In his book about the Battle of Berlin, historian Antony Beevor talks about women "in black uniform" serving in the SS as infantry and driving tanks. What do we know about women in the SS in general and in the late war specifically?

He specifically mentions them while covering the Halbe Pocket, late April 1945.

From what I understand of the role of women in the Third Reich, they were not allowed to fight and only in later stages were recruited as Funkhelferinnen and Flakhelferinnen. The SS strikes me as the last place to make an exception for this but then again everything is possible in April '45.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Looking for book recommendations about Medieval Europe!

I have a limited knowledge of Medieval history, because it’s sandwiched between Ancient history classes and European history courses, and there are infinitely many anachronisms and inaccuracies in the “common/cultural knowledge” about those times.

What are some good books (in English) you can recommend about the Medieval period? I’m particularly interested in the politics and warfare of Europe, but also technology, economy and society, and how those things changed over the Middle Ages. I enjoyed The Pursuit of Glory: Europe 1648-1815, which covers these things comprehensively and am looking for similar works.

One specific I’d like to learn about is the historical facts about castles, knights, and all those Medieval Times and Dungeons & Dragons sorts of things. I’m aware that our cultural idea of the Knight never really existed, and I want to learn what an actual 12th century Knight or 15th century castle would look like.

Also if there are broader works covering Medieval Eurasia as a whole (the Silk Road network and exchanges), I would appreciate that as well.

Thank you!!

3 Answers 2019-06-09

Any info on unit

My Dad served in unit acorn 44 at Okinawa in WW2, I know he was a fireman there by the pics. Does anyone have any information on this? Thank you!

1 Answers 2019-06-09

What was the difference between the Western European feudal system and Byzantine themes?

From a basic overview, they are all just systems were land was handed out to subordinates to govern and control, but I'm sure they functioned very differently in practice. What really differentiated these two systems?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

How much direct control from the State did Rome exert on its provinces?

I’m curious about some of Rome’s really distant provinces like Iberia, Brittania and especially Egypt

1 Answers 2019-06-09

US Army troopers who stormed the beaches at Normandy wore a light green cover that went over their boots. What was the purpose of these, since other troops such as the Airborne did not wear them?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

The Prussian-Danish war of 1864 was fought at the same time as the American Civil War. How different were the weapons, tactics, etc. of these two wars?

Molte described the American Civil War as "Two armed mobs chasing each other around the countryside". So I suppose he at least thought there was a difference in training, leadership, and operational ability, I guess.

2 Answers 2019-06-09

Why was the U.S. Air Force forced to fly missions during the day while the British Air Force flew most missions at night in Europe during WW2?

They said this during HBO’s new documentary The Cold Blue but didn’t really explain why.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

What is that melody that I always hear in 17th-18th century ball music?

Hello historians of Reddit. I've noticed this recurring melody in music from movies set in the Enlightenment era, usually during royal/aristocratic ball scenes. The best example I can find is from What Child Is This (0:34-0:40 in this one, just imagine it with more tremolo). I know that it's a 19th century piece, but that melody is very close to what I'm describing.

Is there some music theory/history associated with that? This isn't just a Hollywood thing, I also hear that melody when I listen to actual pieces from that period, like Bach or Lully. I assume the musical period/style I'm referring to would be Baroque, since I don't notice that melody in classical music, like Mozart's or Beethoven's.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Why did Calvinist communities, like John Calvin's Geneva, hold to such strict behavioral standards if your actions don't affect salvation in Calvinist theology?

I was reading about the incredibly strict policing of behavior in Calvin's geneva (ditto US puritan communities), and was sort of confused by this. If Calvinist philosophy says that not only do one's actions not affect salvation, but one's salvation is already determined in advance, why was there this rigorous policing of behavior which, from a theological perspective, doesn't seem to matter?

Were there any Calvanist theologians who said "Since we're already saved/damned and can't affect that, who cares what you do?"

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Why did U.K. dissolve the British Empire?

I know it took close to a 100 years to slowly release all occupied territory. But what changed that they would want to give over every holding.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

"In 1923, 1924, and 1926 the territory of the Belorussian SSR was extended to the east at the expense of the Russian republic." Is there any place where I can see more clearly the shift of these boundaries of the Belorussian SSR and in Soviet Union in 1920' & 30's in general?

I am interested in the period that deals with first and second decade of the Soviet Union. Often when I read about these early years, I often hear mentions how different Soviet republics changed borders internally. In the book I am reading now, it is said that the territory of the Belorussian SSR changed three times in just three years, but no matter how hard I try I can't find any visual representation of that. Is there any site, atlas, or any other source where I can possibly see these internal border shifts? There also were border changes linked to creation of USSR and because of internal constitutional changes in Caucasus, but the situation there is the same, barely any maps and representations of these internal changes exist.

​

I hope this question fits inside the rules of the subreddit. If not, where would be a good place to ask something like this?

​

The quote from above is from book by Timothy Snyder called "Reconstruction of Nations". Page 65.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Recommendations for a layman of documentaries or books that look at the history of the city? From geographic choice and human change of it to changes to a city throughout history? [x-post from urbanplanning]

I apologize if this isn't the proper subreddit to ask, but I'm interested in learning more about cities as a concept (I suppose). A historical look at geographic locations typically settled, how humans intentionally or unintentionally changed the land to better suit themselves, and the changing of cities through time. I'm not sure if there are any documentaries or books that cover this topic, as most of my looking comes up with stuff about very modern cities (or theoretical futurization). If anyone knows of anything that may be similar to what I'm looking for that would be amazing.

(This is copy and pasted from my thread in /r/urbanplanning, someone suggested I crosspost the question here)

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Help researching Chinese Junks/China nautical history ~1000

I am having trouble finding sources of any kind to research China's naval history. I would like to specifically focus on the Chinese Junk ships but I can't even pull enough sources together to know what time period I should even be focusing on or what direction to go from there.

I have the Van Tilburg book but it is only the one and is a secondary source on a small sample of Junks. Google scholar and my uni library have yielded zilch but more likely my searching for sources is just not my strong suit.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Did recreational tourism exist in the Middle Ages and in the Ancient period?

Was it possible for a plebeian or a bourgeois to go on a vacation to a neighbouring country?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | June 03, 2019–June 09, 2019

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2019-06-09

How did soldiers drafted in WW2 continue to meet financial commitments e.g., mortgages? I am assuming that at least some made more in their civilian occupations than Army wages.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

I've read/heard conflicting opinions on whether it was the Emperor Constantine or what later became known as the Catholic Church that decreed the holidays of Christianity and the status of Jesus (whether man or God) at the Council of Nicea. Which was it?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Are there English sources that detail Rommel's war crimes in France and North Africa?

Specifically having his troops pretend to surrender in France and his cooperation with Einsatsgruppen in killing Jewish North Africans.

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Cast system in India

When exactly the cast system in started.. Is there any connection between collision of Buddhism in India and cast system..!?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Does anyone know an actually solid, scholarly book about the history of the SS?

Hi everyone! I’m a project assistant currently working on a museum exhibition about the history of Nazi Germany. I have (BA and MA) degrees in Modern History and Public History, and I would say my background knowledge on this topic is more-than-average. But I am no expert either. Especially not when it comes to the history and the beliefs of the SS, which is quite important for this exhibition.

So I was wondering: do any experts out there know of a good book to introduce me to the history of the SS? I am especially interested in books that discuss their belief system, racism, neo-pagan ideology, and the role which they saw for themselves as the vanguard of a ‘racially pure’ German Lebensraum.

A quick Google tells me that there are plenty of books about the SS, but as a non-expert I can’t tell whether they have any scholarly merit. A lot of them seem to basically be either (1) exploitation novels, (2) neo-nazi propaganda or (3) boyish military histories fetishising panzers and uniforms. I’m looking for an actually well-researched academic introduction to the history of the SS, and its role in the wider context of the Third Reich - including its war crimes and genocide. Books/articles can be both in English and German. Any advice is welcome, thank you all very much in advance!

*Edit: removed some unnecessary spacing

3 Answers 2019-06-09

Were people able to understand Shakespeare when it was first performed in the 1500’s?

If people today have a hard time understanding what’s going on in his plays was it the same situation back in the 1500’s for the normal people who watched it?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Are Smithsonian and Eyewitness published books scholarly journals?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Why isn't the napoleonic war(s) seen as the first world war?

1 Answers 2019-06-09

Atlantis

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-06-09

⯇ 1929 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start