Did any people who contracted the Plague (in the 14th century) recover?

I know many people survived by not catching it, but was there a chance that if you caught the plague you might fully recover and go on to live a healthy life?

2 Answers 2019-03-30

Cultural links between Anglo-Saxon England and Germania

In this week's In Our Time: History podcast, as an aside, Dr John Hines suggests to Melvin Bragg that the current trend in thinking is that the Frisian language moved from England to Germania, rather than vice-versa. This point isn't elaborated, as the discussion was about the interaction between the Viking and Anglo-Saxon languages in England, but it raised the question for me of what the links were like between the Anglo-Saxon settlers who came to England and their source communities. Was there a strong ongoing cultural interaction between the two groups? Are there some other ways in which this interactions continued to manifest itself?

2 Answers 2019-03-30

Can you suggest lectures for African history?

I'd like to watch some lectures on African history. I know that's a pretty general topic, but I don't know enough to ask about specific countries. I looked it up on youtube but what comes up is just a bunch of documentaries and I'm not confident that they're good sources.

2 Answers 2019-03-30

Is there a reason that the US was not charged with war crimes after WWII, given that the UN called for the elimination of nuclear weapons about 5 months after the bombings?

1 Answers 2019-03-30

Did the ancient Greeks believe that their gods were only the gods of the Greeks or also of all humans?

1 Answers 2019-03-30

Why was the American comedian George Carlin arrested in 1972 for performing his “Seven Dirty Words” bit?

Very obscure question, but I recently discovered that the famous comedian George Carlin was arrested after one of his shows, for performing a comedy bit where he examines the 7 most crude swear words, and he rattles them off several times throughout the performance. I’m under the impression that he was arrested for breaking obscenity laws, but the judge later threw out the case. Why was he initially arrested? Were obscenity laws stricter in the 1970’s? Any more background information would be very helpful.

1 Answers 2019-03-30

How did manufacturing get so accurate?

I know today we have computers, but what first put us on the path to accurate, consistent machine manufacturing? Was it a direct consequence of the industrial revolution, a related event, or a separate happening altogether?

1 Answers 2019-03-30

Aztec history from the indegenous perspective

Hello all, I am currently working on a project that goes through Aztec history. Before reading all of the European sources that come from the conquistadors and others I would like to get a good understanding of who they were from there own perspective. Some questions I would really like answered is how they viewed rival warring states such as the Tlaxcalans and if there style of warfare was truly much more about injuring enemies to capture and sacrifice than it was to kill enemies and win battles. I would also like to know how they missed certain labor saving devices like the wheel while simultaneously achieving the most advanced architectural feats in the Americas. Lastly, how did they consider themselves. Any source suggestions or DMs on the matter would be helpful.

1 Answers 2019-03-30

Why did Peter the Great need the Baltic Sea for his fleet? Wouldn’t the Black Sea have been just as feasible?

1 Answers 2019-03-30

Which areas of France did most settlers of New France come from?

I'd assume mostly coastal, but was it more from Normandy and Brittany, or maybe from Aquitaine? Or am I wrong altogether and colonists were drawn from across France?

1 Answers 2019-03-30

Medieval bludgeoning weapons, were they effective?

Were bludgeoning weapons from older times such as War-hammers, clubs/great-clubs, maces, and flails effective as weapons, and more specifically, were they lethal and feared by those who had to fight against them?

1 Answers 2019-03-30

Did the British create the Sahara Desert through wartime burning?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-03-30

The Court of Swords in the Warlord Chronicles- Is it accurate? Discussion on Trial by combat in general

This question involves a bit of recent literature, but bear with me, it will get historical in a sec.

For those who do not know it, Bernard Cornwell's Warlord Chronicles tells a completly fictional tale, one of Arthur, Merlin, Guinivere etc. However, the historical context is fairly realistc, set in Dark Age Britain, during the Saxon invasions.

In the beggining of the first book of the trilogy, Arthur holds a trial in his Romano-Welsh kingdom of Dummonia. The trial can happen in the court of words, wich has a system of what types of testimony are accepted, wich in this case would disfavor Arthur. These are the Tongued Ones, and are discussed in this Ask Historians post: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/5t6w3u/is_there_any_historical_basis_for_the_tongued/

As you can see, this system presented in the book actually has a historical basis, and so comes the question itself. Does the second system, the one that Arthur choses, the court of swords, or as Game of Thrones would call it, trial by combat, have any historical basis in Welsh-roman medieval society?

It is depicted as a challenging of a lords word, in wich the acuser thrusts his sword into the dirt, and if the other lord knocks it over should he challenge the acusation, he accepts the trial, wich must take place outdors. It is a fight to the death.

Previously I fought that these trials by combat in fantasy (Warlord is not fantasy but you get my point) was only a way of making a trial something dinamyc and that shows a characters prowess in battle. But if the tongued ones system is true, then maybe the good historians in this subreddit can shed light if this sort of practice is accurate.

Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2019-03-30

At what point did demential Lumber become a standard with building houses?

I’m a carpenter and framer, and love this sub. Any short answer will do. Love you all!

2 Answers 2019-03-29

What was the global reaction to the atomic bombs being dropped?

I can’t seem to find much in the way of newspaper articles or really anything else. Does anyone have knowledge of what the world thought about the bombs?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

How could NATO bring tanks into Berlin during the Cold War?

They certainly couldn't just have driven them across East Germany, right?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Good sources on Edward the Black's 1355 campaign

Looking for a good book that contains any detailed information available on the 1355 chevauchee carried out by Edward prince of Wales. Any suggestions.

1 Answers 2019-03-29

I am a non Roman citizen in the year 50 a.d in the Roman empire. What's to prevent me from claiming that I'm a Roman citizen? What kind of proof would people ask for? If I was to go to a different city will they just take my word for it?

2 Answers 2019-03-29

Why was the Qing Dynasty so expansionist?

Given the extent that it enlarged the boundaries of China and acquired the territories that later became the Tibetan and Xinjiang Autonomous Territories as well as Inner and Outer Mongolia, the Qing Dynasty seems rather expansionist compared to many other Chinese Dynasties. What was the reason for this?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Vikings in North Americas

Does anyone know if when the small number of Norse/vikings that landed in North East America had any contact with the local Indigenous Native Americans or Not ?....

I have read accounts giving two contradictory answers this far. One was a yes & the other No.

Any answers appreciated...

1 Answers 2019-03-29

When Arkansas voted to secede from the United States (after initially voting to stay), the final tally was 69-1 for secession. Do we know how/why that final delegate managed to resist what must have been incredible pressure to vote Yes, especially after other delegates had switched their votes?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

How did the Elizabethan era trade route between England and Russia through the White Sea get established?

As follow ups-

What goods were being exchanged on either side?

What common language did the merchants conduct business in? Did they mime it out until someone was roughly bilingual, or did they just use French, or what?

Was anyone outside of those two countries aware of it, i.e., did any Spanish or Swedish privateers ever target that route? Was it valuable enough to keep as a state secret the way that Portugal kept their spice routes under wraps?

Was there any obvious or at least detectable influence either culture had on the other?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

A British Raj administrator wrote that "the young Mohammedan will talk as fluently about Socrates, Aristotle, Plato, Hippocrates and Galen [in Arabic & Persian] . . . as the young man raw from Oxford". Are there other similar accounts of the content and quality of madrasah education in India?

Source: Ramblings and Recollections of an Indian Official by William Henry Sleeman

(Posting this question again for more visibility)

2 Answers 2019-03-29

In Sean Bean's "On Waterloo," it's mentioned that the devastation of the light cavalry sabre was so immense that "the French previously tried to ban it from the battlefield." My question is on the context and validity of this statement. Also, was there an instance prior of banning weapons?

Sean Bean states the following in regards to the light cavalry sabre: "The injuries it caused were so horrific that the French had previously tried to ban it from the battlefield." It can be found at 14:32 of the documentary on the link provided (The link itself should bring you to that exact moment.) Prior to the Napoleonic Wars, was there another example of weapons being banned? Was this something that was common practice between warring European nations?

​

https://youtu.be/SScubWbQKhI?t=868

​

Edit: Just to clear any confusion, if there is any, I am not referring to "Sharpe's Waterloo." :)

Edit 2: (Originally I wrote this in the comment section but I think it provides better context and gives a chance at a more elaborate answer someone may be able to provide. It also let's me progress the question to a more precise one in regards to the origin of these claims, where they started, and how it cannot be confirmed.)

I just read through a section of the novel "Tools of War: History of Weapons in Modern Times" by Syed Ramsey on the British Pattern 1796 Light Cavalry Sabre that reads:

Its blade, unlike other European sabres of the period, widened near the point. This affected balance, but made slashes far more brutal; its action in the cut has been compared to a modern bacon slicer. It is said that this vicious design prompted unofficial complaints from French officers, but this is unconfirmed.

I'd imagine the documentary was just going for the shock value through exaggeration, which admittingly is frustrating for me.

​

Ramsey, Syed. Tools of War: History of Weapons in Early Modern Times. Alpha Editions, 2016.

​

​

​

2 Answers 2019-03-29

How did one secure a boat during the age of sail

During the period of the age of sail theft was very common and boats were costly so how did you lock up your boat to prevent theft or did you just end up having to leave someone to look after it

1 Answers 2019-03-29

⯇ 2043 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start