How did the people who fought in the ww1 and ww2 knew the war was over?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Why did King Kavad I stop his support for Mazdak and the Mazdakites?

His reign seemed to be successful with the common people because of the Mazdakites and their policy.

He punished the nobility for overthrowing him and plotting against him, which they did because of the mazdakites and their "communistic" belief, so it seems like he really believed Mazdak's teachings.. or was it all just for show? I don't understand. Wikipedia just says

"he no longer needed them, so he buried them alive"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kavad_I#Persecution_of_Mazdak_and_his_followers

1 Answers 2019-09-08

What is/was the great controversy about 'Potlatch' in the native communities of the American Northwest?

I came across mention in passing that implied there was a lot of debate and controversy about 'Potlatch', but it didn't expand on this, and Wikipedia doesn't really say too much about that, exactly, either.

1 Answers 2019-09-08

How were Roman ruins treated and what were views towards them in the Medieval Period? Were attempts made to preserve or repurpose them?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

How common was homosexuality in scandinavia between the 9th and 11th centuries?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-09-08

What was the role of the French Navy in World War I?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

What languages where spoken before the Arab expansion?

Iranians spoke Persian and managed to keep their language after the Arab conquest, but Egypt couldn't keep Coptic expect for some small Christian communities. What other languages where spoken where Arabic is now spoken? What was spoken in Irak, Syria, Lebanon...etc?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

My Grandma is a holocaust survivor - I have questions

My grandma is a holocaust survivor however she remembers very little/was very young during her time both in the Warsaw Ghettos and Auschwitz (she was born in 1938 in Warsaw). Only recently has she even been willing to talk about it due to the considerable trauma that it causes.

I know a considerable amount about what life was like inside Auschwitz however I have many questions (both general and specific to my grandma) that I would like to ask to see if people can shed light on exactly what her personal experience would have been like.

  1. How/why as a young child (4-6 ish years old) would she not have been immediately killed on arrival?
  2. One of her most vivid memories was sitting on the edge of a big vat they used for a toilet with her being terrified of falling in - I've never heard of any other accounts of something like this at Auschwitz, were these ever present or was it potentially a memory error?
  3. Were all prisoners (during the liberation of Auschwitz) sent on long death marches? Again I struggle to understand quite how she would have lived during one at her age
  4. She (as far as I'm aware) does not have a tattoo of an Auschwitz number - what is likely the reason as to why?

I have other questions/would love to discuss it with someone in more detail but I figured I would start with some small questions.

If people are interested in her story I can potentially explain (although it is fairly vague and patchy)

5 Answers 2019-09-08

How did the modern system of tax evasion come about?

How much more difficult would it be for a banker in Britain in say 1850 or 1950 to stow away money in Switzerland compared to today?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Why is official time so far off from solar time in Spain, Argentina & Chile?

In these notoriously late-dining countries the sun also rises late, so morning and evening activities happen at about the same solar time as in other places, resulting in late mornings, late lunches, and late nights in terms of 'official' time.

I vaguely remember reading there was a historical reason for this in Spain, and that the custom was imported to the colonies, but have not been able to recover the source where I read this.

1 Answers 2019-09-08

After the demonstration of the power of the Ironclads in the American Civil War, what was the reaction of the European powers to this new type of ship and how were ironclads implemented in Europe?

I find I quite interesting that wooden ships were pretty much phased out completely in the world stage by the 1870s and 80s.

1 Answers 2019-09-08

So the Roman Coliseum has existed for milennia... Why hasn't anyone after them done anything with it?

From ~500 AD to today, why hasn't anyone occupying Rome actually rebuilt or used it?

Has it been unused since?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Why did Germany not try to get turkey involved during WW2?

Why did they not try to bring them into the fold through promises of land or something. It would have been a very strategic ay giving Germany access into the oil feilds of the Soviets and into the Ally controlled middle East where also more oil could be found.

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Why did Hitler’s Germany not deploy chemical weapons during WWII?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Are there any English translations of "Boris I, Rei d'Andorra" by Antoni Morelli Mora?

It was published in 1984 in Spanish, and tells the history of the self-proclaimed King of Andorra, Boris Skossyreff. I was wondering if anyone knew of an English copy or pdf that might be floating around somewhere.

1 Answers 2019-09-08

How did South Vietnam feel about the anti-war movement in the US?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

How did the American Revolution effect Great Britain's treatment of its other colonial holdings?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Are the Muslim armies considered to be more technologically, strategically, and militarily more advanced than the Crusader armies in the first and second crusades?

I’d add the third crusade to the question too.

This is the impression I’ve had for quite some years now. However, reading about incidents like the siege of Acre, for example, the crusaders seemed not any inferior to Saladin’s forces.

What were the differences between the two sides, in terms of military technology and strategy? Which one could be considered superior?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Did an Ionian Crusade happen?

Hello!

I'm reading a book called The Latin Hegemonies of Medieval Europe by Constantine Cyprios, talking about all the Latin states established after 1204. In the chapter about the County of Cephalonia, the author states that Matteo Orsini, the count, came to be at odds with his suzerain, the king of Sicily. The author claims that in order for this to be solved, Orsini turned to the Pope who solved the issue in Orsini's favour. Afterwards, the author states that to please the Pope, Orsini was made to organise a crusade to Palestine called the Ionian Crusade. I have searched the internet for this and found nothing. Can anybody give me any sources? Thanks a lot!

1 Answers 2019-09-08

What would a Temple to Aphrodite Urania look like in the 5th century BCE city of Elis?

I'm trying to recreate Elis City, but I'm having trouble with certain temples about which there is very little information, especially for the time period concerned, 510 BCE till beginning of the Persian war.

I am assuming that there would be a statue of Aphrodite herself, a marble one perhaps, since Praxiteles and Scopas was born much later. Beyond that I'm not sure what it could possibly look like. It seems the city utilizes Doric order columns in some stoas, so it's possibly a doric temple?

Any help would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2019-09-08

In HBOs Chernobyl, we see people handling radioactive material in a very careless fashion, and coming into contact with people who were affected by the fallout, and just not taking proper precautions.

Was this a true depiction of how people went about after the disaster. I understand information was suppressed during the soviet era and the people were dependent, for the most part, on what the state told them. But were they this genuinely ignorant of the potential deadly hazards they were exposed to? I did some search on this sub and I couldn’t find any topics regarding this issue.

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Why the did (and still does) the KKK dress in pointy, white robes?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

During ww2

During ww2 I know that Africa had been involved in the war but did the middle east like Iran or Afghanistan take part of the war or were involved in any way like battles or aid or something like that?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

When we come across anecdotes or coincidences that happened pre-1500s, especially ones that seem like they've been exaggerated, how do we know it actually happened to the person in question, or that it happened at all, and hasn't been attributed to them later?

I'm thinking specifically about anecdotes like this. http://www.avani-mehta.com/2008/08/08/how-fart-can-make-you-grow-spiritually-su-dongpos-story/ Events like these, which don't shape the way a society functions by themselves, but are light-hearted situations that happened in a person's life that might explain some of the decisions the person makes later. They often sound like somebody made them up, or at least changed some of the details to make for a better anecdote, the same way that someone writing a biography or autobiography about a famous person today might change some of the details of an event in their life to make the book itself more streamlined/entertaining/etc. We know that a man named Su Shi/Su Dongpo existed in 11th century China, but how do we know that this event actually happened to this man?

I'm reminded of how people sometimes attribute quotes or events to famous people from history, like Albert Einstein, Barack Obama, William Shakespeare, and so on. These people definitely existed, but there are many anecdotes that people attribute to them (eg. "That boy grew up to be Albert Einstein"). Without the help of detailed records of a person's life, like we have now, how do we separate anecdotes like these from the facts of a person's life? How do we know which anecdotes really are facts?

1 Answers 2019-09-08

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | September 02, 2019–September 08, 2019

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2019-09-08

⯇ 1774 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start