Did any early Christian denominations disagree that Jesus was the Christ?

I remember reading a few years back in some book that I can't remember the name of that posited that there were many early Christian denominations that denied that Jesus was Christ and believed that there was some deception surrounding his death. And that the aggressive rise of Catholicism stamped out any of these beliefs by denouncing differing views on the resurrection and divinity of Jesus as heresies.

That would make sense to me considering that there were debates on Christianity held in the first ecumenical councils and that Catholicism and Orthodox eventually prevailed and persecuted other forms of Christianity, destroying and hiding evidence of the differing beliefs.

And then there is the Qur'an that talks as though it was a well known fact of life that there was deception surrounding Jesus' death. And this idea would have had to have been passed on to them. And how there are many Muslims that believe that Jesus is a separate person to the Mahdi (Islamic Christ). That he was not the Christ and was just a regular prophet.

All this makes me think that there were denominations of Christianity that didn't believe that Jesus was resurrected or that he was the promised Saviour. But is there any evidence of these views other than in Islam and Judaism? Are there any surviving old scriptures that show the differing thoughts on Jesus' divine status and power?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

How common was gun violence in Wild West towns?

In gun law debates, gun-control advocates sometimes decry that their opponents want to return to the Wild West. Hollywood etc notwithstanding, how often did gun violence actually occur within Wild West towns?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

The 1966 Godard film Masculin Feminin contains a speech on the radio from an unamed source which talks of "the first army of justice [who] for 100 years fulfilled the noblest dreams of the world. [And] dethroned 20 kings." What army is this speech referring to and which monarchs did they dethrone?

The scene is available here at around 57 minutes.

The full quote is: A nation took up the sword of Turenne and propelled across Europe the first army of justice. And for 100 years, this ragged army fulfilled the noblest dreams of the world. They dethroned 20 kings, crossed the Alps and the Rhine. What have you and I to do, Mr. Mitterrand, with these immense shadows that made Europe dance to the sound of liberty?

Any other info on this speech would be good too. Who gave it and what was the context of the time, if it was real and not made for the film?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

Habsburg books?

I want to do more reading about the rulers of the Spanish and Austrian branches of the Habsburg empire. I own books that cover English/British rulers as individuals. Are there any book recommendations that cover the Habsburgs in the same way? All I can find are books that cover them in a broad manner in the context of a historical event.

Im looking for a book like this The Lives of the Kings and Queens of England, Revised and Updated https://a.co/d/5xChhOJ

Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-07-20

Are Sumerian and Akkadian mutually intelligible with another?

Could the peoples of either area understood one another without difficulty? To what extent are the languages different?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

Short Answers to Simple Questions | July 20, 2022

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

58 Answers 2022-07-20

Glass Windows in African History

Hello,

I was wondering at what point in history did glass windows start to become a thing, at all really, in African history? To focus the question, North and West Africa would be my priority. I imagine some Romans in the area might have them in a limited degree, and later Muslim states might have also? But what about among the native peoples, as a local thing? And how common would things like curtains be? Thanks for any answer. I am very curious about this topic because I don't think native African history and culture is well covered in the West. I feel like somewhat in the dark about where to start on finding answers.

1 Answers 2022-07-20

What practices and tools do historians use to evaluate sources they suspect might be facetious or trolling?

This recent post discusses the possibility that a source-attested "ancient Irish custom" might simply be an ancient joke, an amusing story the source-writer invented. Surely this would not be the only case where sources, well, take the piss out of future historians. Such things would need to be evaluated case-by-case, of course, but are there any general practices historians use to cross-check absurd-seeming claims?

5 Answers 2022-07-20

Is an "emperor" (at least ceremonially) superior to a "king"?

In Chinese Emperor is translated into 皇帝, whereas king into 國王. 皇帝 belongs only to the Emperor of China, while 國王 was inferior to 皇帝. Was that the same in Europe?

Or, for instance, was the title "Emperor/Empress of India" superior (more important and prestigious) to "King/Queen of Britain"? If so, why didn't the government also elevate the leader of Britain to "Emperor/Empress of Britain"?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

To pay back debts, were the daughters of serfs forced into prostitution?

I'm writing a book taking place in a magical universe similar to medieval England and the main character is a serf girl living with her late father's sister. After her uncle goes into debt (and doesn't want to sell his land back to the landlord), he decides to use the main character to get money. I'm just curious if this is at all possible in medieval times.

2 Answers 2022-07-20

What is the history of global abortion legality and social acceptance, including potential prehistoric evidence?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

Where rangers (as depicted in Lord of the Rings) a thing in the Middle Ages ?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

What are good books on the original World Trade Center before 9/11?

I have become especially interested in the original World Trade Center, from its design to its tenants to how the buildings were built. What I am not interested in is anything that happened after September 10th, 2001.

Are there any good books, tomes, files, anything that go in depth to the original World Trade Center (and aren’t 9/11 focused)? Edit: Grammar

1 Answers 2022-07-20

How were so many eloquent founding fathers so young? Was there really less to learn in 18th and 19th century colleges?

1 Answers 2022-07-20

Did government agents infiltrate the Bolsheviks, CCP, Viet Minh, or other successful revolutionary parties? Did they do anything to try to foil the revolution? How did these parties avoid being undermined?

As a leftist, I find you can't get five leftists together (online) without them eventually calling each other "an op". Paranoia severely affects solidarity. It makes me wonder what happened with the successful revolutions of the past and how they dealt with secret police etc in their ranks.

1 Answers 2022-07-19

When did Irish men stop sucking each other's nipples as a sign of friendship?

Apparently this was a way to show friendship in ancient Ireland, and was even a way for vassals to swear loyalty to their lieges.

1 Answers 2022-07-19

Postwar Japan is well known for its extreme work environment, with 80+ hour work weeks and unpaid overtime being a common occurrence. What gave rise to this work culture? and why were Japanese labor unions ineffective at securing labor reforms?

1 Answers 2022-07-19

To what extent was Marie Antoinette responsible for the failure of the Flight to Varennes?

Several years ago I read a book that talked about the French Revolution (I can’t remember the title). When discussing the Flight to Varennes, the book said “If not for Marie Antoinette the venture would undoubtedly have succeeded” and blames her for wanting her luggage, insisting on bringing ladies in waiting and her hairdresser, and effectively forcing the King and herself to leave in a large, lumbering carriage with a following carriage for her staff rather than just taking a smaller, faster carriage by themselves. How fair is this assessment?

1 Answers 2022-07-19

In 2022, there’s a moral panic in the US with regards to public education. Was there a similar panic regarding the social movements of the 1960’s ?

1 Answers 2022-07-19

It’s 1950, and I am an East Berliner who would like to start commuting into West Berlin for work. Can I do this? Is it common? How do things change between now and the construction of the Berlin Wall?

1 Answers 2022-07-19

What is the original source/history of the common likeness of Crispus Attucks?

Hello. I am an 8th grade history teacher, getting lessons ready for the upcoming school year. I just had a passing thought regarding image sourcing as I was digitizing worksheets and adding images to them. I added an image of Crispus Attucks to a question (see the link) and then I wondered, was this portrait made of him during his lifetime, or was it drawn speculatively at a later date, such as during the abolition movement in the 1800s when Attucks became a popular historical figure? My students do ask me things like this from time to time (for example, when learning about Mansa Musa, all likenesses of him are speculative, including the only image made during his lifetime). After some searching (I've checked LOC.gov, Wikimedia commons, reverse image search, and so on) I have found the image to be both described as a speculative image, as well as a portrait from 1754, if I'm remembering right. Does anyone know the history of this image, or have any tricks to sourcing historical images in general?

Crispus Attucks - Crispus Attucks - Wikipedia

1 Answers 2022-07-19

does any one recommend any books on nusantara ? or other history resources the islands of Sumatra and java ?

1 Answers 2022-07-19

Once common pro-choice talking point is that abortion was not an issue to Christians until quite recently when it was made into a wedge issue by the GOP. Is this true? Was there widespread moral outrage over abortion before the 20th century to the degree that it exists now?

One*

1 Answers 2022-07-19

What are the best (most accurate and informative) sources to learn about Joan of Arc?

Translated or written in English. I’m thinking of getting a tattoo of her but I want to be sure I’m well educated on her life first.

1 Answers 2022-07-19

Legally, is the secession of the Confederacy viewed as official?

In other words, were the Confederate states officially no longer US states during the Civil War (as judged by the US government, then and now)?

In 1863, West Virginia joined the Union and remains a state to this day. However this is plainly unconstitutional (Article IV, section 3) unless we are to assume that Virginia was officially not a US state at the time.

Obviously, Virginia was de facto not a state, but it seems like the secession was not legally recognized at the time. If it were, it seems that might have all sorts of implications for laws enacted in those states before the Civil War and for the legality of secession.

1 Answers 2022-07-19

184 / 7255

Back to start