore, Jamesons raid is being viewed as fabulous sport by the true sons of Albion to which England, standing high above the races, is entitled to.”

I posted about this book on r/books and received very interesting comments about it. One of the main points was that the books representation of the Boers as African natives is not accurate, due to their European descent. Therefore the war was not the somewhat “classical” imperial force vs. natives but more one imperial force against another. The book does however talk about the war as a struggle between the mighty British empire and the native Boers. And as you can see in the segment I quoted, it criticizes the British colonization efforts on a rather general level. Therefore, I think it is reasonable to view the book as source for colonial history, at least for the views about colonization at the time.

Now, to cut a rather lengthy post short: I recently got interested in the debates and controversies around colonial history and decolonization. One of the claims I find repeatedly is that remains of the colonial past should be put away or even destroyed: I read about some museums removing artifacts connected to colonial past from their exhibitions. I am totally aware that this little book is probably not controversial in any sense, but I still see the connection to those general claims, therefore my question(s): What is your take on all of this? How should we deal with remains from this part of our past (like this book)? Should they be put away or even be destroyed? And if not, how would you/how should society deal with them? And more specifically with regard to the book: Do you think its rather critical, cynical account of the war and colonization could add to the controversies?

2 Answers 2022-08-08

What events lead to Issac Newton being the first man to write down the laws of motion? Why were they not discovered earlier, based on their simplicity?

Newton's laws of mechanics fundamentally changed the world, yet they are relatively simple. The first and third laws seem very straightforward:

  1. An object will follow a set velocity until a force acts on it, in an inertial frame

  2. Every force has an equal and opposite force

I understand that the second law has a lot of calculus baked into it, but even then, the idea of how something accelerating depending on how heavy it is and how hard you push it is also pretty basic intuition. I also understand that air resistance might make figuring the first law hard, but there are thousands of years' worth of philosophers who never wrote down these relatively basic set of laws until Newton.

Were there any recent discoveries or precursors that led to Newton being the first to understand the laws of motion? Were these laws really impossible to understand without calculus, even in concept? Or did other philosophers know about them, but just didn't bother to write them down?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Book Review Request: Is "The Glory of the Crusades" by Steve Weidenkopf a good book on the topic?

Hi there dear Reddit historians!

I’d like to ask some reviews about the book “The Glory of the Crusades” by Steve Weidenkopf. This book has recently been translated into my native language and quite praised by some quarters as a revolutionary book for the studies of the crusades. It got me interested, and looking through the reviews in Amazon, at a first look it seems quite well-rated and highly praised by some reviewers, but upon reading them further I got the impression most positive reviewers seem to fall within a very narrow ideological framework that might make them biased.

I couldn’t find the author’s name mentioned in many academic works so it seems that he writes to an specific public, more as a sort of “pop author” than a proper academic writer. The few excerpts of this book that I have seem online seem to be quite mediocre.

As I’m not a professional historian, I’d like to defer to specialists before I invest my money on the purchase of the book.

Thank you for your time!

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Is there dairies, self biographies or books on the POV of the conquistadores in the Americas?

I'm looking for books where it's clear to see their intentions and goals, as well as fears and daily problems. I wonder if they actually believed they were cleansing the earth in god's name or simply making room for themselves. Thank you for any info.

1 Answers 2022-08-08

The word Mohammedan was once commonly used around the world. How did it fall out of use?

The term Mohammedan was once commonly used around the world. But it has now been entirely replaced by the word Muslim. And usage of the term today can be seen as offensive. How did this happen? Were there any Muslim organisations that specifically objected to its use or was it just an organic change?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Why didn’t Africans, Asians go “extinct” from diseases carried by Europeans?

We all know the plight of native Americans from infectious diseases carried by colonizers that they lacked immunity from. However most of the sub Sahara Africa and people in Japan, Korea, Indonesia, Malaysia also didn’t have much contact with Europeans. Was it because the land is still connected somehow and they already had immunity from many of the diseases?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Can someone help me decipher my grandfathers WW2 discharge paper?

https://imgur.com/2ToFrVr

Here is a picture of my grandfathers WW2 military discharge papers. My grandfather passed many years ago, but from what we understand we know was an aerial photographer during the war and he had to be in the nose of the plane.

What's very interesting to me is that it mentions in the discharge paper that he got 6 bronze stars. Is that correct? I was reading about bronze stars and it says bronze stars are only issued for ground combat against enemy forces, not aerial. So does this mean he was on the ground as well? We do have old pictures he took of Hitler's Eagles Nest, the European Theater of Operations were he was stationed, the 'garage' where planes were kept and a bombed out Herman Goerings Home.

I'd love to know if there is a way to find more info on his military experience, and learn WHY he got the medals he did.

Thank you in advance!

3 Answers 2022-08-08

Why were battles in the past always fought with batallions?

Why didn't they just split into small groups of people and go around shooting arrows here and there like in modern guerrilla war?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

Nazis defined race in the Nürnberger Gesetze or Nuremberg Laws. What other attempts have been made to codify race?

In your period of study, how was the concept of race approached, and to what degree were attempts made to legally codify it?

2 Answers 2022-08-08

What was the relationship between China and Taiwan during the Three Kingdoms Era?

1 Answers 2022-08-08

What was Rhodesia?

I keep on hearing about Rhodesia in things like memes

What was it exactly

1 Answers 2022-08-08

163 / 7255

Back to start