How accurate is Apocolypto?

I was watching Mel Gibson's Apocolypto last night and was wondering how accurate or inaccurate it is. Granted it is supposed to depict the end of the Mayan civilization and at the end of the movie the Spanish show up, so in that regards its 100% wrong. But I was thinking about how they portrayed the Mayans and the other tribal groups with regards to lifestyle, dress, and religion.

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Who were the Assassin's in reality? And were they truly that lethal, as portrayed in modern pop culture?

Hi fellow history heads. Long time lurker here. (M 28)

I don't know why, but I've been fascinated by the Assassin's since I was a little boy. Would love to get your insight into who were they in reality, and how important were they in that time period?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Across the Jim Crow period, America's complicated systems of racial categorization were replaced by the binary of white people and black people. Former categories like "creole" or "mulatto" were abolished, and their communities destroyed. Why did this happen?

The period I'm talking about is from the end of Reconstruction up until WW1, and seems to have been a complete process. A system of racial classification similar to what exists in Latin America was replaced with the black/white binary. America's former biracial and triracial communities were destroyed by this process, often at a great cost to their social mobility and local power. The Louisiana Creoles, once an enormous part of the culture and society of that state, are now basically invisible.

So how and why did this change happen? Why did white lawmakers and property-holders decide after Reconstruction that grouping together all persons of any African ancestry was the most useful strategy? And what did the groups caught in the middle do to resist this sudden change to their racial, and thus socioeconomic status?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Why didn't the Soviet's invade West Germany after WW2?

It seems like they had all the advantages.

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Who would an ancient merchant ask to engineer their merchant ships? Who would a 16th century king ask to engineer their war ships? Were there the equivalent of engineering design companies during those times?

I was looking at drawings of oar driven ships of the ancient times and sail driven war ships of the 16th century, and realized how much engineering went into them. How were they designed and who designed them? How would the engineers draw their designs and then get the components made? Who built them and how did the engineers show them how it was to be put together?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Friday Free-for-All | March 29, 2019

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

4 Answers 2019-03-29

What was the relationship between the Angles and the Saxons before they invaded Britain?

Were they effectively one people? Were they two closely related peoples that had a sense of kinship? Were they completely separate?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Abraham Lincoln was reportedly so impressed with the Spencer Repeating rifle that he ordered one for every union troop, reportedly deployment was delayed and pushed back by the army. Why was there pushback on the army's side? What was Lincolns response to this?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

AskHistorians Podcast 133 -- We Have Met The Enemy and They Are U.S. -- The Militia and the War of 1812

Episode 133 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud and Pandora. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode: Today we are joined by a flaired member of the AskHistorians community, /u/PartyMoses! Better known to his friends and family as Adam Franti, who got his MA at Eastern Michigan University. We will be talking today in general terms about the War of 1812 and focusing on the argument of his masters thesis, which centers around nationalistic historical narratives of the war that unfairly criticize the militia. Adam also used to give tours about the war of 1812 at Fort Mackinac so he has great insight into the interesting stories!

Questions? Comments?

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Next Episode: u/AnnalsPornographie is back!

Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.

5 Answers 2019-03-29

Was a Christian religious minister ever lynched in the US?

Either during the anti-Catholic scare of the turn of the century, or black denominations of baptism in the South.

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Were Slaves in the American Colonies Ever Tried For Witchcraft?

I know Europe had its folk-magic traditions, which were imported into the Americas, and I know that African-Americans had their indigenious religious beliefs and traditions which became syncretized in systems like hoodoo and voodoo, but were slaves ever subject to charges of practicing witchcraft?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Nazism in post-war Germany

How was handled nazism, not just high-ranking or in charge in Nazi Germany, but as well rank-and-file members of NSDAP or its mass organisations, people that without being hardline nazis (or even not nazis themselves) gave their support and hopes into this ideology, after 1945?

Basically, what happened to nazis and nazism politically and ideologically in post-war Germany?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

In its over 4000 year history, China has only ever been entirely subjugated to foreign rule once, to the Mongols. How have they remained independent for so long and how is it that the Mongols are the only ones to crack them?

I'm interested in knowing how the Mongols managed to do the seemingly impossible once again, and I'm also interested in knowing why China didn't expand more if they were so powerful. I get there's been a lot of infighting/civil wars during Chinese history but there's also been times of incredible stability where they could have moved into India or the Russian steppes.

2 Answers 2019-03-29

What do we know about Orgetorix alleged suicide?

Orgetorix was an helvetian aristocrat that attempted to migrate his people from Helvetian territory to south-western Gaul, right before Jules Caesar gaul campaings.

He was also party to a clandestine arrangement with Dumnorix of the Aedui and Casticus of the Sequani to seize control of their respective tribes by arms and between them rule most of Gaul. The conspiracy was denounced, Orgetorix was called to a hearing in chains before the government of the Helvetii, he arrived with a small army, and was released, but died mysteriously, a rumored suicide.

What really happened? And what are the historical sources confirming his death by suicide?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Is the historicity of Jesus disputed within modern historians?

If not, how are we sure if he existed?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

What was sex education like in the Soviet Union?

2 Answers 2019-03-29

Are there digitized English language texts of unknown importance that haven't been read yet by anyone in hundreds of years? I would love to spend my free time reading them and do a possibly important yet tedious job to make an impact in the field.

​

​

6 Answers 2019-03-29

Do we know where Caesar landed in Kent in 55 BCE?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

Is there any physical evidence of Leif Erickson's settlement on North America?

2 Answers 2019-03-29

I have a serious inquiry as a history major.

I apologize in advance for asking a question that does not concern a historical topic, but I believe this subreddit is the right audience to ask. (Moderator please take down if inappropriate)

As a history major, I have always loved this field of study. I am your stereotypical history nerd/junkie. I love memes, books, the whole nine yards. This semester I’m taking a WWII ideology course, and it has taken a rather unexpected turn. Learning about eugenics, the Final Solution, concentration camps, race superiority, etc, on a significantly more advanced level than ever before has me a bit “messed up” mentally and emotionally. Of course none of this has been new news to me, but all of it is getting under my skin just fathoming what victims of that era experienced and the pure evil behind these atrocities. I just don’t get it as a human being... and I’m questioning what’s the point in studying all this if I’m not even able to save any of the millions of innocent lives that were lost. And what do you do if evil is too big to fight? Does even a small action matter? Is it just to be able to say later “oh, well at least I did something”? And what’s my significance now? (Especially in today’s messy world) I’m just one person.

I’m typically an unemotional individual that naturally gravitates towards a more objective viewpoint on issues and has a “go for it” spirit (e.g. Go get justice! Fight for your rights!), so my current state has me both surprised and scared. I’m worried about talking with someone, because most people will probably think I’m just getting too much into the subject. But, as a human being, how can you not be affected learning about all this?! So, can any related to what I’m experiencing, and how did you come out the other side?

TL; DR WWII ideology class has me asking some existential-level and questions and not sure how to process this

Thank you

4 Answers 2019-03-29

What does my grandpa’s military pin represent?

In the process of moving, my parents found this pin that belonged to my grandpa. They gave it to me. I want to know what it means before I do anything with it. I think he was an engineer in the US army but the details of his career have seemed hazy to me. It’s a hexagon shape (a bit bigger than a quarter) with maroon in the background, outlined in white. There’s a gold torch down the middle with two dark blue rectangles coming out of it kind of at the angle of a peace sign. Engraved along the bottom on a ribbon design is VICTORIA / ES /SCIEN BA (the word furthest right is the most worn away, so I’m not totally sure what exactly the letters are.

Any input would be SO appreciated!

1 Answers 2019-03-29

How important of a political issue was border security pre-2000's? Would I be mistaken to say that border security has become a more dominant issue in post-millennium politics, or am I just unaware of the political climate before the 2000's?

I'm writing something that explores the motivations behind calls for the construction of a U.S. - Mexico border wall and I've been looking into statistics regarding Mexico to U.S. immigration. I thought I would be able to say something like

Border security has become an increasingly important issue in modern politics as the increase in overall Mexican-born immigrant population in the U.S. places concern in the minds of many voters.

The only problem is that the number of Mexican-born immigrants in the US has actually decreased (albeit slightly) since 2010 [1] so I can't make that claim. Instead, I'd like to write

While the number of people apprehended attempting to cross the border illegally (used as an estimator for overall trends in illegal border crossings) has declined more than 1250% since 2000, border security seems to have become a dominating issue in post-millennium politics. [2]

However, I can't find evidence for this claim, and I don't expect it to be well studied/documented, but I do get the sense that it's true. However, that's a pretty awful way to back up a claim, so I'd at least like some anecdotal evidence to confirm my hunch.

Thanks!

edit: formatting

1 Answers 2019-03-29

in the 14-1500s where Europeans just casually walking around with smallpox?

i keep reading/hearing accounts of Europeans spreading smallpox as they explore the new world. from what i remember when i got my sp vaccine its only contractible if you touch the excretion of a pox. so by this logic the only way that smallpox could be spread was if people used to just walk around with smallpox infections... is that how it was?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

How common were friendly fire incidents in aerial combat during the first and second world wars?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

When did the German Empire (1871-1918) truly become a world power and therefore considered a main player on the global stage?

1 Answers 2019-03-29

⯇ 2044 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start