Prior to the rise of Ataturk, what made someone in the Ottoman Empire a “Turk”?

Ataturk himself was born in modern day Greece, yet he identifies as a Turk. What was a Turk in the Ottoman Empire? What culture binded them together? And did they feel as if the Ottomans failed them too as the other groups under the Ottomans did?

2 Answers 2019-03-21

How extreme was the threat of the cold war going "hot" in 1983?

I recently read a claim that 1983 was the most dangerous year of the cold war in terms of escalating to actual conflict. If this is true what factors made cold war escalation in 1983 seem more likely than something like the Cuban missile crisis in 1962?

1 Answers 2019-03-21

Why did burgers n fries joints (like McDonalds, Whataburger and Burger King) become so successful as franchises? What social and economic changes made fast food king?

2 Answers 2019-03-21

Are there any ancient Hebrew battle cries?

1 Answers 2019-03-21

In school, we were always taught about countries throughout history trading and looting valuables, one commonly being "spices." What were some of these spices, and why are they so noteworthy in history?

2 Answers 2019-03-21

Were black people allowed to vote during segregation?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-03-21

How much evidence is there to support that ritual sacrifice was a superstitious practice in Mayan, Aztec, and similar cultures?

Is it at all possible that it was done primarily as corporal punishment (i.e. modern day execution) or at least the victims of sacrifice were those being punished, at the least?

If not, what do we know about ritual sacrifice and how victims were decided upon?

2 Answers 2019-03-21

When did time become unified?

I would imagine in the past many places kept time differently due to isolation and lack of connection with other civilizations. Was time kept differently in different countries? And when did time keeping become how it is today?

1 Answers 2019-03-21

no fewer than 262 German F-104s crashed out a total order of 916 aircraft. Why was this thing not scrapped? How many crashes did the USAF have?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_F-104_Starfighter#Normal_operating_hazards

Wiki says only a few lost to mechanical during Vietnam. What's the post interpretation verdict on the f104S? Any evidence of ,say, corruption in the procuring process? (rushing into service an unfit, unready plane)

1 Answers 2019-03-21

Why didn't Ethiopia spread Christianity into Africa

While The Europeans spread Christianity around their continent, the Nestorians and Eastern Christians spreading Christianity all the way to India, China and Mongolia even while under Zoroastrian, Muslim and Tengri (Mongol) rule and Islam, another Abrahamic faith, spreading deep into East Africa and West Africa, while the Christian Ethiopia, which was probably just as well placed as the Muslims for such religious conversions, didn't

​

2 Answers 2019-03-21

Why Exactly did the Church of the east vanish from China, Mongolia, India, Central Asia and most of Persia

1 Answers 2019-03-21

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | March 21, 2019

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2019-03-21

How and when did the Jewish memory of the Shoah develop in the United States?

As part of my thesis, I had to study the history of the Holocaust memory (or deportation in general) in Europe. In France, the memory of the deportation was dominated by the figure of the resistant deportee, celebrated as a hero, until the 1960-70s. The emergence of the Jewish deportation memory was slow to appear, mainly because de Gaulle, in the aftermath of the Liberation, called for national reconciliation. The Jewish returning from the camps initially refused the name of "racial deportee", frightened at the idea of being again sidelined by the French society. Negationism in the 1970s pushed many deportees to testify and researches since have intensified.

My questions are: how did this memory develop in the United States? Did Jewish people living in the US encourage testimony? Did the Jewish deportees who then immigrated to the US develop their own memory once there or did they try to "forget"? How did the Jewish Americans react to the immigration of the European deportees?

I am open to any kind of documentation. This is not part of my studies but a simple curiosity!

1 Answers 2019-03-21

What, if any, tactics promoted by the opposition were actually effective in stalling or hindering the rise of the Nazi party before 1932?

I know that there were a wealth of reasons for the Nazi party's rise to power in the early 1930s, but I find it common among liberals in the US today to blame "appeasement" (which I think is mostly people confusing the tactics of the international community in the late thirties with the domestic opposition within Germany). But I am curious: I know there was obviously lots of opposition to the Nazis from everyone from communists to Social Democrats, with brownshirts and communists often brawling in the streets, which leads me to ask...

Do you think any of the opposition groups had effective tactics, and that perhaps if these tactics had been more widely adopted, it might have prevented the Nazis becoming the largest party in the Reichstag? If so, which groups and what tactics?

As a corollary, are there good resources to look at that might shed more light on this or effective oppositional tactics to authoritarian or extremist parties in general that might be interesting to look at?

​

1 Answers 2019-03-21

What brands operated in East Germany?

I am primarily looking to find out about physical stores (such as grocery or clothes stores), though discovering what for instance car manufacturers existed there would also be appreciated.

2 Answers 2019-03-21

Happy Nowruz/ Nowruz Mobarak! What are the origins of the Persian New Year festival, and how has it become such a widely-celebrated holiday in Iran and its neighbors down to the present day?

1 Answers 2019-03-21

After World War One, the Allies (GB, France, US, Japan) invaded Russia, with the purpose of helping the Whites. How big of a force did each power send? What did they actually do (were there other interests)? What was the individual public reactions to their troops being involved in another country?

2 Answers 2019-03-21

Why did Britian and France declare war on Nazi Germany instead of the Soviet Union?

I understand that to most people this will appear to be a stupid question. But as far as I am aware, Hitler had no plans to expand westward, only eastward for lebensraum, therefore it is puzzling to me why Britain and France did not make the decision to destroy Communism of which was (from what I know) perceived as a worse threat than Fascism. I understand that there might be a prevailing argument stating that it was because the Germans considered themselves as superior and discriminated against minorities... however both Britain, France and Russia did the same, if not, worse.

Please don't hesitate to correct anything factually incorrect of what I've said above.

2 Answers 2019-03-21

How did prehistoric humans use boats? Were boats used before the invention of rowing oars?

So I was reading through a wikipedia timeline of human inventions:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_historic_inventions

And found it weird that rowing oars seemed to be invented a long time after boats first were invented.

Is this right? If so, how were early oarless boats used, and for what purpose?

3 Answers 2019-03-21

Did the Levant born-and-raised Crusaders have any differences and conflicts with European Crusaders arriving fresh?

Likewise, how much did the Crusader States adopt local customs and languages? Would they still be seen as very European or becoming Levantine?

1 Answers 2019-03-21

Any historical references/information about women suffering from morning sickness?

Curious about whether morning sickness has always been part of the pregnancy experience for some women and if it was viewed as common. Also curious about what inference was made from a woman experiencing morning sickness - i.e morning sickness means xyz etc

2 Answers 2019-03-21

How did the people of Switzerland feel during WWII?

Where they constantly afraid to be invaded? Was the Swiss Army on constant alert? Where there any incursions in swiss territory?

1 Answers 2019-03-21

Historian viewpoint of the man “Jesus”

Out of curiosity and ignorance on the topic, I’m curious to hear what type of historical facts or storylines are accepted about the man. Not necessarily “the prophet” but what details about him are generally accepted as true among scholars and historians alike.

2 Answers 2019-03-21

In Ancient India were the armies only made up of Warrior castes or was conscription of lower castes done as well?

I ask because recently I read a post about how Muslims conquered India due to most Indians not being able to participate in war due to being lower caste and thus unable to work in the army. I'm not sure if that's even true cause it sounds very counter-intuitive to have western armies did it.

1 Answers 2019-03-21

The French fleet played a famously key role in the American Revolution, but was powerless to do the same in support of Charles Edward Stuart's Jacobite uprising just 30 years earlier. What changed in those 30 years?

1 Answers 2019-03-21

⯇ 2058 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start