Why Germans didn't build a bigger fleet that British in WW2? They had the whole of Europe at their disposal, while they were very successful in stopping aid from USA and colonies.

They had years to prepare, and this is the most debatable question when it comes to 'WHY' Germans didn't beat British.
British had a bigger fleet, they could just sink anyone who comes over.

2 Answers 2019-07-01

Why didn't Abrahmic religions gain as much ground in Japan as in Korea did during the 1900s?

Also, why was Buddhism, despite being a foreign religion, gain much more ground in Japan?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

What were the chances of surviving the Spanish Inquisition

I am a commoner who has been arrested and charged with heresy during the Spanish Inquisition. If I just go along with what they're saying and confess and renounce Satan will they let me go, or would I be killed for confessing in the first place?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

What was the British response to the sinking of the HMS Hood?

I understand that the pride of the British navy was sunk during the Battle of the Denmark Strait when she engaged the Bismarck and Prinz Eugen. What I would like to know is how the British people reacted to the loss of one of their most powerful warships. Were they sad, vengeful, disheartened or something of a mix?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

May-December marriages are a common trope, but were they really as common as implied?

It's not that uncommon to come across a book, movie, or argument online where a "May-December marriage" (i.e., significant age difference between the partners) takes place. However, in the United States and Europe were they really as common as people thing, or did most people tend to marry fairly close to their own age? Or was this something that was a result of the mortality rate?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Why were most currencies non-decimal until recently?

So I've been reading up on non-decimal currencies and was wondering why they were invented. Was this because mathematics wasn't advanced enough to create a decimal system or did it have something to do with how the coins' value was construed (i/e as a fraction of set amount of silver or gold?).

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Leaving the Ottoman Empire

The topic of immigration into the Ottoman Empire has been discussed quite a bit but my question is, for those who were non muslim subjects of the Ottomans, were you freely allowed to leave the Empire? My understanding was that unless you were enslaved, you could choose to leave, you were not held against your will in the Empire, any insight?

2 Answers 2019-07-01

Why was Song China so culturally and economically strong yet so militarily weak?

The amount of things the Song Dynasty gave to us is mind-boggling: Tea, printing, paper money, gunpowder, the compass, etc etc etc. The Song also gave witness to an explosion of creativity in art, music, literature, theater, and much more. With all this, why were they so militarily weak during their rule? After all, it's ironic as beside gunpower, the weapons of war they invented also included rockets, landmines, flamethrowers, and so much more and they definitely did not lack the numbers to have a large army... Just what is the reason that the Song dynasty was so bad at uniting the China proper and being constantly invaded even at its height?

3 Answers 2019-07-01

When and why did three to four minutes become the standard length of most songs?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Did Harriet Tubman really have a $40,000 bounty on her head?

I am writing an essay on Harriet Tubman and need some reliable evidence. There's a common legend that Tubman had a $40,000 bounty on her head. This is repeated in several reliable websites such as a government website http://www.americaslibrary.gov/aa/tubman/aa_tubman_subj.html and even sub .edu sites: http://maap.columbia.edu/place/33.html

http://www.unm.edu/~tinan/social%20studies/Student%20Reports/jenbaca.htm

Yet other sites say that this is a popular myth made up by Sallie Holley https://www.nps.gov/hatu/planyourvisit/upload/MD_TubmanFactSheet_MythsFacts_2.pdf

If this is a popular myth, I'm surprised that it is repeated on government and educational websites.

I also noticed that the "300 people" is also a myth, but is also noted on the government and educational websites.

1 Answers 2019-07-01

We have a lot of details about historical battles like Cannae, Waterloo, Gettysburg, etc. How do you historians gather enough resources to recreate the tactics and events in these battles, what tends to e useful resources, and how do you verify the veracity of these sources?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

I'm looking for book recommendations for Netherlands and Belgium

I'm not interested in their colonial history. Looking for anything relatively accessible but particularly on how the countries were formed.

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Looking for a good read about Jewish/early Christian apocalypticism

Many modern Christian denominations put a great emphasis on eschatology, so I'm interested in contemporary academic interpretations of the Book of Revelation: historical context, Persian influences, Nero Redivivus legend etc. But I see that it's just a single example of a whole literary genre reflecting the developments in Judaism during the Hellenistic era, so I'd like to learn more about these as well.

1 Answers 2019-07-01

At the Nuremberg Trials Admiral Karl Dönitz was tried for ordering unrestricted submarine warfare (a direct violation of international law) he was found not guilty because his lawyer argued the Allies had done the same, so why was such a law ever made? (details in comment)

The Second London Naval Treaty of 1936 article 22 stipulates 'in the case of persistent refusal to stop on being duly summoned, or of active resistance to visit or search, a warship, whether surface vessel or submarine, may not sink or render incapable of navigation a merchant vessel without having first placed passengers, crew and ship's papers in a place of safety'

I am no expert but I would assume a very large part of a submarines success comes from the element of surprise, if one were to spot a merchant vessel and surface with the intention of communicating then it puts itself at risk as it does not know the specifics of the vessel (it may have armaments, it may ram the submarine) and it also gives the vessel time to manoeuvre / get away or send a distress signal to nearby vessels alerting combat ships and dispersing friendly ships.

Karl Dönitz lawyer successfully argued that the Allies had breached the same law by issuing a similar orders thus no extra time was added to his sentence for the breach (he did got to jail for 10 years for other crimes).

So I guess in order to answer the question we need to know what was submarine warfare policy around 1936 did it rely heavily on the element of surprise and if so why was such an article added, was it just wishful thinking or did creators of the treaty really believe submarines would operate in a stop and search manner?

Article 22 The following are accepted as established rules of international law:
(1) In their action with regard to merchant ships, submarines must conform to the rules of international law to which surface vessels are subject.
(2) In particular, except in the case of persistent refusal to stop on being duly summoned, or of active resistance to visit or search, a warship, whether surface vessel or submarine, may not sink or render incapable of navigation a merchant vessel without having first placed passengers, crew and ship's papers in a place of safety. For this purpose the ship's boats are not regarded as a place of safety unless the safety of the passengers and crew is assured, in the existing sea and weather conditions, by the proximity of land, or the presence of another vessel which is in a position to take them on board.

https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/Article.xsp?action=openDocument&documentId=05F68B7BFFB8B984C12563CD00519417

1 Answers 2019-07-01

I'm a palace servant in Shang China. The Emperor just died, and I'd rather not go to the grave with him. What are my options?

2 Answers 2019-07-01

Is there really a debate on the amount of people killed by communists regimes in the 20th century?

I would like to know if things such as denying the amount of victims of the Holodomor (among others) or even disgregarding it as "capitalist propaganda" (such as Ludo Martens) are actually taken seriously or just regarded as blatant pseudohistory such as Holocaust denialism among scholars.

The same would go for the rest of the 100 million deaths supposedly caused by communism in the 20th century, numbers popularized by Robert Conquest and WR Hearst among others. Are those numbers actually accepted as valid among historians?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

On military historian and US Civil War veteran Theodore Ayrault Dodge

I've read three of TAD's Art of War tomes; Alexander, Hannibal and Caesar. I also have copies of Gustavus and Bird's Eye View of the Civil War for future reading. I find him to provide remarkable insights and be quite thorough in covering a subject, while exposing no more personal bias than most modern historians.

Google Scholar reveals the volume on Hannibal is his most cited work, but that is still many times less than Goldsworthy or Hoyos or Lazenby when covering the same topic. What is shocking to me is that none of these three seem to cite Dodge's work (at least on Hannibal, per Google Scholar).

Given his practical military experience as a brevet colonel in the Union army and that he made painstaking efforts to travel the routes of ancient campaigns and to the sites of ancient battlefields, the lack of modern citations is bemusing -- that he traveled so extensively, including crossing the Alps, after having lost his right leg at Gettysburg is incredible.

 

My question is why is he so infrequently cited by modern academia? Is there some fundamental flaw with his methods? Is it simply the age of his works? I'm perplexed.

EDIT: My intent is not to challenge the credentials or methods or any such thing of modern historians/academics. I've enjoyed several books by the three modern authors I mentioned above. I'm genuinely curious as to why such a fantastic source is so overlooked.

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Did the Aztec Empire and Inca Empire have any sort of direct or indirect contact or relationship?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-07-01

How widespread was corvée labor in Southeast Asia during the late 1800s-early 1900s?

I want to know if anyone here can suggest me some journal articles and book chapters that talk about the situation of corvée labor (unpaid and unfree labor) in Southeast Asia. Was it widespread? Were there differences in the labor situation between territories under European control and free non-colonized states like Thailand?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

What were proper--or at least effective--methods of surrender on a medieval battlefield?

This is my first post here so if I'm doing anything wrong, please advise so I can correct it now and prevent it in the future.

Stories are rife with various methods of surrender, some more recurring than others. It makes me curious as to what would and would not work. First of all, I see several mentions--in fantasy books like ASOIAF, as well in a mid 19th century book I found--about knights (or, presumably, any soldier on such a battlefield) offering their gauntlet as a token of surrender. Is that accurate, and was it just any piece of armor, like "look, I'm removing my defenses, please don't kill me"? And while I know highborn warfighters and wealthy knights and such would be given more priority for ransom, but what's the likelihood some regular pikeman that was nobody before he was impressed into service could shout "I yield" and actually be spared?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

How did medieval travellers perceive Rome as a city?

Rome reached its ancient population peak of 1.2 million in around 300 AD. Since then until modernity the population numbers consistently fell. At the worst times the city was supposed to only have a mere 20.000 inhabitants.

So my two questions are the following. How this did drain happen? Did the population simply abandon the city and move to the countryside? And then the titular question of how Rome was perceived as a city. Old infrastructure and monuments were still standing to a degree. Was it something to be mourned, to be awed at?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Why after the armistice was signed soldiers kept fighting in WWI?

I was watching this video (I know it may be misleading and can’t be a valuable source of information) but anyways if the treaty was announced why did they kept fighting. I mean,war wasn’t going to have a turning point in just like 6 hours so why did they kept fighting? Why did they have to wait until 11 am and not just end up the war when they announced it? Last hours of WWI

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Hittite Architecture

Can anyone tell me the characteristics of the hittite architecture. I want to know what the buildings were made out of and what kind of furniture they had (if any).

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Did the black plague happen all at once or did it happen in different regions at different periods?

1 Answers 2019-07-01

Did the Romans and later Byzantines have a plan to conquer Persia?

I thought it’d make great sense if the Romans and later Byzantines led an Alexander the Great inspired conquest of the Parthian and later Sassanian empire.

1 Answers 2019-07-01

⯇ 1895 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start