Is there any benefit to reading a textbook from a general survey course (US, world, European etc..) for somebody looking to start reading history for personal enjoyment?

So I've always enjoyed history but I have not done much reading about history since my freshman level US history courses in college nearly 20 years ago. I've read a handful of WW2 books and a couple presidential biographies, otherwise most of my reading is other non fiction genres amd fiction.

I made one of my reading goals for 2019 to start digging into history for fun but I have no idea where or how to start. One idea I had was maybe reading a broad survey history text (US, World, or European) and just sorting veering towards whatever interests me there.

Any thoughts on this idea? Do you think it is benefical to read a broad survey history book for persomal enrichment to get my feet wet or would my time be better served reading a broad history book written for general readers?

​

Thanks!

1 Answers 2019-01-13

Machu Picchu was never discovered by the Spanish invaders, or anybody else for that matter until 1911. Why did the Incas abandon such a good secluded and strategic location in such a desperate time?

2430 metres above sea level, technically a Citadel so easily defensible if it were discovered at all...It seemed like such a natural choice for the last surviving Inca to escape to yet it appears the thought never even crossed their minds.

1 Answers 2019-01-13

How historically accurate is Extra History

1 Answers 2019-01-13

Why does the Netherlands have so many canals?

1 Answers 2019-01-13

It's the 19th Century and I want to travel to America to escape persecution in my homeland...how did I even learn of America as a Land Of Opportunity?

In Elia Kazan's America America, the main character is in a small village in Ottoman Turkey dreaming of finding a way to America to escape persecution. Whether it's Turkey or Ireland or Austria-Hungary, people made the journey to the United States in search of a better life. But how would a peasant/serf/laborer learn of America as a place they could reasonably travel to and theoretically thrive? Through books? Newspapers? Simply orally told stories?

1 Answers 2019-01-13

What were some of Charles the seconds best accomplishments?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-01-13

I found some photos of the battle of midway in a stack of photographs. How can I tell if they are real?

here is the link to the pictures I found. How can I tell if they are real? They all say J.R. REED on the back of them. They could possibly be photos of photos but is there any way of finding out who took them and if they are the originals?

1 Answers 2019-01-13

Native American tribe settlements

Native American tribes had territory but I can’t seem to find information on how the population was spread over the territory. Did they have one centralized area where everyone lived?(I doubt) Or did they have a sort of capital area with satellite settlements spread over the territory?

1 Answers 2019-01-13

Why Didn’t Japan Annex the Dutch East Indies After Germany Occupied the Netherlands?

If the Dutch government surrendered to the Germans in 1940 why wasn’t the Dutch East Indies simply up for grabs? Couldn’t the Japanese have worked something out with the Germans to annex The Netherlands’ pacific holdings as part of their Axis pact? I’m just curious why the Japanese let a territory abandoned by an occupied government just sit there until after they had already declared war on the U.S. They could’ve solved their oil shortage years before it even became an issue.

2 Answers 2019-01-13

When Schumann wrote the Konzertstück für 4 Hörner, what frequency of A did his orchestra tune to?

1 Answers 2019-01-13

My Jichan told me that our family were once "rural, part-time samurai that grew crops half the year and fought the other half." What exactly does he mean by this? Could you *be* a part-time samurai?

I've been meaning to get access to his genealogy research (He is required to maintain those by the Japanese government since he is technically a Japanese citizen), but he has told me on several occasions that during the feudal period, our family's male line were small-time samurai working small plots of land in the countryside (historically the most I know at the moment is that we have always been from the Hiroshima region). He told me he had learned much of this while he was more or less deported-in-exile to Japan from Canada during World War II, but he hasn't really provided me with the better specifics of historicity which would help me ask (and help you answer) this question. I'm currently bugging him since I know he has a giant-ass folder in his office so I'll have to ask if I can look at it when I visit him.

2 Answers 2019-01-13

Hollywood was a target of Congress for suspected communist activities starting in 1947; were there a disproportionate number of communists in the film industry at the time, and, if so, was this the result of a conscious effort by the Soviet Union to recruit them?

1 Answers 2019-01-13

Concentration camps escapes

I have just watched Son of Saul and was wondering if there exists any number of how many people that escaped concentration camps? How did they manage to escape? Where there riots like the one in the movie?

1 Answers 2019-01-13

In 1590, Moroccan Sultan Ahmad al-Mansur launched an invasion of the Songhai Empire with an army of only 4,000 men. How much did the Moroccans know about the states of West Africa and what were their future plans in the region?

1 Answers 2019-01-12

Why did military in the civil war era just use muskets?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-01-12

In 1949, the Dutch government and Indonesian nationalist leaders negotiated the formation of the federated United States of Indonesia, which within a year was integrated into a unitary Republic. How did this decision come to be, and how did the transition process go?

Hi all! I'm a fairly casual reader of Southeast Asian history, and I'm always on the lookout for detailed sources on the Indonesian National Revolution. My understanding of the 1949-1950 period is fairly barebones - it seems to me that the NICA/AMACAB had been organising community leaders from the non-Republican-held regions of Indonesia to form a series of small regional protectorates. What was the Dutch motivation behind this decision, and was the Republican side justified in its suspicion that it was meant to weaken the fledgling Indonesian state? Did the populations of the federal states generally support their integration with the Republic? And how did the transition itself go? Was it peaceful, or did it involve any forceful takeover?

1 Answers 2019-01-12

Are there any books I can read on the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, along with the period after its partition and before WWI?

1 Answers 2019-01-12

A ww1 question

I know this might sound stupid but this is my first post,when a soldier got trench foot did they still fight or did they go home or sit the battle out

1 Answers 2019-01-12

What were the major hubs for Jewish culture in Europe pre-Holocaust?(1900’s-1930’s)

1 Answers 2019-01-12

Anastasy Vonsiatsky

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-01-12

Question about decolonization in Canada/US

Hi everyone,

I'm starting a course about Indigenous self-determination in Canada and I am curious about the concept of decolonization. Frankly, I don't know a whole lot about the movement/push by some for the decolonization of Canada and abroad, but I would like to understand more.

Firstly, what exactly does(/n't) decolonization entail from a theoretical standpoint? Second, what are the desires of groups wanting decolonization in Canada/US, and how realistic are their goals? Thirdly, has there been any significant "progress" in this respect in recent years?

Thank you and I look forward to hearing some inspiring replies.

1 Answers 2019-01-12

How/are the Bulgars, Mongols, Huns, Hungarians, Xiongnu, Turks, and Khitans related?

This whole relationship of Central Asian groups throughout history and the lack of sources just perplexes me, and the relationship they share is dauntingly complex. To my knowledge, the Bulgars are a cousin group to the Turks, yet speak a Slavic language. There is also the oft mentioned Turco Mongol tradition of Central Asia, and obvious cultural ties, but they are classified as distinct groups. Were they once one group in the past or were they always separate and simply diffused culture significantly? And how do the Huns, Hungarians, and Xiongnu fit into all this, as I've heard they were one people, three completely separate people, or distant cousins?

​

EDIT: This is just an add on I thought of later, as I recently recalled as well the Tartar people, along with the distinct Tatar people, and the geographic regions of modern day Tatarstan in Russia, Great Tartary, and Chinese Tartary. To my knowledge, the Tatars and Tartars are distinct classifications, and the Tatars of Russia and Ukraine are Turkic. How they relate to the Tartars, I don't know, and I have also read that the Tartars were a Mongolic people, but also Turkic in different sources. Then there's the Manchus, the native people of Manchuria in North Eastern China, whom I see often thrown into all this as part of Chinese Tartary.

1 Answers 2019-01-12

Was the cause of admittance in asylums in the early 1900's really this extreme? Can someone please confirm?

Just came from reading Maggie O' Farrell's The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox. A young girl spent 60 years in asylum for being hysterical, which later is discovered was because she was raped and didn't know how to explain to her already wary parents, didn't even know that this caused her to be pregnant and is then forced to let her baby go. The father knew everything and did nothing. Maggie writes in the book how easy it was to send a woman to an asylum and claim she was a lunatic. Refusing to speak, not ironing her clothes, for arguing with the neighbors, for not wanting to marry someone, for wanting it too much, daughters who don't listen, wives who leave their husbands, husbands for wanting to get rid of the wives for convenience. I was horrified.

I came across this article by The Guardian. Maggie shares some even more absurd reasons people has had to spend their lives in the asylums. I'm in my early 20's. I never knew it was this bad. But I see no reason for these women to make things up. The same can't be said about my significant other unfortunately. He refuses to believe things were this bad. Where can I find the evidence? How do I convince him to even consider the idea that these might have been true stories?

Can someone please share stories from survivors, link URLs anything so I can confirm it for myself and my guy?

I'm an infrequent redditor, please excuse any mistake I made or suggest some other appropriate subreddit for this post. Thanks for reading.
Here's The Guardian article from 2006.

2 Answers 2019-01-12

The battle of Stalingrad is often considered a turning point of WW2. Why did the Germans enter the streets in the first place rather than surround it like Leningrad? Wouldn't they have an advantage on a field?

1 Answers 2019-01-12

What happened after british east company rule in india?

1 Answers 2019-01-12

⯇ 2179 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start