Was there ever a period in Russian history where their eastern frontier was kind of like America’s western frontier? Did a type of “Wild East” myth emerge from this period similar to America’s “Wild West” myth?

2 Answers 2019-03-03

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | February 25, 2019–March 03, 2019

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2019-03-03

Nazi Germany famously used MEFO bills in order to rearm in the 1930s. How exactly did they work?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

In Band of Brothers, a soilder is depicted bursting into tears at the news of FDR passing away, what was the overall reaction of the average soilder and how did it impact morale?

3 Answers 2019-03-03

Peter Kroptkin stated that people in many medieval cities had a higher standard of living than workers in all of Europe in the first half of 19th century. Is this correct?

There was not much room for hired work in the early flourishing periods of the mediæval cities, still less for individual hirelings. The work of the weavers, the archers, the smiths, the bakers, and so on, was performed for the craft and the city; and when craftsmen were hired in the building trades, they worked as temporary corporations (as they still do in the Russian artéls), whose work was paid en bloc. Work for a master began to multiply only later on; but even in this case the worker was paid better than he is paid now, even in this country, and very much better than he used to be paid all over Europe in the first half of this century. Thorold Rogers has familiarized English readers with this idea; but the same is true for the Continent as well, as is shown by the researches of Falke and Schönberg, and by many occasional indications. Even in the fifteenth century a mason, a carpenter, or a smith worker would be paid at Amiens four sols a day, which corresponded to forty-eight pounds of bread, or to the eighth part of a small ox (bouvard). In Saxony, the salary of the Geselle in the building trade was such that, to put it in Falke’s words, he could buy with his six days’ wages three sheep and one pair of shoes.[215] The donations of workers (Geselle) to cathedrals also bear testimony of their relative well-being, to say nothing of the glorious donations of certain craft guilds nor of what they used to spend in festivities and pageants.[216] In fact, the more we learn about the mediæval city, the more we are convinced that at no time has labour enjoyed such conditions of prosperity and such respect as when city life stood at its highest.

More than that; not only many aspirations of our modern radicals were already realized in the middle ages, but much of what is described now as Utopian was accepted then as a matter of fact. We are laughed at when we say that work must be pleasant, but — “every one must be pleased with his work,” a mediæval Kuttenberg ordinance says, “and no one shall, while doing nothing (mit nichts thun), appropriate for himself what others have produced by application and work, because laws must be a shield for application and work.”[217] And amidst all present talk about an eight hours’ day, it may be well to remember an ordinance of Ferdinand the First relative to the Imperial coal mines, which settled the miner’s day at eight hours, “as it used to be of old” (wie vor Alters herkommen), and work on Saturday afternoon was prohibited. Longer hours were very rare, we are told by Janssen, while shorter hours were of common occurrence. In this country, in the fifteenth century, Rogers says, “the workmen worked only forty-eight hours a week.“[218] The Saturday half-holiday, too, which we consider as a modern conquest, was in reality an old mediæval institution; it was bathing-time for a great part of the community, while Wednesday afternoon was bathing-time for the Geselle.[219] And although school meals did not exist — probably because no children went hungry to school — a distribution of bath-money to the children whose parents found difficulty in providing it was habitual in several places As to Labour Congresses, they also were a regular Feature of the middles ages. In some parts of Germany craftsmen of the same trade, belonging to different communes, used to come together every year to discuss questions relative to their trade, the years of apprenticeship, the wandering years, the wages, and so on; and in 1572, the Hanseatic towns formally recognized the right of the crafts to come together at periodical congresses, and to take any resolutions, so long as they were not contrary to the cities’ rolls, relative to the quality of goods. Such Labour Congresses, partly international like the Hansa itself, are known to have been held by bakers, founders, smiths, tanners, sword-makers and cask-makers.[220]

1 Answers 2019-03-03

What was the connection between nationalism and industrialism in the 1800s?

I know that nationalism was on the rise at the same time as the industrial revolution, but what was the connection between the two?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

When was it first realised that an atomic bomb might be possible?

Who and when first theorised the possibility of a fission bomb?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

Before no-fault divorce, if a spouse committed adultery, were they able to use that as proof for divorce?

So the year is 1965 in the UK or the US. Say the husband has a mistress he has been sleeping with and he wants to be able to marry the mistress. He is the one who has committed adultery.

Could he then apply for divorce, citing his own adultery?

Or did the one wanting a divorce [husband in this scenario] have to prove some fault of the other [wife]?

So in this scenario, would the wife have to be the one to seek divorce back then as she was the one who could prove fault against the husband?

Could she in effect refuse to get divorced and stymie the husband's wishes, never diivorce him so he could not marry his mistress?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

Did anybody claim credit for killing Major general Sir Edward Pakenham at the Battle of New Orleans?

The history channel says a sharp shooter killed him, do we know who specifically?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

How did naming work for the Ainu people?

In my fantasy story, I'm basing a group of people off of the Ainu, and I want them to seem similar culturally. Did the Ainu have a family name - given name setup similar to the traditional Japanese or did they use something else entirely?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

After the 1833 Factory Act was passed in the UK why did so many factory owners still get away with child exploitation?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

Should this sub allow "Why did X not happen" questions?

It seems a lot of people overestimate the capabilities of historians, somehow believing that historians can accurately determine why things didn't happen. Obviously, most of these questions end up unanswered, since no historians research why things didn't happen, and sometimes determining what did happen is hard enough as it is. Should questions like this be automatically redirected and/or deleted?

2 Answers 2019-03-03

Gaius Valerius Catullus is known for writing Catullus 16 - a poem whose first line has been called "one of the filthiest expressions ever written in Latin." What was the public response to this poem at the time?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

Did NorthAmerican natives actually cast copper?

I've read a paper from some years ago, that shows evidence of how the natives of Wisconsin casted copper to make some tools.

​

A Metallographic Analysis of the Old Copper Osceola, Wisconsin Site : 1900 to 1200 B.C.E. on JSTOR

​

Is there any evidence to refute this analysis? If they actually did it, how old are the copper tools that were casted? I mean, the site is supposed to be old, however each tool has its own dating, yet the arcticle doesn't mention these specific datings.

​

Greetings haha. A link here https://docdro.id/SQ5B74V

1 Answers 2019-03-03

Career in History

Im new to Reddit. I was looking into various ways to gain information pertaining to careers with a history degree. I am a complete history nerd and I really feel like the only thing I could enjoy doing is teaching history on the university level. That being said I have no idea what that career might be like. Is it possible? Is it extremely competitive? What are the demands of this career? The only thing i know for certain is i love history, I love reading, learning, sharing it with others. Im not intimidated by the work load that the degree requires. I suppose im just looking for someone to tell me the ends and outs of the career and to tell me to stop being a coward and buck up and do it!!!

4 Answers 2019-03-03

Did Plague Doctors Make a Difference?

I'm curious, since medical practices during the time of the black death were spotty at best, did plague doctors actually have any impact on combating it? Did they perhaps make it worse? If plague doctors weren't a thing, would the end result still be the same?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

Mardi Gras: How did the bared breasts for beads tradition get started?

It never made sense to me why so many women would reveal themselves for novelty jewelry? Were the beads once worth something at the end of the party? Or is this just part of the general debauchery of the celebration?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

It is commonly know that a lot of Americans were using heroin during the Vietnam war, I was wondering how did they get it? Surely there wasn’t a lot of heroin going around in Vietnam

1 Answers 2019-03-03

My Grandpa was a co-pilot on a B-29 during the war. We talked a lot about his experiences and the B-29 even 50 years after he was an encyclopedia about the plane. But I never asked about what they wore while on a mission. From head to toe what did a B-29 crew wear on a mission?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

The Battle of Nineveh (627) was a set-piece ancient battle that apparently lasted 8 hours ... how is this possible? Did ancient armies ever separate and stop fighting to have a rest?

1 Answers 2019-03-03

Mandaeism and Yazidism are non-Islamic religions practiced in Iraq and Iran; how did these religions survive to the present day despite the Islamic Conquest of those areas?

Also, were these religious minorities subject to persecution during the Muslim conquest of Iraq and Iran and beyond?

1 Answers 2019-03-02

Was there an attempt to make "bullet proof knights" during the transition from bows/crossbows to firearms?

My limited understanding is that plate-armor fell out of favor with the introduction of small arms since a bullet could easily pierce a breast-plate. Thus the extra weight became a liability and armored suits quickly became little more than decorations and heirlooms rather than practical battlefield defense.

My question then is did anyone attempt to reinforce plate suits to try and make them bulletproof? Are there any examples or records of experimentation in this regard. One off historical curiosities / attempts to make a "bullet proof knight"?

2 Answers 2019-03-02

How *exactly* did membership in the Senate work during the Roman Republic?

So my understanding is that once you were elected Quaestor you were eligible for Senate enrollment (assuming you were in the senatorial class). However, you always hear about there being 300 Senators, or so and so increasing or decreasing the number of Senators.

It seems to me, then, that if the Senate had a finite number you would generally have more former Quaestors than Senators. Was there a waiting list? Was a Senator's membership suspended if they were subsequently elected to Praetor or Consul? What happens when they came back from their governorship? Did they just reassume their seat?

Edit: apparently Reddit formatting doesn't work in titles. Oh well.

1 Answers 2019-03-02

Was homosexuality seen as normal in the middle east prior to 1885?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-03-02

Why did the sikhs not get a sikh country during the 1947 partition even though before british rule there was a sikh kingdom?

4 Answers 2019-03-02

⯇ 2090 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start