What was the actual reason the United States joined the Vietnam War? Would America benefit economically by establishing a pro-western state in Vietnam?

The Cold War in my understanding was more of a geopolitical and economical war, and less to do with ideology. All of American efforts of containment were to protect open markets in Europe and maintain laissez-faire policies in Europe, which would economically benefit America. Communism would prevent open markets and laussez-faire policies, which is why the Marshall plan and Trumine Doctrine was implemeted.

But America joining the Vietnam War makes no sense to me. How could it benefit America?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

what was the motivation and inspiration behind Mary Lyon’s activism for women education in the 1800s?

title asks it all i’m trying to see if there are journal or diary records from her. is there a good resource for this?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Sunday in the Eastern Block

Was sunday a thing in the USSR and his allies? Was it the day where you could "relax"?. Sorry if this question is stupid

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Who was "Hitler" before Hitler?

Who was popularly percieved as the "embodiment of evil" before WWII?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Who were the first serfs? Were they former slaves from the romans?

How did feudalism arise from the fall of the Roman Empire?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

To what extent did Russia's 'Vodka Tax' account for government revenues throughout history and was it as influential/important as often stated?

I've come across several more popular history websites and other sources discussing the history and influence of alcohol in Russian history.

Many of them bring up 'vodka taxes' which were abandoned and reinstituted over several centuries all the way up until the 1970s at latest.

The revenues from these taxes are often cited as making up anywhere from 30% to 45% of the governments revenue at various points. Obviously that's a huge number.

Some popular sources (The Dictators Handbook amongst others) Cite Czar Nicholas's 'Vodka Ban' during the first World War as being disastrous to the war effort and the nation's finances, effectively eliminating what was allegedly 30% of the state's revenue at the time. Some claim that this helped precipitate the success of the revolution due to the inability to effectively pay the army (causing them to join the people and/or not stop them).

Later, the re-introduction of legal vodka and its tax is sometimes credited as being a critical aspect in the financing of the state's modernization program.

#To what extend did these 'Vodka Taxes' really account for state revenue and were they really as influential on Russian history as sometimes cited?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Russian anti-tank rifle effectiveness.

From what i was able to find the PTRD-41 was able to penetrate the sides of early war german tanks like panzer 3s and 4s.

But could it harm a stug? Specifically the stuG lll ausf. G.

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | November 07, 2019

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

9 Answers 2019-11-07

AMA: Tank Archives and Designing the T-34

Hi, r/AskHistorians. My name is Peter Samsonov, and my area of research is primarily in armoured warfare in World War II. You may have seen me answer some questions in this subreddit in the last few years. I also maintain the Tank Archives blog and regularly write for a number of other publications. I don't only write about Soviet tanks! Some of my most popular and interesting articles have been about German and Commonwealth armour.

Recently, I wrote my first book, "Designing the T-34: Genesis of the Revolutionary Soviet Tank", which is available for either purchase or preorder, depending on your region. The book briefly covers the development of Soviet armour from 1919 to 1936, discusses how the Spanish Civil War impacted the direction of Soviet tank design, and then goes into detail on the development and production of the T-34 and its precursors.

Edit 18:03 EST: thank you everyone for your wonderful questions! I am off for the night, I will try to answer the remainder in the morning.

Edit 2 16:21 EST: all the leftovers finally dealt with. Thank you all again, lots of wonderful questions. If you did not feel that you got a full answer, you are always welcome to post a front page question for me and other historians to explore.

32 Answers 2019-11-07

Did any of the Indigenous Nations of the Americas have a written language?

If so are there any documents that have been translated into other languages?

2 Answers 2019-11-07

Why did Vikings begin to adopt Christianity?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Did the opening of Japan change the Japanese diet and cuisine? Was there a "Perryan exchange" from increased contact with western trade?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Why did people wash clothing in rivers where people died?

Hi! i saw a documentary a few years back, it was about how peoples clothes would be cleaner when washed in rivers... somehow related to death? i dont remember how exactly it had to do with death but it was quite morbid. Maybe it had something to do with ashes or the holocaust, i honestly cant tell/am probably mixing up things.

Would anyone know of something like this? sorry for the ridiculously unprecise question..

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Why did Australia’s Murray Darling River system never grow major cities like USAs river systems did?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Were there British plans during WW1 to naval invade Germany and if they existed, why weren't they carried out? Furthermore, how successful would such an operation have been, considering the disaster of Galipoli?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

How available was cinema to a regular soviet citizen in the Stalin Era?

We know that from the 30s, soviet film started taking a more active role in soviet culture. Circus is cited as being massively popular, especially with regards to how well known Wide is my Motherland became as a song. Solzhenitsyn's One Day makes a reference to an Eisenstein film.

After the war, more blatant propaganda films like the Fall of Berlin were produced. All in all, soviet film was rather well funded from the 30s onwards, despite the country only being widely electrified in the very late 20s.

So how available was film and cinema to the soviet population? Was there a notable division between the presence of film in rural and urban popular culture (I assume yes)? Did any cinemagoer culture develop?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Did the Great Wall of China actually prevent invasions and was it effective?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Before World War II, who did Americans compare people to in situations where "x is as bad as Hitler" would be used today?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

How common were proxy wars before the Cold War?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Did any loyalists fight, aid, or plot against their own countrymen in the American Revolution?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

How did the Canada Government respond to African Americans illegally immigrating looking to escape the horrors of slavery?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

How did insurance work in England during The Blitz; or other European countries during WW2 ?

Could someone even get home insurance in conflict areas or was there a public fund available to rehouse people?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

What happened to the Catholic church property after the reformation

When a priest decided to become protestant what happened to the actual church building? Did he stay with it? Did he abandon it? Same with any land the local church might have held. When a bishop went rogue? What happened to the church estates.

Were there any legal challenges about the ownership of church property at the time or even later when the dust settled?

How did we come to have some Catholic and some protestants churches today? Did the catholic church keep or reacquire some of their old churches or went and build new.

Are there any issues that pertain even to this day?

1 Answers 2019-11-07

Were Native Americans aware that European diseases were killing them off?

I've read that as many as 90% of Native Americans were killed off by Old World diseases. I know that the science behind infectious diseases wasn't known at the time. But if I saw my tribe being decimated by a mysterious illness shortly the arrival of strange foreigners, it wouldn't take me long to put two and two together. I would probably assume they were harbingers of a divine plague or were poisoning us somehow. Did any tribe try to avoid settlers because of fear of diseases?

3 Answers 2019-11-07

The Spirit of Spartans

Hello, I’m doing a project in a history class for college, and I’ve chosen to do something pertaining to Sparta’s military culture. I originally wanted to compare the Spirit of Sparta, as derived from Leonidas and the 300, with that of the Carolean Army in the Swedish Empire. I’m not asking for people to do my assignment, however I am asking if anyone knows of any sources that could help me complete this project, or direct me to a different culture also impacted by Sparta.

In essence, I need sources to prove Sparta’s influence as an underdog, and the “death and glory” spirit, on other cultures.

1 Answers 2019-11-07

⯇ 1677 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start