What are some good sources covering ethnic clothing in the northern German states?

I mean, north of Baden-Württemberg, Bayern, Rhineland-Pfalz, and Saarland. Special emphasis on areas that are part of the old Saxon heartland, and the maritime cultures. I am interested in actual period clothing from the last 200-400 years, not modern uniforms for things like dance groups, parades, festivals, et cetera.

1 Answers 2019-08-07

What Is The Origin Of The Rolled R?

Apparently, nobody has ever asked this question on the Internet, so lt pleases me to be the first. How did the trilled R come about? It's in every language in one form or another, yet lt's unlike any other phoneme.

1 Answers 2019-08-07

Why did the Allies declare war on the Germans after they invaded Poland, but didn't do anything when the Soviets invaded weeks later?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-08-07

Is this depiction of how Gracchus paid Batiatus plausible, or is this a movie goof?

This is an admittedly very petty film detail that has bugged me for some time, because I'm just very curious about it.

Late in Stanley Kubrick's Spartacus (1960), in this scene (sorry for potato sound quality) the politician Tiberius Gracchus (played here by Charles Laughton) pays the former gladiator school owner Batiatus (played here by Peter Ustinov) "two million sesterces [sic]". Seen at one minute into the clip, the payment is in two stuffed sacks, each about the size of a large loaf of bread, which the aging Gracchus is able to hold out at arm's length, and Batiatus is able to sling over one shoulder, with a combined weight of what looks like maybe 5 kg or so.

My research into Roman coinage of the time -- approximately 71 BCE -- suggests this is implausible. But I don't trust my research at all, because I can only admit to a great deal of confusion about which Roman coins were around when.

Here's what I believe I've gleaned so far:

- The sestertius that's referred to several times in the film was, at the time, a small silver coin that weighed a little over a gram. So one million of them would weigh over a tonne. But most of the time, they weren't referring to the actual coin, just it's value, as the sestertius was the common unit of accounting.

- Most large transactions were made with the more valuable denarius, which was four times the value of the sestertius. This was probably around 4-4.5g at this time. Which would not make any meaningful difference in the weight of the sacks.

- A much more valuable coin was the gold aureus, valued at 25 denarii or 100 sestertii. It weighed about 8 g. But Gracchus would still need 20,000 of them (unless my math is off), totalling some 160 kg. And, I'm not sure if that coin was around that early.

I've spent a good piece of time trying to research this myself, and been forced to throw in the towel. I put the question to /r/numismatics but never got a reply. (I suspect they don't really know much about coins of this period. Even most collectors of Roman coins, I think, deal mostly only with later ones of the mature imperial period.) So now I'm here.

Can anyone suggest how this payment could have been made this way at this time? Or did Kubrick just get it wrong?

2 Answers 2019-08-07

A Question Regarding Historical Hydraulic Mining Texts and Possible Modern Hydraulic Methods

Hey there!

So this is a question I've been trying to research, and am kind of having a hard time finding. I am trying to build a diorama of a "modern," small scale hydraulic mine that would rely on renewable energy such as water turbines, and not use industrial wash plants, combustible engines, or similar equipment. I want to know if there are any texts about historic hydraulic mining that serve as a guide for constructing all necessary structures, (i.e. impoundment dams, flumes, penstocks, and sluice boxes) as well as providing necessary information on mathematical equations for constructing such structures depending on the amount of water and material that is intended to be processed. Basically, what texts would be great references in constructing an accurate diorama? Thank you!!!

2 Answers 2019-08-07

It is commonly cited that in the US military a large percent of the personnel are in non-combat logistics and support roles. In ancient and medieval armies how many of the soldiers would be in logistics and support roles as opposed to combat roles.d

3 Answers 2019-08-07

When was alcohol discovered? Not beer or wine or spirits, but as the substance shared by those drinks which causes inebriation?

At what point did someone realize they had a common element, or did people always think they did? How was alcohol itself first isolated?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

What where the primary reasons the Union soldiers fought for in the American Civil War?

When I was young in my 7th grade history class I learned that the north fought for the freeing of slaves while the south fought for states rights. I learned rather quickly that the south was fighting for the ability to own human beings and it had very little to do with states rights. Yet, I doubt that the Union soldiers would gather on mass in the most bloody war in American history to stick out their neck for what was often a class that was seen equal to cattle. Is it known what was the real reason most fought for the Union army?
I have no background in any of this. If I am totally off the mark please correct me. Thank you.

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Why are the armies in the medieval times so small?

Romans and many other countries managed to put together tens of thousands of soldiers just to make average sized armies. When facing Hannibal romans lost literally tens of thousands just in one battle, then they got up, assembled a new army and lost 15k men, and again, and again and again.

But when i read about medieval armies they rarely achieve those numbers.

why is that?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Were things like sunburn and bug bites common back in Ancient Greek & Roman Times? Did they have an item for it?

They didn’t have modern sunscreen or bug repellent, so was it more common then what we see today?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Did the Soviets actually attach another head to a dog?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

On November 9, 1989 a misunderstanding of an announcement regarding the Berlin Wall led to it being opened. What was the original announcement supposed to be?

On November 9, 1989 the East German government was going to make an announcement regarding apparently travel between East and West Berlin. It most certainly was not intended to open the wall entirely, but a miscommunication and misunderstanding of what they were going to do led to the border being reopened.

But was was the original intent of what East Germany wanted to do? What did the announcement actually say?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Was Socrates ever considered a writer?

In Book II Section 1 line 32 of the Penguin Classics version of Epictetus Discourse and selected writings (page 80) it reads "But wasn't Socrates a writer, and a prolific one at that". This passage then has the associated note "Socrates is generally thought not to have written anything, so this passage is a puzzle".

Are there any explanations for why Epictetus' view on Socrates here is so contrary to the modern one of him not writing things down?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Did the average American have any idea that the US intended to use atomic weapons on Japan? If so, was there any significant opposition?

I understand that they were developed in secret. I'm not sure what anyone could expect of their potential.

2 Answers 2019-08-06

IS there any evidence that the Communist Party of France and the various Stalinist academics and intellectuals in France during the 1950s-1970s had any contact with Soviet intelligence?

I am looking particularly at the Postmodernists such as Derrida, Foucault and their colleagues. Also, if you could recommend some biographies or histories of that group, it would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Paduspanid dynasty and zoroastrianism

At what point did the rulers from the Paduspanid dynasty stop practicing zoroastrianism and convert to islam? Wikipedia states 15th century, but not any specific years, 100 years is too unspecific. I did hear someone say they were zoroastrian "in secret" until 1453, when the senior branch of the dynasty went extinct and the Nur branch inherited their holdings, but no sources.

1 Answers 2019-08-06

How did people in the Wild West/1800s USA survive without vaccines? Or did they have vaccines already?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

What was the original purpose of guns when they were invented?

Basically I would like to know the historical context of the invention of the firearm. Was it originally meant for killing other humans? (i.e. military/protection from other humans) Or was it more geared toward hunting for food?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Britain has a variety of religious State schools; Anglican schools, Catholic schools, Jewish schools, Muslim schools, etc, all funded by the state and free for students. In the USA, all religious schools are private. Why did the systems develop differently?

I guess the simple answer is "because the USA has seperation of Church and State and the UK doesn't", but then, while the UK is (very technically constitutionally, if not in much of a real sense) Anglican, but there are state-funded Jewish, Muslim, Catholic schools, etc.

​

If anyone can write an answer that links and compares the two countries, that'd be good, but that might be difficult. So I'm happy to see seperate answers of why:

a)Americans decided at some point not to fund religious schools (in this thread https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/cmfhxd/was_the_modern_american_homeschooling_movement_in/ u/UrAccountabilibuddy wrote that early state schools were very Protestant because the government was run by Protestants, but Catholics complained, so why didn't they develop explicitly Protestant and Catholic and Jewish schools?)

and

b)why did Britain decide to fund explicitly religious schools, rather than having generic state schools which were originally de-facto Protestant-ish and telling Catholics and Jews to lump it? I mean, in my village we had St Margaret's Anglican primary school and Our Lady of Lourdes Catholic primary school (and a secular school, but it was a private one for fancy rich kids, regular kids like me had to go to a Church school). Why not have purely government schools with no links to local Churches?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

In the 1940s and 50s, what were the issues and policies that caused a person to identify as Democrat or Republican? I ask because it seems that these parties had many more internal divides than they do today.

A little background on me to give this question context. I'm from New England, my dad is white and my mom is black, yesterday I was talking to my grandpa about what it was like for him growing up in a small town in Western Massachusetts in the 1930s, 40s and 50s (I have some questions about that as well, he told me that he didn't know there was prejudice growing up, he had mostly white friends, went to a mostly white church, his family had dinner at white neighbors homes and, in his words he "got teased for looking like a dago or some kind of Portuguese more than for being from thr negro race" and I am curious if this was a common thing for New England at that time, WEB DuBois grew up one town over a few generations previous and also apparently had a very good experience, but that's for another post), and the topic of politics came up. He's a Republican, he's been a Republican his whole life and said the only time he voted Democrat in any election was in 1964's presidential election, I started asking him what were the things he believed that made him a Republican and he said that he was against corruption and for merit, against monopolies, good government and the constitution, that he supported the New Deal but thought that it made the government too large and encoraged corruption and idleness. He said a lot of other things about politics but for this question I think these are most relevant. To me this is very confusing, I thought the Democrats were the New Deal party and the GOP was against the New Deal, but I have been reading that there were many Democrats against the New Deal and Republicans for the New Deal and they formed cross party coalitions against each other. I knew that there was a rift in the Democrats about Civil Rights that caused many kg them to work with the GOP which was wholly pro-integration, but I thought that was the exception.

So, what were the key issues that mace someone choose to be a Democrat or Republican?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

What are some good material on Ancient History? Such as the time of the first civilizations leading up to the founding of Rome, esp the Ancient Egyptian, and Ancient Greek civilizations

I have been studying evolution in biology, and I was looking to integrate and continue it into my love of history. I was looking for good podcasts, or videos that would cover these subjects; And what are some lesser known sources that are really good?

If it needs to be an exact year it would be at about 15000bce-1200bce. Especially the spread of tribes throughout the world.

Thank you, and I read the rules, but if I missed something and this post breaks one, I apologize, if you could tell me which sub would be better I would be very thankful.

1 Answers 2019-08-06

How would someone learn a foreign language in High Middle Ages?

Specifically interested in the Crusades (Northern and the ones for Jerusalem) and how crusaders interacted with the local populace.

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Recently read the Havamal and loved it. Are there any similar sources of "wisdom" from around Gaelic Ireland?

I have read the entirety of the Fenian and Ulster myth cycles, but am asking any fellow historians for good sources of what I guess I'd call practical wisdom and philosophy such as what is in the Havamal?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

How close was Japan to surrending before the bombing of both Hiroshima and Nagasaki

Since this is the 74th Anniversary of the bombing of Hiroshima, I have seen a lot of debate about whether or bombing were justified with both sides discussing how close to surrender they were.

I've seen people say that with Russia joining the war and the destruction of most of their air force and navy that the Japanese were attempting negotiations. Then I've also seen people say that even after the atomic bombs were dropped that the Japanese Ministry of War urged the people to continue the fight, before being overruled by the Emperor.

So, just how close was Japan to surrendering before the bombs dropped?

1 Answers 2019-08-06

Best translation for Histories by Herodotus?

I know that there are several translations available online, and was wondering if there was one that comes better recommended.

1 Answers 2019-08-06

⯇ 1833 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start