What makes an Empire, an Empire? Why is a political unit designated as an Empire versus just a large Kingdom?

Throughout history it seems like there is an inconsistency and how the word empire is used. We call the Byzantine Empire, and Empire regardless of how small it shrank. Or even in the days of Aurelian when the Roman Empire split into four or five separate political units, we still refer to those individual territories as empires and not kingdoms.

So what really makes an Empire? Is a territorial size? Is it the amount of people there are subject to that particular political system? Why are there no empires today? Why do we not refer to the American Empire, or the Chinese Empire?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

When Venezuela was under Spanish rule, how did the Venezuelans of Spanish descent start considering themselves creole? Was this the case for wealthy landowners too?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Went to watch the movie ‘Yesterday’ last week. It was about a world where the Beatles never existed. In this alternate universe, Coca-Cola and the word cigarettes never existed, how did the Beatles influence their popularity?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Are there any modern recreational drugs that could have been synthesized in Europe between 1000-1500CE, with the knowledge we have today?

Sort of like how you can make meth in your trailer with matches and Sudafed, would it have been possible to make chemical drugs with supplies available in this time period? And if not in Europe, would any other region have the capacity for it? Assuming a modern day chemist with complete up to date knowledge was performing the synthesis, using equipment from that age.

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Saturday Showcase | July 20, 2019

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

2 Answers 2019-07-20

what was like the comedy in the past?

I'm asking like 500 600 years ago there must be some kind of comedy book or I don't know something that tells us how the comedy was in that period of time

1 Answers 2019-07-20

What was the war strategy behind the Achaemenid Empire’s “Immortal” soldiers?

How did sending out men with iron masks during battle help the army?

I am referencing the Persian army. Specifically during the Battle of Thermopylae. It came up in the book No Time Like the Past. The Immortals were described as 10,000 soldiers who wore iron masks so their enemy could not see their face. When one went down or injured, another immediately took their place.

Edit: added background on who I was referencing

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Nowadays a lot of people call some modern policies "fascist". When fascism first rose during the interwar years, did people draw any historical parallel to call them?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-07-20

How did both Malaysia and Indonesia convert to Islam and why did Singapore not?

Majority Islam*

1 Answers 2019-07-20

What is currently the most accepted theory among scholars regarding the origins of the Etruscans? An ancient civilization in central Italy which spoke a non-Indo-European language.

The origins of the Etruscan civilization of central Italy has been contested for thousands of years. Dionysius of Halicarnassus described them as indigenous to the region of Etruria, Herodotus described them as Anatolian immigrants to mainland Italy. The uncertainty of their origins widely stems from the fact that they spoke a language isolate, seemingly unrelated to Indo-European or any other language on mainland Europe, although a hypothetical Tyrrhenian language group has been proposed.

Here are some historically dominant theories regarding the Etruscans:

  1. That they were indigenous to central Italy and a continuation of the early Iron age Villanovan culture

  2. Immigrants of Pre-Greek indigenous Aegean origin, often referred to by Ancient Greek writers as "Pelasgians" or

  3. Immigrants from Anatolia (Lydians according to Herodotus)

  4. Connection with the Rhaetians, tribes of the Alpine region. This theory postulates that Etruscans immigrated from the North. This theory was suggested in the writings of Livy and Pliny the elder.

Have there been any new developments in recent years? What is the most widely accepted theory on the origins of Etruscans in year 2019? What has been concluded from DNA studies?

3 Answers 2019-07-20

Why is Gustavus Adolphus not called “Gustavus the great”?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Did the Nuremberg trials ever prove the gas chambers' assassinations?

I've been told that all the available documentation concerning the gas chambers' assassinations during WWII was destroyed by the SS and therefore it couldn't be proven during the Nuremberg trials. Is this even true? Weren't the remaining gas chambers' buildings prove enough of their use? I've always thought that many nazi hierarchs were convicted and executed for these crimes, among others. Thanks beforehand, Reddit.

2 Answers 2019-07-20

Why couldn't the Roman's & Sassanids/Parthians have a real peace?

It seems to me that if both had accepted their areas of influence, and cooperated economically then they would have both gotten what they wanted. For Rome it was access to the silk road routes to India/China/etc, and for the Sassanids it would be Mediterranean Sea Port access across the entire ocean. Maybe their economies would have eventually been so entwined that war would be too costly. Also with that large border secure Rome could deal with the Germans, while Sassanids could counter the Hepthalites, and both could better handle the looming threat of northern Nomadic People's. So my question is are there any periods of time where trade between the two was at it's hight?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

What was it like being an average Londoner 400 years ago?

As in the qualia or the sensation. Did you wake up in a bed with a dirty, sack like blanket? Was it dark except for the light in the window? Was there a stove and a fire pot? What was the first thing you'd smell? Would it be quasi-rank meat or food along with sewage from outside? What about horse droppings? What would you hear? People talking in a crowd outside? Horse trots? Would you see steam here and there and smoke from rooftop chimneys? How dirty were you? Would you be literate? How big was your house or townhouse?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Why did Britain return Hong Kong to China?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

How was the Castro family able to hold onto power despite the collapse of the Soviet Union?

As in given the loss of its main military and economic aid, how did the regime stay put compared to the many governments that collapsed with the Soviet Union?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Trenches after WWI

What happened to the many trenches dug in WWI? I know they were very complicated systems consisting of multiple rows sometimes, but after the war ended, what happened to them? Were they just left there, or did the military took care of the somehow?

Also, are there any preserved trenches systems, for historical purposes?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

We hear a lot about allied intelligence from WWII really fooling a lot of German plans. Are there examples of German intelligence doing the same?

4 Answers 2019-07-20

How much is known for certain about pre-Hellenic indigenous populations of what later became referred to as ancient Greece and who were the "Pelasgians"?

1 Answers 2019-07-20

What's this old, strange political cartoon?

This Political Cartoon has been in my wife's family for decades. Can anyone identify the figures depicted within the illustration and the meaning behind it?

(Sent here from R/Whatisthispainting)

1 Answers 2019-07-20

Book on Ancient Persia

Hi all, Could someone help me find a book on Ancient Persia from before the rise of the Achaemenid Empire to after the fall of the Sassanian Empire. Preferably originally written in English and by a writer who’s neither an orientalist nor a leftist, but as close to objective as possible. Thanks.

1 Answers 2019-07-19

Invention of the wheel: what is the oldest record and registries of the use of the wheel in human history?

1 Answers 2019-07-19

Why didn't Belisarius stay inside the walls of Dara and instead meet the Persians on the field?

Dara was a fort right? It would have been easier to defend from it's walls rather than meet a numerically superior army in the field.

1 Answers 2019-07-19

In "The Decameron," Boccaccio describes people "living immoderately" and drinking all night in an effort to ward off the Black Death. Were people just drowning their sorrows, or did people think that partying would keep them from falling ill?

The quote in reference: "Others, inclining to the contrary opinion, maintained that to carouse and make merry and go about singing and frolicking and satisfy the appetite in everything possible and laugh and scoff at whatsoever befell was a very certain remedy for such an ill. That which they said they put in practice as best they might, going about day and night, now to this tavern, now to that, drinking without stint or measure."

​

Did people really think that alcohol would keep them in good health, or was this some strange social reaction to a major calamity?

1 Answers 2019-07-19

It's 1963 and I'm an unhappy Russian citizen. How do I successfully escape the USSR and defect to the West/US

1 Answers 2019-07-19

⯇ 1862 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start