Is it valid to separate the Medieval Era from the Classical Era outside of Europe?

I know my question is a little vague and is based on Eurocentric/Marxist education I got. In its context, it makes sense to talk about vague periods of time. Prehistoric times with no complex economic relationships, Slavery times in classical era, Feudal relationships in Medieval times, Capitalism afterward. It makes sense when we talk about Europe: before certain time most of it was either ruled by the economies relying on slavery; later those empires crumbled and for most of the Medieval era Europe and the Middle East condemned slavery. While it was still practice it was no longer a basis for the economy.

What am I missing is why world history in general still is divided into same periods. The medieval era is still used even if people talk about India or China or even American people even if another term is used, like the Post-Classical era. I understand why the Modern era is common for everybody; it's the time of globalization and everyone is touched by this process. But what is the difference between the Classical era and the Medieval era for most of the world?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

Did Alexander Hamilton speak or write in danish?

Alexander Hamilton lived on the danish colony of st. Croix between 1765 and 1772 (age 8-15), so could he speak danish or write in it? I've tried searching on the internet, but I didn't find anyone addressing this exact question, so I hope this helps. Thank you in advance

1 Answers 2019-09-20

So the House of Vasa fought on two different sides (Poland/Sweden) during the 30 Years War but there doesn't seem to be much on this internal conflict on the internet. Does anyone have any insight (or even sources) into this interesting family dynamic?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

Tagelharpa, the Viking Lyre. Did Vikings really played this instrument? How old it can be?

I stumbled upon this video and was wondering whether tagelharpa really was used by the "vikings".

I found some references on Wiki, but nothing solid. It is hinted in Eddas (the Old Norse "bible"), as there is a harp mentioned. We don't know if it was bowed or not, though.

Tagelharpa was used by Einar Selvik (Wardruna) in the Vikings TV show, but he himself never really referred to the instrument as the "viking one".

Personally I like the way how it sounds even if it was not 100% authentic, but still, it would be awesome to know how ancient it really is.

What are your thoughts on that?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

What are some good, reasonably-lengthed books about the rise of fascism during the interwar period?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

Did people in the ancient world encounter leftover ice age tribes/creatures that went extinct before 0AD?

Did the ancient world, (Like ancient greek, maybe when the old Egyptian kingdoms) have to deal with leftover Ice age and stone-age stuff? Like where their tribes of the absolute savage stone age "cavemen" coming upon "civilized" ancient greek cities, or some now extinct giant ice age animals that were still roaming the old forests when Rome was still rising, etc.

Like a guy carving stone for the first pyramids just sees some near-extinct ancient creature that we wouldn't know of because it went extinct in 3000bc, so on.

1 Answers 2019-09-20

The title of Duke is relatively new in England, having been created by Edward III. How would English Dukes and their Continental counterparts viewed each-other? Would a Duke of Norfolk have been considered an equal in rank to a Duke of Saxony or a Duke of Burgundy, for example?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

How did Tobacco come to Japan in the 19th century?

In the 53 stations of Tokaido Fukuroi depicts men smoking and lighting pipes, where would the tobacco they are smoking come from? How did Tobacco Enter Japanese society?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

How did generals give orders to their soldiers on the battlefield in the middle ages and antiquity?

They obviously didn't have radios or telegrams, so what did they use?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

Why didn’t the allies just push through the Alps from Italy and not land in France right away? The landing zones were uncontested. Materials and armor could move north uncontested. Then they could capture France without a frontal assault against the Atlantic wall.

1 Answers 2019-09-20

Why did American Revolutionaries dress like Native Americans?

This is just something I wondered about after reading up on the Boston Tea Party and the third boycott (1774). Aside from concealment of identity, I don't understand the message that would convey.

1 Answers 2019-09-20

History majors of r/AskHistorians, what would you say to someone who would like to pursue a degree in history?

History has always been the subject that I had the most passion for learning and naturally was my best subject throughout middle and high school. Always in honors history and going above the requirements for the class since i had a natural love for the subject. I completed a semester of college as a film major but found it slow and reteaching much of what I already knew (I've worked in live media and broadcasting for 4 years).

I'm in the process of going back to college after some time off due to a family matter. With so many degrees heavy on math (my worst subject) and finding many other fields boring or dull (If I have an interest in something I can do well since a passion forms), I've come to the conclusion that I would be a good history major.

My sweet mother is saying otherwise. Questioning my sanity for pursuing a degree that to her, will land me at a desk in a high school teaching fortnite playing vapers. I'm applying for a Marine Corp ROTC scholarship which would allow me to major in anything I want and the Corp would pay for my education. And while I have never lived a day in that lifestyle I could see myself doing 20 years and retiring.

​

Give me the most blunt, honest, humorous, advice you can muster up.

2 Answers 2019-09-20

When did the East Indies stop being so important to trade?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-09-20

By 1990 Japan's GDP surpassed the USSR's - Did the USSR React with the Same Fear as the USA to Japan's Huge Economic Growth in the 70s and 80s?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

Did the polish home army remain active in soviet occupied territory following the German retreat?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

Do we have Any idea what was happening in the Americas during say, the Roman Empire

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-09-20

What do we know about Pre-Colombian forestry?

In places like the UK we can trace back forests and woodlands that have been managed for hundreds of years. We also know quite a bit about logging, lumber trade, and management techniques in Europe throughout history.

I understand controlled burns were common and forests were described as “park like” in America at time of European arrival. What else do we know about Pre-Colombian forestry/logging?

1 Answers 2019-09-20

During World War II, did sailors in the Royal Navy carry guns/other weapons about their person?

I am writing a screenplay, and this will definitely alter the course of the story depending on the answer. Were sailors in World War 2 permitted to carry guns, particularly when on land? If so, what were they? If not, why not?

1 Answers 2019-09-19

Why was the Revolutionary War over after the battle of Yorktown? I never understood why the rest of the British forces didn't keep fighting, especially if they still had significant forces based in New York City, and if Cornwallis wasn't even the commander of British forces in the states.

3 Answers 2019-09-19

Why was opium addiction such a problem Nineteenth Century for China but not elsewhere? Was China especially addicted or especially strict about it or was it manufactured outrage?

2 Answers 2019-09-19

US Economy 1873 to 1897

I read an article earlier today about Hoover's response to the 1929 crash that offhandedly mentioned a recession that began in 1873 and, according to some economists, didn't really end until 1897. Is there much credence to this idea and are there any other significant examples of economies post 1800 that were in states of recession for upwards of 20 years without completely collapsing?

1 Answers 2019-09-19

Was the German “werewolf” plan ever seriously considered? And where there German partisans in occupied Germany?

1 Answers 2019-09-19

Academic Historians - WWI, WWII

I've been looking at the faculty profile pages of the history departments of several universities, and it seems like almost no one describes their work as centering around WWI or WWII. There are plenty who talk about questions arising out of the Civil War and Vietnam, but anyone who lists WWII as a primary area of interest is usually an emeritus professor. To me, it almost comes across like it's 'out of fashion' to study WWII in particular. Any thoughts?

1 Answers 2019-09-19

How can I check if I am a descendant of the toyotomi clan?

First reddit post so forgive me if im not doing it right, i think i may be a descendant to the toyotomi clan. My grandmother recently this year passed away, and on her urn is her family crest, which after a google search on what a family crest even was, i noticed it matched the toyotomi clans emblem. She lost contact with her family after marrying a korean man but stayed in tokyo untill she came to live with my dad and his older brother in new york when he was a teenager. I never have met anyone from her side of the family but it could be that they are deacendants. Her maiden last name was tomiko which is not the same as toyotomi but maybe it was changed somewhere along the line. Are family crests special that not anyone can use any crest they want? How can i varify this other than inquiring of my relatives? If you guys need additional clarification or further questions im open to discussion and would genuinly like to know how i can look into this. I also do not know how to add a picture of the urn to this thread lol

1 Answers 2019-09-19

How much was the expansion of Catholicism to blame for the fall of the Roman Empire?

So, in high school I was taught that one of the factors that led to the fall of Rome was Catholic Missionaries going out and telling all these people of the magic of Rome paved in gold etc. and that led to a lot of attacks on Rome. How true is that?

1 Answers 2019-09-19

⯇ 1754 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start