In Romeo and Juliet, Juliet was only 13. Was Shakespeare just a weirdo or was it common for works to have such young protagonists in romantic roles?

1 Answers 2019-04-03

Why are these US soldiers marching in Beirut, Lebanon, in 1958, holding the Confederate battle flag?

https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-TDZVRuOcH80/TjnPsppLZNI/AAAAAAAAAIU/OvOy8G_OuUI/s1600/marines1958wy2.jpg

1 Answers 2019-04-03

The seeds of most Poppy species are edible, and cannot be misused for illicit opiate manufacturing, yet _P. somniferum,_ the Opium Poppy, remains by far the largest source of commercial poppy seeds. Why did _P. rhoeas_ or another relatively safe poppy species not catch on as a commercial crop?

1 Answers 2019-04-03

What happened to city walls and moats when cities turned to the modern age?

I've been to Vienna before and afaik there's no walls. Now some small towns still have city walls in austria afaik but most big cities don't. How did the transition to modern cities happen? Is the answer really boring and the state just tore them down, filled the moats and sold the land as prime real estate?

1 Answers 2019-04-03

Where would one go to better understand the 7 Years War?

I generally know about the history of the American revolution and the time around it and I've often seen sources touch on the 7 Years War and how big it was but I haven't seen anything that talks in depths about it. Any good books or podcasts?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

Did any Amish men serve in WWII?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-04-02

Were crowns ever altered?

Whenever monarchs wore crowns of rare metals and such, were the crowns ever redesigned or reshaped to fit the next person who took it up?

If so, were such changes frowned upon for potentially damaging the crown just because the new owner could not cope with the minor discomfort when they're expected to rule over all?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

What happened to Hitler? How did he go from inspiring the German people in bars (healthy and - technically- sane) to hooked on drugs and physically dependent?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-04-02

Why did Roman castras usually have more than 1 or 2 gates?

Granted, not all Roman camps had 3 or 4 gates, but my impression is that most of them did. So what for? Doesn't having that many weak spots defeat the purpose of the fortification? What was the pragmatic reasoning behind such decisions?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

Franz Ferdinand - Well known figure at the time?

Hello historians,

Just a quick question.

How well known was Franz Ferdinand at the time of his death?

It’s my understanding that his death was worldwide news, but would it have meant anything to the common man? Would the average person in Britain have even have known who he was before reading the newspaper report?

I can’t seem to find a clear answer online, so any clarity would be appreciated.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2019-04-02

When did Latin die out in (post-)Roman (North) Africa

Including Libya.

​

While in the post-Roman west of Europe languages based on Latin, or Latin topolects/sociolects became dominant to the point of all but entirely replacing the Celtic and other languages previously spoken, there is no trace of Latin in present day North Africa. Did just not that many people speak it in the first place?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

In a Gainsbourg bio, it's said that his family managed to store belongings before hiding, allowing them to return after WW2 largely unscathed. This caused some resentment among Paris' Jewish community, most of whom lost everything.But how were inter-Jewish relations in the immediate post-war period?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-04-02

Could duchies, kingdoms, or city states within the Holy Roman Empire declare war on one another?

Additionally, if they could / did, how did the emperor resolve this issue?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

A few questions for people who studied (or are currently studying) archeology

I'm not sure whether this is the right place to ask in the first place, but I figured I'd shoot my shot since it does not seem to be against the rules. So here are my questions:

​

How is your job? What exactly do you do? How did your semesters look; what did you do in them? Would you recommend it?

I've been looking around and archeology sounds inredibly fascinating, but I'm not too sure if I don't have a really romantized view of it. Please tell me about your personal experiences, both good and bad.

Thank you

4 Answers 2019-04-02

Superficially the Malayan Emergency and Vietnam War seem similar yet had disparate outcomes. What differences were there that led to this?

Both conflicts were protracted (12+ years and 19+ years), both taking place in unforgiving terrain that benefits the communists, and both seem to have had a similar ratio of combatants although the scale of Vietnam was larger.

Was it as simple as the North Vietnamese having an organised military? Or is there more nuance?

As always, thanks to anyone replying.

1 Answers 2019-04-02

What recreational drugs, aside from alcohol, were available in 1500s Europe?

and what was the cultural perception of them (including alcohol)?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

How did exacly John II emperor of Byzantium ended up hiring Harald Hardrada with the rest of his fellow vikings?

So I know this eventually happened but I can’t find any source material telling how exacly this happened. I know that Harald plundered few castles in what I belive to be Sicily and then he served in army under John II. But why?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

World War One repeaters

Why didn’t the armies in WWI use repeaters, they seem much better than the bolt actions used by most troops, was it cost or something else?

2 Answers 2019-04-02

I’ve read that some Byzantine nobles sided with the Ottoman Beylik in the 14th century. What was their reasons for doing so?

Wouldn’t it be better to remain loyal to the Orthodox Christian Byzantines than the Muslim Ottomans?

2 Answers 2019-04-02

The legitimacy of Holocaust oral history?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-04-02

What is the following quote referring to? Clearly it's pre-Islamic, but is it Zarathustran, or some polytheism?

'most of medieval material culture — knights, castles, tunics, pointy shoes, roses, rhyming poetry, princesses in towers wearing conical hats with veils, wizards with robes covered in holy symbols — is originally Persian'

It's talking aboat how most Medieval European fantasy tropes originated in Persian culture. I wanna read the original stories.

1 Answers 2019-04-02

What impact did the United States really have in World War I?

After watching Peter Jackson's documentary earlier today, I went on a bit of a binge on YouTube into WWI footage. The American films seem to give significant weight to Americans joining the war with respect to the eventual Allied victory. Would the War have actually been winnable if the United States had chosen to remain neutral?

Thanks to all the historians who are active here! I find all of your answers enormously fascinating.

2 Answers 2019-04-02

Did people really chase Bonnie and Clyde like celebrities when they came to town?

Asking this at r/AskHistory too.

​

I just watched "The Highwaymen" on Netflix and one scene showed adoring fans swarming the car of Bonnie and Clyde when they stopped to purchase medicine in a small town. Did this really happen? It seems strange that you would do that to wanted outlaws....if you were fans of them, wouldn't that give them away to law enforcement?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

Dr. Katherine Hall of the University of Otago, New Zealand has hypothesized that Alexander the Great died of Guillain-Barré Syndrome. What are historians opinions regarding posthumous medical diagnoses of long deceased historical figures? [Repost]

Dr. Katherine Hall of the University of Otago, New Zealand has hypothesized that Alexander the Great died of Guillain-Barré Syndrome. Said theory has been published in The Ancient History Bulletin, and reported on by numerous websites, such as the Smithsonian website and Science Daily.

What is the opinion of any classicists or ancient historians regarding this? In addition, what do historians think in general about diagnosing long deceased historical figures; especially someone like Alexander, where the surviving sources were written long after his lifetime and the works they are based on (such as Ptolemy’s history) are lost?

For example Dr. Hall states how previous theories failed to account for the fact that Alexander’s body did not start to decompose until six days after his death. Ancient writers thought this to be a sign of his divinity; yet couldn’t this have been an embellishment added later to make Alexander appear divine?

When I first read about this theory it seemed a little problematic. The lack of surviving sources from Alexander’s lifetime and from those who were present during his death, coupled with the fact that attempting to diagnose past individuals with a mental illness (as well as psychological evaluations and explanations for why someone did something) is generally frowned upon by historians, got me thinking about wether the same holds true for attempts to diagnose physical illnesses and causes of death where the answer is not clear cut and the circumstances vague.

A link to an article discussing this: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/01/190122115006.htm

1 Answers 2019-04-02

Sabaton announced a new Album based in World War 1 and it got me thinking. Aside from the fact that the 100 year anniversary of the war's end was a few months ago, why is World War 1 such a hot topic in games and movies right now?

1 Answers 2019-04-02

⯇ 2035 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start