In Bill Wurtz's History of Japan, he says Taika Reforms were "making the government govern more and making the government more like China's government, which is a government that governs more". Could anyone elaborate on these?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Is Richard Carrier's post "Yes, the Dark Ages really were a thing" propaganda or does it have any basis of reality?

https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15567

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Who (personally) was responsible for deciding to fire bomb Dresden, and did they experience any repercussions for making that decision?

From everything I can find, everyone who could distance themselves from the decision making process that culminated in the burning of Dresden did so when the news reported the resulting carnage and death toll estimates. This doesn't surprise me given Dresden's relative lack of military targets, making it all the more obvious that the attack was directed primarily towards civilians. So who was it that actually made the decision to commence the attack? Did any Americans take part in the mission, or was it solely RAF bombers/pilots? Who all knew about, and eventually capitulated to, the plan? Were there any repercussions (court-marshaling, lost rank, etc)?

My grandfather was a WWII B-17 bomber pilot who was shot down on his 13th mission. While he didn't take part in the actual mission to bomb Dresden, he was sick about the fact that the Allied forces would ever do something like that. I'm wondering how something like that ever even happened given that Allied forces were vehemently opposed to indiscriminate killing of civilians, and were at least somewhat clearly winning the war by that point as well.

1 Answers 2019-11-22

I have a picture of my great-grandfather in uniforms around the year of 1910 to 1920 tho I want to be sure precisely what country did he serve during what I presume is WWI.

My great-grandfather seems to have high dark boots, a belt around his bellybutton line and I can only see 4 buttons on his uniform but I assume there's a 5th one behind his hand. There are two pockets on the chest with one button for each pocket and in the middle, there's a bulge. And two kind-of baggy pockets below the belt. Now I can't really see what kind of hat he is wearing i know it's not that tall in height and the thing that blocks the sun is kind of long. And he most likely served in the calvary. If you have any idea what country it's from I'd be really grateful!

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Before VHS, were people completely unaware of previous decades' movies?

E.G, Casablanca came out in 1942. Would it have been forgotten in 1952 or 1962? Or if somebody thought about it, would there be basically no way they could see it? Was there no concept of movies being classics in the same way as books?

2 Answers 2019-11-22

In Weird Al's song 'Amish Paradise', he states, "tonight we're gonna party like it's 1699." How would the Amish (or similar Anabaptist groups) have partied in 1699?

(I did do a search and saw that someone asked a similar question a few years ago, but the answer only touched on music and wasn't hugely specific, so was hoping for a more in-depth one)

2 Answers 2019-11-22

Were African-Americans ever given reparations for slavery?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Were there any attempts at a revival of ancient Egyptian culture/religion in Egypt's history?

I mean after the ban on pagan religions imposed by Christians in the Roman Empire

1 Answers 2019-11-22

In Europe, widespread usage of gunpowder in weapons meant that traditional armor was progressively abandoned. Why didn't the same happen in Japan, even though they had access to them since the XVIth century?

EDIT: Upon further thought, I realized that the Edo period began only a few decades after matchlocks were introduced to Japan. Since the country was unified and isolated, armor became mostly ceremonial and was used to display wealth and nobility rather than for actual usage in combat, meaning that there was no real need to develop protective gear against bullets.

Was that the case, or is my guess wrong?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

How effective was the Lend-Lease agreement in regards to helping the Soviet Union pushing the Germans back in the Eastern Front? Are there any specific academic articles that have analyzed whether or not the Soviet Union could have achieved the same war goals without this material assistance?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Terms like the Dark Ages are now considered outdated. What’s the general ‘catch all’ term for that period now? Or have the periods been thoroughly broken up?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

How did people do fonts before computers?

I know that this question is probably really dumb, but i’ve always wondered how people painted fonts on store windows before they had computers or decals. Did they have a template or a guide to look at while painting?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Why didn't Japan build passenger airliners?

Japan has a highly developed industry, including a very successful car industry. Japan has a long history of building aircraft, they produce their own military jets, they build their own orbital rockets and satellites. Clearly they country is technologically capable.

And yet it appears that post-WW2 Japan has only build two indigenous airliners, NAMC YS-11 in the sixties, and then MRJ now (and MRJ is still being developed).

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Suggested reading for a grade 9 student looking for a general history of World War 1

I'm teaching an advanced grade 7 student who wants to learn about World War 1. She can comfortably read at a grade 9 level and I would like to give her something informative but challenging to read.

Any suggestions??

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Did any western governments contemplate buying Soviet/Eastern Bloc military equipment?

As in, among NATO or NATO-aligned nations? Finland of course has had Soviet/Russian military equipment for ages and Israel at one point took whatever they could get their hands on but those are special cases.

I am meaning countries like France, the UK, the other Nordic countries, Netherlands, Australia, New Zealand, etc. Did they ever contemplate things like, for example, the Mi 26 heavy lift helicopter as an alternative to the Chinook or Sea King? Or did any consider MiG/Sukhoi fighter jets as opposed to Dassault/Boeing/Lockheed/BAE(its forebears)? Or the T72 tank? Or the NSV machine gun? Anything the Soviets/Yugoslavs had that had a western equivalent?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

When was the idea of a single Christian "Bible" book comprising of smaller chapters developed, as opposed to a collection of independent smaller books?

From what I know, the first churches (that ultimately ended up assimilating into the Catholic and Orthodox churches) sorted through all the early writings to establish canonical works. During that time, did they read each separate work as discrete books or were they already compiled together?

If I were a Christian in Ancient Rome training to be a priest in the 4th Century AD, would I be reading the gospel of Mark in its own separate book or would I be more likely to find it in a compilation along with other canonical works? When was the practice of compiling ALL canonical texts into a single Bible developed? When did it become the norm?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

Sengoku military book recommendations.

My grandfather is a retired Lt. Colonel and he is very into militarism and various world leaders.

I'm well versed in the late sengoku era and military detailings of it. But that's over many sessions with a book in hand.

Does anyone know a single book that would be able to detail a good amount of strategy and undergoing of a daily life in the period.

I'm most specifically looking for a book on Nobunaga and Ieyasu.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2019-11-22

What books would you recommend for gaining framework of thinking for historians?

2 Answers 2019-11-22

What caused the Mongols to invade most of the Old World?

Besides the fact that they were great horsemen and bowmen. What gave them the desire to conquer the world? Was it merely Genghis Khan's personal aspirations? Or was it to finally be able to rule over China? Any answers would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2019-11-22

How come US didn't annex Canada?

I mean, 300ml vs 30ml, such economic and military power difference of these countries that share mutual border...And yet, somehow, Canada is bigger...wtf? How did Canada manage to keep such landmass (the second largest country in the world after Russia) while being really weak militarily? I don't understand. How come US didn't attack and defeat Canada to take the land and resources?

​

P.S. - genuinely curious, I love Canada as a country, was just wondering about this question, no ill will intended.

1 Answers 2019-11-22

What direct evidence was there that tied Nixon to Watergate at the time of his resignation?

My understanding of the Watergate scandal is that the only thing that directly tied Nixon was the "smoking gun" tape. And from what I understand the tape only revealed Nixon talking about controlling the FBI to stop the Watergate investigation. Was that really the biggest piece of evidence tying it all together?

I hope this isn't too political for this subreddit. Obviously, I'm asking this because of the current impeachment defenses of the President often include that there isn't enough "direct" evidence.

1 Answers 2019-11-22

I'm a young Russian man in USSR just graduated from an engineering university and I'm in love with the capitalist way of living. How hard it is for me to leave USSR and get a job in a western country like the US or the UK with a intermediate English level?

So, how hard was leaving USSR without being part of the party or being in a mission or something like that? Even if a soviet person was allowed to apply for a leaving permit, what was the chances of them getting one?

1 Answers 2019-11-22

What were George Washington's political stances?

Even as a Brit I have to be impressed by George Washington, with his tactical brilliance and strong moral standing. But he existed in a time before left and right wing were even coined as terms. By contemporary or modern standards, where on the spectrums of politi al ideology did/does/would he stand?

2 Answers 2019-11-22

Given that Pre-Islamic Arabia was a very women-friendly and sexually "liberal" society, what is the source of Islam's extremely puritanical culture?

In Robert G. Holyland's Arabia and the Arabs, various historical sources are mentioned that tell us pre-Islamic Arabian culture was one in which women could marry multiple men, advertise for mercenary husbands when they wanted children, had the right to dismiss their husbands when they wanted, enjoyed significant financial independence, with Arab tribes sometimes having matrilinear lineages, female gods, and queens.

The Qur'an partially mentions some of this (like the female gods, decrying them) and urges Muslim women not to emulate the women of the time of ignorance in their bedizenment, with the Tafsirs pointing out to pre-Islamic Arabian women dressing in a skimpy manner and without modesty. How come that Islam, which developed against this backdrop, came to be such a puritanical religion in which any sexual or romantic affection before marriage is heavily frowned upon, and in which women have to cover themselves partially or fully almost all the time?

4 Answers 2019-11-22

Friday Free-for-All | November 22, 2019

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

10 Answers 2019-11-22

⯇ 1651 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start